₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,384 members, 8,522,755 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 11:04 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 9:00am On Feb 21, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Good, now you seem to finally be getting the point which is that God may or may not love (He is free in that regard). The fact that God happens love isn't because He is mandated to love but because He freely chooses to love. That's the point I and Ihedinobi have been making all along.[/quote]And which God is this that may or may not love? Clearly it isn't the Christian God that I'm talking about so which God is it so we can get rid of this confusion?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:59am On Feb 21, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Can't you see the circular argument this leads to; "Humans should be rational because they are rational". As I answered earlier, I don't see any reason why sapient creatures are required to be moral. And you haven't shown me one.
While I agree that sapience allows us to tell between good and evil but then it doesn't impose upon us an ought i.e. it doesn't impose an obligation to choose good over evil or evil over good. An ought can only come from a higher moral authority than us.[/quote]I notice that like Ihedinobi, you're about to start dodging direct questions despite the fact that I've been answering yours.

Secondly, "Humans should be rational because they are rational" isn't the point I'm making at all. The point I'm making is that rationality entails acting in a way that is rational. If humans are rational, then they would act in a way consistent with being rational.


Here's a syllogism now please show me how it is circular.

1) If humans are considered as being rational, then they would act in ways consistent with rationality.
2) Humans are considered as being rational.
3) They would act in ways consistent with rationality.


The problem you're demonstrating here is that you think that an ought can only come from a higher moral authority. Like I said to Ihedinobi, what imposes the ought is the very concept of morality. This is why I need you to tell me what you think morality is.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Wrong. First of all your bachelor argument is a circular one. Secondly you haven't addressed why the creator ought to love in the first place. That's the question before you.[/quote]How on earth is that circular? Can you actually demonstrate that it is circular?
Your question on the creator is just absurd. I've told you time and again that it is a description not an argument. Don't you understand the difference between the two concepts?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]The objections you raised there look the same to me. I thought my responses here also addressed the objections you made in that post. If there is anything I've missed, quote it specifically and I'll consider it.[/quote]You've missed identifying the creator you have in mind or accepting the one I'm addressing.
You've missed identifying the sorts of entities the very concept of morality applies to.
You've missed saying what you actually think morality is.

Now will you address them?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:09am On Feb 21, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]. . . .
This is true but then I hope you do realize that the statement:-

"I love Cossy Orjiakor therefore I kissed her" is not the same as "I kissed Orjiakor therefore I love her".

Point being that the "obligations" you are referring to here follow from a pre-existing love. The question we are asking is whether there are pre-existing obligations that compel the love to follow.



P/s: by the way, Cossy Orjiakor is my latest crush (DeepSight knows what I'm talking about)[/quote]I know that they're different. The question of whether or not there is a pre-existing love is supposedly answered with the description of the Christian God as loving. I'm using that God as an example in this discussion. If you wish to talk about a God that doesn't love, then say so explicitly.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:04am On Feb 21, 2013
I take it that you're addressing the two questions that I addressed to Ihedinobi which he has avoided for so long because he claimed they were irrelevant. Despite the clear evidence to the contrary.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]. . . .

@thehomer. While i will agree with you that one needs sapience to ponder morality in the first place, I don't see how it places any obligation on anyone to act right or wrong towards another person. In the same way, one also needs sapience as a prerequisite for rationality but it does not place any obligations on the one to act smart or stupid.[/quote]Then let me see if I can show it to you once more with these questions. Do you think that sapient creatures should be moral in the first place?

With your example of rationality, should humans be reasonable at all?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Your second reason is a much weaker reason. It can be summed up as: "The creator ought to because he is good". It is a circular argument and so I'll discard that if I were you.[/quote]No. It can be summed up as the creator ought to care for you because to love someone means to care for them. Just as saying that a bachelor ought not to be married because to be a bachelor means to not be married.

You're yet to respond to this post I made.
Christianity Etc › Re: Myles Munroe Is In Lagos, Nigeria by thehomer: 10:29pm On Feb 20, 2013
Nigerian tithes flying away.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 10:03pm On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: I am not the one unready, friend. However, sayonara.
Basically, saying that clarifying the concept of morality goes off on a tangent so you won't bother with it in a discussion pertaining to morality and that clarifying the idea of an obligation in a discussion pertaining to obligations also goes off on a tangent therefore you won't bother with it too. These facts clearly indicate that you're not ready to have a serious discussion.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 9:39pm On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: This is actually why I said before that you probaly misunderstood the discussion. It is not morality per se that we are discussing. You claimed that God is a moral agent and I asked you to explain to me how He is. This was because I held that God is the Supreme Moral Authority and as such is not subject to any moral authorities. I stated this and you disagreed. So we're back to seeing whether indeed God fits the role of moral agent or not.



But that is what I've been doing. Showing you why it isn't adequate and you keep insisting that it is. What more can I do?




But isn't it a little ridiculous to say that the Moral Authority to which God is subject is a concept? Some sapient entity must also have conceived this concept, not so?



But your answer was not sufficient. The definition of moral agency involves subordination to some moral authority defered to for some reason. I asked for this authority only and your answer there is still unsatisfactory. That really isn't my fault, now, is it?



I already did. If you think I lied about what I said you said, show me which was a lie and I'll get the evidence. However, none of that is really necessary. We, at least, appear to be making some progress in the enquiry.



But, as I already said, we're not enquiring into whether or not God is moral, but whether or not He is a moral agent rather than a Moral Authority as I suggested.



I am not holding you to ransom, bros. I only asked you to explain a claim you made. If that is a problem, it's ok. The questions you're asking me are a spinoff of a tangent from my enquiry. Answering them will rubbish my effort to get clear answers from you. Ihave not refused to answer them, I have only said that I cannot reasonably do so until you're done answering mine which is actually one alone.



And I have maintained that moral agency subordinates the agent to some moral authority and consistently asked who or what God is subordinate to as a moral agent.

At this point, I think I better point out what I have been taking for granted that you understood. It is that sapience is also a quality of moral authorities as is interaction with sentient creatures. Given this fact, both are insufficient to consign God to moral agency. The real distinction between the two is that one is subordinate to the other.



