₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: RegisterLoginWith GoogleTrendingRecentNew

Stats: 3,330,043 members, 8,443,598 topics. Date: Sunday, 12 July 2026 at 06:49 AM

Toggle theme

Enigma's Posts

Nairaland ForumEnigma's ProfileEnigma's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 (of 198 pages)

Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 5:11pm On Aug 09, 2010
KunleOshob:
. . . Cause it is clear to all that the trinity concept is extra biblical and it was introduced by the early catholic church centuries after the apostles had passed on. . . .
nuclearboy:
^^^
Your aversion for the RCC is turning you into a "joagbaje" who chooses what he likes and discards the truth. . . .
Now here is a thing. It seems that people tend to confuse the c[/i]atholic Church with the [i]C[/i]atholic Church or Roman Catholic Church (RCC). The [i]c[/i]atholic Church simply means the universal church. It is the universal Church (granted with dissentients) that formulated the Trinity doctrine and not the [i]C[/i]atholic or Roman Catholic Church. (EDITED See further this thread: https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-497445.0.html#msg6576034 )


Second, it seems to me that people making allegations against the early Church Fathers who formulated the Trinity doctrine are not fully aware of the circumstances in which the Trinity doctrine emerged. It seems there is a sort of ignorance/insufficient awareness of or insufficient credit for the fact that the formulation of the Trinity doctrine was an enforced necessity in view of the fact that the Church Fathers faced various teachings that were considered wrong, heterodox or heretical. There seems to be this unfair suggestion of out and out caprice on the part of the Church Fathers who formulated the Trinity doctrine.

Third, it is wrong to suggest that the Trinity doctrine is purely one of intuition or that it is extra-biblical especially if on the rather flimsy basis that the word Trinity is not mentioned in the Bible or even on the relatively more solid claim that the doctrine of the Trinity is not [i]explicit
in the Bible. If one believes that there is One God and the Bible teaches that the Father is God, Jesus is God and the Holy Spirit is God, I would like to see what better doctrine than the Trinity one can come up with.

Fourth, I'm not aware that the Trinitarians here have been claiming that the Trinity doctrine fully encapsulates God; even I will be willing to countenance a suggestion that the Trinity doctrine is not perfect. But again, has there ever been any doctrine on the relationship of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit that is better than the Trinity? In my view, all of Arianism, Modalism, Sabellianism, Docetism etc are inferior to the doctrine of the Trinity. Let alone talking of things like Tri-theism or Oneness of infinity.  grin

Finally, it is such a pity that the Church has become fragmented and divided on many issues. God gave the Church and ordinarily we should believe that the Holy Spirit is guiding the Church. For this reason we can sing this verse from a personally much beloved Trinitarian hymn:

And I hold in veneration
For the love of Him alone
Holy Church as His creation
and her teachings as His own
Taken from Firmly I Believe and Truly
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 4:44pm On Aug 09, 2010
KunleOshob:
@enigma
I take except to the term "foolish" which you used in addressing my queries, this is supposed to be a mature discuss and you don't need to resort to abuse just becos someone exposes deep flaws and contradictions in your hypothesis.
If you make an allegation that someone is self contradictory without providing proof of the alleged contradiction, then I think it is reasonable if the person calls your allegation foolish. If you can dish it then you should expect to receive it. I put it to you that in the few discussions I've had with you on this Trinity issue, you always start to get abusive even when I had been deliberately cautious to be polite to you. You can go and check the thread For Trinity Sunday for example.  EDITED

KunleOshob:
In answering your questions, this is what the bible says:

>That the father is God.
>That Jesus is his only begotten son.
>That the holy spirit is the spirit of God which can be interpreted to mean a spirit of Godliness. Now where in the bible is it stated that these three entities are the same being even though the bible makes it clear they have similar attributes. Jesus said in clear terms that the father is greater than he is and that he is subject to the will of the Father, I don't why supposed christians would try and make Jesus what he or the bible NEVER claimed him to be.
Well, the Bible teaches that (a) the Father is God, (b) Jesus is God, and (c) the Holy Spirit is God. If you disagree and think that the Bible doesn't teach any of these, that is perfectly fine by me (edited). It is nothing new; you won't be the first and you won't be the last. Go and read up on things like Arianism, Modalism, Sabellianism etc etc.
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 9:38am On Aug 09, 2010
@kunleoshob

Instead of making foolish allegations that you have not thought through why not outline the contradiction that you allege? Here are three questions for you:

Does the Bible say the Father is God or not?

