Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 (of 210 pages)
World cup here we come. |
Of course he should resign. How dare his daughter-in-law try to make herself look pretty on her wedding day? So this is what passes for a serious crime in this church? Well they must have a lot of time and resources on their hands. |
Wow what a bishop. If the devil himself could toy with him this way, what hope does the ordinary church goer have? |
What I would really like to see are the conditions attached to the money. If the funds went towards protecting judges, the prosecution of offenders, judicial reviews and even publicisation of prosecutions, I think there would some marginal improvements. |
Despite the negative feelings associated with drones, I'm starting to think observational drones would be vital in this effort to combat Boko Haram. It is simply too difficult to have troops in the necessary quantities all over the place at all times so I think having drones up there for observation and coordination even if troops arrive after the fact, would be much better than what we have now. |
I hope this isn't the end of this thread. |
The security operatives that should have been electronically monitoring the pipelines should be publicly held responsible. I hope investigations into their bank accounts are made. |
Why were they lodged in a hotel rather than apartments? This is just more waste and fraud. These people should be trying to be independent and one would think that apartments would be the better choice. |
Mr anony: No I'll say he is alive. I don't even see the slope you are trying to build. A person can either be alive or dead, I really see no inbetweenNo you don't since you think that someone on life support for 200 years is alive. If you seriously believe this, then what you're saying implies that taking someone off life support amounts to murder. And that someone unconscious for 200 years is alive though taking them off life support would "kill" them. Mr anony: Basically all you did there was split my response into bits and respond to each bit out of context. My point has already been made which is that during emergency situations, we tend to discriminate between humans; which ones to prioritize their safety and which ones to give less priority within the context of the situation. This does not make the humans any more or less human.What is the reason for this priority that you're assigning? And again, I see that you're really trying very hard not to answer the simple question that shows your absurd ideas. Mr anony: Lol, very interesting so suddenly you can't tell the difference between murder and other types of killing now? I won't fly with you on the tangent you are setting up. Go pick up a dictionary and look up the word. If you are confused by the meaning you find, come back and let's discuss.Oh I can but can you and this creator? It isn't a tangent neither can the dictionary show you how to make the judgement that ascertains whether or not a killing is murder. This is just a side effect of your over dependence on dictionary definitions. Note once more what I said. I asked you who it is that determines whether or not a killing is murder. If you have a dictionary that presents the answer, please show it to me. Mr anony: Test tube babies are human, skin cells aren't human beings rather they are part of the human body. How exactly do these relate to our discourse?Skin cells are potentially human while products of human conception in a test tube doesn't have the "natural potential to be sapient". Saying one of them does means the other does too. Finally, what is the "essence" of being human that is present in a zygote and also present in a 40 year old woman? Mr anony: Very good non-answer, however the fact that you bear responsibility for your actions doesn't really tell us if you ought to do them or not. For instance telling you that a person who decides to molest children bears the responsibility of his/her decision. Tells us nothing about whether or not the person has a moral right to molest kids. You may as well have said that a person who decides to eat amala and ewedu soup bears the responsibility of his/her decision.It is not a non-answer. You asserted that I was making a proposal that I wasn't making. All those people bear responsibility for their actions. Mr anony: Lolol, What happened to "The woman who makes the decision bears the responsibility for her decision"?She still bears the responsibility for her decision. Or do you think you can take away her responsibility? No, I'm arguing that her rights to her body supercedes the rights of any other person to it. Again, she is always responsible for here decisions. Mr anony: It appears to me that you are of the opinion that the responsibility of childcare should not normally fall upon the parent but on whoever chooses to take care of the baby and hence the neglecting parent is only wrong as long as someone else (or the government) is available to take up care of the child.How on earth did you get this from anything I said? Mr anony: If this is case then it follows that women who don't live in "modern societies" where the government is in the habit of taking care of unwanted babies, have the right to abandon their children.That isn't what I've been saying because you've just constructed a strawman. I just pointed out that a mother can take care of her child or give it up for adoption. They do not have the right to abandon their children. That is why I said there were laws against negligence. Mr anony: Consequently, practices like women abandoning twins in the evil forest will also not be wrong in your book since both the women and the community they live in are unwilling to take care of the babies.This is just you running along with your own strawman. Mr anony: I'll be very interested in hearing how you draw the line between moral and immoral abortions.Okay. Mr anony: By the way, the age of viability did not address my point since your argument is that a woman has the right to expel a person from the use of her body, and my counter is that such a 'right' still doesn't allow her to kill the person before he/she leaves her body and if you watched the video in the op, that is exactly what these women are doing.You should take a look at the techniques for carrying out abortions because most abortions simply involve expelling the fetus and when it is expelled, it doesn't really survive. Since you watched the video, you should also have read up on the procedure to realize that what he was talking about was an abortion at 24 weeks. And guess what? 24 weeks is the age of viability. The example he went on to give of a delivery at 27 weeks of the ill woman just proves my point. Most abortions are done medically and this means that the fetus is expelled but is not developed enough to survive independent of the mother. |
Mr anony: I'd very much like to see you try.We have a fully conscious man, The man asleep, The man comatose, The man deeply comatose, The man comatose requiring life support, The man on life support for 10 years, The man on life support for 50 years, The man on life support for 100 years, The man on life support for 200 years, If you came across the man in his hospital bed at this stage, would you say he was dead? Mr anony: I don't see how my preference makes the zygotes or 30 year old any more or less human Furthermore, when saving a person in an emergency, it is not necessarily his humanness that determines whether or not he ought to be saved first. Note that the is is a totally different case when it comes to actually murdering a person. The fact that he or she is a human being makes murdering him/her evil.So what determines whether or not he ought to be saved first? Mr anony: For instance, If President GEJ was in a meeting with 1000 people and there was a fire, saving GEJ first does not make any of the other people any less human same would apply if the 1000 people were saved before the president. Yet murdering another human being is evil.Has the 30 year old man become a president? This is an example of a red-herring. I'm asking for what you would do not some other hypothetical involving the Nigerian president. Mr anony: Apply the same to an emergency scenario where the women and children are prioritized for safety before the men. Does this make the men less human? Absolutely not! and still yet, murdering another human being is evil.Another red-herring. We know that physically, men are tougher than both women and children. And what I'm asking you for is what you'll do not what some trained rescuers would do. Mr anony: I'm afraid your contention is a non sequitor and has really shown nothing.And finally we come to your actual reason which is that you simply wish to dance away from the implications of your position. My contention shows that you strongly wish to avoid it. Mr anony: If I recall