₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,384 members, 8,522,755 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 10:58 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Evang. Benny Hin Remarries Ex-wife, Yrs After Divorce(remarriage Photos). by thehomer: 3:04pm On Mar 13, 2013
To be clear, they got divorced because:

1. Mr. Hinn was married to the church and
2. Mrs. Hinn was using some medication?

Whatever happened to that other woman? I think it was Paula White. The bombshell that nuked the first round of his marriage? Was she at this ceremony?

Anyway, the money must keep flowing in.
Christianity Etc › Re: Q & A With Jesus On The Problem Of Evil by thehomer: 2:58pm On Mar 13, 2013
InesQor: @Uyi Iredia

Nature and its ecosystem are adequately designed to handle famine and diseases. It is when man disrupts nature, that's when both go out of control.
False. Human diseases are "designed" to make people suffer and die in order for the organism causing the disease to flourish.

InesQor: Natural disasters as I said above, increase in frequency due to human disruption. Not to say they'll disappear without our interaction, but they'll be minimal. On the other hand, observe how animals are still so sensitive to natural disasters that way before they occur, they migrate from the scene. Maybe man was also built this way from the onset but we have desensitized ourselves or have grown apathetic such that we've lost that ability.
This too is false. How did human disruption cause e.g a volcano eruption, a tsunami caused by an underwater earthquake or even an asteroid hitting the earth? The claim that animals are so sensitive that they migrate before the disasters occur is false. It looks that way in our reports because we focus on reporting about humans.

InesQor: I do not know for sure but I can't totally exonerate man from these evils. Neither have I said God does only the things that mere men like us will refer to as "only Good".
If man isn't causing an asteroid strike or a volcano eruption, who then are you blaming for such an event?
Christianity Etc › Re: Q & A With Jesus On The Problem Of Evil by thehomer: 2:52pm On Mar 13, 2013
So rather than Jesus answering the question, he plays around with words. Norman obviously knows his stuff and doesn't let Jesus off so Jesus just wastes time until he gets kicked off the show.

By the reasoning that Jesus presents there, we shouldn't bother discussing issues since be thinks that people's minds cannot be changed or that they make up arguments after the fact.

Obviously, I think it is clear that the problem of evil is a serious issue if one thinks that their God is good, kind, loving and omnipotent.
Christianity Etc › Re: Uyi Iredia Sees The Light! Denies the love of Yahweh!! by thehomer: 8:12am On Mar 13, 2013
davidylan: that is EXACTLY the point! grin See atheists foam in the mouth when christians proselytize... but yet hypocritically do the exact same thing!
Really? Atheists try to stop Christians from preaching at the appropriate venue? Do you see Atheists stopping Christians from preaching e.g on this forum?

davidylan: You're going too far... here we have atheists who want to force atheism down the throats of others yet howl like rabid dogs when christians dare speak up for their faith in public. The truth is that atheists are beginning to sound more and more like saudi clerics... if many of you had your way no churches would exist and open expression of religious faith would be a criminal offence.
Is having a serious discussion tantamount to forcing a point of view down the throats of people who disagree? The question is where in public are these Christians doing it? Come on. I'm sure you know that atheists are all for freedom of speech and freedom of and from religion. It is you religious people who would like it some other way.

davidylan: why do you need a christian reverting as validation for your rants? grin Its quite odd to me that you are not sure of your position until you have coerced another to join you. See, whether you revert or not, doesnt affect my faith... i would be quite glad to see you rescue your own soul but at the end of the day the choice is yours to make.
Do you see someone swallowing your ideas of Jesus Christ as validation for your rants? Or does that mean you're not sure of your position until you see someone coming to believe it?

davidylan: Oh dear... you wouldnt know science if it hit you squat in the face. grin
Neither do you it seems.
Christianity Etc › Re: Uyi Iredia Sees The Light! Denies the love of Yahweh!! by thehomer: 8:59pm On Mar 12, 2013
Uyi Iredia: Scratch that. A lapsed Christian. But I think you went over the top making a new thread for my statement.
Hmm. It begins.
Christianity Etc › Re: Dawkins Is A Dunce (how Anony/deepsight/enigma Mirror Extreme Xtians) by thehomer: 9:24am On Mar 07, 2013
davidylan: Fallacy of appeal to authority.
How is it a fallacy of an appeal to authority to point out that Dawkins does in fact have a lot of awards? You guys should try to actually show how something is a fallacy rather than just throwing out a fallacy you've heard of.
Islam › Re: Hijab Dispute: COHI Warns LASG by thehomer: 7:09pm On Mar 06, 2013
lagerwhenindoubt: It is not a veiled threat. it is the voice of a per-meditated violent attack on a society that allows Religion (the various cacophonous voices of various Gods) to Rule over Constitution (The Voice of the People). Anyone who does not recognize this line of reasoning COHI and MSSN are towing is simply ignoring the elephant in the room
Not veiled at all. I just wish that many more Muslims will speak up against such threats against the larger society. They should realize by now it reflects badly on them as a group.

To avoid being banned, please ensure that your post is not offensive to Islam.
My post will not be offensive to Islam.
Politics › Re: Weapons And Bomb-making Devices Found At Politician’s Residence by thehomer: 7:02pm On Mar 06, 2013
desosa: Six AK 47 assault rifles, some ammunitions and bomb making devices were found following an operation by the Nigerian troops in the home of a serving politician, Hussain Dei Dei near Dalet barrack in Kawo area of Kaduna city.

A press statement from Nigeria army division 1, internal security force, led by Brigadier General TC Ude, said the raid was carried out on Tuesday, March 5th, 2013 at about 5.30pm, following intelligence report in the area.

The statement also revealed that two men, two women and five children were arrested during the operation.

Apart from six AK 47 assault rifles, the military listed the following items as part of the weapons recovered:

- One light Machine Gun.
-One teargas Launcher.
-Twenty Seven Loaded and Seventeen empty AK 47 magazines.
-One FN Rifle Magazine.
-Five Sub-Machine Gun Magazines.
- Four Pistols Magazines.
-One loaded Light-Machine Gun Magazine.
-Two Hundred and Seventy Five (275) rounds of 7.62 mm (NATO Ammunition).
-Seven Hundred and Sixty Five (765) Rounds of 7.62 mm Special Ammunition.
-Fifty Eight (58) Rounds of 9mm Ammunition.
-One Hundred and Twenty Five pieces of Detonator-33.
-Two Reels of Detonating Cords.
-Nine Small Cans of Prepared IED.
-One paint Can of Prepared IED.
-Nine pieces of 9-Volt Batteries.
-Three Bags of White Chemical substance.
-Five pieces of Remote Control Switches.
-One Reel of Firing Cable.
-Six pieces of Assorted Car Plate Numbers.
There terrorists are getting more organized. These weapons could probably arm one or two terror cells and that would be enough to make a state virtually ungovernable. Just take a look at it.
6 AK47s, 1 light machine gun, a teargas launcher and almost a thousand rounds. By the way, where are the 9mm pistols to go with the ammo? Weren't they found? With all that they could easily masquerade as members of the police or the military and keep escaping with multiple plate numbers. Then with their false identities, they could easily plant the bombs at places where lots of people gather. They could attack a church while pretending to be guards and all sorts of nefarious activities.

