So...its now a question of relative magnitude of fuel subsidy...versus "one off expenses"?
Interesting that in this back and forth over subsidies - whenever waste in government is exposed and/or challenged, the response by the pro-government team is that "the waste is miniscule relative to fuel subsidies"...or "it is a one-off expense compared to fuel subsidies". Well...if we add up all these "one-off" expenses (federal contingent to COP 28, federal delegation to UNGA, presidential yachts, renovation of the presidential and vice presidential palaces, official vehicles for the First Lady's office, official vehicles for lawmakers etc.) that pervade public expenditure in Nigeria...these one "one-offs" don't look so miniscule anymore.
Since we are going empirical, I would suggest you do the numbers on "one-offs" for this year and the last...so that we know exactly how much this country has lost to these "one-off expenses". Good luck with that, sir. There's a reason why the numbers (N560 billion monthly) on fuel subsidy are readily available...and the numbers on wasteful federal government spending are not.
The point that needs to be made here is that Nigerians are being taken for a ride - and some of us know it. Something isn't adding up when Mr. Wazobia can't afford to buy fuel for his motorcycle...and he hears that the president's son flew in an official aircraft (using free fuel!) to Kano to watch a polo tournament. Something isn't making sense when Miss Egokudiowo can't afford to buy food...and she hears that the federal government sponsored hundreds of delegates to a climate change conference in the UAE.
Some of us predicted these blunders and missteps because we knew. We knew that BAT belongs to the "rules for thee but not for me" school. The failure of his administration is inevitable.
I don't disagree on some of your core points. Of course, there is a "one rule for you and another for me" mentality that is apparent. BAT has never been the kind of altruistic politician to do otherwise but that has never been a genuine contention. Why? Because the same is true for all the other major candidates. So to me, this is a moot point. Peter Obi is often touted as the "good" guy but I think that is just his PR approach to politics,
Being a fringe politician in terms of national politics in his run-up to the presidency would have known that he could not afford to be as brazen about his corruption as the others so he was more careful and covered his tracks but ultimately, as with most misdeeds, he's eventually been exposed. I'm sure you know of the accusations of money laundering, foreign accounts and all that so no need to get into here.
With this as a premise, the only question for me is, can this person who is simultaneously having the time of their life also work and make things better for Nigerians? Of BAT and Obi we could have answered in the affirmative to varying degrees. Atiku on paper had better policies but is actually a deceptive character.
So all along I have said I am for Sowore but I don't mind if any of the three get into office. Now that BAT has made it there is no point constantly seeking to undermine his government. This can be easily mistaken for being a pro-government stance. Nope! It is a pro-Nigeria stance, and occasionally, anti-Obidient (not Obi particularly), and so I have no problem agreeing with you that indeed this government is alarmingly fiscally irresponsible at a time when the common man is being asked to tighten his belt.
Does that mean they will eventually fail to at least move Nigeria from point A to B in some ways? I wouldn't agree with that assessment.
IGBOSON1: Not surprised this thread didn't get past page one and has just a handful of comments, as it doesn't say what anti-Igbo bigots want to read! Those who would have driven this thread to ten pages with inane arguments and back-and-forth are presently camped on the anti-Igbo Reno threads arguing which ethnicity put on pant first during the colonial era; a more topical issue!
You have not added any value to this thread, rather complaining that no one is here to fight with you. What is your own take?
This does not tell us whether it was the police or the army or the airforce or the navy or the NSCDC that is being referred to. But even in the BBC link you shared it is obviously only the army that is explicitly directly accused of shooting protesters.
I guess you don't get my point here. I am replying a poster who justified the killings of policemen because security forces fired on protesters. And I am saying why retaliate on the police who never fired are protesters?
wirinet: Since you understand the subsidy regime better than me and most Nigerians, can you explain how it worked? What happened to the crude oil swap regime that had been in place for decades before this government stopped it when it came to power?
How was it that the NNPC was paying for petrol, paying N160 billion monthly for subsidies and at the same time in a crude oil swap agreement with refineries abroad, whereby NNPC gives them crude and they give us refined petroleum products in return and keep the condensates and other byproducts as payment.