correctly, I said: "to murder a human being is simply evil". Do you think otherwise?And what exactly is murder? Who determines whether or not a case of killing is murder? Is it murder to kill people for the purpose of taking away their land? Also, are the products of fertilization in a test-tube human? And are your skin cells human? Mr anony: Interesting. It seems to me that you are proposing rights without responsibilities. Since you have made your argument clear, it would follow that:-No I'm not. The woman who makes the decision bears the responsibility for her decision. Mr anony: 1. She has the right to her finances and her time and thus is perfectly permitted to neglect her 2 year old toddler regardless of whether it starves to deathWrong she doesn't that is why in modern societies, there are laws against negligence and the government can still take care of the child. Again, what you're ignoring here is the fact that the 2 year old child can live independently of the mother at this point so if she feels she is unable to cope, she can put the child up for adoption or use any of the other legal means available. Mr anony: 2. She doesn't have the right to decapitate the limbs of the baby or stop it's heartbeat while it is in the womb. She must deliver it alive and then let it survive by itself. (She does not have the right to actively kill the person who needs her body to survive she only has the right to deny such a person the use of her body)The age of viability already addresses this issue. That is why there are moral abortions and immoral ones. Remember that you're taking the position that all abortions are immoral. |
davidylan: Unfortunately i am not on the road to joining you. Sorry.I think your positions here are inconsistent if you really think that abortion is murder. You're saying an abortion is permissible if: 1. The mother's life is in danger e.g an ectopic pregnancy 2. The fetus is the product of rape. (Your use of the phrase "forcible rape" I think is just ridiculous.) In the case of 1, are you fine with shooting a 2 year old child who is pointing a gun at you? In 2, are you fine with shooting a 2 year old child who was the product of rape? According to you guys, the zygotes have as much rights as the mother does. |
Mr anony: That's just it. The slippery slope fallacy does not apply every time one says there is no difference between two states that are different. There has to be a blurred range of values (a slope) between the two states for it to apply.Notice that you've just made a statement not an argument. In fact, one can create a slope between alive and dead using the same sort of reasoning you've been using. Mr anony: Good, a human being is the kind of being that is or has the natural potential to be sapient, bipedal hairless primate that stands upright and has a relatively complex language. A human being however, is not necessarily define by what it's body looks like rather he/she is defined by it's essence i.e. an unconscious human being incapable of exhibiting sapience at the moment would still be human, same applies to one that doesn't stand upright or has two of it's legs chopped off. Human beings are not necessarily defined by what stage of development they exist as. They are the same person regardless of what their bodies look like and how it changes. The life of an individual human being starts at it's conception and continues until whenever it dies.You do realize that this insertion of "natural potential" makes your entire enterprise suspect. It would make your skin cells human or deny that test tube babies aren't human and everything else between. Then you also smuggle in the word "essence". What exactly is it supposed to refer to? Some spirit? To show you the absurdity of this position, would you prefer to save 1000 cryopreserved zygotes to one 30 year old person in an emergency? Would you prefer to save 1000 thirty year olds to one thirty year old person in another emergency? Mr anony: Furthermore, all people are created equal, endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights starting with the right to life. To murder a human being is simply evil.I'm sure this creator and the rest of us humans would agree that killing a human being isn't simply evil. Mr anony: You haven't made any argument, you haven't told us when you think the life of a human being starts. Without making this clear, you cannot talk about when it ought not to be ended.My argument is simply that a woman has complete rights to her body. Since she has this right, then she is perfectly permitted to deny its use to anyone else. As you can see, it doesn't appeal to whatever you think about when the life of a human being starts. |
Mr anony: This is simply not true.How is it not true? Mr anony: Since you disagree with how I define humans, how then do you define humans? You can't just disagree in a vacuumHuman being: A person; a large sapient, bipedal primate, with notably less hair than others of that order, of the species Homo sapiens. You still don't see what is right before you. Being human isn't a magical shield that protects a person from having their life ended besides since you like definitions so much, I've not seen you actually define human. Why don't you go ahead and do that. Mr anony: Lol, since you have shied away from telling us what you think a human being is or when you think the life of a human being starts, you have successfully excused yourself from making any objections as to how I define humans because you have provided no concept of human beings upon which your objections can be based.You've not actually defined human beings and you're still ignoring what I've said which is that my argument doesn't hinge on how you wish to define humans. You do realize that there are other ways of making an argument for abortion without resorting to some funny gymnastics. Mr anony: As I said earlier, until you can tell us how you define a human being and when the life of a human being begins, you cannot make the argument as to whether or not a day old zygote is actually different as a human being from a fifty year old adult.This is just wrong. I don't need to have my own definition in order to show you that you're committing a logical fallacy. Anyone with eyes and some knowledge of biology can see that a zygote is very different as a human being from a fifty year old adult. Mr anony: To make that argument will be to assume an initial point which you haven't justified.Again, my own argument doesn't need that but yours does so you should try to justify your position without recourse to logical fallacies. |
striktlymi: Never mind!!!Too hot to handle eh? ![]() |
striktlymi: Hello TheH,Mr anony's response still fails now as it failed in the past when he initially presented it. striktlymi: Now this is pretty...a 'slippery slope' fallacy? Please tell us what the fallacy is and let us know how I committed it if you don't mind...please no links!You've already quoted me doing that below. striktlymi: The above demonstrates that you posted a bit too hasty without understanding my post...I did not ask for the DIFFERENCES, I asked for what is COMMON.What is common to both of them is that they're alive. But that feature also applies to many other entities from other animals to the sperm and egg. striktlymi: Now since you are so keen on the differences, let me ask you this: would the differences matter when there is no human life?I don't understand this question. Do you mean if humans never existed? Or if the mother was dead? Or the zygote was dead? Or something else? striktlymi: The above has been thrashed already...I guess you did not read through the thread before posting...well this can be excused!I just pointed out to you that human life cannot be said to start at conception since the sperm and egg are both alive. |
Mr anony: First of all, that line of argument does not commit the slippery slope fallacy because what it is defining cannot be represented on a slope. It is either one is a person or one isn't. There is no slope of values ranging from non-person to person. The slippery slope fallacy does not apply here.Actually, the slippery slope fallacy applies whenever one says there is no difference between two states that are different. Mr anony: Secondly, human beings are not defined by what stage of development they exist as. They are the same person regardless of what their bodies look like and how it changes.No humans aren't defined by that but how can you refer to a zygote as a person and automatically grant it all rights that accrue to people while ignoring other entities that are more developed? Mr anony: Thirdly, your argument against "life starts at conception" is another example of you muddying the water by tossing in things irrelevant to the discusion such as the lives of other veterbrates and their reproductive cells while pretending not to understand that striktlymi is referring to the life of an individual human being starting at conception. If I were striktlymi, I'd just ignore that red herring.Here you go again chucking out assertions about red herrings. My point is that life couldn't have started at conception if the sperm and egg that formed the product of conception were both alive. Mr anony: Perhaps the important question you need to answer is: How do you define a human being? and when does the life of a human being begin?I don't care about how you wish to define a human being because that isn't pertinent to my own argument. Since you're the one basing your argument on that, then it behooves you to do that to your satisfaction. |
