Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 (of 210 pages)
Mr anony: Yeah but lions have empathy for other lions they will help a wounded lion in a fight yet a male lion will kill another male lion to take over his pride. Is that action immoral?Lions aren't the sorts of creatures that make moral judgements. Mr anony: Dogs also have empathy, they have been known to rescue other dogs and even human children in danger yet male dogs force themselves upon female dogs. Is the action of a dog r[color=#000000]api[/color]ng another dog immoral?Dogs aren't the sorts of creatures that make moral judgements. |
Mr anony: "significant" is a very vague and relative word and the praying mantis is an example you've invented to help you escape. You've said here that human moral precepts are not derived from animals. If all the examples I suggested count as animals, then they are all equally valid.Many words are relative. It doesn't suddenly stop them from being useful. I didn't invent the praying mantis, it is a real animal that illustrates my point. If you think they're equally valid, then you're welcome to show that they are. |
Deep Sight: For once in your life dear sir, please put on your thinking hat and ask your self these questions. I do not trust your capacity to dwell on them so I make a special request. My special request is that you do not respond immediately. Sleep over it, dwell hard on it, and give me a response tomorrow. I mean no offence by saying this. I genuinely mean to ask you to just dwell on it for some time, as I believe that if you respond immediately, your fixed views will automatically kick in.I hope you take that time to reflect on the simple questions I've asked you because your tantrums don't help you. Answering them would have helped move you away from the sorts of simplistic ideas you're presenting. |
Mr anony: What exactly defines what is appropriate or inappropriate?As I said before, judgement, science, empathy, biology and other such features. |
Deep Sight: Not to mention the fact that there are animals of extra-ordinary intelligence, self consciousness and sense of society such as Dolphins, Dogs, Lions and many others.Yes. That is why they've come up with the Pythagoras' theorem and used similar concepts to modify their environment and themselves. |
Mr anony: Why a praying mantis, why not a chicken, a gorrilla, a dog, a shark or an ant. What exactly is this "significant" difference that prescribes what moral actions a man ought to take?Why not praying mantis? Its the example I want to use. My question is whether or not there is a significant difference between humans and the preying mantis. |
Deep Sight: What is the meaning of this? ? ? ? ? ? Abeg I don tire reading arrant NANSENSE this morning.Another hissy fit this time followed by a rage quit. Just what I've come to expect from such childish ideas. Call me when you're ready for something more mature. |
Mr anony: What are these moral considerations if I may ask?Whether or not it is appropriate for humans to treat each other in that way. |
Mr anony: If I asked you how it aptly describes religious orthodoxy I am sure you would be able to tell me. Would you mind doing the honors good sir.I'll do that using simple examples. God is perfectly fine with slavery. God is also perfectly fine with genocide. So what we see is that books of religious orthodoxy say something that is argued for and justified in church but then chose church people go out and protest against the acts they defended in church. |
Mr anony: Don't you also think that they can use their smartness and better judgment to come up with more effective ways of torturing babies for fun?Sure they could but is that a significant difference when it comes to comparing humans to e.g a preying mantis? |
Mr anony: Nah, Orthodoxy is the name of the book itself, that passage was in reference irrational skepticism it (is believed GK Chesterton was criticizing George Bernard Shaw for his politics and two-way criticisms on both the church of england and those who criticized the church). You might want to read the book, it is quite a good read.That still doesn't stop it from showing what religious orthodoxy is. |
Deep Sight: If you think that animals cannot and do not excercise VERY KEEN AND SPECIFIC judgment, then you need to start watching Natgeo Wild and Animal Planet a little more, son. You are not well acquainted with the ways of animals.This is not an answer to the question I asked you but I'll answer yours. I hope you'll answer mine. It is wrong when it comes to moral considerations. |
Deep Sight: Let me translate from English to English to suit your unfortunate situation:You're simply confused but I'm sure you can still see the light. I already asked you: thehomer: Do you think that the fact that humans are "smarter" and can exercise judgement is something significantly different? |
Mr anony: Lol, as I said, I never expected you to get the point.But I see how apt it is when it comes to religious orthodoxy. |
Mr anony: too bad. Perhaps if you told me what you know the word sacred to mean, I might be able to help you Wiktionary: Set apart by solemn religious ceremony; especially, in a good sense, made holy; set apart to religious use; consecrated; not profane or common; as, a sacred place; a sacred day; sacred service. Mr anony: But then you wouldn't be giving them milk in the same context. To one you would be giving him milk knowing that it he is lactose intolerant and to another you would be giving milk knowing that he isn'tSo is it objectively wrong to give someone with lactose intolerance milk or not? Mr anony: Again you have presented two different moral contextsHow do you determine which is more moral? And is this determination objective? |
Deep Sight: O yes of course, that they can and do have different habits and methods of killing and plundering. Particularly predatory territorial animals - which we certainly are - according to your othordoxy. Why would you say that is ok for some predatory territorial animals (Such as Lions or Hyenas) to kill and plunder but is wrong or evil for another set of predatory territorial animals(such as humans) to kill or plunder?Do you think that the fact that humans are "smarter" and can exercise judgement is something significantly different? |
Deep Sight: [size=20pt]! ! ! ! ! ! ! ![/size]You do know that there are many different species of animals out there. |
