PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 (of 287 pages)
tpaine:No, I don't think monotheism is superior to polytheism or the issue of superiority comes into it at all. Something is either true or it isn't. Most african societies believe that the world is populated by many spirits. Yet a distinction is made between the various spirits. What do you define as God. If as God you mean a primal cause, creator of all that exists, material and spiritual then Africans believe in one God. That is not to say they do not believe in the existence of other spirits. That is not to say they have not devised ways to engage and propitiate these other spirits. But is it the act of propitiation that makes them gods? If that is the definition of a diety, a being that is propitiated, then your Boss at work is also a god. If however a god is to be defined simply as a spiritual being then christianity too is polytheistic because it too is full of spiritual beings. In african societies the worship of a High God is not cultic. Rather cults are devised to engage with other spiritual forces, whether ancestral or otherwise. |
Good Question! Yeah, most Africa cultures that I'm aware of have always been monotheistic. Without doubt christianity has been used as a tool for imperialism. Last sunday Chinua Achebe talked on tele about how it was done and how in the mission schools they were made to feel that their parents were inferior and igbo culture was wrong. http://www.itv.com/PressCentre/TheSouthBankShow/Ep6AchebeandAdichieWk20/default.html However another very important question is whether religion is just merely a CULTURAL ARTIFACT or whether it is based on a more universal reality beyond culture. If it is just cultural then you should practice your religion as an affirmation of your culture. If it is more than cultural then it is important to explore what it is that gave rise to religion and why. |
huxley:And God Bless you in your endeavour. |
huxley:I don't disbelieve you Huxley. I reckon that not only do you dream Nairaland but you eat and breathe it too judging from the number of threads you've started up. |
huxley:LOL! You're such a joker! That was a conditional statement. IF christians are required to answer every question, then he would have failed. IF!!! And as regards stubborn children I think that you should be flogged thoroughly yourself for being such an obviously stubborn child. |
JJYOU:No, I do not believe that is a christian duty to answer any question asked of you. Otherwise even Christ failed miserably when asked by Pilate, 'What is Truth?'. No, What peter was talking about is if people ask us for the reason for our hope then we are adviced to be ready with the answer. I don't think the man's age is the reason for his hope. And on the subject of Duty, I believe that christians are each given an appropriation according to the spirit in them. It seems to me that Kunle is being inspired to speak about Tithes and it's abuse. That there are worse forms of extortion going on in the church has nothing to do with it. If you all feel so badly about the other forms of extortion then maybe that is your appropriation to speak out about those. However all that is happening now is rather than doing your part you are busying yourself with interfering with someone else doing his part. Kunle cannot solve all the problems in Christianity. He can only do that which has been apportioned for him to do. Everybody had their part to play. It's like a football game. The defenders have to defend, the strikers have to score. The playmakers have to create opportunities. Only the manager should busy himself with the overall strategy. When the striker, instead of trying to score busies himself with seeking faults with the defenders and the playmakers chances are that the entire team will lose the game. As it stands it sounds like a guy who gets pulled over by police for speeding and then he starts complaining that there are murderers and thieves out there and the police are wasting time arresting people for the relatively innocuous crime of speeding. That argument ain't gonna help him none. |
JJYOU:After thinking about this further, I've come to realise that it is quite a gem. A perfectly circular way of reasoning. Starting with the argument, we consider that such a poor argument can only be made by someone who is immature. So we determine the person's age to be quite young. If we then establish the age to be young we can then apply the ad hominem and say 'ah, small boy, no wonder he makes such poor arguments. And of course if we find the guy to be older than us then he is an agbaya. |