What does any of this have to do with what i posted?
wirinet: Nigeria cannot afford it, but Nigeria can afford to pay our legislators the highest salaries and emoluments in the world. Nigeria cannot afford it, but can afford to buy a car worth N160 million for each legislature, Nigeria cannot afford it, but can afford to afford to renovate the presidential and vice presidential Lodge for N7 billion. Nigeria cannot afford it, but it can continue to expend over 70% of our budget (mostly borrowed) on a few civil servants and politicians, while the remaining 30% that was to be spent on the rest of us is still stolen. Maybe you are one of the very few elite gaining from the corrupt system.
My comment is best understood in the context of what I was replying to. I never argued that it was right or wrong - I merely challenged a core premise of that person's argument. That does not necessarily mean the conclusion is wrong, but he has to adjust his workings first.
It is important to comprehend before you argue though I know most nairalanders just love to argue as a form of self-expression.
In any case, even if one were to address your arguments, however off point, the government says they were spending 560 billion monthly on subsidies. Add up all those things you listed there most of which are one-off expenses and they won't reach half of this amount - which is even monthly. We were spending trillions on subsidies annually.
Finally, it is possible for it to be simultaneously true that Nigeria cannot afford subsidies and that the little we have is still mismanaged.
EleventhWeirdo: I understand that subsidy regimes are massive corruption structures that scare away free market investors, and that removing them is like freeing self of a bottleneck. But the problem is that, I don't think any underdeveloped country can develop by playing the good boy of the economics textbook of IMF and other Breton woods. I suppose we need a combination of positive, ironclad, interventional and massive government machinery and a merit based, development -hinged private enterprise to achieve true development. Even the American govt, the leader of the developed world, is still subsidizing some of it's industries and nurturing them for international competition/national self sufficiency. Why would we discard the much needed public -private partnership model on the basis that we cannot defeat and remove the abuses that come with it?
Very reasonable comment but you got one thing wrong in your last sentence: the basis of the removal according to the current regime is that Nigeria cannot afford it. That changes the dynamic of what you've addressed in your post considerably.
Do you know there is a difference between the police and the army? Look at the topic above: it is about the police. Look at the comment you replied to: it is about the police. Didn't you notice all this before you sent me a video about the army?
I am aware of allegations of army atrocities and I think the claims of human rights abuses against them are well-established. This topic is about the police though. If you say it was the army that killed unarmed protesters, why are you retaliating against the police?
Lagos is practically brimming with all kinds of environmental pollution. Lagos has no place in a discussion of climate change.
It's a lot like inviting a virgin to give a talk on sex positions to prostitutes.
What do you think they do at climate change forums? Give lectures?? They gather to negotiate ways of reducing climate change while mitigating the economic impacts of change efforts - and in that context, places heavily affected by pollution are actually the most relevant participants.
Ogene001: When you shot unarmed protesters you taught it was fun. Shebi una don dey cry now
When did police shoot unarmed protesters??
Police have done a lot of evil, and they have killed so many innocent Nigerians; but one thing they hardly do is shoot protesters openly. Except for SARS though. Regular anti-riot police would rather fire teargas tire before using a live bullet on protesters.
SweetBuns: They say that "beauty is in the eyes of the beholder", but honestly speaking there are certain calibres of men I will never go near no matter how hard they try.
To get straight to the point,
1. Short men Oh my God.... I don't just know what to say about these sort of men. If I'm taller than you as a girl, then sorry but I can never see you as my second piece. You'll always be like a younger brother to me. No hard feelings. Short men also have this irritating attitude whenever they see girls around, as if they're trying to compensate for their low height. And some even go to the gym and gets muscles.... But it just makes them look shorter like a 5 litre jerry can and irritating Also, why in the world would I pick a short guy over a tall guy? I literally feel so protected and safe when I'm with a guy that is wayyyy taller than me (I'm 5'2 so my height is kinda average)... So ofc I'd want a tall man and not a mini man. Imagine hugging a man and he's hugging your waist cause he's short ugh. I wanna stand on my toes whenever I kiss him and strain my neck just to look at his face. No more no less. Tall men also stand out more, they're far more attractive and I also want taller sons and daughters. Who should the short guys date then? I dunno... But not me. The bar starts at 6'0, but If you're like 6'2 or 6'3... I want your babiesss
2. Bald men The only age where I think baldness is acceptable as a man for me is if he's like in his 50s or 60s. But if you're in your 20s-30s and you're already going bald.... It just irritates me low-key in a inexplicable way... Like why will a young guy have a hairline that receeds all the way to the middle or back of your head? Where did all your hair go? Gross I also read somewhere that early balding is genetically inherited so that means my children too will suffer the same fate? God forbid. My man ought to have a head full of hair well into his 60s, then we start talking about hair loss.
