Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 (of 210 pages)
davidylan: there is evidence in shale that fossilized unicellular organisms do exist.Sure and I said it was virtually absent. You do realize that the number of fossils of multicellular organisms far outweighs that of unicellular organisms despite the fact that unicellular organisms are far more numerous. So what I'm basically saying is that fossilization is a rare process. davidylan: I struggle with this... because quite clearly, evolution required genetic mutations to be expressed as distinct phenotypes. How is it possible then to argue that the lack of intermediate species is down to mutations that could only be seen in the genes?Actually, evolution doesn't require that all genetic mutations be expressed as distinct phenotypes like I said, most mutations are "silent". e.g a man is genetically distinct from his father yet their bones will generally look alike despite their genetic differences. |
Deep Sight: WRONG SIR: Apparently, you are not reading. Surprising for you, but normal for your "gbammist" above.This is a trivial matter. Have you tried looking up the term "intermediate fossil" like I said? How can they find species with no traits observed in some ancestral group? Isn't it made of cells? Or do you think that you'll find a fossil that rather than having cells presumably based on carbon, they'll find one with cells made of silicon? Like I said, that is probably just a confusion in the article. Again, look up the word "intermediate fossil" and show me where biologists describe the idea in that way. |
Deep Sight: No sir, the distinction is quite finely made in that link already. And that distinction goes to the pith of the gaps that I placed in my OP for which I asked for intermediate fossils.That distinction makes no sense. Try looking up the term "intermediate fossils" somewhere else. Talking about fossils with no traits connected to either their ancestors or descendants is like talking about a person who bears no traits connected to their biological parents or offspring. It implies that the person magically sprung up with no connection and that is contrary to the theory of evolution. |
Deep Sight: @ thehomer -As far as I know, the term "transitional fossil" is synonymous with "intermediate fossil" so what you have in bold there doesn't really look right to me. So you can go through the information on that page. It shows you different transitional fossils. |
Deep Sight: I did not ask for the contrast: I merely stated that I do not see the notions in either to be mutually exclusive. You are surely aware that even Darwin did see any such mutual exclusivity when he propounded the theory?Stating that they're not mutually exclusive is a trivial conclusion. Deep Sight: Because with regard to the first claim there is abundant evidence of features that cannot be explained by the mechanics of the theory of evolution by themselves alone, and with regard to the 2nd claim, the age of the earth simply does not support the amount of mutations and the time therein required to arrive at what we have today.Features like what? How long do you think it should have taken? Deep Sight: Yes, that too, sir.That would be a fallacious argument. The fact that you cannot conceive of it doesn't make it false. Deep Sight: None of this addresses the absence of useful intermediate fossils.Well I think it does. If fossilization is difficult, or virtually absent in the case of unicellular organisms, why then would you think that these fossils will be found? I also said there were lots of transitional/intermediate fossils available. You were wondering something about mutations and whatnot. The thing is that these mutations are often easily discovered in the genes. e.g one won't know about the mutations causing SS from bones alone, but from genetic material. Deep Sight: I quoted the separate definitions from one of the links above.What link? Could you please post the quote again here for clarity? Deep Sight: As to your second question, no: life generally is, not man alone.Good. |
Deep Sight: . . . .The contrast between the theory of evolution and intelligent design is that one is a scientific theory while the other isn't. Deep Sight: 1. That there is sufficient evolutioanry impetus - unaided save by nature alone - to produce the human being and mindWhy do you not accept those two claims you presented above? Deep Sight: As such I believe, and have always believed, in some form of evolution, but only that which is necessarily guided by an obvious supervening intelligence. The make-up of the flora and fauna of the earth give me to believe this; and I regard it as only reasonable to any human being acquainted with such.Why not? Is it that you simply find it incredulous? Deep Sight: Now, being an evolutionary id.iot, who cannot understand (quite apart from the fact that the Theory of Evolutions does not, and was not intended to discuss the origin of first life) how natural selection alone would lead to that which we have today (starting of course with a unicellular organism and ending - or perhaps continuing) with space-age beings who wear Armani Suits, drink champagne and enjoy Caviar & Sushi. Aside from write philosophy, build nuclear craft and discombobulate the atom. Or