KunleOshob:Now, while I haven't actually done a statistical test to determine what percentage of churches preach compulsory tithes, it seems to me that at least 90% of the churches that I am familiar with, probably 98% of nigerian pentecostal churches make a big deal of tithes as a compulsory matter. And even those that do not say it is compulsory teach that there are special benefits to be accrued by the person tithing. Now, it could be that Pilgrim and others have not come into contact with these other churches that use tithes as a means of extortion. That is possible which would mean that the 2 sides of the argument are coming from two very different experiences so there is no common ground on which they could both argue from. I tend towards siding with Kunle because my experience of churches using tithes to extort tallies with his, but I can accept the possibility that others have never come across churches that do this. JJYOU: ![]() ![]() ?? It always puzzles me that people can read a text and tell whether the text is shouting or whispering. Some can tell the emotional state of the writer, probably even what he had for breakfast. Puzzling as that may be, it doesn't blow the mind so utterly as the blatant attempt to apply Ad Hominems by speculation. Obviously one's age is considered to be relevant to whether one can speak intelligently or not. Never heard of Old Fools, I guess. What about the biblical adage . . . Psalms 8:2: Out of the mouth of babes and sucklings hast thou ordained strength because of thine enemies, that thou mightest still the enemy and the avenger.Those that God inspires he inspires and the matter of age does not come into it at all, stop trying to cheapen this argument. Applying one's age to the validity of one's argument is an Ad Hominem and it is wrong. Actually it turns around and exposes the person using it to be arguing without foundation. |
My understanding of Matthew 23-9 is as follows: First the verse beginning with the word 'and' which is a conjunctive in english grammar. A conjunctive means that the following is to be read in conjunction with the preceding. In Greek the conjunctive is 'Kai' which is interpreted as 'and'. Even the previous verse also has a conjunctive word 'also'. '. . . also do not be called Rabbi' So what must it be read in conjunction with? The previous verses that precede it. abi? What are these verses addressing? People who like ostentatious titles and ranks to puff up their heads. And all their works they do to be seen of me[/b]n: for they make broad their phylacteries and enlarge the borders of their garments, and love the chief place in feasts and the first seats in the synagogues, [b]and salutations in the market-places, and to be called of men, Rabbi, Rabbi. So When Jesus says do not be called Father, teacher or master, he is basically saying do not be like those people who like to be called with titles. I recall one prominent pastor (I won't mention names) that I once called by his first name, after all he was a family friend long before he became a pastor. He just ignored me. Not realising anything wrong I thought maybe he hadn't heard me, I called again. Then one of his assistant pastors tapped my shoulder and whispered 'pastor' in my ear. I believe it is exactly this type of incident that Jesus was referring to. |
Enigma:I would add to that that it is important that people should be aware that there is no special blessing or advantage to be gained from being a Tither. And no curse on the guy who won't tithe. I fear that most people who are tithing do so because they feel that they will receive some benefit from the act, like even more money will come to them. |
[quote author=Negro_Ntns link=topic=48078.msg3855478#msg3855478 date=1242098381]I do too, I embrace the universal brotherhood but I know where and when to draw the boundary.[/quote]Where and when do you draw the boundary? It would help if you gave me an example. [quote author=Negro_Ntns link=topic=48078.msg3855478#msg3855478 date=1242098381]Europeans do not see the world the way the rest of the ethnic groups of mankind do. Europeans consider themselves the dominant race and everyone else must bow to their whims. If you don't they put a label on you and seek a way for your elimination. You will yield or you will be eliminated. It is evident throughout history, it is evident now and if you read the policies they are formulating into the future it is very obvious that they intend to continue this practice of exploitation and dominance. They did to India what they did to Africa except they did not ship their people onto a foreign continent as slaves.[/quote]I don't know about that. . . They practiced slavery in India too and shipped them to a different land, only they called it a different name. They called it Indentured Labour. Why do you think that there are so many Indian looking, and chinese looking, Jamaicans? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_indenture_system - Today China is slowly colonising Africa. It is only a matter of time with the rate they are buying up everything. The point I'm trying to make is that it is not due to European wickedness. An idiot that comes into money is only going to attract a whole load of sharks. And when China is done another people will come and do the same. Why not? Considering how stoopid africans are, who in their right mind won't take advantage. so China and India were subjected to slavery too, not to mention atrocities like the Opium war, but today they are mighty global powers. I don't see that turn around happening in Africa though. [quote author=Negro_Ntns link=topic=48078.msg3855478#msg3855478 date=1242098381]I am willing to take the discussion up with you. We should not call what the Europeans did slavery, a new name should be found to define the horror. I know it has historically been referred to as slavery, but no, it is far worse. They did not start slavery but they joined in and totally lost their mind and sensibilities and committed atrocities that the slavery institution under the customs of the African traders would never have allowed. Africa's progress is not contingent upon the study of slavery but rather on a change of philosophy. We practice religions that are completely un-natural to us, we speak and communicate in languages that lack spiritual rhythym with our nature,[/quote]No, I do not think that African ancestor's gave a damn about what happened to slaves or any such atrocities. They probably even encouraged the white man to be more oppressive. All one has to do is look at the record. Even today, look at how the leaders have no care for the people. This, it seems, is typical of africa. Could it be a congenital trait? I recall scandals where politicians allowed foreign nuclear fuel companies to dump their toxic wastes on africa soil, where people are living. Look at the rape of the Niger Delta. And these scandals are usually exposed by the White people, spoiling the show for the Africans that were benefiting from it. You know that most of the resistance to the abolition of slavery came from african chiefs who were making their living from the slave trade. The religion you practice won't make a difference. The religion is just an expression of the contents of your heart in the first place. If your heart is Black then your religion will be Black too. If your heart is full of canker then your religion will be full of canker. [quote author=Negro_Ntns link=topic=48078.msg3855478#msg3855478 date=1242098381]Look at Israel and their situation, who should they truly be upset with, Arabs or Europeans? The Arabs have not killed one third as many claimed to have been slaughtered in Germany. So, yes I believe in universal brotherhood and I understand the history of slavery in ways that many people do not and because of my understanding and enlightenement in this area, , I have choosen to embrace my ancestry and heritage above that of a race of people that seek to destroy me in the name of democracy. Don't carp on me for loving my heritage, without it I won't be who I am.[/quote]I'm not saying that you should not love your heritage. I am saying that you do not need to embellish it with talk of quantum physics just because it sounds impressive. Such an attitude seems to belies a deeper insecurity, or maybe even inferiority complex. It sounds as if you are compensating by making Ifa out to be quantum mechanics. I think it is important that Ifa stands or falls on it's own terms. It doesn't need to be pegged to science via such an extreme contrivance. I think it is important to take the Truth however you find, bitter or sweet. If Ifa is Rubbish then let us accept that it is rubbish, but if there is any good stuff in it then let us accept that to. It is not because it is what our ancestors followed that we must accept it whether right or wrong. p.s those guys you quoted, Awo Fatunbi is a white man. |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=264092.msg3861263#msg3861263 date=1242211524]I find your answers answersory. You were set to follow a career in the church?Interesting.As a priest? And you were distracted by global religion and man's spiritual experiences. How so? I'd think these would re-enforce your commitment to pursuing your career. Or you felt dedicating yourself only to Christianity would be too confining in the light of all the religions out there?[/quote]Now you are probing too deep, and I'm actually a coy guy. There were other distractions too, but I'm not going to go in to them. . . . Sooooooo what was it that we were saying about christians and the Pharisees . . . . ? |
OLAADEGBU:Not knowing the number of women and children any speculation would just be wild nonsense. |
I believe it is 600, 000 Israelites that leave Egypt. |
Bastage:Where are you? |
Did you all check this link: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bible/program.html It throws a lot of research light on what you're talking about. |
[quote author=Negro_Ntns link=topic=48078.msg3846767#msg3846767 date=1241922881]Pastor, I am sure you have read about Homer. The myth sorrounding Homer is deeply ingrained in European classics. Yet when you read his series or watch the plays you will instantly recognize that there are institutions in Europe that protect the history of their classic arts and mythological figures. They have woven what is grandeur and noble about their ancestry and sold it to the world as civilization. Unfortunately Africans do not have that. I am not one to herald the errors of my ancestors. I cherish their memories and wish to promote it as a lofty and noble ending, however way progeny chooses to judge them; and because I am an ideologue, I choose instead to find fault and flaws in the history and myths of Shakespeare, Homer, Van Gogh, and the rest of those falsehoods sold to us as civilization and path to salvation.