3. "Oju yo Bo" people I didn't know the English term for this so I had to Google it. It's a Yoruba term for people whose eyes pop out of their sockets like that of a wall gecko. This is also something I don't like in my man.... I want his eyes to be like that of Henry Cahill... Neatly tucked inside and having small slit like opening.
Addition: so I just googled it and it's called prey eyes. I prefer the hunter one since it gives my man a piercing gaze and I just wanna hug him immediately.
4. Eyebrows A man MUST have thick eyebrows. If you don't, I can't take you seriously
5. Men with bad posture
6. Men who supports man U
That last one was a joke but I'm dead serious about the rest. And I'm sure other girls will agree to some up there too.
Do you know you have a very manly looking face? Unless that's not you.
Whether he is lying or telling the truth the fact that he can articulate to himself the wisdom of investing in real estate tells me he is not the total nutjob he is being portrayed as.
But I already knew that. Just judging by one or two things, it's clear his madness is just his brand.
I find it so unreasonable to spend anything more than times 3 of my monthly income on a wedding. Whatever my income is, my maximum budget for a wedding is times three of that sum, whatever that may be at the time, or in the alternative, no more than one third of my savings.
Anyone who doesn't like it can find someone else to marry.
People are out here spending their life savings on a wedding when they could have started a business or taken some other life-changing decisions.
Marriage that 7 out of 10 times they end up hating each other within 2 years.
observanc1: how will a constitutional requirement be a formality?
As I understand it, the constitutional requirement is that the Budget should be presented before the Assembly, which is what was done, not that it should be physically submitted at that particular moment. Can you shed more light?
I know most people don't understand what this piece of news is really about.
What has happened here is that there is a pending Court case involving a specific area in Festac. The case has been going on for some time before now. Now, the Court has just ruled that no more demolitions should take place in this particular area until the final determination of the suit which could go against either party.
Key points:
1. The area affected is not all of Lagos. It is just one part of Festac.
2. This is not a final judgment. It only applies until the final determination or judgment of the Court in the pending case.
Shoodboi: They will soon claim it was Hamas, watch them. In the same Jerusalem where there are no Palestinians. The same Jerusalem fully controlled by Israel. The same Jerusalem where Israel has soldiers and tanks all over. Watch them, they will soon say it was Hamas. They've even identified the shooters as Palestinians. How did they know the dead men are Palestinians? Dead people o.
Jerusalem is shared between Israel and Palestinians.
Petmayor: With an increasing middle-class population and a robust economy, the country's demand for air travel is surging.
Where the hell are these foreign media getting these false narratives about Nigeria? Increasing middle-class bawo?
Reality: Nigeria Middle class falling into poverty/low class on daily basis.
Nigeria has a huge middle class and always will and its easy to see why. Poor economic conditions don't affect producers much because they simply pass on the cost to consumers.
If you're producing something people need, there'll always be high demand and when this is coupled with a huge consumer population, you get the idea.
I see the difficulty here - well the truth is such transactions will appear suspicious because round-tripping is a typical money laundering operation.
The one thing she should have no fear of is whether the Uni will hold her money. They will surely refund it though they may start to charge for the inconvenience.
It seems that some of us have not really understood what the government is. The government has no business building houses for state functionaries. We also have to look at the macro and micro effects of this policy. So you built houses, furnished them, and handed them over to judges to live in. Now what? It's important to remember that houses deteriorate and need regular maintenance, which Nigeria and Nigerians often fail to do.
So, how about building a responsive and responsible civil service like we had before this crop of rent-seeking politicians happened to us?. Pay workers at all levels a responsible living wage. Let them go to the banks and take out mortgages to build homes for themselves.
They will maintain it properly because it is their and their children's inheritance, and the micro and macro effects of this investment and related activities are huge and very positive for the economy of the country.
Governance must trickle down to all citizens, regardless of class. What we are witnessing is selective patronage of those they use and will use in the near future. A clear prerequisite for state capture.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with the government building and maintaining quarters for state functionaries. It is in fact prudent to do so since commercial house rent will come at a premium and will always increase, making it far costlier over the long run, whereas government-owned quarters have been paid for once and for all and will only require maintenance. It's a more pragmatic approach so far as the facilities are well maintained, and all that is required is the allocation of a budget to that, or for allocatees to maintain them on their own.
