Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 (of 210 pages)
Mr anony: No it doesn't and you haven't shown how it does.Would a moral being torture babies for fun? Mr anony: here we go again. Your perception of God does not determine His natureNot my perception, but what is already written in the Bible about him. Unless what is written in the Bible is wrong, I don't see how it is my perception being wrong and not your perception being wrong. |
Mr anony: An action cannot be called a moral action if it isn't done for a reason. For instance you would blame a man who deliberately bumps into you and be more willing to pardon one who was shoved into your path without his intention. You can't just blurt out "bumping into people is wrong" without providing context.So is it truly good to forgive offenses for money? Is it truly good to save a child from drowning for money? Mr anony: What you are failing to realize is that in the exact same context, the exact same moral principles apply regardless of societal or individual bias,Is it moral to give milk to someone who is lactose intolerant? Mr anony: To torture a baby for fun is always morally wrong everywhere and every time in the same way 2+2=5 is wrong . . .and this is despite whatever contrary opinion a person might hold on the matter.It cannot be in the same way that 2 + 2 = 5 is wrong because as I've said before, they're in different categories and it is a category error to make that comparison. One is mathematically wrong, the other is morally wrong. |
The pope said it, I believe it, That settles it. ![]() |
Mr anony: This is simply you jumping from an is to an ought. The effects of actions on other animals doesn't place a demand on an individual to act in any particular way towards it.Well, it does for you to be a moral being. Mr anony: GodI'm assuming you're talking about the Christian God. How could humans have derived their morality from such a blood thirsty tribal God? |
Mr anony: Yes some actions are truly good or truly evil e.g.Do you notice what you did there? For what you consider as being truly evil, you attached reasons i.e you said they were for fun but for what you consider as being truly good, you didn't. Is there a reason for that? How about: It is truly good to forgive offenses for money. It is truly good to save a child from drowning for money. Does that make the forgiveness or child rescuing no longer truly good? Mr anony: And this illustrates my point exactly. Morality like rationality is not something that we evolved but something that stands by itselfAs I said before, morality is not independent of what happens to the person while rationality is. e.g if humans had evolved the gene for producing vitamin C, it won't be immoral to deprive someone of vitamin C but however humans evolved, 200 apples would still be more than 2 apples. |
Deep Sight: A strict materialist would hold that nothing exists but matter - physical things - and that we are the product of the mindless interactions of such matter. Such a worldview would would subscribe to the ToE as the basis for our existence, and thus regard man as nothing but an animal - only a more intelligent one. Within this worldview it is difficult to see why it should be wrong for men TO DO AS ANIMALS DO, but merely do the same things with smarter methods.Why is it difficult to see this? What animals are you comparing man to? The female spiders that eat the male ones after copulation? Lions that kill off cubs that don't have their own genetic material? Deep Sight: If anyone then says that the smartest method for staying alive would be to have collective codes, that is fine: but it should be recognized that that is a system for self-protection, and nothing more. It does not then render any proscribed acts intrinsically evil: this is the key distinction you fail to make.No it doesn't. But then, what action is intrinsically evil? Deep Sight: There is a difference between law and morals. This is a huge subject all by itself within the subject of Jurisprudence as taught in Law. It is a distinction that I see many within this thread, notably Plaetton, have failed to absorb. Legality is not morality and vice versa, although of course there are converging areas. It may be illegal to park your car in a certain space, but not necessarily immoral. Likewise it may be immoral to be unfaithful within marriage but not necessarily illegal. Some things that are illegal are criminal and others are not. There are civil wrongs called torts, which may arise from negligence and may not necessarily be immoral. These are the distinctions.What examples do you have in mind for an act that is intrinsically evil? |
Mr anony: Lol, I wasn't even heading towards God per se. I just wanted to show that Moral principles are truly objective much like logical and mathematical principles.I don't think you can do this because morality and mathematics belong in different categories. |
striktlymi: Wow!!! A politician couldn't have done a better job...I think this sort of response just trivializes something complex. |
Mr anony: Interesting. From where if I may ask do humans derive their moral precepts?They're derived by multiple sources like the effects of certain actions on other humans and some other animals, empathy, reasoning. Where do you think humans derive their moral precepts? |