[/quote]I lay claim to the entire heritage of Human culture and creativity. I don't care whether it is Chinese, European, African or South american aborigines. They all have something to teach me and I embrace it all. One of the biggest problems with Africa and africans is our inability to make objective self criticisms. To much kowtowing to ancestral this and ancestral that. When you place these things above criticism you destroy them or render them useless eventually. I'm sick and tired of hearing about 'How Europe Underdeveloped Africa'. Are africans so stupid that someone is going to come from outside to underdevelop them? Why didn't Europe underdevelop China or India, if Europeans are such destructive people? I've brought this point up several times but no one's taken the bait, but I'll repeat it again. I don't think Africa is going to develop anywhere until there has been a proper symposium to discuss Why the Slave Trade Occurred in the first place. It is important to bear in mind that the slave trade has been going on before the Europeans came to africa by boat. We were selling ourselves to the Arabs en masse for centuries. Until a proper study has been made of this historical phenomenon, I don't think africa is going anywhere, but backwards, no matter how much you talk it up with claims about quantum mechanics or whatnot. |
huxley:The reward is Status and acceptance within the group. |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=264092.msg3845196#msg3845196 date=1241888616]And what are your religious beliefs? Yes, I know people ask that and the moment you answer they put you in a box and think they know everything about you. I'm merely curious. Are you a Buddhist?[/quote]you don't ask simple questions, do you? I don't think that I fit into any of the boxes that are out there. I believe in the Oneness of the Truth, yet this Truth has been articulated variously by various cultures at various times in history. When we add to this the fact that religion is a powerful tool used by Social Engineers to control societies then we find that we can account for pretty much all the diversity that we find in world religions. To the extent that I do not actually belong to any Buddhist group, then No, I'm not a buddhist. I'm not a convert to Judaism either (though I like to interact with jews), and I am not a babalawo. Neither am I hindu nor muslim. No group of people that bear these names would recognise me as a member. I was baptised and raised a christian and was set to follow a career in the church but I got distracted. I actually find the word christian, as an identifier of someone's religious beliefs and practices, to be a meaningless term. Telling me that you are a christian tells me next to nothing about what it is you believe in and how you live. There is too much of a diversity amongst those laying claim to the term. I hope you've found my answers satisfactory. |
These are interesting for further research: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bible/program.html Especially chapter 3. This is interesting too: http://www.icejusa.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=9431&news_iv_ctrl=0 |
[quote author=Negro_Ntns link=topic=48078.msg3843130#msg3843130 date=1241839430]KO, On the other side of physical, you have metaphysical. This will be like comparing conscious activities to unconscious ones. For example, in conscious activity you can exercise willpower to activate your mechanical mobility. In unconscious activity you can walk or run or climb but your physical body is in no way involved in the activities because it remains mechanically motionless. This is the case when you are awake versus when you are asleep and you have a dream of running after someone or someone running after you. You are the primary driver when you are awake, your spirit is the principal driver when you are asleep. You have two different states of interaction experienced by the same individual. We believe in the power of Ifa as a divine decree and the practitioners did not exploit or seek to extract its material value, probably because in the wisdom of our fore fathers, doing that might introduce greed that will then lead to impropriety amongst mankind. Physical sciences on the other hand and in its applications is an avenue for acquisition and hoarding of material knowledge and wealth to the disadvanatage and sometimes elimination of a competitive opponent. Ifa practitioners view themselves as custodians of universal power and this duty carry responsibilities that may not align well with the interest to destroy or harm mankind. Quantum physics is a race for advantageous hand and does not concern itself with a divine code of honor.[/quote]I think that you have an overly lofty opinion of our forefathers and Ifa practitioners. Greed needs no introduction to african societies, present and ancient. In fact Greed is very much at home and a familiar guest with our ancestors. How else do you explain 400 years of transatlantic slavery, and 1000 years of trans-saharan slavery? I believe that Ifa would be related to physics to the extent that physics is a part of the functioning of the world and Ifa philosophy encompasses and concerns itself with the World, both spiritual aspects and material. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=263218.msg3844204#msg3844204 date=1241872118]Lol, people deride 'tithes' simply because they don't like the word, not because it sends them to the grave. Understandably, anti-tithers would ferret all kinds of excuses that cannot stand up to face value when closely examined. Is it not funny that it is the anti-tithing professors who are calculating all sorts of figures for the word 'tithe'? And when, for the sake of argument, we agree with such inferences, they immediately abandon their own arguments. Na wah! ![]() Okay, we say 'tithe' is 10%; but anti-tithers say "that is not true," and they holla back with anything from 23% to 40%. Wetin we go do again? If we then go on to say that anything one sets apart from their income is also a percentage, wahala go start again!Anyways, make una enjoy.[/quote]. . . But to be fair, I don't think that Kunle used Tithe to mean 23 percent or more. |
[quote author=m_nwankwo link=topic=268896.msg3839495#msg3839495 date=1241783997]I absolutely agree with your statement Pastor!!![/quote]Thank you! It is a demonstration of spiritual underdevelopment to regard the Will of God to be encoded in one religion's rituals whether it is Christian, muslim, or Hindu. God's will as respect to an individual is very specific towards that individual. That individual will only find it encoded within himself or herself and obedience and adherence to that which s/he finds within is the only way to obey God and come close to God. To the extent that a religions codes and mores can be a guide and a pointer to the Will of God, it can also be a distraction and an obstacle. Not to mention the tedium of the endless squabbles between various religious factions. |
O boy! I've always thought that 'Tithe' was an old english word meaning a Tenth. I think we're conflating that with the act of giving in general. When the Jews are requested to bring a tithe of their agricultural produce to eat before God that is quite specific and does not refer to other taxes and offerings that they might also bring. Perhaps it would be easier to scrap the word Tithe altogether because it seems to be a meaningless term now. When people start tithing more or less than 10 percent it's like people being ferried across the river in an helicopter! To ferry across the river would presumably require a ferry, ie a boat, not an helicopter. Similarly to give a tithe would require 10 percent, not 40 percent. Many words change their meanings in very subtle ways, especially old words, and we need to be careful we don't conflate things when we read old texts like the bible. It is common in the english language for nouns to slowly become verbs. So instead of 'taking the bus to the other side of town' people now 'bus it to the other side of town'. Or in the above example, instead of taking the ferry across the river, we ferry across the river. Similarly with tithes, a tithe is actually a noun that has become a verb 'to tithe'. This it seems is what has opened the door to all sorts of confusion. |
Who is obeying God is obeying God, whether or not they are muslim or christian. It is not what you call yourself that will determine whether you are obeying God or not. |
Please anyone that is unsure as to where to pay their tithes, both pastors and laymen, should send a cheque addressed to me to my address. I shall post the relevant details soon. Cheers. |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=264092.msg3834207#msg3834207 date=1241691822]I know Judaism and Christianity shared the same historical backdrop. I didn't think they had anything else in common. What doctrines did Judaism and early Christianity share?[/quote]I already answered this earlier in the thread but I'll repeated it again: [b] -Jesus was a Rabbi and taught in the Synagogues. This is what the Pharisees did. - Jesus actually endorsed them (ideologically) when he tells us to do as they preach because they sit on the seat of Moses. He only tells us not to do as they do, because even they do not do as they preach. - Jesus also demoted the importance of the Temple as the Pharisees did. He told the samaritan woman that God would be worshipped neither in the temple nor on the mountain. He dismissed the magnificence of the temple saying one day not one stone will be found on top of another. This was a typical pharisee attitude. Actually it was found more so with the Essenes, but the pharisees had a similar attitude. - the Christian doctrine that we are all priests is a pharisee doctrine. The laws of cleanliness that they upheld were originally actually only meant for the levites and priesthood initially but they interpreted it apply to all the israelites, a people to be set apart for God. The Pharisees believed that the idea that all of the children of Israel were to be like priests was expressed elsewhere in the Torah, for example, when