Was Nani's Red Card Justified? - European Football (EPL, UEFA, La Liga) (12) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum / Entertainment / Sports / European Football (EPL, UEFA, La Liga) / Was Nani's Red Card Justified? (30389 Views)
Diego Lopez Punch On Vidic's Face Worse Than Nani's Collussion With Arbeloa / Sir Alex Ferguson Blames Nani For MANU Defeat To Chelsea / Messi Red Card: Should Messi Have Gotten A Red Card In The Barca V Chelsea Game? (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) ... (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (Reply) (Go Down)
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by babyboy3(m): 8:44pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
elampiro: We were talking about decision united get away with, who cares whether they finish with 13 v 11 |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by elampiro(m): 8:44pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
Babyboy, Always get your facts right. The Kompany's video you uploaded was not even a league match. Thats FA Cup match of last season, over a year ago. This season, November 2012, United beat City at Ethihad with 11 vs 11. Be cleared. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by Deiok(m): 8:45pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
dopeJemi:that what i said earlier. They try to do same thing last season chelsea vs barca, and munic vs madrid. But it didn't work. They are trying create an El clasico final. Watch bacelona returne leg against ac milan then you will know what i mean. 1 Like |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by babyboy3(m): 8:45pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
elampiro: Babyboy, Was Kompany sent off in that match? yes or no....... |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by babyboy3(m): 8:48pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
elampiro: Babyboy, Knowing that they beat United at home 6-1 well nothing to brag about |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by elampiro(m): 8:51pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
baby-boy: That is illogical, somebody said united was favoured this season against city when Kompany was sent off. I said it was not correct because City never got a man sent off in that match. You went and uploaded irrelevant vidoes, old videos. Which teams don't get away with decisions? Totteham vs United, United got robbed and the match ended in a draw. Last season, Newcastle were awarded a penalty for a Rio Ferdinand clean tackle and the match ended in a draw at Old Trafford. Man U eventually lost the league on goals difference. This season, city has had favours from referees poor decisions. They won a match from an offside goal the other time. Last weekend, they fowl a Villa player to get the only goal of the match. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by elampiro(m): 8:55pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
baby-boy: Kompany was not sent off in the LEAGUE MATCH of November 2012 that United won 2-3 at Ethihad. He was substituted with K.TOURE due to hamstring injury. The match ended 11 vs 11. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by samilo88(m): 9:02pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
Fabville:Bro Vincent Kompany not company. He "Kompany" was sent off last season for a two footed challenge in a FA cup game against united which United went on to win 3:2. Replays latter show that Kompany actually took the ball and not the leg. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by harlos: 9:14pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
Fabville:are u a learner  Oh! Sorry maybe u were told very well,so let me help u incase of next time Kompany was sent off against United on his tackle against Nani, even without making contact, and nani was even still rushing back to cover up before the ref blew for a foul. Go for a re-watch. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by harlos: 9:17pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
elampiro:if u no watch the ball why are u commenting rubbish,mayb the person the told u forget to tell u the part |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by TableLeg(m): 9:25pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
samilo88:Thank you sir... That dude is a tosspot  |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by JohnAkpa1(m): 9:42pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
Out of sentiment, mayb nani was thnkng of it so rashd bt d force of Arbeloa grease 2 dat level and nani's foot was drctly 2 hz opponent sternum u knw! So he dsrv d red card. And note dat if it were man u, it would have even been 2 red cards. What a carelex jump and mindset? |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by emmatok(m): 9:58pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
John Akpa: Out of sentiment, mayb nani was thnkng of it so rashd bt d force of Arbeloa grease 2 dat level and nani's foot was drctly 2 hz opponent sternum u knw! So he dsrv d red card. And note dat if it were man u, it would have even been 2 red cards. What a carelex jump and mindset? Well from the video Nano leg was already up before Arbeloa ran in. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by Kayman3(m): 10:18pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