Mr anony: Beautifully putYou're ignoring the fact that good and evil actions aren't just about the mind, but also about the body. Is any action truly good or truly evil? Is it truly good to give away all your wealth? Is it truly evil to kill a man? Mr anony: Edit: I'll go even further from morality to the question of rationality. How do we know that our basic rational intuitions are true and not just merely how we happened to evolve. For instance how do we know that we ought to test truth claims with logic? How do we know that it isn't merely how we happened to evolve?This to me just misunderstands rationality. Could we have evolved to actually think that 200 apples were less than 2 apples? |
Deep Sight: WHY? IF MAN BE NOTHING BUT A SMARTER APE, WHAT MAKES TERRITORY GRABBING AMONG SMART APES IMMORAL? THE LOWER APES DO SO BY PRIMITIVE FIGHTING: SINCE WE ARE SMARTER, WE DO SO BY SOPHISTICATED FIGHTING: WEAPONS, GUNS, BOMBS, JETS, ARMIES. HOW IS THIS IMMORAL FOR HEAVENS SAKE?Humans don't derive their moral precepts from other animals so comparing what animals do with respect to trying to discover moral ideas is a waste of time. |
Deep Sight: Reduced deductive argumentsIt is not necessarily wrong but so what? |
Uyi Iredia: I find that the problem with materialism is that concepts such as morality, empathy and logic are not strictly reducible to the material processes responsible for them.There is more to materialism than strict reductionalism. Uyi Iredia: We know the basis of all mentations is the human brain but why should the materials in the brain evoke these mentations.Since we know this, why shouldn't they evoke such mentation when it helps improve our survival? Uyi Iredia: There is no reason for a purposeless, amoral material to start considering purpose, yet this is what we see in the brain and in all biological systems. Going by the known fact that purpose & morals can only be defined in context of that which has intelligence I can extrapolate that morality (particularly in humans) ultimately comes from an intelligent being (God).You do realize that purpose is what one makes of it not something endowed upon you by the cosmos. I don't think that purpose and morals can be defined by God unless you already know this God and his purpose. Uyi Iredia: Materialists must realize that matter alone can't think or feel. These attributes require a specific assemblage of materials which CANNOT self-assemble the only reasonable option is to infer from human ability to create intelligent machines that intelligence is required to create intelligence and this necessitates a God. After all is said and done I think the basis of morality is intelligence.This is just a round about way of making an argument based on a weak analogy. The universe isn't like anything created by people. |
Image123: you know He is bad and evil from one passage you call fact, but you refuse to see He is good from other passages? Stop deceiving yourself. Oh give thanks unto the Lord for He is good, too good.Hey it's from your Bible. If you don't think it is factual, then just say so. No matter what else he does, the fact that he gave such a command reveals just how depraved he is. As Lord Acton said (and I agree with), "judge talent at its best, character at its worst". If God can do that, how much worse can the devil be? |
OLAADEGBU: Then life begins at fertilisation and all human life is precious and made in the image of God.As I mentioned before, both the sperm and the egg are alive. |
truthislight: Lol.smr |
OLAADEGBU: When does conception begin?After fertilization. |
truthislight: ^Don't just syh, sys. |
At least you're willing to engage the questions head on. Unlike Mr anony who has suddenly found it difficult to understand English. dexmond: God's way is different from the ways of man. He knows the future. The reason why God could have given such a command was to ensure that the remnants of the people does not come back to haunt Israel. It is interesting to note that Saul did not completely obey the instruction which led to the Amalekites coming back in 1samuel 30:1-2 to carry the family members of David and his men captives.Since God owned the entire world, why then didn't he send his chosen people to Australia or even create land from the sea for them? dexmond: The most difficult part in this instruction was the order to kill infants. The reason for this action is beyond my understanding. Who knows, may be when the children grow, they will want to take revenge. However, the LORD, Adonai, is perfectly good.Has it occurred to you that there is no justification for such an instruction? Maybe they will or he could have accepted them into Heaven like he did to Elijah or Enoch. How do you know he is good given the fact that he gave such an order? If a highly intelligent alien gave such a command, would you think it was perfectly good? |