Mr anony: .........[size=13pt]The man of this school goes first to a political meeting, where he complains that savages are treated as if they were beasts; then he takes his hat and umbrella and goes on to a scientific meeting, where he proves that they practically are beasts[/size].......Still don't see your point here. Does the man of this school go to the scientific meeting to beat up his colleagues and take their land? The general point of the quote is pretty clear. When you start splitting it up, you'll just be destroying his point. |
Mr anony: Please explain how I am using the word in a strange way.That's just it. I don't know how you're using it. Mr anony: What do you think I said? Explain what you understood from my comment so I know if you read me correctly.You said: Mr anony: What you are failing to realize is that in the exact same context, the exact same moral principles apply regardless of societal or individual bias,That means if two people come to you and ask for a drink, it is fine to give them both milk irrespective of the individual feature of someone being lactose intolerant. Mr anony: But taking care of babies for fun is an entirely different moral activity from torturing babies for fun. In the same way that 3+3 is greater than 2+2 but 3+3 and 2+2 are entirely different mathematical exercises.Okay how about taking care of babies for fun and taking care of babies for money. Which is more moral? |
Deep Sight: This gets more and more hilarious. He writes the above and turns about to insist that humans are animals. Men, it really cant get any funnier that this! Just read the bold, and then reflect on the fact that this same man says humans are animals!This is just ridiculous. Humans are animals. They're not plants or bacteria, they belong to a certain taxonomic kingdom. You just seem unable to see past the error in your reasoning. |
Mr anony: Lol, I didn't expect you to agree that it describes you.It describes people as a group not a person. |
Mr anony: Remember you said we don't draw our morality from the actions of animals. Secondly, you'll have to look up what sacred means in a dictionary.Yes. Is there a contradiction? I know what it means. You're using the word in a strange way. Mr anony: What did you understand my comment to be about and in what ways do you think that it didn't address your question?Your comment didn't say anything about it. Mr anony: Is there a spectrum of right and wrong moral answers for torturing babies for fun?Yes. Taking care of babies for fun is more moral than torturing them for fun. Now is there a spectrum of right and wrong answers to the question of 2 + 2? |
Mr anony: Lol, I quite like how the chap can shift from position to position as it suits him. I think this quote by G.K. Chesterton about The Modern Revolutionary describes him quite well.I don't know. It looks to me like it fits the description of Christians. Unless you think Christians aren't "modern people" in any way. Ah orthodoxy. Like any word better describes Christian dogma. |
Deep Sight: And the veritable clown does not realize that animals do this. Tomorrow, he will claim to be an apostle of logic.All you're doing is just committing the naturalistic fallacy. The fact that animals do it doesn't make it appropriate for humans to. Humans commit these actions everyday? Everyday do you have humans eating their partners after copulation? You're just being a buffoon. |
Deep Sight: HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !This is the recourse of the ignorant who have no response. |
Mr anony: Because God made man's g[color=#000000]eni[/color]tals in such a way that they fit a woman's ge[color=#000000]nita[/color]ls perfectly for the purpose of bringing offspring. The act of s[color=#000000]e[/color]x is a sacred act and it is validated through the institution of marriage between a husband and wife.He also made it fit the rectum, mouth, hand and even genitals of other animals. Last time I checked, people don't have to be married to have sex and for some reason, God was fine with marriage between a man and multiple wives. Sex is sacred in what sense? Sacred like prayer? Mr anony: About your lactose question, my comment on context has addressed it sufficiently.No it didn't. Mr anony: And once again you have agreed that a there are objectively correct and incorrect answers to moral questions as there are objectively correct and incorrect answers to mathematical questions. Torturing babies for fun is immoral just like 2+2=5 is unmathematicalIs there a spectrum of right and wrong answers to 2 + 2? |
Deep Sight: ^^^ You have been amongst the most notorious strict materialist atheists on this forum. You have insisted several times, that man is nothing but an animal, an ape. Please, please, please and please, kindly tell me what on earth is wrong with an animal acting as animals do, only doing it smarter?Asked and answered. thehomer: Humans don't derive their moral precepts from other animals so comparing what animals do with respect to trying to discover moral ideas is a waste of time. |
truthislight: Lol, you want to go to heaven!What I want doesn't matter. The pope has said it. |
Mr anony: Then you have answered your question. You have agreed that a moral being can torture babies for fun. . . . unless of course you think man would never torture babies for fun.No I haven't because as I said, the person who tortures babies for fun isn't being moral. You're just ignoring the fact that man can also be an immoral being. Just as man is a being with sight yet we have people who cannot see. This is one of the reasons why morality isn't like mathematics. Morality is on a spectrum from more moral to immoral but the answer to 2 + 2 isn't on such a spectrum. Mr anony: whatever rocks your boat.Not what rocks my boat but what is written in the Bible about the Christian God. |
Mr anony: Ho[color=#000000]mosex[/color]ual s[color=#000000]ex[/color] is objectively morally wrong in the same way i[color=#000000]nce[/color]st is objectively morally wrong.How have you managed to determine this? And you never responded to my question on the lactose intolerant person. |
Mr anony: Is man a moral being?Generally speaking, yes. Mr anony: Yawn. your perception.Yet the Bible agrees with me about what that God did. |
Mr anony: A deliberate attempt to miss the point. My answer was quite clearIf it was that clear, then surely you could use that to answer the question. Mr anony: They are wrong in the same sense that they are both objectively wrong.Let's see. How do you determine what is objectively wrong for you to classify it as such? e.g is homosexuality objectively wrong? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 (of 210 pages)