I just hope they recovered a lot of intel whether in hard soft copy. And I hope they rewarded the person that tipped them off.
Islam › Re: Hijab Dispute: COHI Warns LASG by thehomer: 6:51pm On Mar 06, 2013
AbuHanifa: Press Release:
Hijab crisis: COHI warns Lagos govt against reneging on agreements with MSSN
The Council of Higher Institutions (COHI), an arm of the Muslim Students’ Society of Nigeria, (MSSN) Lagos State Area Unit, has advised the Lagos State Government not to renege on the agreement it reached with the society following last Thursday’s mass protest in Alausa against the victimisation of Muslim students using hijab in secondary schools by their principals.

The group warned that reneging on the agreements may result to the disruption of the relative peace being enjoyed in the state at the moment.

. . . .

https://www.facebook.com/mssnlsau/posts/487485604632577
This line in bold caught my eye. I wonder why.

Now I'm afraid of voicing my opinion because I don't want to be banned.

To avoid being banned, please ensure that your post is not offensive to Islam.
Always silencing dissidents. Well here we go again with the religion of peace.
Christianity Etc › Re: Solipsism: You Are All Alone! by thehomer: 6:36pm On Mar 06, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony2][size=14pt]Bus Ads Deny The Existence Of God Other Minds[/size]

Citing the impossibility of having direct, immediate experience of another person’s consciousness, a group of solipsists is running ads on buses declaring “There Are Probably No Other Minds . . . Now Stopping Worrying and Enjoy Your Hallucinations.”

The campaign is the brainchild of Richard Dawkins, author of the self-published “The You Delusion.”

Dawkins said he got the idea from his life-long study of atheism. “Once I realized there was no proof of a higher intelligence in the universe, it struck me as a colossal leap of faith to believe that there were any other minds out there besides my own,” he said. “All of my experience of ‘them,’ however real it may seem, occurs exclusively in my head, and the fact that ‘they’ appear to exhibit signs of self-awareness similar to my own is simply another part of the same personal, subjective phenomenon.”

Dawkins added that he had long suspected that the sinful, chattering idiots by whom he found himself surrounded were too stupid to be real. He nevertheless expressed a certain affection for the amusing, imaginary creatures, even when they were bad. “Having brought them into being by the force of my will, I feel a strong, fatherly, near-infinite love for those whom I have made in my image.”



DISCLAIMER: The above is not really Dawkins. It is merely a parody of him


Source: http://ravingatheist.com/page/7/[/quote]This is erroneous for many reasons and I'll go ahead to point them out.

1. We see other people and due to their similarities to ourselves, we reasonably conclude that they're like us in a significant way.
2. We do not see a Christian God and we do not have access to him.
3. I think are objective facts about subjective experiences so someone concludes that other humans are significantly like them based on their appearance, behaviour and other physical features, it would be absurd to simply conclude that it is "exclusively all in my head".
4. Observing humans acting as humans isn't a hallucination. A hallucination is a mistaken perception of something that isn't actually there but we actually do see other people.
5. Then there's the inherent problem with solipsists forming a group. I mean, who is the real person and who is the figment of the imagination in the group of solipsists?

In summary, it may be an attempt at humour but I think that the idea of the bus campaign was a good one and it did fulfill its purpose which was basically raising the public consciousness.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 8:02pm On Mar 05, 2013
This discussion has dragged on long enough so I guess you can have the last word here but I'll end my contribution here by saying once again that frankly, I don't care about the will of Adeboye's God with regards to same sex marriage or anything else in particular.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 8:00pm On Mar 05, 2013
Image123: Is Russel not a man? Is Nietzsche not a man? Are you not emulating them? Why then should i not emulate Jesus or any of the apostles? i'm pointing out the trend to you. The atheist life trends and gravitates towards the same destination. the christian life also trends towards the same destination. i'm doing you and yours a big favour.
Emulating them in what way? After all, Ingersoll was a man, Thomas Paine too was a man so what exactly is your point? What trend? What you're doing is simply a fallacy of hasty generalization. Cherry picking people who you think led bad lives and claiming that whatever you think they did wrong is what atheists should be doing is just fallacious.

Image123: Is the father's seed not planted in the mother? Answer please. i do not imply that the mother doesn't contribute any genetic material. Do you think that when the seed is planted into the ground, it doesn't get anything from the ground. Pls, do not let me question your JSSCE result if you have one(that is if you studied in nigeria).
The very concepts that you're using simply tells me that you're trying to force fit science to fit the primitive ideas written in the Bible. When you're using the analogy with planting seed in the ground, you are implying that the mother doesn't contribute genetic material. Or do you think the ground contributes genetic material to the planted seed?

Image123: What is atrocious about the terms and conditions in the scriptures?
The idea that belief frees you from responsibility. The idea that you were created sick and commanded to be whole? The ridiculous notion that God created man, allowed man to be tempted and for redemption, sacrificed himself to himself in order to cancel the punishment that he was bringing about.

Image123: i've already answered this.
2Pe 3:16 As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other Scriptures, unto their own destruction.
Peter said that the writings of Paul were scriptures, do you recognise scriptures better than Peter?
More ignorance. Who told you that it was Peter the disciple of Jesus who wrote 2 Peter? Educate yourself.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 7:44pm On Mar 05, 2013
Image123: Thought it should be obvious, you can also think as an option. Red for scriptures, Green for your words, Purple for mine. Appreciate NL forum colors, what are you always bitter about. The faith of many is an available evidence presented to you. i'm showing you how unreliable reasoning and evidence alone can get. Also, don't forget you can pray, God wants you to.
Rev 3:20 Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me.
Rev 22:17 And the Spirit and the bride say, Come. And let him that heareth say, Come. And let him that is athirst come. And whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely.



Jesus has been calling you for years now. He invested His life on the cross of calvary for you. He died for you. All you need to do is accept it.
No, faith isn't evidence. And you're now telling me that reason and evidence isn't good enough so you add faith (which to you is evidence)? What an absurdity.