If I remember correctly, I have grantes theae things, not said them as declarations. Regardless, I have returned to my initial enquiry already. Until we clear it, I do not intend to debate the morality or immoralitu of God. So, if you are unwilling to indulge my question and clear your claim of all misunderstanding, feel free to beg off. I'll understand.
As far as I can see, you're not at all ready to engage in a serious discussion. I'm done with you here.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:03pm On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: I said what I said for the record, friend. I don't mean to dwell on it. It's tangential to the issue at hand.
It isn't tangential or irrelevant because it has to do with morality which is what is under discussion.


Ihedinobi: I posted Wikipedia's definition of moral agency. Feel free to refer to it again. I just want you to show me how God fits the role of a moral agent.
And I've done this already. What you're supposed to do is to either accept what I've said or explained why it isn't adequate.

Ihedinobi: Ok. You're saying that God's Wisdom somehow renders Him subordinate to a moral authority. But I don't see how. What moral authority is he subject to? Who presents right and wrong to Him as choices and is responsible to reward or punish Him for them?

I hear that He can make moral judgments and I agree that He does. What you need to answer is "based on what?" Upon what authority does God base His moral judgments? Who holds Him accountable for them?
I've answered this too.

thehomer: He doesn't have to the fact that he can make those judgements is all that is needed the "notions of right and wrong" is another way of referring to morality. What he is accountable to the very concept of morality.
Ihedinobi: I'm complaining because if the explanation you give is the same thing I asked you to explain, then you haven't answered me, rather you have wasted my time. I can't ask you how God is a moral agent and you respond, "because he is."
Then show me how they're the same thing. Again you're either being deliberately dishonest or just ignoring what I actually said. I didn't say he was a moral agent "because he is", I said:

thehomer: [size=14pt]No. I'm saying God is morally responsible because he is sapient.[/size]
You acknowledged this response but went ahead to ask the same question again.

Ihedinobi: When you answer my questions as I described above, you give me the runaround.
Please show me giving you the runaround by actually quoting me not by making bald-faced assertions. Show it to me.

Ihedinobi: Oh, I don't think I've been evasive. I meant this to be an enquiry into God's moral nature, whether or not it is true as you claimed that he is a moral agent. Briefly it ran away into a battle over the meaning of morality and other associated matters irrelevant to the issue. I will gladly answer your questions when I see real answers to mine. I promise. After all, unless we reach some compromise on my questions, my answers would be quite meaningless.
How can the meaning of morality be irrelevant to whether or not God is moral? I'm sorry but it looks as if you're either an amateur trying to catch me off and failing miserably, trying to be evasive or just out to waste my time. If you cannot hold up your own part of the conversation by answering my own questions especially when I've been patiently answering yours all along, then frankly I won't be wasting any more time with you on this thread.

Here are my questions again. If you don't answer them with your next response to me, then our discussion here is done.

thehomer: Do you think morality has anything to do with the interactions between sapient creatures?
Does loving someone entail caring for that person?
Basically, where we are now is that I've described the Christian God as being sapient and he is also described as being moral and beneficent towards humans by Christians. I'm accepting those descriptions for the moment. I've also explained that based the fact that he is sapient and that the very idea morality refers to the interactions between sapient creatures, then the Christian God being sapient and interacting with humans makes him a moral agent.

You on the other hand have failed to say what you think morality even entails, failed to accept that the Christian God is a moral agent and failed to accept your own descriptions of the Christian God. i.e you've said he is wise, good and loving. Each time I use your own descriptions for your God, you try to either try to dodge the question or you wonder about what morality is.

So, the ball is in your court if you want to continue this discussion with me, then please answer my two short questions.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 7:03pm On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: Love is not obligatory.
The point isn't that love is obligatory, it is that once love is in place, then some obligations follow.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 6:59pm On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: This is quite irrelevant. However, for the record, my statement meant nothing of the sort.
How on earth is it irrelevant? You said you didn't understand something, I explained it to you and asked you a question and you try to evade it. Why do you guys keep acting this way?

Then can you expatiate on your statement?

Ihedinobi: The question remains, does he make hos moral judgments based on any commonly held notions of right and wrong? And the other, by whom or what is he held accountable?
He doesn't have to the fact that he can make those judgements is all that is needed the "notions of right and wrong" is another way of referring to morality. What he is accountable to the very concept of morality.

Ihedinobi: What do you mean other sentient creatures? In other words, you are saying here that God is morally responsible because He is morally responsible. That is a non-answer.
No. I'm saying God is morally responsible because he is sapient.

Ihedinobi: No, bros, you have not been answering my questions. You have consistently been giving me the runaround. It is not right that you should answer questions like, "why this?" with responses like, "because this".
How do you answer direct questions? A "why" question is asking for an explanation. The "because this" is giving you the explanation. And you're complaining?

Where did I give you the run around? And why haven't you answered any of my own questions? Here they are again.

thehomer: Do you think morality has anything to do with the interactions between sapient creatures?
Does loving someone entail caring for that person?
Now I've approached this discussion with a reasonable expectation of give and take but so far, I've been disappointed in the behaviour you're displaying. Why exactly are you trying so hard to be evasive when you should have known by now that I won't let you off that easily?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 4:12pm On Feb 20, 2013
Deep Sight: Ihedinobi & Anony, I have to say that I see with thehomer on this one. Rather than seek to excuse God from morality, I would have thought that you would argue that he is the supreme morality or moral agent itself. Whilst you can argue that God's bird's eye view of creation is such that God will always have a larger, further, bigger and better perspective on the true significance of any happening than any human will. As such, the human will never be in a position to judge God's actions or inactions, because we necessarily only see a minuscule fraction of the whole. I would have expected you to also throw in overtones of Karma into this overall picture.

But to address the question simply by asserting that a creator can do anything whatsoever with his creation (especially when I pointed out, and thehomer has also pointed out now, that we refer to living sentient beings here), is almost insensitive, and endears no one to such a notion of such a God.

If God has no responsibility to be moral towards me, a sentient being created by God, tell me, what obligation do I have to be moral towards God or anybody? Why must any two creations of this being have moral obligations towards one another?