No thank you. Looking around the world at the societies currently available, I'd rather stay in one that doesn't try to Impose Islam on everyone. What sorts of changes to society have we seen with Islam? Well in Nigeria, we have some states that decided to adopt Sharia law and for some reason, it doesn't seem to have been doing them any good. |
striktlymi: What do the following have in common:This line of argument commits the slippery slope fallacy. There are significant differences between you as a zygote, you as a foetus and you as a teenager. e.g as a zygote, you had no skin, no brain, no eyes etc but as a teenager, you had all these features. If your argument is that life starts at conception, that too is incorrect. It would be more correct to say that life continues at conception because both the sperm and egg are alive. I also don't think you'll want to follow that line of reasoning to its conclusion because it isn't only humans that are alive. Other vertebrates too are alive and many of them also have sperm and eggs yet unless you're a vegetarian, I suspect you would be fine with killing them. |
Uyi Iredia: You are dull you know. Axioms are believed in, aren't they ?This is just stupidly fallacious. Not all beliefs are axioms. Uyi Iredia: Okay.Well go ahead and show it don't just mumble okay. It doesn't imply that our physical laws are arbitrary. I'm saying we don't know enough to make that conclusion. You think we do so go ahead and show that we do have enough information to make that conclusion. Uyi Iredia: I choose the one I want.Why on earth do you guys find it difficult to answer simple questions? I asked: thehomer: How do you decide which book to buy out of a collection of 5 books if you can only afford one? Do you consider the books one after the other or do you instantly buy one as soon as it occurs to you to buy a book?The two options there end up with you choosing the one you want. The question is how do you make the decision? Uyi Iredia: That's your quandary, not mine. You hardly think, as the humans Russell was alluding to.It is my problem that you don't have the background knowledge to have a discussion involving physics when you injected yourself into the conversation? This just keeps getting worse. When you're ignorant about physics, why did you decide to join a conversation that requires it? Uyi Iredia: God. It is non-contingent.Other than this God, is there anything else not designed? Uyi Iredia: You are being silly. 4 + 2 = 6 contravenes the law of identity. As far as the law is concerned A = A or 4 + 2 = 4 + 2. Now get lost.You must be an ignoramus. I see no other reason for such a stupidly asinine and fatuous response. Uyi Iredia now declares mathematics null and void because he doesn't realize that 4 + 2 = 6. What a mindless response. Uyi Iredia: Time is a function of thought. I proposed that God is conscious, intelligent energy, as energy it perforce effected matter. There is no 'how' because how strictly applies to material events.Yes. Time is a function of thought. Why don't you use your thought to manipulate time such that you appear 2000 years ago? Just how ridiculous can you be? Uyi Iredia: It is. Energy is matter is confuted by the proposition that energy is indirectly observed, through matter.Your problems with physics and equations in general runs deep indeed. The equation you have in mind is E = mc2 not E = m Uyi Iredia: Then quit the conversation.Thanks for the invitation. I've ended this conversation because you fail to accept facts about physics, mathematics and history. Maybe it isn't that you're not ready to have a conversation, but you're just incapable of having one due to profound ignorance and idiocy. |
Uyi Iredia: Okay.No. And that is not what I said. I said it is logically possible but not physically possible. Please take the time to understand those concepts. Uyi Iredia: You mean your ignorance. Because Einstein's equation doesn't tell us what energy is - only its relation to matter.This is getting bogged down again due to your ignorance. You said: Uyi Iredia: That energy is matter. An asinine proposition.This implies that you disagree with the mass-energy equivalence. Uyi Iredia: I did that.No you didn't. You really should learn how to have a conversation because what you're doing is just ridiculous. This was my question: thehomer: Now do you think any of those two cities was designed? And why do you think so? Please answer honestly.This was your response. Uyi Iredia: There is a functional correlation of parts that can, in theory, be discerned.I showed you how to answer questions and you claimed to have done that. Where is the "yes"? Which city were you talking about in your response? Uyi Iredia: He does. I doubt you KNOW what this means.I take it that he exists just as humans exist in time. If you think it is something different, you're welcome to expatiate. Uyi Iredia: According to you, magnets have 'alternatives'. Maybe lights have alternatives too - on or off.Of course those are alternatives. But I won't say a magnet has free-will as you do. Uyi Iredia: That doesn't explain anything. You state energy can't be created (come into existence) nor destroyed (pass out of existence). If it can't be created, how does it exist ?It always exists. Uyi Iredia: Okay.Then you've successfully shown nothing. Let me explain as usual. You said the presence of intelligence today indicates a mind. You also said the absence of intelligence millions of years ago also indicate a mind. You're basically saying that whatever the situation was, you would always assume a mind was behind it. Uyi Iredia: Yes. However, I understand God to be conscious energy, and the substance of the physical world and, by extension reality.If you're making this assumption, then why are you complaining about my point that energy always existed? |
This is rubbish. All modern foods are genetically modified. Some were modified by insertion of genes in labs others by selective farming over several centuries. Another thing to realize is that naturalnews.com is a questionable source of information. You should keep in mind the fact that they also peddle misinformation about vaccines and quack treatments. Take the time to review the sources of your information. |
Uyi Iredia: All the above involve belief. It's obvious, clear, apparent, unmistakable since you believe it. I need not tell you how God is evident to believers or evolution is evident to its believers.Now you find it difficult to accept the concept of axioms. God is not an axiom neither is the theory of evolution an axiom. Uyi Iredia: Oh, you mean they haven't physically occurred. Okay.No I mean showing that it is physically possible. Uyi Iredia: State your definition of the terms. I may work with them.You should have read through a few posts before jumping in. Physical possibilities are a subset of logical possibilities. Physical possibilities: Something is physically, or nomically, possible if it is permitted by the laws of physics. Uyi Iredia: You failed to understand the point. You don't look up the time to make every decision, ergo, you DO make decisions without time.Are you deliberately failing to understand something straightforward? Let me see if I can help you with a few simple questions. How do you decide which book to buy out of a collection of 5 books if you can only afford one? Do you consider the books one after the other or do you instantly buy one as soon as it occurs to you to buy a book? Uyi Iredia: No. I am a material. So is the sun. The energy behind both, I don't see.You're still denying elementary physics. That is a problem you'll have to solve for yourself by getting some education in physics. Uyi Iredia: God.Is there anything not designed? Uyi Iredia: Precisely. Maths involves rationalizing a set of contradictions. That's why it can be abstruse for learners. 4 + 2 = 6 violates the law of identity which requires A = A. Hence 4 + 2 = 4 + 2, not 6. Now we can have a funny conversation, or end it.That statement of yours in bold is just absurd. There's nothing funny in denying basic arithmetic. I'm simply not interested in playing such pointless games with you. Uyi Iredia: I recall saying energy is indirectly observed, or energy expressed as matter. Anyway, let's see the familiar path you wanna take.Since you accept that God is physical and works in time, how exactly could he have created the universe or designed elementary particles? Uyi Iredia: That energy is matter and is observed. Hmmph !Again, not a contradiction. Uyi Iredia: Unashamedly dense. You forget that reason demands if someone make a claim about a person I don't see. He shows me the person. Could you show me Napoleon or would you admit you depend on my faith that there was a Napoleon ?I see you've just not learned to train your potty mouth. You're still showing your childish petulance. If you wish to also deny historical evidence in addition to basic arithmetic, then you're just not ready for a serious conversation. |