the Law itself was transferred from the sphere of the priesthood to every man in Israel (Exodus 19: 29-24; Deuteronomy 6: 7, 11: 19; comp. 31: 9; Jeremiah 2: 8, 18:18). Moreover, the Torah already provided some ways for all Jews to lead a priestly life: the precepts concerning unclean meat were perhaps intended originally for the priests, but were extended to the whole people (Leviticus 11; Deuteronomy 14:3-21); the prohibition of cutting the flesh in mourning for the dead (Deuteronomy 14: 1-2, Leviticus 19: 28; comp. Lev. 21: 5). The Pharisees believed that all Jews in their ordinary life, and not just the Temple priesthood or Jews visiting the Temple, should observe rules and rituals concerning purification. -And indeed Paul's letters are full of Pharisee doctrines. (This very same Gamaliel it was that Paul claimed with pride was his teacher. ) -When asked what was the greatest of the laws Jesus responded that it was the Shema. That is 'hear o israel . . . '. This is pharisee doctrine as taught by Hillel the grandfather of Gamaliel, probably the most influential pharisee ever. And I would add to that also very importantly the belief that there were two adams. There are just too many similarities when you look closely at it. [/b] [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=264092.msg3834207#msg3834207 date=1241691822]I see you've gone from wondering if Christ was a Pharisee to concluding that he was. How did you know he was one? If he was, why does he speak about the pharisees from the outside looking in,why did they have to meet him in public or ambush him to challenge; why isn't there an instance where his departures from standard doctrine were addressed in the council to which he belonged? If he was one of their own and he erred, surely they would deal with him first as a pharisee subject to the laws of the council?[/quote]I consider it as conclusive as it can get considering that I'm not actually an eyeball witness, and Jesus didn't tell me personally that he is a pharisee. I'm making my conclusion from the evidence available. How do I know he was one? Well the examples I gave above are a good start. There is nothing to suggest to me that Jesus spoke of the pharisees as an outsider looking in. Like I said earlier the Pharisees practiced self criticism as part of the tradition. It evolved according to a dialectic, usually between the two schools of Hillel and Shammai. The Talmud, a pharisaic book makes similar criticisms of pharisees as Jesus makes, denouncing ostentatious displays of piety etc. Why wasn't Jesus' departures from doctrine brought to a council? Because there were no departures of doctrine. Jesus did not say anything contrary to pharisee tradition. Absolutely nothing. As regards the ramifications. Well there are so many. Which ones would be considered pertinent would depend on the context. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=264092.msg3834207#msg3834207 date=1241691822]Because we know a little science it's the pastime of some to acribe all religion to ancient superstition and laugh it to scorn.And of course, there is superstition. But there's also far more than that. One cannot tell a Yoruba shaman that his 'gods' does not exist; he would rightyly consider one foolish,superior and ignorant,because he knows better. You cannot tell Shirley Mclane and her New Age friends there isn't an extra dimension, because they're adepts at separating their body/ brain from their spirit/brain. You can't tell Tibetan monks nothing survives bodily death, because they travel out of their body, and are adept mystics. You can't tell the myriad of Princeton,Stanford and Harvard professors,initial atheists who changed their tunr after self experimenting with the occult (they self-experiment because they didn't really expect anything to happen but it did) and discovered the ancient Babylonians had it right.[/quote]Tell me about it . . . ! But it's still gonna come back to bite them on the ass, all these 'rationalists'. It is one thing to experience something and say 'there's got to be a rational explanation' and therefore leave it as unexplained phenomena . . . . . . . But it is quite another thing to deny that the experience is even possible at all. When they do that these so called 'scientists' have overstepped their mandate from explain phenomena to actually messing with the data by saying that such and such phenomena cannot ever occur. [quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=264092.msg3834207#msg3834207 date=1241691822]So yeah, one would expect diverse religions to have layers in common;they're human attempts to connect with 'god', and each interperetes his own experiences differently, something founding religious philosophy on nothing but. I'm not sure, but I don't think Hinduism teaches reconciliation with God. Isn't it karma and Nirvana for the happy Hindu?