How is it possible to even say "God loves you" and at the same time say "God has no moral obligations towards you." That is a philosophy that will swiftly lead many to detachment from God, as God becomes unnecessary in their moral worldview.
You've basically exposed the reason why they really want to first hide their God from consideration. That is the reason why each time I present their God as an example or continue with it when it has been introduced as being a part of the discussion, they try very hard to back away from it because as you've rightly pointed out, a God who loves humans has moral obligations towards them.

Even they would refuse to accept such a God as being a God because they would rapidly discover that he isn't worthy of worship.

One thing that is clear is that your conception of a God is very different from theirs.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 3:41pm On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: Ok. Let's dial back a bit, shall we? My question was, how is God a moral agent? Your answer was, first, that it is the Christian God you mean. Ok, I'm fine with that. Second, you say because God is supposed to be sapient etc etc. The answer makes no sense to me and I say so and you say that the Christian God is held by Christians to have these qualities. And I try to explain that this does not make Him a moral agent and we start addressing morality. Only in doing so, we have gone away from finding a sensible compromise on God's moral agency.
How can it make no sense to you? The Christian God fits what it means to be sapient. Saying that he is sapient is a description of the God. Firstly, do you agree that the Christian God is sapient?

Basically what you're saying from the highlighted part of your attempted explanation is that morality is independent of a God or at least the Christian one. And you're right. I think he is immoral based on his actions towards humans.

Ihedinobi: So far, you have not told me how God, any God, could be a moral agent. Moral agency means,

an individual's ability to make moral judgments based on some commonly held notion of right and wrong and to be held accountable for these actions.

That's from Wikipedia which you advised me to use. Now, on what basis do you say that the Christian God (your prefered target of discourse) is a moral agent? Is he bound by any commonly held notion of right and wrong? Is he accountable to anyone?
I say he is a moral agent on the basis that based on his description, he can make moral judgements and be held accountable for his actions.

He is bound by the notion of right and wrong because he is supposed to interact with other sentient creatures. He is held accountable to the very concept of morality.

At this point, I've consistently answered the questions you've been asking but you've not been answering mine. Now, please don't just bracket my questions and start shooting off another bunch of questions. You need to start addressing my questions. Here they are again.

Do you think morality has anything to do with the interactions between sapient creatures?
Does loving someone entail caring for that person?

I think we can proceed with those two questions.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 3:25pm On Feb 20, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Did you notice also in that same post that I clearly and carefully explained to you that your "clear and careful explanantion" mysteriously managed to avoid altogether the creator/creation relationship upon which the question was based in the first place.[/quote]It didn't avoid the relationship, the point was that for the idea of morality to even apply, both the creator and the creation have to at least be sentient and at least one of them has to be sapient.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]I don't necessarily have any particular creators or creations in mind. I am referring to them in general. If you think that there are certain kinds of creators that are morally accountable to their creations, then it is up to you to explain to me what these characteristics are and why they impose moral obligations upon the creators towards their creations.[/quote]You need one in mind because morality needs both agents to at least be sentient. Proposing a creator that isn't sapient means that morality won't apply at all. So, I need an example from you because so far, you've rejected the example I proposed or the one you were initially referring to.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Actually, I don't expect you to accept omo tu dun's premise that is why I asked you the same question I asked him so that we can argue based on thehomer's premise.
You have not shown us how sapience lays a moral obligation on a creator towards his creation.[/quote]In that case, what do you think morality is? And what sort of entities it can apply to?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Secondly, it is poor logic to argue that a creator ought to be beneficent because he is said to be beneficent. That's like saying "The reason why God ought to be good is because He is said to good". That's a non-answer and you know it.[/quote]Again, when I said that the creator example that I presented should be beneficent, it wasn't an argument. It was a description of how he was supposed to be. Keep in mind that since you've refused to present the type of creator you had in mind, I proposed one but again, you refuse to address it.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]And I am trying to establish a first premise with you. I am not switching Gods (I haven't even specified any). I am only inquiring on what ought to be the relationship between creator and creation. You are the one projecting towards some particular God.
The argument before us is very simple

Premise 1: A creator is/is not bound by a moral obligation towards his creation.
Premise 2: God is a creator and man is His creation
Conclusion: Therefore God is/is not bound by a moral obligation towards man.


The stage we are in this argument is establishing premise 1. Once we establish it, the rest of the argument will logically fall in line. Unfortunately, you are trying to use a conclusion that we have not reached to argue a premise that we have not defined. It doesn't work that way my friend.[/quote]You need to establish the creator first. I proposed one but you rejected it. Or rather you backed away from the one you were initially referring to. I ask you to propose one, you refuse. If we don't know the creator, then how can you establish that the first premise is true?

Please you need to do one of the following before you can even begin to evaluate the syllogism you presented above.

You can either accept the proposed creator and creation or propose your own creator and creation.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 9:32am On Feb 20, 2013
davidylan: As usual, the atheists NEVER answer any question... they only way they can survive on a thread is to perpetually have the christian answering circular questions that lead no where... all the while providing nothing of substance for their own beliefs.
So much empty empty talk. From what I've seen so far, it appears that Christians just want to hide their God behind a flimsy sheet or attempts at jiggery pokery. Are you guys so scared that if you spoke plainly, the errors in your thinking would be exposed?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 9:30am On Feb 20, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]And I also responded to your answer here
https://www.nairaland.com/1198534/cowardice-atheism/28#14392157[/quote]I never said you didn't respond, I said you didn't answer it.


Did you notice that I clearly and carefully explained to you why the ability to decide right and wrong does place a moral obligation on you? For some reason, you sidestepped that one right here.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]I am not trying to shift any discussion. I am first trying to establish a general rule for creators and their creations. After we have established this, then we can insert God and humans to see how they fit. Jumping the gun without establishing a basic framework is what I am trying to stop you from doing.[/quote]What sort of creator and creation do you have in mind? I ask again because what pertains to one type of creator may not pertain to another.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Let me refresh your memory:

1. You butted into a debate I was having with omo tu dun to address why he thought God to be evil which originally started from here: https://www.nairaland.com/1198534/cowardice-atheism/18#14369265

2. It continued here: https://www.nairaland.com/1198534/cowardice-atheism/19#14369783

3. The point at which you butted in was in response to this: https://www.nairaland.com/1198534/cowardice-atheism/19#14370149

Notice that by this point I and omo tu dun had already established that a creator is not morally accountable to his creation before we now moved on to God. I was continuing the argument with you based on that established premise. However somewhere along the line, you said this:[/quote]Your confusion is that you expect me to accept omo_to_dun's premises in my own argument but I don't. That was why I told you that if that God was sapient and his creation was sapient and if he was to be beneficent to his creation, then he had some moral obligations towards them. Clearly, the God he was talking about there, the God you were referring to and the one I was referring to were the one and the same Christian God. He clearly referred to the Bible and Christianity, and you went ahead to talk about that God's omniscience but not retreating to some deist God.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]To which I replied:


Then you said:


This prompted me to say this:


Notice that I was obviously drawing you back to the question that established the basis of the argument you butted into since you denied that we hadn't established it yet.