Uyi Iredia: Only the one's I replied.Yes. If they can be physically different they had to be logically different. Uyi Iredia: How do you know these physical laws can be physically different?Playing blind man's buff. Because last I checked to be physically possible it had to be logically poSsible. Uyi Iredia: That energy is matter. An asinine proposition.So you disagree with the mass-energy equivalence? This just demonstrates an ignorance of basic physics. Uyi Iredia: I see. So the electrons, nucleus, protons etc in all matter have no function eh ?Another failure of understanding a simple question and how to respond. Here's the question again. thehomer: Now do you think any of those two cities was designed? And why do you think so?You answer the first question with a yes or no, then go on to state why you think yes or no with respect to each city. Uyi Iredia: All people, fictional or not, are temporal.So for God to exist, he has to exist in time. Good. Uyi Iredia: Yes. You outlined its pre-determined alternatives.And according to you, a magnet has free-will. Uyi Iredia: It is relevant. If it was not created, in the first place, how did it exist ?It exists because nothing cannot exist. Uyi Iredia: Okay. I infer you take the material universe to be eternal. Since there had to be something.I'm not saying this either. Uyi Iredia: First, note this axiom (belief): Physical objects, are MENTALLY CONSTRUED as evidence or not. If you disagree with this, end this discussion and I'll carry on a monologue. If you agree then here's the logic:What is the point of this series of statements? We know that 30 million years ago, there were no humans with the mental capacity to explain our world. Did that also connote an underlying intelligence? Uyi Iredia: Didn't I make it ? God, like those fictions, is a concept that exists in time.So God is actually physical. |
Uyi Iredia: Evident I take to mean believed.No, by evident, I mean obvious, clear, apparent, unmistakable. Uyi Iredia: But every instance of logical possibility you made (eg faster than light or multiverses involve things occuring differently.)The point is that they're not physical possibilities. You need to show physical possibilities for your argument to get off the ground. Uyi Iredia: Physical possibilities are concieved by a mind. Hence, the need to use logic.Just take the time to understand the difference between logical and physical possibilities. Uyi Iredia: Do you look at the time before making every decision ? No.This is your failure of understanding. The question is "Can you make a decision without time?" Uyi Iredia: Then try and state a material example of energy .You are a material example of energy. So are the rays of the sun. Uyi Iredia: They are.Who designed them? Uyi Iredia: No they are not.Denying those axioms amounts to denying mathematics. And if you're going to be denying mathematics, then you're not ready for a serious conversation. An example of the first is: A: 4 + 2 = 6 B: 4 + 2 = 6 To deny the above, you'll be saying that 4 + 2 ≠ 6 Uyi Iredia: God is conscious energy expressed as matter.So God is actually physical? That's an interesting step. Are you willing to go where it leads? Uyi Iredia: No. We infer energy from behaviour of matter.This doesn't contradict what I said. Uyi Iredia: Yeah. But where are the bodies and is it the same time ?More irrelevant points. Again, keep your focus on the relevant differences between the usual ideas of what it means to be a person and God being a person. |
Lets see if you'll act better here or if you'll do better than Mr anony. I hope you've read through a few posts to know what you're trying to defend. Uyi Iredia: Actually, the physical world could be different. There is a reason for this.Can the laws be physically different? Uyi Iredia: Okay then. So how do we seperate logical, from physical impossibilities ?I don't care about the logical impossibilities. What is relevant to this discussion are the physical possibilities. Uyi Iredia: Nonsense. Energy is an indirectly observed quantity which materially acts. Hence pole magnets attract energy is coined to explain this attraction.This is a useless response. What do you understand by what I said? Uyi Iredia: There is a functional correlation of parts that can, in theory, be discerned.That doesn't answer the question that was asked. Uyi Iredia: And this isn't a bald-faced assertion ?Is there something non-obvious to you that all people you know are temporal? Uyi Iredia: Free-Will and determinism are not isolated, they are intertwined. To the extent that there are alternatives to choose from, I believe free-will holds sway. To the, the extent that, alternatives are already chosen I understand there is determinism.The north pole of a magnet has three alternatives. It can attract the north pole of another magnet, repel it or not react at all. Does the magnet have free-will? Uyi Iredia: If energy is neither created or destroyed, how does it exist ?This is irrelevant. The fact is that it exists. Uyi Iredia: If nothing cannot exist how could you know this ?Simple. Nothing can come from nothing. Since something already exists, that means it didn't come from nothing. Uyi Iredia: All the physical world connotes an underlying intelligence assumed to be God. Of course, certain people simply shred the notion of intelligence, and say the world is non-contingent.Do you have evidence for your claim here? Uyi Iredia: In theory, fictional characters could, and have been said to exist in time have bodies and we read of their accounts and accounts by people these fictional character know. We also see these fictional characters in portraits.Unlike God. So what is your point? Uyi Iredia: God like time is abstract and immaterial as known by humans. God like bodies is seen and percieved in the physical world.This doesn't answer the questions raised. I'll just repeat them again to you. hehomer: Now, the person you're referring to as God, does he exist in time of any sense like the two examples above? Or does he have a body in any sense like the two examples above? |
This will be my final response to you on this thread because frankly the ignorance and duplicity that you're showing here simply cannot permit a serious discussion. Mr anony: I've lost my interest in this babble. You have just shown that it is either you don't know the meaning of the so called physical possibilities you have been hammering on about or you are simply a dishonest fellow. Is it physically possible for another galaxy other than the Milky Way to have a planet that permits life? Or do I have to actually show you such a planet before it becomes possible?Yes it is physically possible for another galaxy other than the Milky Way to have a planet that permits life. We already know of one that does. Mr anony: Lol, So does the amount of energy in a closed system of expanding gas due to heat increase. You have made no pointNo it doesn't and I didn't say it did. This too is elementary physics. Mr anony: Please rephraseWhat didn't you understand? Mr anony: How did we infer this energy in the absence of matter?You should have read up on the big bang theory as I said. See this source for example. Mr anony: Neither does it make sense for time to have a beginning. Yet here you are.It doesn't make sense to you because of your ignorance. Again, read up on the big bang theory. Mr anony: Then what is energy? Please define it in the absence of space time and matter.The term energy describes the capacity to produce certain changes within a system, without regard to limitations in transformation imposed by entropy. You should really learn to picture entire concepts rather than trying to chain yourself to some definition. Since you love definitions so much, please go on to define God. Mr anony: You were the one saying that a thing was designed because it had a boundary so it was perfectly reasonable to ask you if you were designed because you fit into your skin. You can't eat your cake and have it you know.You're still quote-mining I see. I already told you on that paragraph that there were commas showing you the criteria