Does the Bible say Jesus is God or not?

Does the Bible say the Holy Spirit is God or not?
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 12:43am On Aug 09, 2010
^^^^ Exactly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Human "descriptions", "representations"  or "depictions" rarely if ever work! We all (at least we Christians) recognise that we cannot fully encapsulate God --- thus in a way the less said the better. We can only confine ourselves to that much that is revealed in Scripture and confirmed to our own individual spirit (the experiential element) by the Holy Spirit. This much is revealed in Scripture:

a. the Father is God
b. Jesus Christ is God
c. the Holy Spirit is God

We will be on strong and surer ground if we confine ourselves within the boundaries of revelation. Whenever we go beyond that we are always likely to fall short or to stray. In fact, that is what is at the heart of the debates from the very beginning (i.e. pre Nicene/Athanasian creeds) (a) understanding what is revealed and (b) going beyond or even falling short of what is revealed because of trying to fit revelation within the very finite limits of human conceptions and perceptions.
Christianity EtcRe: Why Does The Catholic Bible Have More Books Than King James? by Enigma(m): 1:13pm On Aug 08, 2010
aletheia:
^^^That was an interesting read! Raises all sorts of interesting implications with regard to the Septuagint and our "modern" translations of the OT which are based on the Hebrew Masoretic Text (perhaps a revision arising out of the Jews rejection of the Messiah?) What's your take on the issue?
I also found it quite interesting. I certainly would like to see a western Christian (new) version of the Old Testament using the Septuagint and/or the textual tradition on which it is based (if only the manuscipts can be found). One thing though, that the Septuagint (compiled 100-300 years even before the advent of Christ) is the way it is testifies quite powerfully to the Christian message; that it was compiled by Jewish rabbis, who were not "Christians", is powerful attestation that the gospel and testimony of Christ is not just a fable. I am inclined to support/accept the view expressed that the Holy Spirit guided the compilers of the Septuagint. I also find of great significance the fact that Jesus Christ Himself and the writers of the gospels and epistles tended to quote predominantly from the Septuagint.

Having said all of that, I do not think that having our current Old Testament based on the Masoretic tradition is in itself a necessarily bad thing; despite the "marked" differences, we can see that the esential message and overall doctrine of the Old Testament is the same ---- whether as expressed in the Masoretic textual tradition or the Septuagint tradition. A very positive spin that has been put on this is that the "differences" in ancient manuscripts show that really the writers were not trying to create falsehoods otherwise you might have had everything tailor-made to "agree". I do realise that some will say that - 'but the Jews and the Christians each had reasons to put their spin on things'. Then we will ask again if the Septuagint was produced by Christians.
Christianity EtcRe: Top 10 Reasons Why Jesus Christ Is Not God by Enigma(m): 12:55pm On Aug 08, 2010
@italo

I think with some people if you seem to 'agree' with them on their falsehood, they will start beating their chest that oh yes you have agreed that they are right and they will be telling others that even you agree with them. Thus, what I will do when I tire of arguing with them is to say "No, it is not red, it is green; however, I am happy to leave you to continue thinking it is red; I will simply continue to see you as wrong!" That way, there will be less room for doubt or misrepresentation of where you stand.
Christianity EtcRe: Why Does The Catholic Bible Have More Books Than King James? by Enigma(m): 11:25pm On Aug 07, 2010
Here is an interesting piece albeit from an Orthodox perspective http://www.orthodoxengland.org.uk/septuag.htm
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 1:48pm On Aug 07, 2010
MyJoe:
grin
We are looking at things from biblical perspectives in this thread. We can show from the Bible that the Father is personal. But that won't be necessary, of course, since you probably know lots more about it than I do.
smiley

Sure (as in we are looking at things from the biblical perspective essentially  wink )

While we can easily point to personal references to God the Father, we can also point to personal references to the Holy Ghost as your penultimate post acknowledged.

Now: is it more (or less for that matter) difficult to show from the Bible that the Holy Ghost is sentient than it is to show that the Father is sentient? That is the issue I was trying to point out.

We are generally talking about human conceptions and perceptions. As has been pointed out many times on this forum, often we are trying to box "God" within finite human perceptions/conceptions whereas God is transcendental and above and beyond human conceptions/perceptions.

Let us consider it: leaving Jesus out of it, can we paint a picture of what "God" (i.e. the Father) looks like? Can we paint a picture of how He can feel or exactly how he is sentient? Even as a force, how exactly does the Holy Spirit emanate from the Father? What part of the Father does the Holy Spirit emanate from? Or perhaps the Father Himself is spirit ---- in which case we come back to the need to explain how the Father is sentient?
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 12:29pm On Aug 07, 2010
We may also ask: is "God" the Father a personal sentient being? If we can show that "God" the Father is either not personal or sentient, then not only the idea of the Trinity is dead then the "Father" too cannot be "God"; we might as well say with Nietszche that God is dead.
Christianity EtcRe: Top 10 Reasons Why Jesus Christ Is Not God by Enigma(m): 10:06am On Aug 07, 2010
By the way, what single word can be used for "virgin" in:

1. Yoruba
2. Igbo
3. Hausa
Christianity EtcRe: Top 10 Reasons Why Jesus Christ Is Not God by Enigma(m): 9:29am On Aug 07, 2010
0@ italo

Don't let him mislead you; it is more complicated than that and even 'alma' does/can mean virgin. Do some more study on the subject. An example: the Septuagint which was compiled way way before the Christian era translates it to a Greek word that is widely reckoned to mean virgin ---- even though some will argue that even that word can be used e.g. to mean maiden.

EDITED I have found a link with a useful simplified discussion (though the discussion can be 'heavier or more 'scholarly')

http://www.secondexodus.com/html/jewishcatholicdialogue/virginbirth.htm
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 8:28am On Aug 06, 2010
@nuclearboy

Email sent. smiley
Satellite TV TechnologyRe: Official Thread Of Free To Air Satellite Tv (part 5 - The Final Part) by Enigma(m): 3:48pm On Aug 05, 2010
@ jossybless

Big congrats oooo; God bless you and yours.

cool
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 3:39pm On Aug 05, 2010
Deep Sight:
^^^ Hmm. E se o. Maybe someday I may be worth your time for a chat over a cup of tea.

Untill that day, now I am quite heavy hearted and must be bowed.
^^^ No problems; really, no hard feelings. I should be in Naija soon and I move in legal circles, so we might even meet without realising it.

Anyway, what I have expressed is my genuine assessment/judgment of the thread. I am not averse to discussing the Holy Spirit or the Trinity; indeed I was pursuing such a discussion with Kunleoshob recently, except that he pulled out. If my perception is that the discussion is a genuine attempt at either grappling towards the truth or a genuine attempt to understand my/the Trinitarian perspective, I may be happy to engage.

cool
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 3:24pm On Aug 05, 2010
Deep Sight:
Your aversion to open discussion is most telling. It both saddens and frightens me. There is something very frigteningly dictatorial about it. Persons who are willing to discuss their faith and seeming inconsistencies therein are democrats and open teachers. Persons who will brand a discussion as "contemptible" and refuse to engage in it simply because it refers to the ontology of the Holy Spirit, and proffers a view that a given ontology will be inconsistent with certain doctrines  - are certainly very intolerant of open discussion indeed.
Whatever.