perhaps my more specific problem is believing the idea that mutations can and do lead to the sort of complexity we have today within the time-frame referenced. In that regard, please remember that the earth is about 4 billion years old, and even if we accept the pre-biotic soup idea of the origin of life, that could hardly have occurred as soon as the earth came into existence - that would have "chopped" out of the time as well. So we are talking about -I don't think statistics supports that claim. While there are random mutations, you need to accept that most of the the mutations that survived, either improved the chances of survival or virtually did nothing. Deep Sight: . . . .Firstly, unicellular and multicellular organisms don't really fossilize well. Secondly, fossilization is rare. Though we do have a staggering collection of fossils Thirdly, a lot of those mutations are genetic and as you know we're yet to recover genes from fossils millions of years old. Now my own questions, what do you think an intermediate fossil (transitional fossil) is? Do you think that man was the intention of evolution? |
Logicboy03: Am I the only one here that realises that Ihednobi tries hard to sound like Anony but ends up with foolish and illogical statements?No you're not. It can be quite painful to watch. |
Deep Sight: thehomer, please come and educate me on the thread "Evolution for Id.iots" which I created. I am having a terrible time with 0.1 baked evolutionists there. Come and give me something proper to chew on. Thanks.Okay. I'll see what I can do just bear in mind that I'm not an evolutionary biologist myself. |
Ihedinobi: It's still a supposition, dude, and a demolished one for that matter.It is a supposition that atheists are humans? Ihedinobi: Right. Sorry.Apology accepted. Ihedinobi: Didn't you say that I said?Is English a problem for you too? If you're implying something, that means you're saying it indirectly. Ihedinobi: No, man. You are the one confused. And that's true because I say so. And I say so because it's true.Ooh. And this is the best you can do with your confusion. Ihedinobi: No, man. You are the sieve here. Concepts phase through you like light through a transparent glass pane.This from one who doesn't understand that there are various concepts of God. Ihedinobi: Well, considering that your whole argument was nullified a full page ago, I think it's you who lacks ability to recognize the demolition of your points. I've been facepalming since the last page.Yes. That is why you couldn't respond when you were shown that atheism like theism says nothing about morality. Ihedinobi: But you see I think that you are the blind one by reason of both a deep-seated willful ignorance and a deep-rooted pride. Therefore, if logic stomps you on the face as I have been guiding it to do all this time, you still won't know anything hit you. You're totally inured to reason. That's my opinion, of course (and my opinion rules!)Looking at how you failed to understand what you're supposed to show, it isn't surprising that you find it difficult to make logical connections and conclusions. Ihedinobi: How am I supposed to see things that aren't there?But what he said is right there. Go back and take another look at what he wrote. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]My friend, I will have to press you a bit further because I want you to commit to something. Do you agree with all the principles or are there any that you object to? I need you to be crystal clear so that we don't proceed to argue strawmen.[/quote]I agree with them well enough. Now you're talking about being clear but when I ask the same of you, you keep ducking and dodging. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lol, actually one does need a worldview in order to define what "better" means to him/her.[/quote]Sure. You need a worldview to know that people are e.g living longer lives. Good luck with that. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]If you had understood it, you would have realized that what it was affirming that nothing ought to be held specially sacred. Which is what religion is really about i.e. that some things are sacred.[/quote]If you had understood it, you'll see why I don't agree with it. Take these lines. Religion consists of those actions, purposes, and experiences which are humanly significant. Nothing human is alien to the religious.I disagree with both of them. e.g there's the ritual eating of Jesus' flesh and drinking of his blood and there are the religious who think that homosexuality is alien. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Then you haven't satisfied my request.[/quote]Maybe your request is irrelevant. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Then you agree that God is not under any compulsion to love His creation[/quote]That depends on the God as I've said over and over again. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]I wonder how you can say that a person is taller than another and yet disagree that their must therefor exist a tallest person. Or talk about longer and shorter poles and yet reject the fact that a pole must exist which is the longest.[/quote]We don't need to measure the height of the tallest person in order to know that one other person is taller than another. Existence isn't like measuring heights, it is binary i.e either yes or no not one person exists more than another. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]You sound like a child complaining that the parents don't love her because they force her to get an injection and she doesn't know why it is necessary she gets injected.[/quote]And you sound like an adult who is fine with someone who wishes to treat an ingrown toenail with an amputation of both limbs. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Yawn here we go again.[/quote]I ask you to defend your claims and you complain? Come on. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Nonsense. I am not jettisoning the language I'm only amused at how you try to twist it.[/quote]Wait I'm twisting the language? You must be joking. Please go out and tell those molesting priests that they're acting morally since morality actions to you are actions that could be right or wrong. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]No you haven't[/quote]I did that with proper examples and naming characters that would make a proper example. What about that example didn't you understand? [quote author=Mr_Anony2]I'll ask you one question: How do you know that the username Anony is one person and not 500 people taking turns to press keys on a keyboard?[/quote]I don't know that but I think it is unlikely that 500 different people would have that sort of coordination. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Mind you, all you have to go on are my posts and you would still be referring to the same person as Anony even if you chose to call me Rihanna and 500 people chose to call me 500 different names and gave me 500 different descriptions ranging from a black negro man to a blond haired caucasian female.[/quote]Once again, you decide to avoid my direct question and introduce some pointless distractions. If you want to claim that all the Gods that humans have spoken about are the same one, please say so but I'm sure you can see the problems that will follow from such a bold claim. |
Ihedinobi: Ok. So now, it wasn't in that first post of his you quoted, eh? It's in this oneI guess atheists aren't people any more. Maybe it is news to you but if people can do something, it means that atheists can do it too because atheists are people. Ihedinobi: And I needed one because....you thought so?Huh? You claimed I hadn't presented one when I had. I'm countering your claim. Ihedinobi: So? Does that still prove your statement that I said anarchy means no morals true? The question is, did I say that? Where did I say that? Pulling out dictionaries and encyclopaedias won't make me say something I didn't say, buddy.You were implying it. Ihedinobi: In any case, clashing morals still means anarchy. And even in state, morals still exist. But, perpetuate that state and you'll arrive at what I did indeed say.This is the source of your confusion. You're confusing acting morally with a concept of morality. I'm not surprised you didn't see it. Ihedinobi: What nonsense!This is why so many simply concepts fly by you. Ihedinobi: Oh yeah? And who says it is so? You? Funny guy!And here we see that not only are you unable to carry out a conversation based on reason, you don't even understand when your point has been nullified. What a shame. Ihedinobi: Hehehe. Coming from a guy who wouldn't recognize logic if it kicked him in the face, in my opinion, of course (but then in my moral code, my opinion is law), I think I'll pass over your advice. I'm already kicking you in the face with logic and reason but maybe out of ignorance or pride, you're blind to it.Ihedinobi: Why should he be? Because you think he should?No because abandoning a point implies a rejection of such a point. For some reason you didn't see this too? Wow. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]You lose me my friend, perhaps a little bit more clarity might help[/quote]What don't you understand? Is it that the idea of subjectivity being used is important or that what I presented was an example of subjectivity that has to first be agreed upon for the discussion to proceed? |
F00028:Wow. Just wow. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]@thehomer, Can we agree that the following define your worldview? [size=13pt]The Affirmations of Humanism: A Statement of Principles [/size] We are committed to the application of reason and science to the understanding of the universe and to the solving of human problems. We deplore efforts to denigrate human intelligence, to seek to explain the world in supernatural terms, and to look outside nature for salvation. We believe that scientific discovery and technology can contribute to the betterment of human life. We believe in an open and pluralistic society and that democracy is the best guarantee of protecting human rights from authoritarian elites and repressive majorities. We are committed to the principle of the separation of church and state. We cultivate the arts of negotiation and compromise as a means of resolving differences and achieving mutual understanding. We are concerned with securing justice and fairness in society and with eliminating discrimination and intolerance. We believe in supporting the disadvantaged and the handicapped so that they will be able to help themselves. We attempt to transcend divisive parochial loyalties based on race, religion, gender, nationality, creed, class, sexual orientation, or ethnicity, and strive to work together for the common good of humanity. We want to protect and enhance the earth, to preserve it for future generations, and to avoid inflicting needless suffering on other species. We believe in enjoying life here and now and in developing our creative talents to their fullest. We believe in the cultivation of moral excellence. We respect the right to privacy. Mature adults should be allowed to fulfill their aspirations, to express their sexual preferences, to exercise reproductive freedom, to have access to comprehensive and informed health-care, and to die with dignity. We believe in the common moral decencies: altruism, integrity, honesty, truthfulness, responsibility. Humanist ethics is amenable to critical, rational guidance. There are normative standards that we discover together. Moral principles are tested by their consequences. We are deeply concerned with the moral education of our children. We want to nourish reason and compassion. We are engaged by the arts no less than by the sciences. We are citizens of the universe and are excited by discoveries still to be made in the cosmos. We are skeptical of untested claims to knowledge, and we are open to novel ideas and seek new departures in our thinking. We affirm humanism as a realistic alternative to theologies of despair and ideologies of violence and as a source of rich personal significance and genuine satisfaction in the service to others. We believe in optimism rather than pessimism, hope rather than despair, learning in the place of dogma, truth instead of ignorance, joy rather than guilt or sin, tolerance in the place of fear, love instead of hatred, compassion over selfishness, beauty instead of ugliness, and reason rather than blind faith or irrationality. We believe in the fullest realization of the best and noblest that we are capable of as human beings.[/quote]As you may have noticed, in these sorts of discussions, I try to be careful with words so once more, it isn't a definition of a worldview, it is a series of values that I agree with. And as I'm sure you can see, it is very different from the straw-man you initially presented. Even the previous list of principles you presented were very different from the poem you posted. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]The more reason why your criticism was discarded because you didn't provide me with the worldview upon which your criticism is based. You don't criticize a thing by merely saying it is wrong, you criticise it by providing the correct alternative.[/quote]I didn't merely say it was wrong, I also pointed out to you why it was wrong. One doesn't need a worldview to know that things are actually getting better for example. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Actually I did. It's references to religion are to only criticize it and present Humanism as an alternative. Religion plays no part in defining it as a worldview, You would have got that if you actually read it. My guess is that you saw "religious humanism" in the first article and immediately your anti-religion antenna lit up.[/quote]Take this for example. SEVENTH: Religion consists of those actions, purposes, and experiences which are humanly significant. Nothing human is alien to the religious. It includes labor, art, science, philosophy, love, friendship, recreation--all that is in its degree expressive of intelligently satisfying human living. The distinction between the sacred and the secular can no longer be maintained.If you had read it, you'll realize that it doesn't really apply to my own understanding of some these issues. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Doesn't show that God was compelled by any obligation to love the world[/quote]It isn't to show that he was compelled, it is to show that he loves the world. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]?? Did you understand me at all? You do not realize that if it is contingent upon a certain law, it therefore means that such a law causes it's existence and therefore it can't be a necessary being?[/quote]The attitude of love towards something else isn't by law, so I still don't think you understand the problem with what you're saying. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]?? This response does not relate to anything I said. Basically what I've said is that there must exist a maximally strong being or else an attribute like strength i.e "stronger" and "weaker" will have no meaning.[/quote]And what I'm saying is that you're wrong. One can determine that someone is taller or shorter than another without the existence of a maximally long pole. But when it comes to existence, the being must either exist or it doesn't. Maximum strength plays no role in this determination. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]true because you don't protect a child from death by killing it yourself but you could break a child's legs to save it's life because from the human point of view, physical death is ultimate. However from God's point of view physical death isn't the end so your analogy doesn't apply. Secondly, the extent pain that can be deemed necessary can only be truly judged by one who knows God's mind and is of equal or higher intelligence and power. In the same way that a baby cannot truly judge necessity of the pain of vaccination as it lacks the intelligence of the adult that does the vaccinating.[/quote]Well what is God's aim then? Is it merely toying with humans? Or perhaps torturing them? I don't need to know the mind of God in order to tell that it would be better not to command a genocide than to command one whatever his aims may be. If you do not know his aims, then for all you know, he doesn't really love humans. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lol, and where I have been corrected, I have admitted it and replied appropriately. It still doesn't make your other questions justified just because I was mistaken in some of them. The bulk of your questions on this thread have been mostly irrelevant to the argument we are having.[/quote]Really? Which ones were irrelevant? [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lol, nonsense. If we define morality as the ability to distinguish between moral actions (good) and immoral actions (bad), then I think it is disingenuous to try to capitalize on the peculiarities of language in order to suggest that the ability to recognize moral actions imposes upon one the necessity to act in a particular moral manner. Which is really what we are arguing about. Your style of argument really does amuse me[/quote]Rubbish we're communicating using English language. If you're requesting that we suspend the language and its connotations so that you may be satisfied with yourself then sorry that won't happen. Please don't misconstrue my points. I've tried several times to help you along but you refuse to drink from the pool. We're now talking about what it means to act morally and what do you do? You jettison the entire language to fail at showing your point. That is a poor way to proceed. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]The point is that you haven't shown exactly how such minor specifications help us understand the relationship better. As I said, they are irrelevant wastes of time and you haven't shown them to be otherwise.[/quote]I've shown you but for some reason you're unable to see it. I wonder why. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Well, we don't look at Fur Elise and ascribe it to Morzart, Bach, Beethoven, DBanj and Rihanna. Where we may call the composer Rihanna but we will really be referring to Beethoven. All these people are looking at the same creation and trying to describe it's composer. Calling him different names doesn't make Him many different beings.[/quote]How do you know that there aren't many different beings? That is my question here. And what do you do? You try to sidestep it too. Shameful. I already showed you that attempting to do so without justification would just be special pleading on your part. |
FXKing2012: You cant steal from the house of God and go scot-freeWhy didn't the pastor discern the spirit of fraud in the man? |
F00028: and if your pleasure will plead to someone else's pain, what then?Then it leads to their pain. What is your point? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Is your argument therefore that actions that lead to pleasure are morally better than actions that lead to pain?[/quote]No, it is that the idea of subjectivity being used matters in the discussion. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Actually I'd like to see something detailed. If you are too lazy to type it, you can copy and paste it here.[/quote]The spam bot might ban me so here's a nice link. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Actually I don't think it is a strawman. I think it pretty much describes the worldview of atheists in a broad sense. Of course you can always prove me wrong by detailing what your worldview is.[/quote]I already showed you what was wrong with it by directly criticizing it but you declared that it wasn't your purpose. A direct criticism is also a very good way of showing you what is wrong with the ideas you present. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Actually that post was not about religion. I would have preferred if you actually read it. I expect rash answers from logicboy and not from you.[/quote]Obviously, you didn't read it. If you did, you'd have noticed the references to religion. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lol, I and my bible are in full agreement. If you don't think so, then please show from the bible that God is compelled to be kind towards His creation.[/quote]The passage that talks about God loving the world so much that he gave his only son. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]And you don't think obligations placed upon such a being make Him contingent?[/quote]No, what makes it contingent is whether or not it has to exist. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lololol, A maximally great being must exist from which we draw reference for our attributes i.e. perfect must exist from which we draw reference for different levels of imperfection. A maximally great being defines the attribute and not the other way round[/quote]Wrong again. Existence isn't a property like say strength is. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Good we have got that clear because now you must agree that if God is of the highest benevolence, then allowing pain to His creation does not negate His benevolence as long as He has a higher purpose like a parent has for the child. Even death does not negate His benevolence especially since there is life after death.[/quote]What is this purpose that the only solution is to allow so much pain? If the parent felt that they wanted to protect the child from having a broken leg decided to amputate both legs, that won't be a satisfactory approach now would it? [quote author=Mr_Anony2]It is funny how you think that asking irrelevant questions score you points when they are rightfully discarded.[/quote]They're irrelevant? Yet your answers to them now show the flaws in your thinking. Some of them that you thought were irrelevant were because you didn't seem to understand the logical structure of a syllogism. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Finally you answer. . . . .I don't think so. Acting morally in the context of our discussion means to act in such a way that shows one is conscious of the difference between good and evil. It doesn't necessarily mean good behavior.[/quote]Then we part ways. This of course means that you cannot say that someone is acting immorally since to you, acting morally and acting immorally are the same. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]And how do these petty specifications change the relationship they OUGHT to have with their creations? Do Beethoven, Bach and Mozart have different obligations imposed upon them towards their music because of their differing natures? You just love throwing irrelevant contentions in don't you?[/quote]The point is that they're proper examples that will enable us to actually examine if the relationship actually works. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]But then God is singular. The multiple conceptions of God does not equate to multiple gods.[/quote]How do you know it is singular? Why do you think that the multiple conceptions don't equate to multiple Gods? Did any of them tell you? Another thing to notice is that if you're saying there's only one, then it won't be an apt example because one can name other musicians e.g Mozart and his works or Guido van Rossum and his works but if there's only one God, then you seem to be carrying out special pleading for us to accept him as the only thing that works as a type of creator in his class. You're excluding other Gods to force us to accept that it was your own God that did it. This one of the reasons why I asked for specific examples and as you can see, it is very relevant. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]I'll leave you to make the clarifications. So what sort of subjectivity do you apply to morality?[/quote]The type that pleasure is better than pain. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Actually, I didn't because that was not what I required of you. I am more interested in hearing you define your worldview than hearing your attack on James Turner's poem.[/quote]So you merely presented a straw-man, declared it to be what atheists believe then asked them to "define" their worldview if they didn't agree? I think the first thing you need to know is that a worldview cannot be defined because you'll most likely always find multiple exceptions. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]By the way, here is a copy of the humanist manifesto. Does this accurately define your worldview?[/quote]It doesn't really encompass my worldview. I'm not religious and it isn't a definition. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]I'd like to hear you state it.[/quote]I just stated it. Or do you want a list of statements like the Apostles' Creed? Sorry you won't get that the same way that you cannot merely state the Christian worldview so you would do well to just look it up. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]It is precisely because of the bold that I am sure morality is objective even though it is subjectively percieved. Perhaps you should tell me why you think it is totally subjective[/quote]That will depend on the concept of subjectivity and objectivity we're using. e.g is morality objective in the same way 2 + 2 is objectively 4? Or is it objective in the same way that if you love someone, you'll care for them? Or is it objective in the same way that good health is better than poor health? Is it subjective in the same way that chocolate is better than vanilla? Or that pleasure is better than pain? Or that the better way to treat someone who gives you a slap is to turn the other cheek? |
Ihedinobi: Ain't this what you said?He presented you with an analogy of trade didn't he? Do you remember he said this: debosky: I disagree with this - people may simply decide on a 'fundamental' set of morals that everyone can agree on simply for the sake of expediency (e.g. for trade), and not for accommodating 'God'.I in my case have already gave you a sketched out way. Ihedinobi: And that, uh, means that I did say that anarchy means no morals. Right?Morals indicate some sort of order doesn't it? Ihedinobi: And, of course this one answer is without any kind of consequence, right? How ingenious!Actually it is if the God the person had in mind was an indifferent one a deist God. You really need to know that there are many more conceptions of God besides the monotheistic oppressor type you're familiar with. Ihedinobi: Who says I'm unable to form proper connections? Or that I made haphazard ones? You? And I should believe it because...you say so? What a guy!Not because I say so, but because it is so. You saw that fact when I replaced theism with theism and that makes your points there not even wrong, just pointless. Ihedinobi: Oh sure. Feel free to give me the exact description of what qualifies as good evidence for you, sir, and I'll have your order come right up. Lol. I still think it's all about what rocks your boat, man.At the very least, you'll need to form logical connections between your assertions. But with respect to the topic at hand, you'll need to show that all atheists are necessarily performing immoral actions simply because they're atheists and not that e.g all humans are performing immoral actions. You'll note that even Enigma who you're trying to defend won't be willing to say this. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Yes my answer remains "No" the Christian conception of God regardless[/quote]Then either you're wrong or the Bible is wrong. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lol, if you grant that God is a necessary being, then the whole question of moral obligations paced upon a necessary being immediately falls to pieces because a necessary being by definition can't be under any obligations. You can't hold both ends of the stick my friend.[/quote]No, a necessary being by definition is one that must exist not that it cannot be under any obligations. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]God is a necessary being in the sense that He is maximally great. However, His benevolence towards His creation is not a necessary attribute of God as He can choose not to be benevolent towards man.[/quote]Wrong again. A God is a necessary being in the sense that it has to exist not that it is maximally great (whatever that means). Whether or not it is benevolent depends on its nature. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]By the way, I do not hold that God is omnibenevolent rather that He is all-loving. The point being that benevolence describes a God who can never allow pain(what I call a genie) but Love will allow for pain and will even bring punitive justice for the sake of good. Christians do not see God as an almighty genie whose purpose for existence is to pet them and make them happy. The bible doesn't teach that.[/quote]Being benevolent doesn't mean never allowing pain, it generally means acting in a kind manner e.g a benevolent parent would vaccinate their child despite the fact that such an act will be painful. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]You only asked irrelevant questions with the aim of throwing us on a tangent. All I did was bring us back into focus.[/quote]It's funny how the questions become irrelevant when answering them destroys your arguments and/or conception of God. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]i asked you this same question first. So is it?[/quote]I think it is. What do you think? [quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lololol. . . .interesting. I'll humor you anyway.[/quote]After running for so long, you decide to sidestep the question as usual. You failed to answer any of the questions and I'll show you why. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]3 examples of a creator and his/her creation: 1. A musician and his music[/quote]A proper example here would be Beethoven and the 9th symphony not what you wrote. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]2. A programmer and his software[/quote]A proper example here would be Jimmy Wales and Wikipedia. [quote author=Mr_Anony2]3. God and man[/quote]And here we have the reason for all the evasion. An example here would be Jehovah and man or Shiva and man or Brahma and man etc. So please be specific in your answer and tell me the God you have in mind so we don't end up with logical fallacies. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lololol, it appears our in-house atheists on the whole don't like having any burden put on them at all. This is why so many of them don't want to admit they have any positive beliefs as well as being atheists. Often when asked what their positive beliefs are they can't even elucidate it properly. It's always easier being on the offensive than defining your stance isn't it?[/quote]I hope you've properly considered the criticisms of your original post. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]......then please define precisely what your personal worldview is.[/quote]My worldview is broadly consistent with secular humanism. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]The absurdity of moral subjectivism[/quote]In what sense do you think morality is objective? I ask because you don't seem to realize that there can be objective facts about subjective values. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 (of 210 pages)