I was considering but you happily ignored it as usual. Mr anony: For the same reason, because I don't trust you to stick to rational arguments that's why I ask you define your terms. At least it puts you in check whenever you try hard to be deliberately vagueDefine my terms? As if I use some strange concepts when I'm making my arguments unlike you. This is another reason why I say you don't know what you're doing. Mr anony: I think I explained that when I talked about why Rubia is designedNo you didn't. You said there were relationships you didn't say what the relationships were supposed to be. Mr anony: Asked and answeredNo you didn't. You've now decided to start avoiding direct questions that expose your confusion. Mr anony: I'm sorry, I can only but speak, I can't force comprehension upon you.You don't understand what you're saying. Mr anony: Basically all you've done is a long winded way of sayingYou asked for axioms, I provided them and now you're whining that I directly answered your questions? Mr anony: Nah, I only lose my amusement when your already bad arguments drop below a certain threshold of silly.It is now silly expecting you to answer direct questions that show the absurdity of your position. Don't run away, the question still awaits you. Here it is. thehomer: Other than God, do you know of any other person that did not begin to exist? Or do you think people have always existed?Please answer this question at least for yourself. Mr anony: Now you're just clutching at straws and asking questions that have already been addressed or that I would expect to have been addressed in elementary physics classes.This just stupidly absurd. You said God was a person and was trying to show this by some argument. Now, you've shifted to God is God? This is why I say you're just not ready. Mr anony: In the same way a first uncaused cause must exist for matter and energy to begin to exist (or for your mysterious eternal undetectable energy to become the first particle of matter). Therefore you know God exists because you exist.Do you know of any other person other than this God that was uncaused but used its will to create a universe? Mr anony: Please doGo back and read my posts. This is just laziness on your part and another example of your unseriousness. Mr anony: As I said, we never observe energy devoid of matter. So your answer is ignorant.This is why you need to first rectify your ignorance on elementary physics. Mr anony: And what exactly is historical evidence rather than stories told by ancient folks? I don't deny the stories I am only pointing to you that they do not prove they had bodies in any scientifically testable way.This is another example of your unseriousness. You're denying the fact that the characters being spoken about were being spoken of as having bodies and working in time unlike your God-person. Mr anony: Another red herring. I never said anything about Jesus being God in this thread. I only pointed out to you that if you believe Julius Ceasar's historical deeds you'll believe Jesus rose from the dead. The accounts are present in the stories about them.Wow. This has to be one of the most ridiculous methods of demonstrating the resurrection that I've come across. Based on that reasoning, you may as well believe that Mohammed rode a flying horse to some place. Sheesh. And you're talking about red-herrings while introducing the claim of the resurrection as a red-herring. You really don't know what you're doing. Mr anony: Reading out of context again are we? I pointed out to you that I have no problem with historical evidence but since you claim that you can only deduce person if there is the presence of a body, I will have to demand that you provide physical bodies for anyone you think is a person or else you are not justified to think they are. That is not incoherent.More incoherence and quote-mining on display. Please learn to read what I actually write in order to address them. I said: thehomer: All the people whether fictional or historical had fictional or actual bodies and made decisions in fictional or actual time. The person you're proposing neither has a body nor made a decision in time.I really don't see how you can misconstrue what I've said to whatever the rubbish is that you're saying. Mr anony: I have explained to you how I deduced Person without necessarily observing a body. Once you have rejected that, you have locked yourself out of any deduction of person if you cannot provide proof of a body. . .and no, stories don't count as proof.Just take the time to read what I've actually said because you're just addressing your own strawman. You never deduced a person. You said God is God. I asked you a simple question that shows you that your God is not a person in the way we use the word (should I ask for a definition) but you just avoided it. Here it is one more time. thehomer: Other than God, do you know of any other person that did not begin to exist? Or do you think people have always existed?In summary, you've managed to actually show nothing. 1. You failed to present how you knew that there were different universes with different constants. 2. You failed to show how decision making could occur without time to make decisions. Seriously, take a look at decision theory. 3. You were unable to counter the fact that mere alternatives doesn't imply conscious decision making. 4. You failed to show how exactly this God of yours was actually a person. 5. You failed to show how he actually created the universe beyond mere assertion. 6. Your general ignorance of elementary physics of course prevented you from having the background knowledge to address anything I said. 7. Your failure to understand what I even actually said in response to you was just the icing on the cake. When you started denying historical evidence I knew there was no more hope. When you've actually learned something, you can look me up. |
Going through that thread again, I realized again just how clear what I was saying is but for some reason, you just kept missing it as usual. Take a look at this post of mine. My final paragraph there says it all. thehomer: No, one doesn't need to propose such a world because because you simply cannot calculate these probabilities that you're claiming. You don't even know that there is a multiverse in the first place. You are assuming that the values that we've calculated must be mutable because we've assigned numbers and units to them but guess what, it may not be so. We simply don't have enough information to make such conclusions so the probability claims simply go out the window.Of course what follows is you as usual getting confused about the implications of what you proposed as the topic of the discussion. |
Mr anony: Lol, it just shows you don't know what you have been talking about when you accuse me of ignorance only to quote me in the end. You are such a funny chap.I wasn't quoting you, I was telling you something I knew that you happened to have said but just didn't and still don't comprehend. Mr anony: I also wonder if you have been paying attention too because you haven't shown how your question is coherentI asked a question, you claimed it was incoherent so, you're to show it is incoherent. Mr anony: Lololol, let us see if you even know what you are talking about. What do you mean when you say that something is "axiomatic". Explain in your own words because you seem to be confusing yourselfSuddenly, you don't know what axiomatic means? Again, consult a dictionary. Axiom: An axiom, or postulate, is a premise or starting point of reasoning. As classically conceived, an axiom is a premise so evident as to be accepted as true without controversy. Mr anony: Lol, This is a gross and purposeful misunderstanding of my point. I did not say C can vary in this universe but that C could have been different therefore resulting in a possible different universe. Learn to comprehend.I see. You don't even understand what you're saying or what I've said. I've told you several times that logical possibilities don't indicate that something could have been some other way but you just persist in making statements without backing it up. Mr anony: Hahahahaha. Now I know what your real problem is, you don't understand the meaning of possibility. So if I told you it is possible for Anony to be in Tokyo right now, you'll ask me whether I know of any other Anony in Tokyo and therefore it is not possible for Anony to be in Tokyo. Your thinking is warped my friend.You've just said rubbish because if you said it was possible for you to be in Tokyo right now, I'll accept that it was possible both logically and physically. Mr anony: Lolololol, I think Anony has grasped it and thehomer is only being purposely irrational just so he can hold out on the argument till it dies. In fact Anony remembers thehomer strongly arguing for the possibility that other universes