So oga, please let us follow the argument step by step without speculating on what particular creator I might have in mind[/quote]You established that with someone else not with me. When you asked me that same question, I answered here. Or do you just want to force another person's words into my mouth?

This is why I've asked you to explicitly say you're not talking about the Christian God if you want to go through all that again so we're clear on what we're tackling rather than oscillating between the conception of the deist God and the Christian one whenever it suits you.

So I've clearly followed the argument but you keep dragging me back when you don't like my response.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 9:06am On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: Really? What then is the meaning of law courts and the concept of judgment and the dispensation of justice?
Law courts are supposed to render legal judgement. But this is orthogonal to the issue of morality which is what we're discussing.

Ihedinobi: What particular God?
The one you're talking about here. It obviously isn't the Christian one.

Ihedinobi: Like you said, if you have any difficulty comprehending my argument you only have to ask questions.
I understand it perfectly.

Ihedinobi: Explain the bolded. What effects do you mean? What effect, for instance, would make a moral act good or evil? And why?

You know, from where I stand, I have said pretty much the same thing to you.
The effect I mean is that e.g simply killing 20 people everyday you want to go to your work as a cab driver is immoral because you're deliberately harming those people for no sensible reason.

No you've not said pretty much the same thing as I have. I'm saying your example of killing those 20 people is immoral every time you want to go to work is immoral while you're saying it is moral if God says so.


Ihedinobi: Who made this rule about treating sentient creatures in some particular way? And why should anyone obey it to be moral?
It is not a "rule" about morality, it is what it means to be moral. Moral decisions depend on the effects of actions on sentient creatures and not on e.g stones. Do you think that morality has something to do with actions on sentient creatures?

Ihedinobi: You decide what Love is?
No, what love is has been decided by the language. To communicate, words and meanings need to be consistent across usage. Or do you think love doesn't entail caring for someone else?

Ihedinobi: Again my question about the proceedings of the law comes in handy. What is the whole point of law courts and the dispensation of justice if morality cannot be measured?
Their point is to implement the law not to determine what is moral. Do you think slavery is moral or immoral? How do you think it came to be abolished? Did the law courts "measure" it against something?

Ihedinobi: Seriously, please take the time to look into the definitions of aome terms used in moral philosophy. As always, a good dictionary is a fine place to start.
Obviously this has to be a joke because you're the one who doesn't seem to understand what love is.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 3:25am On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: Perhaps you really don't understand this discussion or else you're really just fooling around. I honestly don't know which it is.
Actually, your problem is that you have no idea of a cogent concept of morality. You actually think that morality can compared to say a ruler that it has to be compared to God.

Ihedinobi: I said, God, by definition, is the supreme moral authority. It makes no ssense to describe God as a moral agent because then it is no longer God of whom you speak. An authority is an authority and as such cannot also be an agent. Once you describe God as having to be moral, sapient, caring or whatever, you have to say why he has to be so. Either God is completely arbitrary or He is not God. Being God makes God subject to no moral requirements, rather it subjects all morality to Him. He decides what is right and what is wrong. If, for instance, God said that it is wrong to get to work on any given day without killing at least twenty people, then it is wrong. We, not being equal to God or above Him, would automatically have a moral compass that applauds mass murder and frowns upon forbearance. We would send people to jail for killing less than twenty people every morning. This is becausr our natural morality then would be built like that.
You're just stipulating that here and why should I accept that this particular God is the supreme moral authority? Can this God you're talking about here tell the difference between right and wrong?

So if God told you that you should kill twenty people each day, then it would be the moral thing to do? I'm sorry but what you've effectively shown is that you're in no position to consider moral issues.

Ihedinobi: You call right right because some arbitrary moral authority says it is right. You call wrong wrong because the same arbitrary moral authority says it is wrong. The moral authority decides what is right and what is wrong, moral agents are answerable to it on their choices which to follow.
And I disagree. I call something right or wrong based on its effects on sentient creatures. Frankly, you need to explore some moral philosophy because what you're saying here is really dumbfounding.

Ihedinobi: Now if you say that God is moral, immoral or amoral, the question would be, "with reference to whom or what?" What is God answerable to as a moral agent? What is God obligated to? Why does God have to be or do anything?
With reference to how he treats sentient creatures. You see morality can be considered without the need to refer to a supreme commander. Try to understand this basic point. It is what God does that determines whether or not he actually is moral, immoral or amoral.

Ihedinobi: Ok. About the God of the Bible, can you show how the Bible has described God in such a way as to obligate Him to anything? Of course, the Bible holds that God is Himself Wisdom, that God is Himself Love, that God is Himself Good. If He is "supposed" to act in some ways and not others, it is entirely at His discretion and dictated only by His innate Nature, which both mean the same thing anyhow.
No, if God is actually love, then he is supposed to love people. Loving people entails acting in a certain way that is beneficial towards them and not acting in ways that will harm them. e.g loving someone means keeping them safe rather than torturing them.

Ihedinobi: This is our difficulty when you talk about the morality of God. It makes no sense when you measure God's morality if you have nothing to measure it against. And if you could produce something against which God's morality can be measured, then it is not God whose morality you're measuring, rather that yardstick against which you measure God is God. And on and on and on...as far as you care to go.
Then your main problem is with your understanding of what morality is. We don't "measure" morality in a way analogous to measuring a meter. Basically, the moral system you espouse is bankrupt as you demonstrated by saying that if God demanded that 20 people be killed before you go to work, then killing those people would be a moral act.

Seriously, please take the time to look into the ideas presented in moral philosophy. As always, Wikipedia is a good place to begin.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 2:35am On Feb 20, 2013
Image123: Yep, they didn't try enough. there are folks who fell into homosexuality and repented of it. Their trial was with the help of God though. they asked God/Jesus to help them, and today, they are free. i know that living with, hanging out with, and watching sinners can make one attracted to doing the same sin. Sin can be enticing, and we are warned not to consent. not all sin, infact, not many sins are repulsive to all. Sin is enticing.
Pro 1:10 My son, if sinners entice thee, consent thou not.
1Corinth 15v33(ASV) Be not deceived: Evil companionships corrupt good morals.

(BBE) Do not be tricked by false words: evil company does damage to good behaviour.

(CEV) Don't fool yourselves. Bad friends will destroy you.
Then there are those who tried and failed. I've not heard about people "falling into" homosexuality. What we've heard is that people just find themselves attracted to the same sex in the same way that you find yourself attracted to the opposite sex.

Image123: observe the passage below.
Exo 33:15 And he said unto him, If thy presence go not with me, carry us not up hence.
Exo 33:16 For wherein shall it be known here that I and thy people have found grace in thy sight? is it not in that thou goest with us? so shall we be separated, I and thy people, from all the people that are upon the face of the earth.
Exo 33:17 And the LORD said unto Moses, I will do this thing also that thou hast spoken: for thou hast found grace in my sight, and I know thee by name.
Exo 33:18 And he said, I beseech thee, show me thy glory.
Exo 33:19 And he said, I will make all my goodness pass before thee, and I will proclaim the name of the LORD before thee; and will be gracious to whom I will be gracious, and will show mercy on whom I will show mercy.

Moses was asking God for a favour based on Israel's 'specialness'. And to paraphrase what God told moses, He said " Moses, I will answer you, but I will have mercy on who I will. mercy is not only for Israel. God's mercy is clearly conditional. Read the fine print. Quoting scriptures in isolation with disregard for other scripture will only lead to your confusion. Except you are not interested in understanding of course.
What fine print are you talking about? From what I can see here, you've not shown that this mercy is conditional.


Image123: Did i at any point state that Jesus was being asked the reason of His hope, or you are springing up your fallacies again? I have answered tens of your questions(perhaps you may not like the answers, that's another issue). I cannot believe that you are asking me if the only question i can answer is "What is the reason for your hope"? Re-read what i said, perhaps you might understand it this time. Stephen was debating, and i've been singing all this pages or what? i've shown you with many scriptural examples that you cannot blackmail any christian into answering every one of your questions by quoting some misconstrued verse. i can decide to avoid you at my discretion. So says the Bible, and so shows jesus my perfect example.
You seemed to be implying it when you brought him up while you were talking about the sorts of question you could answer. Sure you can decide to avoid me but the fact remains that Christians have been debating in the past and usually, if they're worth their salt, they won't be scared of being challenged.

Image123: The point is that confusion doen't stop at the door of one sect. Every sect has their own confusions. nobody is omniscient but God. Atheists show even more confusion. Nietzsche is an epitome of confusion, have you read his story. Wiki is your friend. he is a role model to many serious atheists. Is your role model irrelevant? He is confusion personified.
Exactly. If you Christians are already confused, then why are you surprised that many of us don't want to join you guys in your confusion? Nietzsche was also a philosopher was that the cause of his confusion? He was also a man could that too have been a cause? You see I still don't understand how you think showing me that one atheist had a bad outcome somehow means that atheists are bound to have bad outcomes. There are mathematicians who have been hospitalized. Does that mean that Mathematics makes people prone to mental illness?

Image123: And i have been telling you that the seed is the man. the seed doesn't become the man without the woman, just like the seed cannot become the tree on its own. Have you any sense of agriculture? Saul was in his fathers loins. I already answered you, you seem to be making great efforts at evading the answer.
And I've shown you that you answer makes no sense. Men don't live in the loins of other men. If you say that the seed is the same thing as the man, then you have to realize that you're not making any sense. I've been asking you about the mother but you just keep running away and trying to ignore it. Is there some seed in the mother or not? Please answer this question.

Image123: The whole earth is filled with wrong information. Pastors and Bishops children can be atheists. i think Nietzsche was the child of a pastor, so also were some of todays superstar sinners. My father was no pastor. Your father doesn't have to be rich for you to be rich, and vice versa. Their state may influence, but nobody is limited to that except, USUALLY, if you choose to be limited. People are getting Bibles, messages, discussions(like ou are getting), TV messages etc, and they are doing nothing about it.
Mat 21:34 And when the time of the fruit drew near, he sent his servants to the husbandmen, that they might receive the fruits of it.
Mat 21:35 And the husbandmen took his servants, and beat one, and killed another, and stoned another.
Mat 21:36 Again, he sent other servants more than the first: and they did unto them likewise.
Mat 21:37 But last of all he sent unto them his son, saying, They will reverence my son.
Mat 21:38 But when the husbandmen saw the son, they said among themselves, This is the heir; come, let us kill him, and let us seize on his inheritance.
Mat 21:39 And they caught him, and cast him out of the vineyard, and slew him.
Mat 21:40 When the lord therefore of the vineyard cometh, what will he do unto those husbandmen?
Surely you cannot ignore the fact that getting born in Saudi Arabia to Muslim parents means that the child will most likely be Muslim. And for all you know, they may never come across one Christian in their entire life. What does God do to such a person? He fries them forever in Hell.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 2:03am On Feb 20, 2013
Image123: i said perhaps. Do you know the meaning of 'perhaps'? Like i said earlier, my point was not on the Bible being a special book, you were the one who decided to dwell on its specialness. You are free to back-read. i talked about 'changed' laws, the inverted commas represent something, they are not meaningless or decoration. Like i've stated there are different forms and levels of laws. There are simple one time instructions like stretch your rod, or circle the town. there are some instructions that are simple for our present state on earth, and there ae some with eternal consequences. You may just group them all as laws. They are all to be observed in context and to see if they still apply. The law of God against homosexuality is a moral law and still applies. Homosexuality is an abomination to God, An abomination TO God remains an abomination. It doesn't change.
Lev 18:22 Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind: it is abomination.
It is also repeated in the NT for emphasis with the clause of eternal judgement.
1Co 6:9 Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God? Be not deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate, nor abusers of themselves with mankind,
Obviously, you're still having a deep problem with communicating. Merely saying "perhaps" doesn't absolve you. Notice that it was you who who began all this talk about special right here.