Mr anony: What! you can't read anymore?This is just ridiculous. You made a claim to have answered a certain question on this thread. I ask you for evidence and you're dancing around about that too. Mr anony: Where did I claim that? or are you lying again?If you don't know what the purpose is, then you're confused as usual. Read what you wrote here. If you don't know what the designer's purpose is, then you have no reason to try to introduce that as an attempt to answer. Mr anony: Then you don't know what you are talking about. You cannot derive an ought without assuming a purposeObviously you have no idea of what you're supposed to do when you claim that some designer has a purpose. Mr anony: Irrational and arbitrary in what sense?In the sense of what those words mean. Simply look them up. Mr anony: The exact question I've been asking you all week.And I'm asking you now. I don't believe in a designer. You do. You claim it has a purpose and some standard. Can you say what they are? Mr anony: Objective morality is morality that does not depend on individual subjective bias. For instance, the moral principle that states that a man ought to keep his word would be one of such objective moral principles.In that case, it cannot depend on your God because your God is a person (or three people) with individual subjective bias. You may as well appeal to some advanced alien intelligence. You are aware that Jesus and Jehovah didn't keep some of their words. Mr anony: Interesting.Did you not that region in bold? You obviously have the intention of not understanding anything unless it is injected into you. Mr anony: I know that it is objectively good to be true to one's word. Would you accept this as an example of an objective moral truth?How do you know this? What does it have to do with this mysterious purpose? What in fact is the purpose? What does it mean to be good to you? And finally, can you answer the question in the OP assuming your own answers to the questions posed? |
Mr anony: You still haven't provided me with what you mean by natural neither has wikipedia.Then your problem is with the English Language. Mr anony: As I said earlier, I did not ask you what naturalism is, I asked you what you mean by "natural" because according to you:Where did I say the statement in bold? My point there is pretty clear. I'm simply saying as Kay has pointed out, that if something cannot come from nothing, then nothing never existed. Mr anony: Your idea of what is natural seems to include spaceless timeless and immaterial entities. It is only fair to ask you to explain exactly what you mean by "natural".Wikipedia has answered your question but you've refused to answer mine. Just pick up a dictionary and look up the definitions within. |
OLAADEGBU: When do you think life begins in the womb if you can draw the line?You do realize that both the sperm and the egg are alive. |
Mr anony: Lol, I explained to you exactly why it isn't a fallacy. I'll do it again for the last time:This is so ridiculous. It appears that you even find it difficult to understand the information from the reference source I presented. Mr anony: A human being is an "either or" kind of entity. i.e. It is either a human being or it is not. There is no such thing as "becoming a human being" or "half a human being". If you were to saw a human being in half, he/she wouldn't become half a human being or two people, it will still be one human being. Even if you were to change every single cell in a human being's body (as we see when babies grow into adults) it does not become a different human being.Baldness is an "either or" kind of entity. i.e one is either bald or is not. There is no such thing as "becoming bald" or "half bald". If you were to saw a human head in half, he/she won't become half bald or two bald people. It will still be one bald person. etc. Do you really not see your text book fallacy? Mr anony: So my friend, contrary to your baldness example where there is actually a slope of hairiness ranging from less to more hair, there is no slope of humanness ranging from "less to more human" therefore your slippery slope accusation simply doesn't apply here.Whatever you think a human is, can you be a human without a brain? Mr anony: I would have been interested in what you would render as the correct definition of a human being since you keep harping on about this "fallacious definitions" but I notice that as usual, you're unable to actually present your own view and defend it. You just prefer to chuck out pointless diversion. A tactic that you and others in your shoes have accused me of without showing evidence for your accusations. Your attempts are just so obvious its embarrassing.Once again, you're trying to shift your own burden to me. You're the one basing your argument on what it means to be human, I'm not. So if you can demonstrate your point without committing a text book example of a logical fallacy, then please do that. |
Mr anony: lol, and what is naturalism? please try to answer without using the word "natural".You should have read what you quoted from Wikipedia. Or checked out a dictionary. Mr anony: Quote mininig wikipedia now are we? Let's read that statement in it's full context:It looks like you don't know what quote-mining is either. Neither the first nor the second part are adjectival forms of the word christian. The third part clearly tells you this. Christian can be a noun or an adjective so, you compare adjectives to adjectives, nouns to nouns. I simply presented you with the relevant parts in order to show you that we compare within similar categories. Another error you're fond of making. Once again, this is what we see from Wikipedia. Wikipedia: Naturalism refers to the viewpoint that laws of nature (as opposed to supernatural ones) operate in the universe, and that nothing exists beyond the natural universe or, if it does, it does not affect the natural universe.[1] Adherents of naturalism (i.e. naturalists) assert that natural laws are the rules that govern the structure and behavior of the natural universe, that the universe is a product of these laws.[2]You're seriously saying that from this you do not know what naturalism is? Then you're welcome to go through this article and understand what is meant by naturalism. This is another one of the reasons I point out that you're just bad at apologetics. Even with an encyclopedia entry, you're confused about what naturalism is. |
Mr anony: I have shown you that it is not a fallacy. Shouting "fallacy" until you are blue in the face won't make it fallacious. Keep dancing. I didn't fail to notice that you avoided my question.You never showed that it wasn't a fallacy and as I demonstrated previously with the help of that reference link, I didn't simply shout "fallacy" I showed you why it was a fallacy. Those posts of mine are still up if you would like to review them. In fact, you've claimed before that I merely said it was a fallacy when I in fact showed you why it was a fallacy. I didn't avoid your question, I simply pointed out to you once again that you were the one making the argument that hinged on the foetus being human not me. And you made that argument based on a logical fallacy you're yet to rectify. |
Mr anony: Lol, perhaps you are blind I can't believe how you failed to notice that wikipedia didn't give us any idea what the "natural" is at all, it just assumed that that the reader knew what "natural" meant.As I pointed out to you, natural is the adjectival form of naturalism. If you know what naturalism is, then you should know what natural is. Mr anony: Or perhaps next time you ask me what christianity is, remind me to define it as:This is why I keep saying you don't understand what you're doing or what you're supposed to do. Naturalism is to Christianity as natural here is to christian. So, the question I would ask for is what christian is. And happily, Wikipedia delivers. Wikipedia: The term "Christian" is also used adjectivally to describe anything associated with Christianity, or in a proverbial sense "all that is noble, and good, and Christ-like."[3]I'm sure you find this ridiculous too. |
Mr anony: If I hear you correctly, you grant that the fetus is human yet you think that the mother's right to choose justifies her killing another human? Tell me how that works.You're so desperate to avoid your own argument that you're trying to shift it to me. I'll just repeat myself by telling you again that you were the one whose entire argument hinged on a fallacious line of reasoning about the foetus being human. You can try to resolve that fallacy or pick another line of argument. The choice remains yours. |
Mr anony: yawnI'm sure you're tired. Mr anony: I have answered your question. You are always free to reject my answer.Since you've answered it, can you remind me of whether or not it was a yes or no? Or can you direct me to where you answered with a yes or no? Mr anony: Without you acknowledging a designer, nothing can be assessed on your partAnd here you once again show that you have no idea of what you're doing. Recall that you were the one claiming that a designer had told you of what its purpose was. Mr anony: I have made it clear to you. if you say that a person objectively ought to act in a certain way then you have granted a purpose.No, you're the one talking about a purpose not me. Or can you show me where I was talking about some hidden purpose? Mr anony: In what universe is a designer subject to the laws that he created for his design?What is the purpose of this designer? Is it to be irrational and arbitrary? Mr anony: By what standard do you judge these effects?By what standard do you judge the purpose of your designer? Mr anony: Irrelevant, We must first agree on what constitutes an objective standard for moralityThen tell me what you think constitutes an objective standard for morality and I'll tell you whether or not I agree. Mr anony: You mean like you danced away from these questions?They were irrelevant since what that example demonstrated was clear. You just tried once again to obfuscate. If you can tell me the relevance of those questions to determining whether or not you're supposed to reveal what the purpose of this hidden designer of yours is, then I'll consider responding but you have to say what the purpose is. Mr anony: There is no sense in telling you what I think. What matters is that which is good regardless of our opinionsDo you know what is good regardless of your opinion? Please answer with a yes or no and tell me why. |
Mr anony: Lol, of course, "naturalism is the belief that the natural is all there is" tells us everything we need to know about the natural. You are such a genius!And here, you've managed to quote-mine Wikipedia to make me appear ridiculous. You're one amazing fellow. In fact, this is what you posted about the link from Wikipedia. Wikipedia: Naturalism refers to the viewpoint that laws of nature (as opposed to supernatural ones) operate in the universe, and that nothing exists beyond the natural universe or, if it does, it does not affect the natural universe. Adherents of naturalism (i.e. naturalists) assert that natural laws are the rules that govern the structure and behavior of the natural universe, that the universe is a product of these laws.As you can surely see, it isn't as ridiculous as you tried to make it seem. You'll notice that since natural is an adjective, you'll see that it was used to qualify universe and laws. You should have read through your post. This introduction is pretty clear. If you still don't understand what is meant here, then the problems you're having run much deeper than I can help you with. |
Mr anony: Lol, Yeah I forgot. It is irrelevant to you whether it is human or not.Yet you have been arguing with me over whether it is human or not and whether it's rights weigh more than the mother.I wasn't arguing with you on whether or not it is human, once again, you were the one who introduced that as your defining factor and tried to back it up using a text-book case of a logical fallacy. I've already addressed my point of view about the rights with respect to the mother. It is up to you (as it has been for a pretty long time now) to make a non-fallacious argument for your point of view. |
Mr anony: I wasn't asking a question. I was pointing out the absurdity of your statementObviously you once again failed to do that. Mr anony: As I said for the umpteenth time, your definition of well-being is vague. A serial rap[color=#000000]ist[/color] can regard as necessary to his/her prosperity, health and happiness the exact same things that a non-r[color=#000000]api[/color]st would call evil. The only way you can legitimately say that one is wrong and the other right is if there is indeed a way humans ought to act. If it is true that there is a way humans ought to act, then it is true that there is an objective purpose to human life i.e. life ought to be lived according to a particular design. If this is true, then it means there is a designer. To ask what the purpose is is to ask if people ought to live a certain way. To deny a purpose is to deny that people are bound by any moral obligation.You know, the question still remains unanswered despite your hand-waving. You can answer that question with a yes or a no. And realize that so far, you've not said what the purpose of this mysterious designer of yours is. Mr anony: I thought you were about to explain your analogy, this doesn't do the job you know.It wasn't an analogy, it was a hypothetical situation to let you know that without you informing me of the purpose of your designer, then nothing can be assessed on your part. Mr anony: Interesting, tell me exactly how I have misrepresented you.I didn't introduce any ideas of a purpose, you did and so far, you've tried to avoid saying what this purpose is despite the fact that I've asked you over and over again. Just declare what the purpose of this mysterious designer is. Mr anony: Nonsense. You have not yet defined what you mean by objective good yet you want to make the magical leap to accusing God of "atrocities".You have not yet defined what you mean by anything at all. You've not given any idea of what you mean by good not to talk about "objective good". Oh I can accuse your God of atrocities alright based on what he has already commanded. In fact, I did that in the OP but you've just been trying to dance around answering the question despite the fact that I said you're welcome to do that using your own idea of good. Ignore my own idea or assume mine is actually evil, just use yours to answer the direct questions. Lol, and calling me a bad apologist won't let you off the hook. I still haven't seen the standard by which you want to judge God's goodness. I'm always ready to discuss with you when you actually have something to discuss about.[/quote]I already answered this. This is another one of the reasons why I said you're a bad apologist. Do you remember when I said this: thehomer: Just so you know, my points of reference are on the effects of Gods actions on humans at the very least. In fact, that much was made clear in my OP here.Do you remember what your answer to this question was? Let me tell you. It was nothing. You simply danced away from it. Surely you can tell me what you think good is before even talking about this "objective good" is. Even if I cannot. |
Mr anony: Apparently I don't. I don't know what you mean by natural, how should I know what you mean by naturalism?Have you already forgotten the concept you posted right here from Wikipedia? It's still up for you to read. Mr anony: lol, this guy you are funny, you have not yet explained what you mean by "natural" how do you expect me to know what you mean by "non-natural incidents". Surely you know I cannot read your mind. I don't have psychic powers.Once again, just take a look at what you posted as the concept of naturalism. It refers to the natural. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 (of 210 pages)