exist in a multiverse once upon a time. But today he denies that possibility because it doesn't help his argument.These sorts of comments show that you don't actually understand the concepts of logical possibilities and physical possibilities because what I was showing you there was the logical possibility of this universe being in a multiverse (the actual idea under consideration). You can go through the thread and quote me saying either that the multiverse hypothesis was true or that the universe could physically have been some other way. Failing to do that would be you just quote-mining as usual. On a side note, I enjoyed that thread but you still fail to understand now as you failed to understand then that the multiverse is a logical possibility. I don't know whether or not it is a physical possibility. Once you choose to have a discussion on it, it is presumed that you understand you're now discussing logical possibilities probably with some physical constraints. Mr anony: And this is what shows me that you have no idea what physical possibilities are. By your argument; at the time the first car was invented it was physically impossible to have another type of car to exist until another type of car was actually observed.No you cannot make that conclusion from my argument because e.g when the first car was invented, it was still physically possible to make it a two single seater, two seater or let it have any other configuration by just attaching a cab to it. You on the other hand still cannot tell the difference between physical possibilities and logical possibilities. Mr anony: By the way I didn't fail to notice that you didn't even bother to tell us what you mean by the physical possibility of a law that defines physical possibilities to be different.What I mean is that you'll have to show us a universe with different constants since the constants in this universe are constant. Mr anony: Lol, but this is where you are simply wrong because the amount of matter in the universe has increased as it expanded since the big bang.The amount of energy has remained the same. Mr anony: 1. true, 2. Only true in a closed system. What you are describing isn't a closed system.Why do you think it isn't isolated? Mr anony: This is simply nonsense because we have no matter, space or time with which to infer anything.But we have energy and that is enough to make the inference. In fact, that is what actual scientists did. Mr anony: As I said time is not necessary to decisions, choices/alternatives are.Then you don't know what it means to make a decision. Please take the time to look up decision theory and let me know if anything it says makes sense without time. Mr anony: Lol, I think you really should look up big bang cosmology and explain how a universe magically popped up from nothing.That is exactly what I've not said. Energy is not nothing. Mr anony: Lol, this is just you messing around. so in thehomerverse criteria means same components? so if I say that my house and my television are designed, I must mean that my television is therefore made made of brick and cement? This just you being purposely irrational again.You were already being irrational when you were comparing the slum to yourself. Mr anony: I wasn't confused really, I just don't trust you. Knowing you, you'll probably start pretending not to know the difference between city and slum very soon if you think it will help you escape. For now I'll say Kibera is the slum and Rubia is the city. If you disagree, correct me if not I'll just take that to be what you mean.This comes from the person who suddenly gets confused about what physical and axioms refer to. Mr anony: Fitting into borders is not the reason why a thing is specifically complex. Water is not specifically complex because it fits within a cup. That's why I said if you think that Kibera is designed because it fits within boundaries, then you must also hold that you are designed because you fit within your skin.I did not say it was the reason, I said it was one of the criteria. You just picked up on that and ignored the fact that it was separated from other criteria by a comma. How should they be in relationship to each other to tell you that there is design? Since you're the design expert, why don't you tell me if water, the moon, electrons, viruses and a mill-stone are designed. Mr anony: And I showed you how it did in fact make senseNo you didn't. You just made an incoherent assertion of decision making and persons without time. Mr anony: This is really weird coming from you. Do you even know what special pleading is? I have made an argument to justify why God is a unique and necessary being yet you are shouting special pleading.A simple question that would demonstrate to you that once again, you're just lost. Other axioms include: 1. If equal numbers are added to equal numbers, then the wholes are equal. 2. If equal numbers are subtracted from equals numbers, then the remainders are equal. There are many more available. thehomer: Other than God, do you know of any other person that did not begin to exist? Or do you think people have always existed?Of course you're not amused when you get so flustered and confused. Mr anony: Lol, so the energy is isolated from any other source? (wouldn't this be special pleading according to you?) It is also now a physical law?(lol seriously you didn't say that). You know energy exists because you exist?(doesn't let you off the hook. If I had said I know God exists because I exist, you wouldn't have been satisfied). It was inferred from simple premises(like?). Mass, distance and time are formed when it expanded?(So the mysterious impossible to observe energy expands? Right) Dude, please take time to read up on the big bang theory what you have said so far is incoherent.Now you're just clutching at straws and asking questions that have already been addressed or that I would expect to have been addressed in elementary physics classes. 1. It isn't special pleading to say the singularity was actually a singularity. It is what it means to be a singularity. 2. The point is that energy and matter can be converted into each other i.e you're made of matter from that energy. You cannot make that claim for God because it has no matter nor energy. 3. I listed the premises before would you like me to repeat them? 4. As I said, we already observe the energy so your question is just confused. Finally, you just don't understand what it means to talk about incoherence. I'll show it to you with your own claims. Mr anony: I'm not denying historical evidence only pointing out to you how irrational you are being. If you are going to say I am not justified to deduce a person because I don't have evidence of a material body, you have effectively thrown all historical characters under the bus because all they really are to us now are stories and stories of a body don't count as evidence of a body.This is just a false equivalence and you should know it. The God you're talking about never had a body and didn't work in time (just like the good old Grim Reaper) but the people I picked had bodies and worked in time. I demonstrated this using historical evidence but now you're denying that evidence. Mr anony: Lololololol, very poor attempt at a red herring. The point you are trying hard to evade is that Jesus Christ has better historical evidence than Julius Ceasar. I won't chase your red herring for you. I've had breakfast this morningHere, the very evidence you're denying is what you wish to use to support a Jesus God? That is incoherent. Showing you that you effectively killed your Jesus is a red herring when you introduced Jesus? That is your self confusion. Mr anony: What sort of evidence will prove that Julius Ceasar and Napoleon were people? Ah that's very simple. You claim that a person must have a body. The physical bodies of Julius Ceasar and Napoleon would be sufficient. If they only exist in stories, then I have no reason to believe they are persons.This is another demonstration of you being incoherent. You began by saying you're not denying historical evidence that those people existed. But with the evidence you're asking for, it would amount to denying historical evidence that they existed. Now that is incoherent. Mr anony: P/s: If you think the above is an irrational demand, you would be right because that's exactly the same kind of irrational demand you and yours make all the time. The point I'm making is the presence of a physical body is not necessary to deduce person if you still don't think so, feel free to provide the bodies I have demanded.Where did I make such a demand? All I've asked you for is that you demonstrate your claims to knowledge. You on the other hand are requesting that I demonstrate my claims using what you've admitted as being an irrational demand. That is of course unreasonable. |