You're still failing to show that God changed the laws. e.g are tattoos now permissible since they weren't mentioned in the New Testament?

Image123: The division into chapters and verses is not esoteric, it is already inherent. The paragraphs and spaces are already there and any other person would probably do the same division or similar. It's the same way that the laws are broadly divided. moral laws deal with right or wrong, ceremonial laws deal with cleansing of sin. Most of the laws are easily put under any of this two. the ceremonial is already fulfilled and no more necessary. the moral is still obtainable. Not forgetting that some laws are not of eternal/hell damning consequences even if disobeyed. Some are just for humans to live and co-exist in the best way. like instructions in a manual to help enjoy a product and make it last long. You asked if the diet and sabbath laws are moral laws, and i said yes they are. Moral laws are laws that specify what is right or wrong, what is good or bad. they tell the proper thing and just thing to do.
This is why I said you're ignorant about how the Bible came about. If you knew anything about that process, you'll know that the paragraphs and spaces weren't already there. You keep saying that the divisions were inherent yet so far, you've been unable to show that these divisions were inherent.

Image123: At all. it's the classic case of the unserious student who failed, blaming his teacher. Others passed. You're not the first person i've used analogies with. There are others who grasp, get a lesson teacher perhaps.
No, it is the case of ignorance begetting more ignorance. When you don't know what you're talking about, your analogies will tend to be rubbish.


Image123: You and a minority are the ones that seem to have access to this principle you speak of. The supernatural like the name suggests is SUPERnatural. The spiritual realm is visible to any one that believes. in that realm, believing is usually seeing. In the natural realm, seeing is usually believing. You and every human can choose to believe or disbelieve.
Are you serious? Do you seriously think that there are more people who actually have access to this supernatural than there are people who can interact with a computer?

Image123: And what book did God write? The average christian takes the whole Bible as the Word of God, you can choose to keep playing tombo. Where you seem to see God in a wicked form or inhuman form or unbelievable(miraculous) form, it is God, but where God's Word answers you, its not God, right.

And what book did God write? The average christian takes the whole Bible as the Word of God, you can choose to keep playing tombo. Where you seem to see God in a wicked form or inhuman form or unbelievable(miraculous) form, it is God, but where God's Word answers you, its not God, right.
God spoke to Moses. Jesus' disciples were said to have written Jesus' words.

Image123: Here is the fact, the Leviticus passage talks about special treatment for an Israelite different from the treatment meted to a gentile in same circumstances. The Galatians passage says there is no such distinction again. Wake up, we are in the new testament era.
Eph 6:5 Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ;
i see no slave in this passage, except you mean to say that servants are slaves. In that case there is no abolition of slavery anywhere as there are servants all over the place. i'm a servant BTW.
I don't know about you but my translation says slaves. So your God is satisfied with enslaving other people.

Image123: i've told you already that the two passages are relevant . All you are interested in is arguing on whatever my interpretation will be.
So you're scared about your interpretation being discovered to not be the correct one? Don't be afraid.

Image123: .

he looked like the Saviour of the world. He was on the pages of the scripture. He spoke plainly in English. He told me to tell you that He died for you. You are very sure that Jonah spoke about living in the fish. You have a lot of misguided faith. the Bible is very plain about his message.
Jon 3:3 So Jonah arose, and went unto Nineveh, according to the word of the LORD. Now Nineveh was an exceeding great city of three days' journey.
Jon 3:4 And Jonah began to enter into the city a day's journey, and he cried, and said, Yet forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown.
Jon 3:5 So the people of Nineveh believed God, and proclaimed a fast, and put on sackcloth, from the greatest of them even to the least of them.

Jonah was a servant of God, and servants of God speak what God tells them to, not what they want to.
Joh 8:28 Then said Jesus unto them, When ye have lifted up the Son of man, then shall ye know that I am he, and that I do nothing of myself; but as my Father hath taught me, I speak these things.
You have heard about Jesus, about Peter, about Paul, about Abraham, about david. Nineveh only heard about being destroyed in 40days. you have a complete Bible, you've heard more than 40days of preaching, you have no excuse.
Are you sure you weren't hallucinating? You saw Jesus by reading a book and heard him speak in English? I've heard about Jesus and I've heard about Santa Claus. I don't believe that any of them did anything for me.

Image123: God did not flood the earth to wipe out evil on the earth. He flooded it to destroy the people. He knew the heart of men was desperately wicked. He knew all men were defected. Your claims have no scripture backing. 2 Peter shows us that the flood and every other judgement is a warning, should serve as a warning to every generation that follows or hears. Where in Genesis did God say that th flood was a warning?
Gen 6:8 But Noah found grace in the eyes of the LORD.
Noah survived because he made an attempt at righteousness. he made an attempt at believing God.
I mistyped there because I've been saying that it wasn't meant to be a warning because God himself said he regretted the creation and decided to wipe them all out.

Image123: As long as we are in the world, no man is too holy above temptation or tests. So there is a possibility of passing the test or failing the test. But do not deliberately fail, or stay in failure. Sorry, i sincerely do not recall qouting a passage about God sanctifying all creation, at least not in the context of being a child of God and being a child of the devil. kindly remind me.
Check you quotes here. It is the one with Acts 10. No it wasn't in that context, but in the context of certain animals being clean and others being unclean.

Image123: And what is the point of it being easy when you can't do it?
The point is that it is easy as a sacrifice to perform.

Image123: The God of the bible says He is a faithful God. he also says that the soul that sins will die. He also told Adam that he would die if he disobeyed God. He also said that there is no other way given among men for salvation except Jesus. The One that said whosoever will let him come. he is the One that promised rest o everyone who comes. You can't help someone by force. Like they say, you can force the horse to the stream but cannot force it to ddrink water. God so loved that He gave. He has given, it is left for you to receive. He is God, not man.
I'm sure the child dying of cancer will be happy to know that he cannot be helped by force.