Your opening statement has no nexus on the following arguments, btw, since you failed to provide your own definition of government in a way that explains why the government has no business building basic facilities for its officers.
It's also not clear what governance trickling down to all citizens has to do with the post. Are you suggesting that until the government builds houses for all citizens it shouldn't build for high-ranking judicial officers?? If not, do clarify what your point is here, in relation to the general subject of housing for judicial officers.
googi: I can understand building Public Housing for President, Governors and their Vice. Barracks for Police, Army and Navy.
Why not build public houses for the poor and working class like Jalande?
So Presidents and governors deserve housing but Judges who are paid poorly yet determine the fate of the nation don't deserve housing? Do you know that no judge earns up to 1 million naira per month? What am I saying? The average pay for judges is probably around 500k with senior magistrates earning less even as inflation soars. Let's be serious.
Chetas81: I CAN SEE MANY STUPID NAIRALANDERS FIGHTING EACH OTHER OVER THIS POST, LACK OF SINCERITY EVERYWHERE
The funniest part is that any one of them stopped to read the post they would have seen that the message has nothing to do with the Oba and their imaginary tribal war. The message is to Edo people to refrain from acts that would tarnish th image of the state.
Racoon: Even the riff-raff too is talking? What value does Tony Kabaka contributes to the Benin Kingdom? Who is proud of him except the likes of Adams Oshiomhole that produced him?
You saw Osaze Kabaka nd rushed to castigate Tony Kabaka. That is what happens when you refused to behave like a learned fellow.
seunmsg: The Bini people are our brothers and we’ve always treated them as such. However, the Oba of Bini dragged the Bini kingdom into the mud by coming to Lagos to share a beer parlor gossip as Yoruba history. As a proud people who know our history, we have to put him in his place which is what we’ve done. We will not allow any miscreant in any guise to disrespect us and misrepresent our history. Oba wey no respect himself go collect wotowoto.
You are a first class delusionist sha.
According to Comrade Osaze Kabaka, it is sad to realize that some bad eggs from the state are hellbent in using the good name to catch cruise all for their own personal and selfish benefits. The good people of Edo State have built a sort of tremendous image for their land both nationally and internationally; hence, no individual or group will be allowed to disrepute the state’s image or hide under her identity to be engaged in frivolous acts and unwarranted attributes.
This message is directed at Edo sons and daughters misbehaving not at Yorubas over any imaginary triabl war. Who told you you're relevant??
Programmer47: Here is your answer as well. If one is not well versed on an industry , it shows in their speech. This case is similar to a novice blaming the Mason for the structure of the house when the buck stops at the architect
I've seen Keyamo's full interview and he directly indicted the control tower too. This is not about any blame game - and if the airline had no part in it, why did they then come out to say the plane was diverted due to bad weather when it was obvious there was a fundamental mistake made??
Programmer47: Every flight has a GPS coordinate for the pilot to follow. You do not need to be familiar with the terrain. That is what your navigator is for. The minister has no idea what he's talking about
Read the write up. From the beginning the pilots confused Abuja with Asaba. That's what he means...this is based on recordings retreived from the control tower.
Its all there in the write up.
In any case the minister is saying the whole episode is about incompetence not the weather. That's the point!
Racoon: -United Nigeria Airline: "Flight diverted to Abuja because of bad weather."
-NCAA/FMOA/Aviation Minister: "United Nigeria pilots weren’t familiar with Nigerian terrain"
Hear the senseless thing this fool is saying. This is what happens when you have a charge and bail lawyer heading a sensitive sector like aviation.
And no one have been relieved of his or her appointment nor the operating license of this irresponsible airline withdrawn? Playing with human lives while downplaying same for stupid reasons? Chai
Plane no be car naa, the plane carry something wry go suppose direct the pilot where to go. They must have as a result of incompetence giving the pilot wrong destination or they are just plain idiots
What you sre saying is what he said. But for some reason you people cant read.
The airline initially lied that it was due to bad weather. Keyamo is exposing them.
legitnow1: john 10 10 the thief cometh to steal, kill and destroy.
Romans 13: 3 - 5: For rulers hold no terror for those who do right, but for those who do wrong. Do you want to be free from fear of the one in authority? Then do what is right and you will be commended. 4 For the one in authority is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for rulers do not bear the sword for no reason. They are God’s servants, agents of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer.