Lawani's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Lawani's Profile › Lawani's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 (of 277 pages)
Brendaniel:The budget was based on 75 dollars per barrel and 2 million bpd but price went to 60 and production at maybe 1.5 mbpd so there was a revenue shortfall. Previous governments would have devalued the naira massively but he resorted to non oil revenue. This year now benchmark is 60 dollars per barrel and total expected revenue from oil will be around 30 trillion naira but the budget is 58 trillion naira. This is the first budget in years that is not overly dependent on oil and it is based on last year revenue without the tax law. With the tax law I believe revenue will be close to 70 trillion naira with oil revenue inside it only 30 trillion. That is a move forward. Quarter one last year, oil revenue was only 25 percent of total. No presidency has ever managed to do that |
Kemetian:I agree that he is intelligent. What he has accomplished should be celebrated by all Nigerians |
Kemetian:A country can and should balance it's books. That is how it used to be in the past. If an individual should not be steeped in debt why should a country?. What the USA and others are doing is not the right thing |
Brendaniel:I am not in support of piling up sovereign debts. A government should balance it's books and have excess to invest in a swf. However if there is a project that needs urgent funding then debts can be understandable. I think revenue this year will be in excess of the budget. Therefore the government should be able to offset some of the debt if not all. What should be commended is that oil revenue is being relegated to the background |
Brendaniel:We don't know yet if they are going to take more loans but loan or no loans it is still a good development that the oil revenue has dropped as a percentage of government revenue. I believe all governments should spend less than their revenue. It is possible to be debt free. Sokoto state is debt free. However if you have an urgent project, loans too are not bad |
Beer drinking is not wrong but it should not be done excessively. A little drinking is good for your health |
Putinofrussia:It is not the North. Not only Northern states are depending on FG handouts. It is just an unfortunate situation caused by the military incursion into politics. All Governors that have led their states and LG chairmen that led their local governments without going after the revenue granted them by the constitution to bring change are to blame. What Tinubu is doing is what he did in Lagos. He is going after the revenue granted to the FG by the constitution and he may end up reducing oil income to less than ten percent of fg revenue. If I am a governor of a state or a LG chairman the majority of my revenue will be igr and not allocations. If there is enough non oil revenue in Nigeria the country will be more likely to break up because the oil revenue is the main thing holding the country together |
Putinofrussia:It seems Tinubu is about to turn Nigeria into a real country. Let's wait and see |
If you want your currency to be stable and be a reliable store of value then the majority of your government income must be in that currency and you must as a country have a high tax to GDP ratio. A high tax to GDP ratio means a higher revenue per Capita which means more money for government and less need for inflation. Inflation or money printing is a source of income for the government and if the government does not have revenue from tax then they will naturally resort to inflation. There is no magic to making a currency a hard currency. It is simply not printing it anyhow |
Putinofrussia:That is not always true o. There are companies owned by Oodua group existing for over 70 years and they are thriving. The Chinese government made over 300 billion dollars from state owned enterprises in 2024. |
Nigeria can not get more than twenty billion dollars from oil or thereabouts after all obligations met so it is not possible to lose a whole ten billion dollars when the price has not halved. Then Nigeria's oil is easier to refine because of low sulfur content and it is therefore in high demand. Twenty billion dollars is about thirty trillion so the 58 trillion budget is much bigger than oil money. Then oil money is falling rapidly as a component of fg revenue |
chariisGRACE:It appears even without the tax law the non oil revenue has overshadowed oil revenue |
Nigeria is free from oil dependence I read earlier from a lady in government that oil revenue is now less than half of government revenue in Nigeria and I wrote it like that during a debate with someone online only for someone to oppose me then for me to find out via AI that as at first quarter 2025 that oil revenue was less than 25 percent of total federal government revenue in Nigeria. Nigeria is officially no longer majorly dependent on Niger delta oil but on incomes from avenues like VAT, CIT, customs and etc. This is a good news that should be celebrated by all Nigerians. It explains why most states now have big budgets The country is a country of over 200 million and it can be like western Europe if it is organized like western Europe. There is nothing they do in Europe than everybody pay tax to make life easier for everybody. It is like what President Bola Tinubu did in Lagos he has successfully done it at Abuja. The feat was achieved without any special law. I project that with the new law, oil and gas revenue will become less than ten percent of federal government revenue by December 2026 and maybe less than one percent in two years
|
kaltonga:You think the surge in states allocation happened without any reason?
|
tctrills:I have read reports on 2025 data and oil is already less than 45 percent of federal government revenue and it will continue to go down
|
Sermwell:Don't you like a Nigeria where oil revenue is only five to ten percent of FG revenue that is being shared? |
AqualinaXYZ:Oil is now around 50 percent or less of FG revenue and it may reduce to twenty percent by year end as a result of FG revenue drive |
ozo13:South Africa is around 50 million people |
Brendaniel:If you are an average citizen, can you use 440 to plan your business? What you can use to plan is the true value of the naira not any phantom CBN rate |
Brendaniel:Are you saying Buhari was right by devaluing the naira and trying to fix the rate? When you devalue a currency you let it rest at it's true value |
Brendaniel:In Japan the chief owners of forex are companies like Toyota and etc. In Nigeria it is the FG. How will it possible for them to be starved of dollars?. |
Brendaniel:During Buhari time which one is the correct rate that someone in the economy without government connections must use? That one is the real rate than any other |
Brendaniel:Is the CBN using the market rate? You flood the economy with naira and you refuse to sell your oil dollars at what people are asking for it. You also go ahead to confiscate people's dollars by not allowing people to freely use domiciliary accounts. You sell dollars only to your cronies at 40 percent of what people are ready to pay. It was a swindle. They are printing naira recklessly but want to prop up the value |
Brendaniel:What is the real rate is what matters. Not what FG says. If one million people buys at 740 and ten thousand people bought at 350. What is the real rate?. What is the rate that matters to the average importer or exporter? |
Brendaniel:Buhari was using dual exchange rate and Tinubu stopped it. People with privilege were buying millions of dollars at 440 even 350 and crossing the street to sell it at 750. The dual exchange rate was in place in 2022 |
Brendaniel:You can't use 440 and be right in your calculation when maybe ninety percent of people were buying at 740. Let us leave it at that. You maybe right as I said because I don't know what agreement they had on how to share the funds saved from oil subsidy removal. In principle it is federal government money. I only used a few states to show that the dollar value of state budgets are rising. Then allocations to states will drop if the revenue drops and the revenue is like fifty percent oil money which can drop anytime. I don't know anything about how they agreed to share the money saved from oil subsidy removal |
Brendaniel:Ok. I was not quoting 2025 figures for Osun that I quoted. I did 2023 and 2026. If we use 2025 then what is the valid exchange rate for 2023? It was a dual exchange rate at the beginning of the year and 900 by June. In early 2023 more than seventy percent of those who needed forex will get it at 740 |
Brendaniel:Then I might be wrong because I don't actually know how they agreed to share the gains from oil subsidy removal. Federal government was borrowing money to pay the subsidy. It must also be realized that subsidy removal is not an increase in revenue but a reduction in government expenditure. The FG revenue is yet to increase but some expenditures has been removed. The revenue can sharply increase from the new tax law and that will automatically increase allocations to states. If there was no agreement on how to share the savings from subsidy removal then the FG will be right to keep the monies to itself since everybody is looking for money |
Brendaniel:Rivers budget in 2026 was not 1.4 trillion as you claimed but 1.8 trillion https://punchng.com/rivers-approves-n1-8tn-2026-budget/ |
Brendaniel:Dollar to naira in 2023. But this is something you can get yourself. Then there is no way the allocations would not have increased after the subsidy removal and if it does not increase can you blame anybody? Maybe the price of oil dropped. It is not something one person can do alone and the FG can not take more than it's percentage of revenue. It is a no brainier that allocations to states increased. If the President is pocketing the money saved from the subsidy removal and not giving states and local governments their constitutionally approved share who is to blame? Or how is that possible? Then the real exchange rate for 2023 was not 500 to one dollar. It was more like 700 on average. You can't even compare dollar value and be right because the forex market was not a free market as at early 2023.
|
Brendaniel:I am using AI too and market rate for dollar in 2023 was 700 while government rate was around 500. Did your AI tell you anything different? Bottom line is there no state whose budget has not increased substantially in dollar value since 2023. That is the point I am making. Osun was 200 million dollars in 2023 and 500 million dollars in 2026 if we use 500 to one dollar in 2023 and 1500 to one dollar in 2026. If we used the market rate for dollar in 2023 then the gap will even be wider. That is the point. Kano's budget 2023 350 billion which is around 700 million dollars if exchange rate is 500 Kano's 2026 budget is 1.47 trillion which is around one billion dollars today at exchange rate of 1500 |
Brendaniel:If I use 700 that was the rate in the open market then Rivers budget will only be some hundreds of millions of dollars and not close to one billion dollars but I closed it at one billion dollars using 500. You were wrong about Rivers 2026 budget. It is 1.8 trillion and not 1.4 trillion and that is like 1.3 billion dollars. Then Rivers state is not a state that depends on allocations. They have always had IGR. Use a state with insignificant igr |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 (of 277 pages)