I also felt dat d ref was too harsh, it could hav just been yellow card ofence. Now let us assume d kick was unintentional.. Which i personal dont believe. There was this que that every MAN-U fans are dodging.. Why was he (Nani) rolling on the ground as if he was d one kicked but d Kicked person was on his feet ? I need honest answer by man u fans. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by jerryzy: 10:23pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
Nani was expecting 20 yards space for himself as he practises I̶̲̥̅̊n̶̲̥̅̊ his Taekwondo session, Nani noni |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by Belovedd: 10:41pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
All this ranting from chelsea fans and their still being in europa or arsenal fans.......bla bla bla, even liverpool fans are talking....hmmmm!!! In all of this, one thing i can say is man utd is taking at least one cup home this season but for chelsea, arsenal and Liverpool; none of them is taking anything home whether silverware or plasticware (mark my words) Both premier league and fa cup are coming to MANCHESTER (whether united or city) So, enjoy licking your wounds and like someone earlier said; Man utd would return to EPL and continue bossing our bitches around. 2 Likes |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by elampiro(m): 10:46pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
harlos: if u no watch the ball why are u commenting rubbish,mayb the person the told u forget to tell u the part It's you that didn't watch the match. I don't know when last I missed a United match. Even if I am not at home, I stream it. We are talking of two different matches here, but same scoreline. One is FA Cup of last season while the other EPL match of this season. see the match report below. Now tell me who is correct. LINEUP, BOOKINGS (7) & SUBSTITUTIONS (6) Manchester City 01 Hart 04 Kompany (K Toure - 21' ) 05 Zabaleta 22 Clichy 33 Nastasic 08 Nasri Booked 18 Barry Booked 21 Silva 42 Y Toure Booked (Dzeko - 84' ) 16 Aguero 45 Balotelli (Tevez - 52' Booked ) Substitutes 30 Pantilimon 03 Maicon 06 Lescott 28 K Toure 14 Garcia 10 Dzeko 32 Tevez Manchester United 01 De Gea 02 Rafael 03 Evra 05 Ferdinand Booked 06 Evans (Smalling - 48' ) 07 Valencia (Jones - 84' Booked ) 16 Carrick 18 Young 23 Cleverley (Welbeck - 87' ) 10 Rooney Booked 20 Van Persie Substitutes 50 Johnstone 04 Jones 12 Smalling 11 Giggs 22 Scholes 14 Hernandez 19 Welbeck http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/20571835 |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by Cheks01(f): 11:01pm On Mar 06, 2013 |
I think y d red card ws given 2 him ws dt he didnt get up immediately 2 apologise knowing he has committed an offence. My opinion |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by Nobody: 12:57am On Mar 07, 2013 |
He Showed Studs... he got Straight Red. The rule says no fucking STUDS, ITS DANGEROUS PLAY! |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by licensed2k(m): 1:02am On Mar 07, 2013 |
fresh_dude: You're a tw@t. Your brain cells have been lost to excessive garri consumption ode.Was that all u got in ur arsenal? I can see u are a very delusional boy who has bn greatly abused by peers. D mistake is, u got the wrong person to pick on son. One thing I assure u tho, I'm gonna have u for breakfast one of these days. U can count on that. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by loswhite(m): 1:34am On Mar 07, 2013 |
Beaf!:his stud was on arbeloa's rib . I agree wit u on it was not intentional but if u fowl sumbody on box 18 weather it is intentional or not it is a penalty so d same applies |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by loswhite(m): 1:37am On Mar 07, 2013 |
Frostyzone: No, it wasn't. Nani didn't even see the guy coming as he went for the ball. Nobody, not even The Madrid players expected such an hard decision the ref, as none of them contested it.really ! Decision swing ur way chai na back of television u watch |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by pareto(m): 3:39am On Mar 07, 2013 |
Nani forgot two things.1, it was not Howard webb officiating.2, a champions league match and not premiership. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by Kelvinigho(m): 6:18am On Mar 07, 2013 |
D ref made a blunder.ramos shd has been sent off if d ref was a harsh man.over 4 diferent yelow card offenses comimted by ramos.what about the two hand ball offenses in the penalty box?d dream of the treble is dash.but the double is sure.d Epl and FA cup |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by harlos: 6:37am On Mar 07, 2013 |
elampiro:man i still standing on the fact that he we sent off against united, i think it was in the FA. I was not told, I watched the match and i remember very well that we argue about the ref's decision after the match. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by ddippset(m): 7:03am On Mar 07, 2013 |
i wouldnt want to go into the controversy of whether the red card was justified or not since the arument could go on forever. all i want to say is that the red card qualified real madrid for the quarters. without reducing man u to 10 men, madrid would never have qualified. simple! 2 Likes |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by tribalism(m): 7:31am On Mar 07, 2013 |