Mr anony: Yeah you sure did. . .by quoting me from another thread.Is that the difference or isn't it the difference? If you've said this before, then it just shows that you didn't understand what you were saying. Mr anony: And with this you have carefully evaded my answer. I have explained to you how your question is simply incoherent. subject to being physically possible the very thing that determines physical possibility.This is why I wonder if you've been paying any attention at all. I demonstrated to you using the example of a coin changing into a rock to show you that the fact that something isn't necessary doesn't make it physically possible to be some other way. You didn't show how my question was incoherent. You don't even seem to understand what it means for an idea to be incoherent. Mr anony: So are physical laws if you want to do any physics. Keep dancing.Yet another demonstration of your ignorance. Physical laws aren't axiomatic, they're measurements or formalizations of measurements. Mr anony: You seem to know that the speed of a photon is not necessarily always the same as C yet you think it is impossible for C to be different. That's why I asked you whether you think C actually represents the speed of a photon or do you think it was merely a number chosen to solve an equation.More ignorant misunderstanding. The c represents neither of the options you've presented above. c is a constant while the speed of a photon can vary. You on the other hand seem to think that because the speed of a photon can vary, then the constant too can. That is an example of an incoherent idea. Just go and study some physics. Mr anony: And my point is that that just happens to be the fastest speed in the universe nothing necessitates it to be that way.Another example of your confusion. Do you know of any other universe where the constant known as the speed of light is different? If you don't, then you're not justified in saying it just happens to be that way because it is logically possible for it to be otherwise. Mr anony: Let me illustrate to you why your argument really doesn't make any sense to me.That is Mr anony's problem because for some reason, he doesn't seem to realize that something not being necessary doesn't mean it is physically possible for it to be some other way. Something not being necessary means it is logically possible for it to be some other way but it may not be physically possible. This is why Mr anony would need to first grasp the concepts of logical and physical possibility. After understanding those concepts, then he should have realized that the way for him to demonstrate his point would be for him to have access to some other universe. Mr anony: Lololol, I love it when you call me ignorant especially when you don't know what you are talking about. We observe expansion when we see particles in a system concentrically moving further apart from each other. We see the same within space and about space itself. We know our universe is expanding because particles of matter are moving further apart from one another. The rate at which a thing is expanding can very well be different depending on the initial conditions by which it expands. We also know that these initial conditions do not exist by necessity.Still with the necessity when you have no idea of what you're talking about. Again, I said they're conceptually different do you know why I said so? Let me tell you. It is because space itself expanding is conceptually different from a balloon expanding. A balloon expands by having matter inserted into its membrane but space itself expands not by the injection of matter, but by the intrinsic increase in the distance between particles. Again, they're conceptually different. Mr anony: Lol, But we only observe and measure energy by considering space time and matter. You on the other hand are talking about an energy that exists devoid of space, time and matter. How can such an energy be observed and measured please?We can infer it again based on these simple premises. 1. There was always something. 2. Energy is neither created nor destroyed but changes from one form to another. We can neither observe it nor measure it because we couldn't have been present when it happened. We can simply infer it. Mr anony: right about when time beganSo how can you call what happened "making a decision" without time? Mr anony: How does it even make sense to you that time began?It makes sense based on the evidence we have before us. Look up the big bang cosmology. Though what you've proposed is even worse than magic. Mr anony: Abeg keep quiet make I hear word joor. I am comparing what you consider design to another entity that can be considered design based on the same criteria you used to make your decisions.Criteria? Do you have schools built on your body? Or do you have a base station somewhere on your skin? You're just being ridiculous again. Mr anony: Like what amenities exactly did you see? And by the way which one is the slum and which one is the city? they have names you know. Just so I'm not mistaken which you are referring to.What is so confusing to you? I'm not using some strange idea of "slum" and "city". Mr anony: I think Rubia was designed and Kibera was not. Kibera shows no specific settlement pattern in the arrangement of it's buildings.So according to you, Kibera isn't specifically complex despite the fact that it fits within its borders, doesn't encroach on roads and has amenities like schools found in other places where people live? Mr anony: All energy you know is a function of matter. Somehow you are specially pleading for an energy devoid of matter.Again, take a look at the big bang cosmology. Mr anony: Yeah. you were saying that I am not justified to hold that a body is not a necessary attribute of a person even after I had made it clear to you that a person is not deduced from a material body but from the presence of an active will.Have you forgotten how you deduce the presence of an active will? You deduce it from the presence of alternatives. And I showed you how that made no sense. Mr anony: This is simple really. every thing that begins to exist is caused to exist by something else. If there is indeed a first uncaused cause that starts the causal chain, it has to be a choice independent of any preceding influence because if it isn't then nothing can actually begin to exist.Another classical case of special pleading that will be the undoing of your God. Other than God, do you know of any other person that did not begin to exist? Or do you think people have always existed? Mr anony: Point of correction. Energy can neither be created nor destroyed in a closed system such as is the universe. The energy you are describing however is not in a closed system. So how do you know it is neither created nor destroyed? How do you know it is even existing especially since energy is calculated by a relationship between mass, distance, time and force.The energy I'm describing is isolated from any other source. Its neither being created nor destroyed is a physical law. I know energy exists because we exist. Again, it was inferred from simple premises. Mass, distance and time are formed or can be conceived when it expanded. Please take the time to read up on the big bang theory. Mr anony: mehPlease show me the accounts of the grim reaper that implied it had a body. Show me evidence of his relatives and companions. So you wish to deny historical evidence? Do that at your peril. Mr anony: So did Jesus Christ exist. We also know he had a body, did miracles, and died and rose from the dead as written by people who knew Him. He had family members too.And you've successfully explained why Jesus isn't God. If he had a body worked in time and had relatives, then he couldn't be God who had didn't have a body, didn't work in time and had no relatives. Good job there. Mr anony: You are arguing that God is merely a metaphor for explaining what we see in nature and can't be shown to actually exist but you haven't shown that Julius Ceasar and Napoleon actually existed and are not metaphors for explaining the ruins of ancient cities.Err I did that using historical evidence. I could refer you to articles on them if you want more detail. It looks to me like you just want to deny historical evidence just to keep your concept of a God that is not really different from the concept of the Grim Reaper. Since you're already denying historical evidence (which would also kick your Jesus to the curb), out of curiosity, what sort of evidence would show you that Julius Caesar and Napoleon were people? Or are you going for your own incoherence and confusion? |