I decide who I consider worth discussing what topic with and when. Actually, looking back over the thread someone made a good response very early on.

enitan2002:
when you personally think you an idea of a subject, why asking a question about it againhuh Cos i'm very sure any explanation different from your own definition wont be acceptable by you.
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 3:00pm On Aug 05, 2010
Oh, I agree with that; and funny enough there might be some good discussion out of it. I will keep out of it for the most part after this though.

cool
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 2:52pm On Aug 05, 2010
It is connecting that post that I quoted with the opening post of the thread that confirmed my own personal initial assessment that the thread is contemptible.
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 2:37pm On Aug 05, 2010
@Nuclearboy

Did you see this:

Deep Sight:
For the Trinitarians - once it can be shown that the Holy Spirit is conceived in scripture as a force and not a person. . .the entire trinitarian construct instantly collapses and must be and remain dead on arrival.
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 2:10pm On Aug 05, 2010
@ Deep Sight

No big deal; I will address issues as I see fit or comment as I deem apposite. I deem my comments in my two initial posts on this thread quite apposite and of course I will not hesitate to make such comments in future if I consider them apposite to the situation.

cool
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 1:54pm On Aug 05, 2010
@ Deepsight

Please point to where I have referred to you in derisive terms --- a link will do. What I know is that indeed I have deliberately ignored your posts even on occasions when you insulted me directly. I can find the links if you want.

Finally, what I wrote in my two earlier posts is what I genuinely believe about the discussions of certain topics on this forum ---- particularly in recent times.
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 1:31pm On Aug 05, 2010
Ah, I've actually been popping in and out of here. I will send the email a little later. smiley

And you are right that the nonsenses need to be countered by truth sometimes --- particularly to help and strengthen others who believe in the Trinity. Nevertheless, I still generally do not take these kind of posts/topics too seriously --- at least on this forum taking account what I know of/have read from some of the personnel.
Christianity EtcRe: Is The Holy Spirit A Personal Sentient Being? by Enigma(m): 1:14pm On Aug 05, 2010
As a Trinitarian, I never see the point of expending too much energy on this type of threads.

My people say: ọmọde ko mọ ogun, o npe l'ẹfọ!

On this type of issue, I usually leave the ignorant to be ignorant and the mocker to be mocker.
Christianity EtcRe: Speaking In Tongues by Enigma(m): 1:33am On Aug 01, 2010
@Viaguru

You'd better avoid that "church" like the plague; keep away from it! The "prophetess" is deluded and possibly a charlatan; her followers are ignorant or misguided.
Christianity EtcRe: Are You Commanding Your Mornings? by Enigma(m): 1:16am On Aug 01, 2010
http://www.hymnsite.com/fws/hymn.cgi?2062

1. I have found a friend in Jesus,
he's everything to me,
he's the fairest of ten thousand to my soul;
the Lily of the Valley, in him alone I see
all I need to cleanse and make me fully whole.
In sorrow he's my comfort, in trouble he's my stay,
he tells me every care on him to roll.
Refrain:
He's the Lily of the Valley,
the bright and Morning Star,
he's the fairest of ten thousand to my soul.  . . . . .
Christianity EtcRe: Are You Commanding Your Mornings? by Enigma(m): 1:06am On Aug 01, 2010
http://www.cyberhymnal.org/htm/t/h/y/thykicog.htm

Thy Kingdom come, O God,
Thy rule, O Christ, begin;
Break with Thine iron rod
The tyrannies of sin.

. . .

O’er heathen lands afar
Thick darkness broodeth yet:
Arise, O Morning Star,
Arise, and never set!
PoliticsRe: Hon. Patrick Obahiagbon Vs Pastor Chris Okotie by Enigma(m): 12:44am On Jul 31, 2010
They are both idiots.
Christianity EtcArmed Robber Abandons Raid After Shop Assistant's Sermon by Enigma(op): 6:04pm On Jul 30, 2010
[flash=500,400]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEvFVECuv1Q&amp;hl=en_GB&amp;fs=1" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed>[/flash]

Link to Story

ETA Miami Herald Report

A would-be armed robber who held up a mobile phone shop repented during the raid  and left as a rescued soul after a sermon from a Christian shop assistant.

Nayara Goncalves, 20, told the man calmly that God had better plans for him when he drew a gun and demanded cash from the till of the shop in Pompano Beach, Florida.