Image123: i thought i brought up the example when i said "Different individuals have their different softspots and weaknesses. Some folks naturally detest stealing and are NATURALLY disciplined enough not to steal. Other folks are so principled and honest and would not tell lies. Some other person values his honour and will never sleep with another man's wife. This doesn't negate the fact that these despised sins are what some other folks cannot do without, or must give in to frequently. It's natural, and they 'find themselves just attracted' to these despicable acts. It's a similar thing with homosexuality. Trying to force a natural angle on it doesn't absolve the sinner. Sin is sin and must be dealt with and frowned at."Here(https://www.nairaland.com/1171126/adeboye-same-sex-marriage-against-god/10#14450992). i don't do red herrings, its all yours. Every man is a natural born sinner, but we all have to repent and believe in God, or else we will be found useless to God on judgement day and punished(put in hell). That's what you do to damaged goods or corrupt files on your hard disk, you remove them if they cannot be treated. god has given us the treatment on the cross, look and live.
Joh 3:14 And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of man be lifted up:
Joh 3:15 That whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have eternal life.
Joh 3:16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
Okay. So you were the one who brought up the example but it still is a red herring. Comparing a feeling of attraction to stealing is a red-herring.

Image123: on your C to Z assumptions, i don't do baseless assumptions. In assuming, we can assume anything, like i can assume to be a dog and my computer a human being, its just crazy and pointless. let's face reality instead.
That's no assumption, that's what according to the Bible, God commanded some people to do.

Image123: That have repented and have been cleansed and forgiven. That is the gospel, the goodnews. That all men can be saved, can start anew. There is hope for you too.
Nah I'd rather stay away from those people. And that is why Christianity is inherently immoral. Just mumble some words and you can be free of any atrocity.

Image123: You're asking in proxy then. i'll say if i've not already said and depending on the context, that Jesus Christ is the reason for my hope. i'll respond to the remainder later, have to go.
Mmmhmmm.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 7:27pm On Mar 05, 2013
Image123: i said it is special because it's not just like every othe book, and i have consistently insisted that my point is not on the special quality but on the Bible not written at once. i asked you to go back and re-read since you seem to have forgotten but it seems to also lazy to do that. Here it is then,
Yes, the revelation of God's will to man was progressive. It was made complete in the new testament. In the new testament, all things are ready, and nothing is needed for addition again.
Joh 19:30 When Jesus therefore had received the vinegar, he said, It is finished: and he bowed his head, and gave up the ghost.
Rev 22:11 He that is unjust, let him be unjust still: and he which is filthy, let him be filthy still: and he that is righteous, let him be righteous still: and he that is holy, let him be holy still.
Rev 22:18 For I testify unto every man that heareth the words of the prophecy of this book, If any man shall add unto these things, God shall add unto him the plagues that are written in this book:

The Bible was released in series, like releasing a book in chapters until the whole thing was complete, except that it is not just like every other book, it is special. There is no change there. i used the word 'progressive' in the sense of ongoing, or gradual or developing. Not in the sense of being a radical or a reformist. The testaments are like step by step until you reach a goal. It's reason that you focus on the goal/destination, instead of how one step is not the same step as the other step. that way, you'll not end up confusing yourself.


What are these sources you are on about? You seem shy to disclose them. You may hav to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the NT gives a different picture and meaning. The Bible and believers in the Bible attest to the fact the NT is a clearer picture and meaning of the OT, it completes it.
So every other book is the same? Sheesh. The Harry Potter books were also "progressive". The story was also gradual and it developed. The sources aren't to be found in some primitive books, they're based on reason, evidence and secular values.

Image123: You said "This is why I said you're ignorant about how the Bible came about. [size=13pt]If you knew anything about that process, you'll know that the paragraphs and spaces weren't already there[/size]. You keep saying that the divisions were inherent yet so far, you've been unable to show that these divisions were inherent." In this link, https://www.nairaland.com/1171126/adeboye-same-sex-marriage-against-god/10#14400771
It sounded so ridiculous that i immediately said Paragraphs and spaces were already there. how can one write without spaces?, then i gave you the wiki link. Now, you want to dishonestly twist things. Shows you're only interested in an argument, not in understanding the biblical viewpoints. The fact that the many translations into many languages end up with the same number of chapters and verses makes nonsense of your assumptions. And where did i seem to think that working on the Sabbath is a moral issue while tolerating slavery isn't a moral issue? Am i now in your brain?
You're seriously asking how one can write without spaces? This is such an unserious line of thought. So you think the fact that there are spaces between the words in this sentence means that each of them deserves to be a verse or a chapter? Ridiculous. And you claim I'm just arguing for fun? Your reference to different languages just shows how little you understand. You said working on the Sabbath was a moral issue and implied that since the issue of slavery wasn't addressed, it wasn't a moral issue.

Image123: It's common sense i suppose, that's why i said it is inherent. God doesn't have to tell you that man is different from other animals, mammals and primates even though they can be classed together in some instances. It's no contradiction, its just an issue of grouping. Anyone can understand basic taxonomy. how you find it hard to understand simple classifications is mind-disturbing.
Did God do the classifying or are you just doing it on your own? If God doesn't have to say anything, why did he bother with giving any commandments? Why did he bother with the beatitudes?

Image123: You don't need, right?
I already have it.

Image123: You are either very dishonest or very forgetful. You said "My point is that you do not have to be literate to actually touch a computer". Now you are asking if a hand is needed. You said that was YOUR POINT, now you're on about who knows what. What exactly is your point, or are you pointless? You are actually showing that you do not know the meaning of faith. God reveals Himself to the gullible, yes.
Mar 10:15 Verily I say unto you, Whosoever shall not receive the kingdom of God as a little child, he shall not enter therein.
1Co 1:18 For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God.
1Co 1:21 For after that in the wisdom of God the world by wisdom knew not God, it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save them that believe.
1Co 1:25 Because the foolishness of God is wiser than men; and the weakness of God is stronger than men.
1Co 2:14 But the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God: for they are foolishness unto him: neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.
That was a rhetorical question because you were absurdly thinking that only literate people could interact with computers. For some reason, the word "interact" seems to confuse you.

Image123: God is not a broken record as it were. All that is needed for our salvation is already revealed in the Scriptures. People are still inspired today, but not to write scriptures as that is already complete. No one is saying you should swallow just any story that walks your way, i wonder where you got that idea. All you need to do is to believe God, and His Word(the Scriptures)
Believing what was written in the scriptures amounts to swallowing just anything from my point of view. Sure he isn't a broken record until he decides to perform a miracle or appear to people.

Image123: The instructions of Jesus are commandments that i obey and that i believe everyone should obey. On God's decisions, i think otherwise and so does the Bible. That settles it for me, your opinions are irrelevant in this case.
They're irrelevant until I slap you or you get sued for your car and you're expected to give them your house too. What a joke.

Image123: i guess you've been to one. It surely didn't look like it helped you much. No, thanks.
Oh it helped me learn more about the Bible than it appears you have done. You're welcome.

Image123: If it 'abolished slavery', it would just be personal correspondence right?
Sure. That is why someone like Jesus should have said something about it.

Image123: Please suggest one to me, thanks. Sportsmen aren't being bought? Do you leave on this planet? There is usually a lot of noise about buying players during transfer windows and there is a swag attached to being the most expensive buy. So, i guess the title is not your problem, the buying is not your problem, the salary is. i've read of slaves that were given salaries, the ones that refused to work were denied of their salaries. And there are many workers in Nigeria where i live who are being owed months of salaries which would definitely not be paid, at least not in full. These people call themselves teachers, accountants, secretaries, nurses, personal assistants and other nice names. Are they slaves? Not funny but i think they are, seems i'm with you on this one.
Nah. It is relevant so I won't bother with suggesting one. That is your line of reasoning it seems. You have to be grossly ignorant of the use of language to think that sportsmen are being "bought" as slaves were once bought and sold. What a joke. No, actually buying people is the problem. People being denied a salary aren't slaves, they are people who can address such grievances at a court unlike slaves.

Image123: Because i don't have to discuss things simply because they are relevant.
Wow. This shows you have no idea how to have a discussion.

Image123: Try to remember those words, you might need to repeat them when you die. Here is the great commission and what is expected of me.
Mar 16:15 And he said unto them, Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.
Mar 16:16 He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved; [size=16pt]but he that believeth not shall be damned[/size].

God did not tell me to talk to Him on your behalf, He told me to talk/preach to you so that you can come talk to Him. It's very simple what happens when you choose not to believe, consider those words of Jesus extra carefully.
Yeah yeah. Threaten me with your hell. While you're at it, invite the Muslim and the Viking to threaten me too.

Image123: Sorry i do not understand the bolded 'fact', can you explain with scriptural proof? Also, this God's aim to remove evil from the earth, can you show me? Peter's 2epistles are scriptures, live with it or tear them out of all the Bibles you can find.
Go and read the story of Noah in the Bible.

Image123: Again, Were Jesus' and God's words also selected at this meeting that you seem to be unhappy about? Are you seriously imagining that i do not know about the council of nicea, constantine and other councils? You really think i know about your uncles(Nietzsche and Russel)and don't know about 'the origin of the Bible'? Indeed, a thousand councils and governments cannot remove one verse from the Word of God. You can rest assured that the complete Word of God is found in the Bible in your hand(hope you didn't tear off the Peter epistles, i didn't mean that literally as a command).
Mat 5:18 For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.
Mat 24:35 Heaven and earth shall pass away, but my words shall not pass away.
1Pe 1:25 But the word of the Lord endureth forever. And this is the word which by the gospel is preached unto you.
Isa 40:8 The grass withereth, the flower fadeth: but the word of our God shall stand forever.


i believe you have read about Voltaire, you can continue from where he stopped, perhaps you might make it ehn.
What a fake image you are. Those people decided what was to become the Word of God itself. I really don't see what point you're making referencing historical unbelievers.

Image123: When someone says "Suffer little children to come unto me . . . " by your reasoning can mean that you're supposed to torture children then kill them in order for them to get to heaven.", he obviously needs sackcloth to cover himself in shame. Jesus loves the little children and there's nothing you can do about that. as for you, if you want mercy, confess your sins and REPENT of them.
And you're just confirming your poor understanding of the language.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 8:26pm On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: This in itself should render pointing them out easy. Your task is to bring up the known reptile-like amphibians, bird-like reptiles and such, for discussion. I already brought up some to other posters earlier in the thread but they refused to discuss them, such as Archeopetryx.
No it doesn't because they don't fit neatly into either group. Take the description of the Tiktaalik. This is what has been noted about their features.

Wikipedia: Tiktaalik is a transitional fossil; it is to tetrapods what Anchiornis is to birds, troodonts and dromaeosaurids. While it may be that neither is ancestor to any living animal, they serve as evidence that intermediates between very different types of vertebrates did once exist. The mixture of both fish and tetrapod characteristics found in Tiktaalik include these traits:

Fish
fish gills
fish scales
fish fins
"Fishapod"
half-fish, half-tetrapod limb bones and joints, including a functional wrist joint and radiating, fish-like fins instead of toes
half-fish, half-tetrapod ear region
Tetrapod
tetrapod rib bones
tetrapod mobile neck with separate pectoral girdle
tetrapod lungs
Deep Sight: Come on. You know very well I am referring to fish with paddle like feet as referred in the species in the link on Transitional Fossils. Why you seem determined to stunt the discussion on petty word games is of deep concern to me. This alone shows you are not willing to face the direct issues. Will you kindly stop doing this?
Then I would advise you to put some effort into properly putting your ideas into words. As far as I know, feet are different from legs and due to the sorts of errors you've been making, I'm hesitant to assume such things with you.

Deep Sight: That is not a problem, but the fact remains that that creature remains "possibly the oldest" such to have feet - as alleged - and the fact remains that this is a deduction or inference from its shoulder girdle, and not that any such was ever found because its fins were never found, no?

Since we are speaking long evolution here, surely it is not inconceivable - infact, it must be the case, that even with creatures of such similar shoulder girdles, there would be gradations in the nature of the ensuing body part, no? This IS exactly why I point out that such a similarity cannot suffice to make the conclusion made.

Simple really.
For the shoulder girdle to work effectively, it would need to be coupled with certain anatomical features. Just as for the gorilla's shoulder girdle to work, it would need to be coupled with certain anatomical features of its arms and fore-arms.

Deep Sight: Surely you will not claim to be unaware of the method of reconstruction deployed in many cases of supposed "ape-men"; wherein the pieces relied on are merely a jawbone and in some cases some teeth and fragments of skull? Surely, you are also aware that this method of reconstruction has led to many blind-alleys and even out-right forgeries such as Pilt-Down man?

The point being that the method of reconstruction which looks at a few bones only is grossly insufficient, and in some cases, outrightly presumptuous if not even totally deceitful and fraudulent, and this, you know for a fact. You cannot deny this.

Thus, it emerges that using such limited fragments is a window into a world of many presumptions and the possibility of many future forgeries and blind alleys. You know this to be true, and that is the point sought to be made.
And your point is erroneous. That is why I asked you if you knew how those frauds were discovered to be frauds. They were discovered to be frauds not by discovering complete skeletons, but by proper examination of the bones. My point is that the complete structure while being a nice finding, isn't quite necessary to arrive at certain conclusions.

Deep Sight: Maybe you have not got the point yet. If fossilization is rare, on a planet with extinct creatures, say for example, several trillion, you will agree that even a mere fraction of this should be substantial enough for reasonable investigations - which of course in reality have been and are still ever underway.

Perhaps it does not occur to you that this excuse would serve well even with the most gap-filled fossil record imaginable. How then is that to be canvassed as proof of a positive claim, which evolution is? Arguing that your proof is rare, even if true, cannot be proof, can it?
You do realize that we have a mere fraction that is substantial enough for reasonable investigations. In fact, that is what has happened so far. The evidence isn't that it is rare, the evidence is that what has actually been found despite the rarity dovetails nicely with the theory of evolution.

Deep Sight: Here again you are deliberately trying to read absurdity into what I have asked of you. Just like you did when you referred to a creature with a billion mutations in an instant, in which case, you were just trying to absurdify the analogy of probability made. Of course no body talks about a fish that gives birth to a frog as its direct offspring or other such, as you have tried to insinuate here. You know very well that we speak of broad groups, which over time, and through evolution, devolve and branch out into further and further groups, thus producing in the long run the other groups of species which I dumbed down in the OP as general groups for Id.iots. Surely you know that. Please stop trying to absurdify simple statements.
And I have to inform you again that I'm trying not to assume anything with you. Frogs aren't reptiles and I didn't take you to be saying that a fish gave birth to a frog, but that you said reptiles were sort of direct descendants of fish.

Deep Sight: As far as this issue of "transition" versus 'intermediate' fossils is concerned, I believe I can now see the area of confusion. The area of confusion results from either deliberate mangling of the text on your part, or from another attempt to absurdify.

Here it is -

When it is said that an intermediate fossil shows a host of traits not common to ancestral or derived groups, this factors time, and does not mean that it shows "no traits" common to either group. It means that there are traits it has, which are not seen in its ancestral groups and also not seen in its derived groups.

The reason I say that you are absurdifying the matter is because you are reacting as though we are speaking three generations of Grandfather, Father and Grandson here, whereas you know very well that we are speaking millions of years during which new features may appear and dissapear. This you know very well. And on account of the fact that the fossils in question are not necessarily or likely direct and immediate offspring of the anscetral group in question, then it is obvious that there will be other intermediate or transitional forms between them which will show gradual evolution or dispensation with such features, even if not found as yet.

As such, by way of analogy -

1 - - [MILLIONS OF YEARS] - - 12 - - [MILLIONS OF YEARS] - - 123 - - [MILLIONS OF YEARS] - - 234 - - [MILLIONS OF YEARS] - - 456.

Where 1 is the ancestor Group, 456 is the descendant group and 123 and 234 are intermediate groups that have a host of traits ("2" and "3" ) (mark you, not "no traits" ) that are present in neither 1 nor 456.

This is a simple analogy and is intended only to show you that when you factor in the extensive period of time between the said fossils being referred to, then of course, since they are not direct offspring, but species that have mutated through time, of course it is perfectly possible and even reasonable to speak about such intermediate species, which will have a host of traits (not no traits) that the ancestor Group or the derived group do not have, based on environmental adaptation over time, etc.

So you have to understand that this does not mean that the descendants do not inherit traits, they do, naturally.

This is why I was shocked at your conclusion in that regard, when you speak about descendants not inheriting traits. That is not what is inferred in the article by that definition.


At all events, I have told you already that I do not care for these definitions that you have decided to stunt the discussion with. Since you say they are the same, I am happy to go with that without further trouble. There is no logical basis to strangulate the discussion on that. I already showed you a distinction from an article that you rejected. It matters not, because the distinction is largely a matter of quantum of traits.

For peace and consistency, let us use the term "transitional fossil" only, going forward. Let us proceed.
Then this will serve as my last response with respect to your confusion about these terms.

You should have realized by now that classification isn't done based on absence of traits but based on the presence of traits. And your tailor made example happily distorts the concept of evolution. But just think through your example carefully. Surely you can see that it isn't really different from the term "transitional fossil" as it is commonly used.

Deep Sight: I did not say it is not a fact. Cop-outs, as far as I know, are usually based on one fact or the other. In any event, what a cop-out does is to attempt to absolve the "outter" of responsibility. In this case I say that this is a cop-out and does not absolve of responsibility because -
Cop-outs are supposed to be flimsy but the facts about the rarity of fossilization and the other things I pointed out aren't flimsy, they're just facts about the world we live in.

Deep Sight: 1. The sheer quantum of species that have walked the earth surely provide a pool of fossils useful for this matter - even if only a small fraction of species have fossilized or are useful at all - such a fraction will still represent a veritable bank of many millions of fossils for useful comparison. And given that this is in fact what evolution is based on, and has in fact been proved on severally, it becomes odd to begin to point at the same fact as your reason for not producing at least some of the key links that creationists like to make noise about.
Creationists aren't interested in the science so fossil discovery isn't to please them or bother with their claims. And as I said, a small fraction of the fossils are in fact, what we have and they work well enough to buttress the theory.

Deep Sight: 2. The fossil record is the scripture for evolution. Inchoate records in most or all of the crucial areas will mean that people will indeed be entitled to say that this is a theory that should not be regarded as grounded science as yet until more and more fossils are found, with continuous work going on for the next few hundred years and beyond.
False. The fossil record isn't the "scripture for evolution". The lines of evidence of evolution are numerous and the results generally confirm the theory. You can take a look at just how diverse the lines of evidence for it are here.
Politics › Re: Kwara Police Commissioner Killed In Enugu by thehomer: 12:03pm On Mar 03, 2013
Who was this visitor that made him abandon his official escort?
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 10:39am On Mar 03, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Hmmmm. . . . . .I think we should have an audio conversation. I'll send you an email.[/quote]Okay. How does the e-mail thing work? I just dismissed it since I didn't see the actual message.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 5:28am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: @ Thehomer. I will continue tomorrow. (later today). I proceed to bed.

I will just point out for now another astonishing leap of yours. How do you exclude descendants from new traits of an intermediate specie. This is just pure magic and discombobulated reverse reasoning. The idea is of course that the intermediate specie is called intermediate because it has new features its ancestors did not have, but which it obviously passes to its descendants. Later.
I didn't exclude descendants, you claimed that the traits were absent in both the ancestors and the descendants. My question then is; how do you know they are related?

Really? Is that the claim? How is that different from the concept of a transitional form? Then this is the quote you've been harping on that I told you and showed you was meaningless.

Deep Sight: Fossils having relatively few such traits are termed "transitional", while those with a [size=16pt]host of traits found NEITHER in the ancestral or derived group[/size] are called "intermediate".
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 5:22am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: How many million years does it take, (give average, since we do not know the precise) for the sort of mutation sequences necessary in that timeline to occur?

Juxtapose this against the timeframe for the existence of only unicellular organisms!
It is your criticism. You do the work to back it up.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 5:21am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: Now, as sleep weighs heavy on my eyes, let me give you the promised summary of questions which I am always compelled to do for you in every discussion. These questions will address the point.

1. Is it the case that life commenced with unicellular organisms.
Most likely.

Deep Sight: 2. Is it the case that the progression of the development of life in evolution is understood to be from unicellular - multi-cellular - waterbased/fish - amphibian - reptile - bird - mammal?
No it is not the case.

Deep Sight: 3. If 2 above is true, is it not the case, that since these transitions were not instantaneous but over millions of years, then millions of species would have existed in between/ part of these general categories?
Well 2 above is false though there were millions of species between the correct categories.

Deep Sight: 4. Please show me the fossils that link these general categories.

Once you do that, we discuss them. And please do not hedge in the water only.

End of.
I have shown you the fossils. I even gave you the names of some of the organism showing a nice transition yet you act as if you didn't read what I wrote.

Here are my questions.

1. Is it the case that fossilization is a rare process?
2. Is it the case that the process is biased towards organisms with hard structures?
3. Is it the case that these fossils are buried in diverse locations all over the earth from the sea to mountaintops? From crisis ridden areas to inhospitable areas?
4. Is it the case that we do not have access to all the locations where these fossils may be buried?
5. Is it the case that it takes a lot of resources to locate these fossils?
6. Is it the case that it takes a lot of resources to retrieve these fossils?
7. Given the sorts of problems indicated above, are you surprised that there will be gaps in the fossil record?
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 5:10am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: Now it is past 4 am here and I am getting tired, but I just had to point this one out. This is by far the most ridiculous and nonsensical response you have ever given me on this forum. I will leave you to discern your error. Or maybe not!

Don't be so silly in your reading, sorry sir! Of course no one says that "one individual organism had that number of mutations instantaneously."!
Of course you don't but you may as well be saying that because it is one implication of your ridiculous notion.

Deep Sight: We speak of the probability of the sequence of mutations that led up that that creature's genetic make-up, occurring over a period of time! We then compare those chances all-in-all for the overall global sequences to the overall age of the earth to see it possible, probable, or improbable.

Dang, Man!
For some reason, you're unable to actually state the error as usual. Rather than simply throwing out the words probable or improbable, why don't you present some ballpark figures or examples? I cannot trust your use of those words because you keep demonstrating that you do not understand the concept.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 5:06am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: I really don't know what to make of your wild flipping about here. I did not say that everything there were fish, certainly not, I pointed you to what was categorized as fish within the Fish - Tetrapods list.
And I explained to you that they had to be classified somewhere didn't I?

Deep Sight: And in that list, as a good example of the sort of fossil I have been demanding, a good one would be to show me a fish with legs that serves as a genuine intermediary (or whatever else you want to call it) fossil. I do not say they do not exist; I say point them out for discussion. Now in this regard, that was exactly why I zeroed in on the creature described thus -

A large, dorso-ventrally flattened predatory fish with a well armoured labyrinthodont-like skull. While the fins themselves has not been found, the shoulder girdle is essentially similar to that of Acanthostega, indicating it too had feet rather than fins.[16]

And stated to be "Possibly oldest animal to have feet rather than fins.[16]"

And of course it is of interest that in this case, no feet were ever observed on this creature, rather the mere similarity of its shoulder girdle to another creature was used to arrive at this conclusion.
A fish with legs? Now you're talking nonsense on stilts. This is why you need some understanding of basic anatomy and it is for this reason that I asked you what you thought transitional fossils were. If you knew anything about anatomy, you'll know that taking a look at the shoulder girdle can give you some information about the structures that may been attached to it. e.g the significant difference between the human shoulder girdle and that of say gorillas tells you a lot about how they moved.

Deep Sight: This is a simple fact that speaks for itself and you would be being disingenuous if you claim not to be aware of multiple instances where this has been done in the fossil record which turned up false or simply unsubstantiated. The same has been done with apes and even birds, surely you know this? Where a Jaw bone has been used to artistically reconstruct a head and claim similarities later disproved, abi I lie?
How was it disproved? Was it by suddenly discovering a complete fossil or by a closer examination and comparison to other jaw bones, knowledge of skulls and considering the circumstances around the discovery?

Deep Sight: Please the simple point here is that the genuine link is not proved by that which is shown. Do not cry about how difficult fossilization is, because, with the sheer quantum of creatures, biolgists would find the links we are talking about, inspite of rarity.

Now, so as to avoid much back and forth on this matter, I suggest to you the following. If you believe that there are linking fossils which show that fish evolved to reptile and reptile to bird and bird to mammal, please, just indulge me and name and shame these fugitive fossils here for me, with pics and sources. Fossils linking these major groups, that is what I ask of you, and we are on 4 pages now, so please dont lets get to 10 pages with me still begging for these!
You're not even reading the links right before you to understand what is being said. The fact that fossilization is rare isn't an excuse, it is a fact about the earth we live in. It is as much a fact as it is a fact that Mt. Everest was formed by the movement of tectonic plates. Get that through your skull first. You can take a look at this link for more information on fossilization.

What I have italicized there is just information flowing from you maybe due to laziness or ignorance but if it is ignorance, you're not even trying to rectify it. Fish didn't evolve to reptiles and birds didn't evolve to mammals so I wonder why you think you'll find such fossils.

Deep Sight: Stated and re stated. Nevertheless, for best clarity just use the blanks in my OP. Those are the fossils I want to see, regardless of what you call them. I am not interested in defeating the discussion with semantics. Intermediate, Transitional, Linking, Middle, etc, whatever words you wish to use, I dont care. So long as they are fossils that show an evolutionary link between those major groups I mentioned.
Err you haven't restated it. We have to first agree that you know what we're talking about because from what you've said so far, you don't seem to know what you're talking about. So, I'm hoping that when you state if for yourself, that you'll actually read and digest it before proceeding once more.

Deep Sight: This is just a cop-out. As said above, just show me the linking fossils for the major groups mentioned.

In all of this, just also remember that I am not trying to disprove evolution. I am trying to show that the factors referred to cannot conceivably be solely responsible for what we see.
Pointing out that fossilization is rare isn't a cop-out, it is a natural fact. Just as naturally formed large diamonds are rare is a natural fact. Besides, I have presented you with some but due to your misconceptions, you're unable to see them as what they are.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 4:42am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: @ Thehomer,

I see we are right about where we usually get when we discuss. I am going to briefly reply some of your comments which are clear misconceptions either of facts or of things that I have written. However, the what is more important is that I do you the usual style summary of few questions that nails the point home and lucidly to you in just a few questions. I will leave that for my next post. Just for clarity, I will devote this post to some of your comments above.



Now you see, I really remain shocked that you cannot see the simplicity of that which was stated in that wiki-article. It made a very simple distinction between intermediate and transitional species which you prefer to toss into the sink. No matter. Regardless the words used, the precept explained there remains simple and valid. For the avoidance of doubt, I reproduce it here -

Ideally, this list would only recursively include 'true' transitionals, fossils representing ancestral species from which later groups evolved, but most if not all, of the fossils shown here represent extinct side branches, more or less closely related to the true ancestor.[2] They will all include details unique to their own line as well. Fossils having relatively few such traits are termed "transitional", while those with a host of traits found neither in the ancestral or derived group are called "intermediate". Since all species will always be subject to natural selection, the very term "transitional fossil" is essentially a misconception. It is however a commonly used term and a useful concept in evolutionary biology. The fossils listed represent significant steps in the evolution of major features in various lines and therefore fit the common usage of the phrase.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_transitional_fossils
And I've told you and shown you that:
it makes no sense,
the terms are synonymous based on the usage by the professionals,
the part you're hinging your entire idea on is un-referenced.

Do you disagree with criticisms I've raised above?

Deep Sight: Now the description and delineation here is very simple and commonsensical and I cannot imagine why you take issue with it, if not to escape the question I have asked: namely, produce intermediate fossils, a simple question which seems to have rubbed you the wrong way this morning. You prefer to ask for a reference for the explanation given, rather than show why the explanation is wrong in principle. You will not find references in any articles for statements that read like 1 + 1 = 2. Nobody is going to start giving you a reference for such self-evident statement.
If the very idea of intermediate fossils as you're using the term makes no sense, then how do you expect to find examples of such a fossil? If you want examples of transitional fossils or intermediate fossils as the term is used by biologists, then you'll see them on the article you posted.

Deep Sight: Now, worse you choose to dwell on word play rather than address the issue raised in that simple delineation. The very simple issue is as follows -

- - - For creatures to evolve, there will be naturally occurring changes in the species with time. If these changes lead to mere subsets of the same creature, without differences said to create a new specie, then you will agree that these are transitional species. What is referred to as intermediate species are the species that show new characteristics which are not discernible from their ancestors, and the emergence of which show the emergence of a new specie, or at least the beginnings of it. To use a very crude analogy, I might say that a breed of bird developing more feathers as it procreates or longer wings as it procreates may be transition: but what we are looking for is that breed of bird that begins to show a loss of feathers or wings altogether and even perhaps mammalian claws such as to suggest that there is a transition from bird to mammal.
How is it that you do not see your ridiculous notion? Using your example, the ostrich is a bird showing a huge reduction in wings is it an intermediate specie? If it became extinct, would it still be intermediate? Now if the bird developed mammalian claws, won't the claws then be a trait shared between it and its descendant? Based on the way you're using that term "intermediate" here, it won't be so but based on the concept of transition, it would.

Deep Sight: This is not hard to comprehend. To the extent that it is contended that mammal arose from the bird, then, and it is also contended that this occured over millions and millions of years, then IRREVOCABLY, there must have been species of intermediate bird that would display the dying characteristics of the preceding ancestry and the merging characteristics of the emerging specie. This, my friend, is indubitable, and this is all I ask you for: to show me such species, fossils of such. There must be a great many, sir.
You obviously haven't even taken a look at the basics of the theory. It isn't contended that mammals arose from birds, but that they shared common ancestors.

Deep Sight: Therefore it is disconcerting that you could begin to ask such an odd and inappropriate question as that which you ask - namely that if new features are observed, (which is of course necessary at some point, for evolution to hold true): how then do we know the ancestry of the emergent creature. We know it because of the common features that still exist in the said creature, with its ancestors! Come on, this is 101.
Now you're being a tad disingenuous. According to your usage of the word, the organism had traits absent in both descendants and ancestors. Well where then did the traits come from? Where did they go? Were they mutations caused by gamma rays like the hulk?

Deep Sight: In all of this your grand pretense is simply the semantics of "intermediate" and 'transitional' and whether they mean the same thing or not. My friend, so as not to waste our time, as I told you earlier, you can readily fling those distinctions out the window as you wanted to do anyway. Just provide for me the transitional/ intermediate/ middle/ existing/ continuing/ preceding/ [*add choice word*] FOSSILS that necessarily existed for there to be a development into new species. As that process was slow, there needs be many such gradations of such changes, simple sir.

I hope you are clear on this issue now.

I will proceed to your other comments before summarizing the key question yet again. Many thanks.
Like I said, the examples are right in the article you posted a link to.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 4:22am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: Because, sir, they share traits with the said ancestral groups. What is said is that such intermediate fossils also show new traits as well, period. Are you seriously trying to discuss, or kidding me?
What do you think is the distinction between transitional fossils and intermediate fossils? I ask because what you've just said above applies to transitional fossils.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 2:39am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: @Plaetton -

Let's use the summary of the basic evolutionary timeline for discussion -

The basic timeline of a 4.6 billion year old Earth, with approximate dates:

3.6 billion years of simple cells (prokaryotes),

3.4 billion years of stromatolites demonstrating photosynthesis,

2 billion years of complex cells (eukaryotes),

1 billion years of multicellular life,

600 million years of simple animals,

570 million years of arthropods (ancestors of insects, arachnids and crustaceans),

550 million years of complex animals,

500 million years of fish and proto-amphibians,

475 million years of land plants,

400 million years of insects and seeds,

360 million years of amphibians,

300 million years of reptiles,

200 million years of mammals,

150 million years of birds,

130 million years of flowers,

65 million years since the dinosaurs died out,

2.5 million years since the appearance of the genus Homo,

200,000 years of anatomically modern humans,

25,000 years since the disappearance of Neanderthal traits from the fossil record.

13,000 years since the disappearance of Homo floresiensis from the fossil record.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_evolutionary_history_of_life

Observe any oddities, or grossly unlikely timeframes?
Not really. Can you let us know what these oddities or grossly unlikely timeframes are?
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 2:38am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: Infinite, you say? How presumptuous! Anyway, I posted the timeline of evolution for the earth up there for you right after my post, maybe you should scrutinize it.

But before you do so, please let us agree on a simple principle.

Note carefully the following:

If we were to agree that the probability of a given sequence of events, is 1 in say, 1 billion days.
This is misunderstanding of probability. Probability is a ratio and has no units so introducing days here shows you don't understand what you're talking about.

Deep Sight: And that sequence of events requires 1 billion precise mutations and incidents of chance to occur as a full sequence once in 1 billion days.
This is a misunderstanding of the theory of evolution. What you need to keep in mind is that while there are random mutations, it is the organisms that live that can serve as ancestral species so the "1 billion precise mutations" to use your frame of reference doesn't mean that one individual organism had that number of mutations instantaneously.

Deep Sight: Now let us say that we are given a timeframe for a venue for such an event to occur.

Let us say that that venue exists for only 1 day so far.

Would you agree, given the foregoing analogy, that it would be statistically improbable to say that the 1 day could support the occurrence of the full sequence of events?
Your analogy fails because you obviously don't understand what the actual theory says.

Deep Sight: I ask this question (and I hope you appreciate it) in order to see if you understand the fundamental reasoning behind my assertion that the age of the earth does not support the full spectrum of evolution. If you understand the analogy, you should see the point already - that is, once you take on board the period required for each instance of relevant macro evolution.