Image123: Some folks say that there is no God. Some folks say God is wicked. Are we to believe them? you ran from the point of the quote as is customary. Jesus coming every 33years to die is not what will make people believe in Him. Some folks lived when He came and crucified Him. Some folks saw His miracles and didn't believe but betrayed Him. Some folks watched the resurrection live but were paid not to believe. God has spoken once, you had better pay attention for your own good.
That's just it. What we have are stories of stories of people who say that those things happened. The problem is that what we know about people tells us that they can be fooled.
Jesus was happy to show himself to Thomas for his holes to be felt but he was shy about presenting himself to historians of those times.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 1:29am On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: Alright then, it's safe to say that you really don't have an answer to the question.
That is the answer to the question. The words I wrote have meanings associated with them. If you understand the meaning of the words, then you should understand the answer to the question. If you find any of the words confusing, please let me know.

Ihedinobi: It doesn't matter to me what God concept you are concerned with. I'm only concerned with God as a concept. What obligates God to be all these things you claim that he is obligated to be? To whom or what is he so obligated?
It does matter because there are very many God concepts out there and they can be contradictory. e.g the deist God cannot be the same as the Christian God because one is moral while the other is amoral. And the Christian God cannot be Brahma etc.

Ihedinobi: Now, just to keep things as straight as possible, what obligates the God of the Bible to be and do as you have insisted that he is obligated to be and do? To whom or what is he responsible?
What do you mean? I'm presenting you with a description of the God of the Bible. That he is supposed to be moral, sapient and beneficent aren't supposed to be obligations, they're supposed to be descriptions. Just as saying that a person is moral, sapient and caring about her family, isn't an obligation, it is a description of them.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 12:44am On Feb 20, 2013
Ihedinobi: What does it mean for God not to care about things?
Exactly what it says there. A God that is indifferent to the universe after creating it.

Ihedinobi: I don't believe this. I ask you why God is supposed to be sapient and benevolent and whatnot and you answer, " because he is supposed to be sapient and benevolent"? With a straight face? And I'm not wasting my time with you?
And I don't believe what you've said above. What sort of God concept do you have in mind? The one I have in mind is the Christian one spoken about in the Bible. And that one is supposed to be sapient and benevolent.

I already said this right in my post here.

thehomer: [size=14pt]Firstly, the God under consideration is the God of the Bible.[/size]
God is a moral agent because he supposed to be sapient, he is supposed to care about humans and he can do something to affect humans.
If you're seriously telling me that as a Christian you do not know that the Christian God is supposed to be moral, sapient and beneficent, then I have to ask what concept of the Christian God you have in mind.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 12:35am On Feb 20, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]This is where we backtracked.

https://www.nairaland.com/1198534/cowardice-atheism/23#14385248

My quotes from that post:[/quote]How on earth can you say we backtracked when you were clearly referring to the Christian God? Did you miss your references to a certain specific God in that post? Or were you deliberately conflating two different Gods?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]So please can you now answer the question as it is without jumping to what you think I might say next?[/quote]I answered that question here

thehomer: As I said before, the creator is under moral obligations if the creation is sapient and if the creator is said to be beneficent towards the creation.
In no way have I tried to read your mind. If you think I did, please show me where I did this.

And I notice that you're yet to answer my own question.

Now if you want to shift this discussion to first trying to find out which God it is you want to start talking about, then explicitly do so rather than playing these games.

In fact, since you're feeling so skittish, I'll do it for you.

What sort of creator and creation do you have in mind? Obviously, none of them can be mindless if it is to be relevant to this discussion.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 10:43pm On Feb 19, 2013
Kay 17: Wouldn't it be sound to say, that morality is possible only under the force of moral laws. Therefore its giver (God or the State) isn't moral, because they don't come under the force/influence of moral laws. Hence both are amoral.
The problem here is that laws don't determine whether or not an action is moral.
God cannot be amoral if he is supposed to be sapient or beneficent. With respect to the state, what are you referring to?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 10:22pm On Feb 19, 2013
Ihedinobi: Why does God have to be a moral agent to be a moral authority? And by what standard can God be said to be moral/immoral? In short, what is an indifferent God like?
An indifferent God would be like the deist God. That God can be claimed to have created the universe and left it to be. He wouldn't care about humans, in fact, humans wouldn't be considered to have been his aim for creating the universe.

Ihedinobi: Ok, you're just being funny now, aren't you?
No I'm not. Is there something baffling about what I said there?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 10:15pm On Feb 19, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Technically no because He cannot be subject to moral laws that are subject to Him[/quote]Being a moral agent has nothing to do about the laws one is supposed to be subject to. It has to do with whether or not one can make moral decisions.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]If I recall correctly, we have backtracked a bit from that (we'll still get there anyway) but then you'll remember that I asked you the question because it was the basis of the debate I was having with omo tu dun which you butted into. The question was to provide you with the context that leads us on to pondering whether God is good or evil. So please answer the question as it is and not as you expect it to become.[/quote]Are you seriously saying that at that point you weren't talking about the Christian God? I don't recall us backtracking. Can you show where we backtracked to saying that it wasn't the Christian God that is under consideration?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]i asked you a simple question concerning a creator and his/her creation. You decided to anticipate God and argue against God without first answering the question itself. This is like me asking you if a man ought to marry a woman and you reply with "Anony is not a homosexual therefore he ought to marry a woman". The question was not about a specific creator but a generic creator and creation. please answer in terms of the question as it has been asked.[/quote]No, you asked me a question concerning the relationship between your God and humans.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]My point exactly. I have not said the bold in this debate neither did I ask you about a beneficent creator in particular. If you think that a beneficent creator has a moral obligation toward his creation, you must tell me why it is so.[/quote]I simply have to clearly declare that you're trying to be deceptive here. This was where I entered the conversation. Please can you tell me the God that was under consideration?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Imagine you ask if cars ought to have owners and I replied with "red cars need to have owners", the burden is upon me to show why the quality of redness necessitates ownership. It would be irrelevant if i happen to know that your car is red because that was not the question you asked me. It will also be dubious of me to ask you why you think a red car "which you happen to own" doesn't necessarily need an owner[/quote]Please just stop with these stray stories you keep throwing in and respond to your own part of the discussion. Where I came into the discussion, you were already talking about your God. Please check the link of where I came into the discussion.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]So please for one last time my friend answer the question as it is and not as you want it to be.[/quote]I've answered your question several times already but you've not answered the question we began with. Again, look back at where we began. The very first part of what I wrote was referring to meeting moral obligations. And you were trying to say your God had no moral obligations because there was no higher law.