Mr anony: Lololol, so it appears I do know what physical possibilities are.I just told you once again what the differences are. Mr anony: Lololol, interesting. I hope you know that all that needs to happen is the chemical reactions and voila! there you have it your coin becomes a rock. Dead plants and animals under the right conditions get to change to crude oil and with further refinement kerosene. I am sure that before we knew how kerosene gets formed you would probably have argued that it is physically impossible for an animal to become kerosene.No I did not agree that was true. And you do not seem to understand how to show that something is incoherent neither do you even realize what you need to do in order to demonstrate your own idea that the laws could be different. With this long post, you've just tried to sidestep something that I presented clearly. I used that example to demonstrate the differences between a physical possibility, a logical possibility and necessity. Showing you that the fact that something isn't necessarily some way doesn't mean it could physically be some other way you're thinking. And nothing I've said can be related to what you're thinking about logic because laws of logic are axiomatic. The physical laws aren't. Mr anony: That was precisely what I asked you whether you think it is just a made up number to solve an equation. Since you seem to believe that it is impossible for an actual speed of a particle in space to be different from what it currently is.This is just absurdly false. I said: thehomer: It is an actual speed at which photons can travel not a made up number, it is 299,792,458 m/sYou on the other hand seem to think that the constant known as the speed of light can be just about anything because you see particles moving at various speeds. Mr anony: Lol, I am really beginning to wonder how you think. My argument is that the photon just happens to be the fastest moving particle. It is not an impossibility for the fastest speed in the universe to be a little less or a little more than 299,792,458 m/s.And I'm wondering why you persist in such ignorance. It is physically impossible for a particle to move faster than the constant known as the speed of light. It is not logically impossible. Please take the time to educate yourself. Mr anony: Hahahahaha, I remember asking precisely this question sometime ago when we argued about multiverses. So today are you arguing that the universe is expanding into a spaceless, timeless void? If yes, how do you know it is expanding? How do you know that the universe is expanding since in order to expand, space has to increase within the universe. What is this new space being gained from? and why do you think it is impossible for it to gain this space at a different rate?I'm really baffled at your degree of ignorance and your poor attempts at self confusion. I was simply pointing out to you the fact that the expansion of the universe itself is conceptually different from the expansion of an object within the universe and you just start confusing yourself as usual. All I did was to point out the conceptual difference. Since you think they're relevantly similar, then you're supposed to answer the questions you're posing because that is what would help you counter my point. Mr anony: Hahahahaha, this is just you repeating "scientific" dogma. You have claimed that an energy exists somewhere that cannot be observed or measured (how do you even know that this energy exists?) and that this mysterious energy changed into a myriad of specific law abiding particles. How do you explain this change without a cause for it?More ignorance on display. Can't we observe energy today? Opposite poles of magnets attract, energy changes from one form to another. Mr anony: Now to answer your question what did this "person" cause? If in the beginning there is absolutely no matter. Things will continue to stay that way unless some force acts. Now a force does not act if there is nothing to generate it and nothing for it to affect. The only way matter can pop out of non-matter is if there is a conscious will that brings it to be. So there you have it. The universe can only exist by the will of an eternal being (God). If you have an alternate explanation, I'd like to hear it.So your explanation is that magically, some eternal person just "willed" matter into existence. When did this person decide to "will" matter into existence? How did he even do make the decision without time? How does this even make any sense to you? Mr anony: This is very interesting. Let us see how you didAnd you've just began to make all sorts of absurd comparisons. You've successfully compared your human body to a slum in an attempt to show design? Talk about category error. Mr anony: This is the part of your quote that I love. You have claimed they are both designed however you think one is better designed than the other. May I ask which one it is and why you think so? And more importantly what was the criteria you used to come to that conclusion? Please answer honestlyI think the city is better designed than the slum because when it comes to humans living in close proximity, the city has all sorts of amenities that would benefit people. Now do you think any of those two cities was designed? And why do you think so? Please answer honestly. Mr anony: The very idea of decision making for temporal beings such as humans and animals is what requires time. The same cannot be said for a being that is itself not subject to time.All people you know are temporal in some way except this special person you're calling God and that is a textbook demonstration of special pleading. Mr anony: I think it is. Why do you think it isn't?You got this: Mr anony: You are saying that I am not justified to deduce the existence of a person based on ability to make choices because I haven't come across a material body. So I am not justified in thinking you are a person neither are you justified in thinking I am a person.From this? thehomer: No you're not wrong because surprise surprise, you've not encountered a person without a body before. You can show that it is possible for a person to be a person without a body by just presenting an example of such a person. Sure you don't hold that a person needs a body but then my point is that such a belief isn't really justified.How did anything I wrote imply that you're not justified in thinking that I'm a person? When you in fact do think that I have a body? Was it "encountered" that threw you off? Mr anony: We are arguing that a person evidenced by a will exists before time i.e. brings time into existence. You are asking me which came first a person or the characteristic of a person. By doing this you have sneaked "time" into the question. Furthermore the question itself is faulty because it tries to distinguish between a thing and it's characteristics. kinda like asking which came first; a liquid or wetness?How on earth do you not see this? I just showed you using magnets that the presence of alternatives didn't indicate a choice. That alone destroys this chain you're holding up. Let me make it more explicit and show you your poor logical line of thought. Alternatives -> Choice -> Will -> Person. I presented you with alternatives (the magnet) that had no choice but you of course side stepped that. You then went on to say that the will is actually an attribute of the person and not separate despite the fact that you separated them yourself in drawing your chain. If it is not separate, then why include it on this causal chain? (It would be begging the question.) The chain would actually be: Alternatives -> Choice -> Person. My question here was basically how exactly do you know that God made any choice and that the process wasn't actually like the poles of a magnet attracting. Mr anony: How did you determine that it was energy at all in the absence of space, time and matter?And here, you try to sidestep the main problem with your idea of God being a person. I'll answer in good faith. You should answer my question too. I determined it based on these simple assumptions. Energy is neither created nor destroyed and nothing cannot exist. Your turn. How did you determine that God is a person in the absence of time and a body? Mr anony: Pick any two you like. Preferably one fictional and one non-fictional.You had these preferences but decided not to pick. Well, too bad about your preferences then. Napoleon was situated in time between the years 1769 and 1821. He had a body as we can see from representations of him in portraits and accounts of his deeds. He also had family members. Julius Caesar was situated in time at least between the years 100 BCE and 44 BCE. He also had a body as we know from his accounts and accounts of his conquest written by people who knew him. He had other family members too. Now, the person you're referring to as God, does he exist in time of any sense like the two examples above? Or does he have a body in any sense like the two examples above? |
What's so special about your God?
|
The really awesome God.
|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 (of 210 pages)