Finally, please note that although this problem became apparent to me without reference, I find that it is a huge issue which has been debated by even evolutionary scientists. Some have come to their own conclusions. What do you say?
Ooh it became apparent to you without reference. You must be very good to figure all this out from your armchair. I just think that you need to be humble and study the abundant material available. You could also try to actually calculate the probabilities involved.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 2:21am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: For the last time I will help you out with your illiteracy and wasted school fees.

"A host of traits" is what was said. What does "A host of traits" mean? It means several traits.

Therefore when it is said that - "while those with a host of traits found neither in the ancestral or derived group are called "intermediate".

- - -> This simply means that they are referring to creatures that had several traits not traceable to their supposed ancestors and not creatures that had no traceable traits!

Disgraceful! Simply disgraceful!

Like, guy, seriously? ? ? ? ? ?
Why do you persist with such ignorance and misconceptions? I've explained to you that the idea you're pushing here makes no sense, I've shown that the specialists don't misuse that idea in that way yet you continue with this misconception. If this host of traits cannot be found in either the ancestral or derived groups, how do you know they're related?

Why don't you answer that?
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 2:17am On Mar 03, 2013
Deep Sight: O, SO AFTER making a big deal about the terms, you now wish to say its not just the terms? This is one of the weakest showings I have ever seen from you friend.

The idea I have hung everything on is that of seeking fossils between major divisions, simple.

Show me them.
Obviously, you've not been reading what I wrote because you're once again making ridiculous claims. Did you notice this line?

thehomer: If the traits aren't observed in the ancestral or derivative groups, how does anyone know they're related? Go ahead and explain it.
Deep Sight: Useless, because you will see that what you refer to are designated as Fish, no? In fact, if you look through to list, you will see that when the going gets tough and assumptions begin to be made about creatures that had feet, no feet were in fact observed, but such were assumed from the shape of the jaws, which was all that was available! ! ! !
This is astonishingly and amazingly ignorant. Did you actually read through that link? Did you look at organisms like Tiktaalik, Elginerpeton, Ventastega, Acanthostega and Ichthyostega? They're all fish? Take a look at even Tiktaalik alone and you'll see that it had features present in both fish and tetrapods and some features between both. The fact that it is "classified" as fish simply shows that it had to be grouped somewhere. Just bear in mind that these classifications are human impositions on the natural world.

If you actually understood the concept of transitional fossils, you'll understand why you do not need the entire fossil to tell that an organism belongs to one group and not another. That is why I asked you to state it again for clarity.

Deep Sight: I have told you exactly what I refer to as transitional and intermediate fossils. You make issue with the definitions, so no worries.
Simply state it here for clarity. Surely since you've done it before, you can do it again. I want to be sure that you have some idea of what you're talking about because so far, you're showing some confusion with respect to these concepts.

Deep Sight: To be clear: I ask you to show me the fossils that show features between the groups I mentioned. This is a very simple task. And you cannot run away from it with your excuses, because if indeed evolution occurred in the way described, then for heavens sake there must be simply trillions of such fossils all about. When U say that fossilization is rare, the high number of such creatures must still render a cognizable amount of fossils available.
And I've shown you these fossils but in your confusion, you're unable to see what is right before you. Can you give an estimate on the amount of fossils to be expected, where to dig for them and how much it would cost to do that? Or do you think that the fossils will be shouting out from the ground to invite scientists to dig them up? Ridiculous.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 8:17pm On Mar 02, 2013
Deep Sight: My friend, I don't know why you are getting excited. Its simple really. Of course the terms are generally similar. But there remains a fine distinction - and that remains the question in the OP. If you noticed, I already crafted the OP in such a way as to convey what I was looking for. Namely fossils that show features that make it evident that indeed fish did evolve to amphibian, amphibian to reptile, reptile to bird, bird to mammal, and so on. This is a very simple question which no amount of attempts to render "intermediate" as transitional" will obviate - even if successful.
It isn't just that the terms are similar, it is that the idea you tried to hang everything on made no sense.

Deep Sight: So the words regardless, the fossils being sought are obvious. Please call them what you please. Heck, even call them middle, or evolving or worever. The fact is that I am looking for fossils between the major groups of creatures. Crying about the similarity between the words 'intermediate' and transitional' will only show that you have no such fossils to show - even where I have shown you a difference.

Just fetch me the fossils I indicated gaps for in the OP, simple.

Other than that, all you have shown here is just rambling.
Right on the page that you got the misleading information from, there's a list with pictures of the fossils. The link between fish and tetrapods is listed from here on that same page.

Now, what do you think a transitional fossil is? Since as I've shown you, the idea of intermediate fossil you were using was erroneous.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 8:00pm On Mar 02, 2013
Deep Sight: And do you assert this to be an instance of mutation in the evolutionary context?
It isn't an assertion, it is a fact of biological organisms and their fossilized remains. Surely you can understand the inference being made. If genetic mutations within people living within a 100 years of each isn't seen in their bones, how much more will that of organisms whose remains are millions of years old?

It is also a fact that not all mutations are expressed in such a way that they'll be significantly different from their parents.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 7:55pm On Mar 02, 2013
Deep Sight: This is unlike you. Confess, you are having something to drink, or you are at a party or something? ? ? ?

I repeat, and READ AGAIN: IT DOES NOT SAY "NO TRAITS! ! !"

It says "species with a host of traits not observed in the ancestral or derivative groups" That simply means species with some new traits that were not previously seen in ancestral or derivative groups ! ! !

Haba now?
And this is very much like you. I hope the brunch you had wasn't so heavy that it is still diverting blood to your GIT.
If the traits aren't observed in the ancestral or derivative groups, how does anyone know they're related? Go ahead and explain it.

You came accepting that you had little knowledge. I've told you that the two terms are similar, you disagree and show me a single line on Wikipedia that you'll notice has no citation. I also inform you that the way it is generally used by the experts is how I'm using it and that google will clearly demonstrate this but you refuse to budge from the uncited line that I've shown you in various ways to make no sense.
Christianity Etc › Re: Evolution For Simpletons by thehomer: 7:49pm On Mar 02, 2013
davidylan: there is evidence in shale that fossilized unicellular organisms do exist.
Sure and I said it was virtually absent. You do realize that the number of fossils of multicellular organisms far outweighs that of unicellular organisms despite the fact that unicellular organisms are far more numerous. So what I'm basically saying is that fossilization is a rare process.

davidylan: I struggle with this... because quite clearly, evolution required genetic mutations to be expressed as distinct phenotypes. How is it possible then to argue that the lack of intermediate species is down to mutations that could only be seen in the genes?
Actually, evolution doesn't require that all genetic mutations be expressed as distinct phenotypes like I said, most mutations are "silent". e.g a man is genetically distinct from his father yet their bones will generally look alike despite their genetic differences. How much more when it comes to fossils millions of years old?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 (of 210 pages)