How could you have send the one you regard as a prodigal son, a son you have unjustfully treated like an outcast, to a very important mission requiring trust. I see it as a revenge on SAF by the brave and ruthless nani. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by snowprince01(m): 9:00am On Mar 07, 2013 |
Jerrygotswagg: Let's be truthful here , I am I die hard Man U fan, yes I know that the Red card was worth it, if you to be the Ref and u see some1 jump like jet li and he tries to hit u, so he hit him with a jet li move, JEsus , referee don't you have black card and ban him for life or are you a learnerU are not a man u fan... Dat was nani first foul nd Clearly he has not gotten a warning b4, also if u look closely u will notice dat his eyes Was on d ball nd was backing d defender. He saw him late nd his leg was already Suspended to come down dat fast..d defender in his own crashed in2 d leg knowing he will get payed for dat by giving nani dat red card. In a game of such magnitude ref should try d best way possible to keep d red card off his hand, because its a game where d best team should win, not with any advantage. Its not a red card Offence to me. Madrid knew wat they were doing, they needed to clip our feathers to b able to win dat game. Nani was d best on d pitch...its obvious cheating 1 Like |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by emma4much4u: 9:01am On Mar 07, 2013 |
I have 2 questions for all manu fans who think it wasn't worth a red card.1.Why did Nani have to raise his studs so high just to control a ball that would naturally come down to his feeth if he felt that there was no other contender for the ball?.2.Why did he stay down after the incident feigning injury?.If u can answer this 2 questions without sentiments,then u will see why he was red carded. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by elampiro(m): 9:33am On Mar 07, 2013 |
harlos: man i still standing on the fact that he we sent off against united, i think it was in the FA. I was not told, I watched the match and i remember very well that we argue about the ref's decision after the match. So why not be sure before you attack people? If you had followed the previous comments carefully, you should have seen where I clarified that the red card was in FA cup match of last season. Some other people corroborated it. United were leading three nil, then city scored two, and it ended 2-3. The argument was that it was not the league match of this season which was played in November. The match Rooney scored two goals, then Zabeleta and Y.Toure equalised before RVP scored a stoppage time winner with a stunning free kick. That was a clean match without any sending off. You jumped into the argument half way just because you want to criticise Man United. The anti Man U guy who started the argument said Kompany was sent off in the league match this season. That is the basis of this argument. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by elampiro(m): 9:34am On Mar 07, 2013 |
ddippset: i wouldnt want to go into the controversy of whether the red card was justified or not since the arument could go on forever. all i want to say is that the red card qualified real madrid for the quarters. without reducing man u to 10 men, madrid would never have qualified. simple! Well said. |
| Re: Was Nani's Red Card Justified? by elampiro(m): 9:42am On Mar 07, 2013 |
When the whole world knows Nani red was biased, only Nigerian haters think it was justified. FA Cup becomes priority for wounded Man United By Martyn Herman | Reuters – 3 hrs ago Reuters/Reuters - Manchester United will aim to vent their feelings of injustice on holders Chelsea in the FA Cup this weekend after a controversial Champions League exit against Real Madrid on Tuesday torched their hopes of a treble. Alex Ferguson's side have concentrated their firepower on bigger prizes since last lifting the FA Cup for a record 11th time in 2004 when they beat Millwall. But knocking out the club who have won the FA Cup four times in the last six seasons - including the 2007 final when Chelsea beat United in the first final at the re-built Wembley Stadium - would be some consolation. The clash at Old Trafford is the standout match of the quarter-finals which also features the all-Premier League tie between Everton and Wigan Athletic. Manchester City, the 2011 winners, face 1912 winners Barnsley of the Championship and in an all-Championship tie Millwall meet Blackburn Rovers, who knocked out Arsenal in the last round. "We've still got an FA Cup tie and we're still in a commanding position in the league. So we'll get over it, we'll bounce back," United assistant manager Mike Phelan told the club's website after United's 2-1 home defeat by Real Madrid in which Nani was controversially sent off. "We've had disappointments before and we'll get over this one. We'll come in (to training) and kick on. "The players will rally round, the staff will rally round and we'll be Manchester United right the way through until the end of May." |
(1) (2) (3) ... (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (Reply)
Fulham Vs Manchester United (1 - 2) On 20th January 2021 / Tottenham Hotspur Vs Arsenal (2 - 0) On 30th April 2017 / Crystal Palace Vs Manchester United - (0 - 1) - Live
(Go Up)
| Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 81 |