[/quote]Diverse religions do have a great deal in common and this is why I keep saying that if religion was a mere invention by lying clerics then not only are they liars but altogether they show very little imagination. There are too many similarities that if these people were making it up surely there should be a lot more diversity in the religions. Every language had a word for cloud. Why? I would imagine it is because clouds exists and not because they invented the idea of clouds independently. Nirvana or Nibbana is a Buddhist concept. Karma is just the Law of Causality. Cause and effect. It is the belief that every event, every action is connected to every other event in a fixed relationship called the Law of Karma. Both Buddhists and Hindus belief in Dharma. What is Dharma?from here: http://www.hinduism.co.za/dharma.htm#What%20is%20Dharma? |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=263218.msg3830529#msg3830529 date=1241622666]No, I don't see a contradition between those verses, and it would be obvious as soon as you look carefully before making flat statements. May I look forward to your kind attempts to draw a coherence between them, or you'd just like to leave it at the fact you didn't answer the question? I'm sure you could do better than the terse "figure it out yourself", yes? Cheers.[/quote]I'm curious to know how you reconcile these apparently contradictory verses. Me personally, the only way of reconciling them from my perception is that the Levites did have their own cities but where they migrated and lived amongst the other israelite tribes they were not allowed to own property in those towns. The citizens of those towns had to provide for them. This was probably done to mark out the levites as a people separated unto God. They also had to undergo purification rites that the other Israelites didn't go through. However having said that, to get back to the topic of this thread, it doesn't change the fact that tithes are foodstuff and supposed to be eaten in God's presence. That is what Tithes really mean. The meal is used to feed also those without possessions in the city. This practice does not occur in any contemporary christian church that I'm aware of. Tithes are here used to fill up the coffers of the already rich. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=263218.msg3829606#msg3829606 date=1241613878]Could someone who contemptuously easily dismisses the subject please share their thoughts on what Paul was referring to in 1 Corinthians 9:13-14. If some prefer, here are those verses as rendered by the NLT - [list]"13 Don’t you realize that those who work in the temple get their meals from the offerings brought to the temple? And those who serve at the altar get a share of the sacrificial offerings. 14 In the same way, the Lord ordered that those who preach the Good News should be supported by those who benefit from it."[/list] What did Paul mean by quoting the OT and saying "in the same way" in order to encourage Christian giving?[/quote]There are two points that leap out at me here. The first is that I don't think Paul was referring to tithes at all. And secondly, christians believe themselves to be members of the priesthood. Subsequently as the priests shared in the eating of the sacrifices so also all christians share their sacrificial meal. A third point has just occurred to me. Many christians consider evangelism to be a great commission extended to all christians. This blurs the lines between those who preach the gospel and those who benefit from it. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=261892.msg3829516#msg3829516 date=1241613062]You're mistaken.[/quote]Is s/he mistaken about the way you talk or about the fact of whether you are a tithe collecting (im)poaster. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=263218.msg3829484#msg3829484 date=1241612792]@Pastor AIO, I don't know if the life of a believer is determined by "small details", though I don't think they should be discarded out of hand. The point is that it is not in the small details of legalism that the NT discusses or encourages giving, even though the apostles quoted copiously from the OT Law to teach giving for Christians. On the other hand, I don't know how many Christians would draw a parallel in "awuf" and the Lord's Supper, if we can understand that they're not the same things. However, although it seems more probable that early Christians enjoyed such fellowships of 'feast of love' (or 'agape feast' as it's commonly called - Jude 12), yet some may be misled to think it is the same thing as the Lord's Supper. As for the awuf type of fellowship nosh, I know several churches which have such expressions often in areas I've visited.[/quote]My tongue was in my cheek when I said 'small details'. I don't think it is a small detail at all. And I don't think it is only an act of charity either. It has spiritual repercussions. Sharing a meal dedicated to a diety is a practice that is recognised in almost every religious tradition in the world. It is rooted in the belief that nourishment is a sacred act. |
huxley:Huxley, I doubt you've written the above in order to help Christians find their way again. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 (of 287 pages)


If we then go on to say that anything one sets apart from their income is also a percentage, wahala go start again!