I know that you so-called sophisticated Christians like trying to hide your God but really lets try to have an honest discussion. We both understand that when you're talking about God, it is your God that you're talking about and not Brahma so why go for this needless rigmarole? I never said we were talking about some other God you never did until it began to dawn on you that I would use the fact that your God is supposed to be sapient and beneficent and not just some stone floating out in space.

If you want us to begin afresh by wondering what God is, you can clearly state that right now because you've just been hinting that you want the conversation to begin from there but we didn't actually begin from that point.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:54pm On Feb 19, 2013
Miss Ope: Seriously... Logic boy and the likes... Deserve being hanged to death....
Wow. Just wow.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:53pm On Feb 19, 2013
Ihedinobi: I think that's kinda funny because his arguments essentially were leaning toward asking you how God could possibly be a moral agent seeing as He is by definition the Supreme Moral Authority. And you answer that it is because said God is a moral agent. And go on to ask him if he agrees! Yeah, I think it's quite funny.
To be a moral authority, he has to be a moral agent. Do you think an indifferent God or an immoral God can serve as a reference for being a supreme moral authority? Or can a stone be a supreme moral authority? I still don't see what is supposed to be funny or puzzling here.

Ihedinobi: Ok. Why is he supposed to be and do all these things?
Because he is supposed to be sapient and benevolent to humans.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:11pm On Feb 19, 2013
ooman: I disagree, the God of the bible CANNOT be a decider of morality and a judge of goodness because HE IS NOT A DISINTERESTED ARBITRATOR
I never said the God of the Bible was a decider of morality.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:07pm On Feb 19, 2013
Ihedinobi: Um, YOU declare that God is a moral agent and YOU ask Mr Anony if that is true? What am I missing?
No, I'm asking if he agrees with that assessment. So far, he has tried to evade responding.

Ihedinobi: Anyhow, explain to me how God is a moral agent. I'm kinda curious.
Firstly, the God under consideration is the God of the Bible.
God is a moral agent because he supposed to be sapient, he is supposed to care about humans and he can do something to affect humans.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 7:49pm On Feb 19, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Let me repeat the question I asked you:[/quote]And I answered it by telling you that your God is a moral agent. If he is a moral agent, then he does have moral obligations. Is your God a moral agent?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Obviously I am referring to a creator/creation relationship.[/quote]No, you're referring to "moral obligations". Do you remember that this part of the discussion was on whether or not an entity had moral obligations?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Secondly I have given no special characteristics to the creator or the created at this point. If you are going to give any characteristics, you must explain how that characteristic places a moral obligation on the creator towards his/her creation.[/quote]This has to be a joke. Haven't you been talking about the Christian God all along? Do you remember when you were making an analogy with God, Jesus and car keys?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]First we must establish a general rule then we move on to specifics. please stick to the argument and let the straws be. There is no need to dance around and try to argue against what you think I am going to say next.[/quote]I've been sticking to the argument you're the one who has consistently failed to hold up his own part of the discussion. If you're accusing me of attacking a strawman, please show me where I did so.

I'm not trying to argue against what I think you'll say next, I've been repeatedly asking you the same question. A question that I've answered and you're failing to evade. Here it is again.

Now why would you say that a creator who you say is beneficent towards his creation doesn't have any moral obligations towards them?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 7:10pm On Feb 19, 2013
Firstly, the God under consideration is your Christian God.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Irrelevant. First of all, you and I are not in a creator/creation relationship with each other or other persons (please don't forget that that's the basis of the question).[/quote]Then please actually show that it is irrelevant. Actually, the basis of the question is whether or not you or God can be considered as being moral. Your getting stuck on the relationship is actually irrelevant. The meaning of the concept doesn't change.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Secondly, the creator's beneficence isn't the reason why He ought to be beneficent. That's like asking "why should thehomer be nice?" and you reply "because thehomer is nice". It is a non-answer and you know it.[/quote]I never said or implied that it was. We're both using that as a starting point. Are you satisfied with using that as a starting point? If not, please tell me why.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]I am sure that if you asked me "why should God be good?" and I answered "because he is said to be good" you will out-rightly reject such an answer.[/quote]I'm not asking you why God should be good neither am I asking you if he is good. I'm working with the idea that you Christians accept that he is good. For us not to talk past each other, we need to accept some starting points. If you wish to start by wondering if God is good or why he should be good, just say so but keep in mind that I'm using your own worldview to show you its internal inconsistencies.

I notice that you've still not said why a creator who is assumed to be beneficent won't have any moral obligations toward them.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 3:39pm On Feb 19, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]You do realize that this doesn't answer anything. All you've done is make the assumption that if the creation can ponder morality, it automatically makes the creator morally responsible to them. There is no reason why this should be true. The fact that I can tell what is good from what is evil does not automatically impose a moral duty upon anyone else towards me. My sapience is not binding on anyone else least of all my creator.[/quote]Would the fact that you're human mean that moral reasoning applies to you? Actually, the fact that you can tell right from wrong does impose a moral duty upon you towards others and upon others towards you. That is why you can be sent to prison if you kill someone. And another person can be sent to prison for murder.

So it turns out that I have answered a lot of things with respect to the morality of keeping your promises to people.

You do realize that being morally responsible towards someone doesn't mean that you have to guard them all day, it means that at the very least, you shouldn't harm them especially when you can avoid it.

In order for us not to be arguing at cross purposes, what would you say morality entails?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]The second part is also a non-answer because the question requires that you tell us why a creator ought to be beneficent to His creation. Echoing that He is said to be beneficent does not help us in any way.[/quote]Let's not play games here. The creator we're talking about is already said to be beneficent to his creation. Unless you wish to retract that, then you shouldn't try to run from the consequences of such a line of thought.

Now why would you say that a creator who you say is beneficent towards his creation doesn't have any moral obligations towards them?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 (of 210 pages)