The fearless shop assistant even made the robber promise he would go back to church and turn his life around as he sheepishly left after listening to five minutes of preaching.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1298991/Armed-robber-Nayara-Goncalves-abandons-raid-shop-assistant-preaches-Christian-sermon.html#ixzz0vBbSSNSY
Christianity EtcRe: Benny Hinn Dating Paula White? ? by Enigma(op): 11:07am On Jul 30, 2010
Meanwhile apart from donating for his $2 million donor appeal, you can also buy your "prosperity prayer shawl" from Hinn's website for $50! They stop at nothing when it comes to fleecing the flock.
Christianity EtcRe: Top 10 Reasons Why Jesus Christ Is Not God by Enigma(m): 10:53am On Jul 30, 2010
@ italo

Well done for holding firm even though it seems hardly worth it with your 'opponents'! smiley
Christianity EtcRe: Benny Hinn Dating Paula White? ? by Enigma(op): 11:32pm On Jul 29, 2010
Even after the news broke, the knobhead had the gall to ask his victims, er, partners to give him 2 million dollars to cover deficit he claims to have suffered recently because people in some countries that he visited did not give. Apparently, he has now removed the appeal from his website after ridicule just as he has removed his denial of the Paula White affair.

From http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/global-filipino/world/07/29/10/televangelist-benny-hinn-asks-2-m-donation

Televangelist Benny Hinn is asking his prayer partners to donate $2 million to his ministry because of financial difficulties.

In a message in his website, Hinn said his ministry accumulated the $2 million deficit in the last few months because of the poor economy, which translated to fewer offerings in some of his crusades in different parts of the world.

He cited one crusade in Jakarta, Indonesia recently where his ministry lost money "because the people could not give."

Hinn, who built his ministry through massive healing crusades and TV shows, said Benny Hinn Ministries has cut down on staff and expenses amounting to $21 million since 2008.

He added that the $2 million deficit is not a large amount and that God could surely provide. He pointed out, however, that some of his vendors "are asking for their money. They have been very kind in helping us and standing with us, but the time has come for this deficit to be taken care of so that I can go on preaching the Gospel without pressure."

He then asked his prayer partners to sow a seed into his ministry so that the gospel would continue to be preached.

"Think about the impact, the negative impact it would have If I said, 'OK, I cannot travel anymore. The financial pressure is just too heavy on me. Let somebody else do it.' God would judge me. Secondly, think about the souls that would not hear the gospel. Is it really worth? Of course not. $2 million, that's nothing. God can do that," he said.
Christianity EtcBenny Hinn Dating Paula White? ? by Enigma(op): 6:02pm On Jul 29, 2010
I know this is gossip and I am breaking one of my own rules on trying to avoid focusing on personal relationships or morality per se of these televangelists/prosperity"gospel" people unless context requires it. However, I think the story/gossip is interesting enough!

The American rag National Enquirer reported on a romantic trip to Rome with pictures. See pictures here: http://twitpic.com/288cb8/full

However, both have "denied" 'immorality' or 'impurity' in their relationship. See story and denials here: http://www.cbn.com/cbnnews/us/2010/July/Evangelists-Hinn-White-Deny-Affair-Allegations/

If you read each "denial" carefully, you will see that they don't clearly deny that they are dating ---- just that there is no 'impurity' or 'immorality' in their relationship ----- yet (if you read Benny Hinn's carefully); and that is even if either of them can be believed.

While both Hinn, 57, and White, 44, have admitted to being friends for over two decades, both issued statements denying that there is anything inappropriate about their relationship.

"There is nothing inappropriate or morally improper about my friendship with Paula White," Hinn wrote in a message on his Web site.
In a statement issued on her Web site, White said she and Hinn have become closer since both have endured painful public divorces, but "our friendship has ,  Remained morally and spiritually pure."
Still, Hinn and White said in the future they would seek to avoid any appearance of impropriety.

"Because of my preeminent priority to my ministry and calling, Paula and I have concluded that we should avoid the appearance that our friendship is biblically impure or violates Scripture in any way," Hinn wrote.

He added that the two had "independently determined that we will have no further social relationship until such time as my divorce has concluded and only if we feel direction from the Lord to do so."
Christianity EtcRe: How Come Other Pastor In Christ Embassy Dont Work Mirracles Except Chris ? by Enigma(m): 9:01am On Jul 23, 2010
@ aletheia

You'd better leave him to his ways and hope and pray that he repents; also that he soon learns the difference between hope and false hope.

cool

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 (of 198 pages)