₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,384 members, 8,522,755 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 11:04 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 9:43pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: Er, excuse me. Did you say debosky showed me something? Show it to me please. I may have missed it.
Looks like you did. Won't be the first time.

debosky: Furthermore, I disagree with the superficial assertion that atheism recognizes 'no standards' - that isn't the case, it simply doesn't recognise any standards as 'absolute' or 'divine' - that doesn't stop individuals or groups of individuals from setting their own standards as they deem fit - it may not be homogeneous among all atheists, but that isn't a requirement either.
Ihedinobi: What's that about anarchy not meaning different answers to the same frigging question? Damn!

What's that you say aboute saying that anarchy means no morals? Where'd I say that? Damn!
Look up the definition of anarchy. You'll note that in anarchy, there is generally no order.

Ihedinobi: Hehehe.... Grasping much? grin So based on what do you say that "theism cares naught for right and wrong"?
Based on the fact that theism only answers one question. Which is about whether or not the person believes that some God exists.

Ihedinobi: All I saw above was a lot of grasping, buddy.
Then you should be able to form proper connections rather than the haphazard ones you made.

Ihedinobi: Yeah smiley Whatever rocks your boat, buddy. grin
This isn't about what rocks my boat, it is about showing you that you need to back up what you say with good evidence and not flights of fancy.
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 7:37pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: Ok. So are those two things the same?
They're close enough for my purposes.

Ihedinobi: I was warning debosky not to join unbelievers in attacking believers considering that he is one himself. I preceeded the warning with an intimation of the fact that I'm always praying that God help me not to attack believers in the name of being fair to unbelievers. It was a subtle warning about the dangers posed by playing devil's advocate, dangers I know intimately.
In other words, it looked to you like debosky with his post was joining unbelievers to attack believers. And in your opinion, what he was doing was simply playing devil's advocate. Didn't it occur to you that he was expressing his actual views? i.e Atheism doesn't necessarily lead to immorality?
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 6:56pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: I said that? undecided My post ain't going anywhere, man. Feel free to quote it and mark where I said that.
I'm clarifying what you didn't understand about my response. I asked you to clarify what you said but so far, you're yet to do so for fear that you'll be wrong as usual.

This is a quote directly from you:

Ihedinobi: There is an unspoken prayer in my heart all the time rising up to God, it is that I never for any reason raid the cities of the Lord and harm my own brothers and sisters even if only out of the need to be fair to unbelievers. Debosky, my brother, never let your David be found in the battle on the side of the Philistines striking down the perhaps erring armies of the Lord.
Now will you clarify what you meant by your quote above? Or will you once again, run away from explaining your own words?

Ihedinobi: Sure thing. cheesy So, you should have no difficulties answering Enigma's poser.
It would be pointless because he began by contradicting himself. You'll notice that he began with this.

Enigma: Some say that a person who is an atheist can act morally. Agreed! That was never the point at all.
Which is contradictory to saying that immorality necessarily follows from atheism.

Edit: Proper attribution.
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 6:45pm On Mar 01, 2013
I wonder if any theists can answer this question.

Can anyone point to ONE SINGLE thing that is immoral due to theism?

The same question in a different way: is there one single thing that is immoral on the basis of theism?
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 6:27pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: We're agreed then smiley Atheism cares naught for right and wrong, that is amorality. That leaves atheists to come up with their own moral codes. And each one is as right or wrong as its designer says it is. That leaves everyone in a state of anarchy. Anarchy breeds immorality. Therefore, atheism leads straight as an arrow to immorality. smiley Thank you, sir.
Amorality is different from immorality. Wow what a stream of purely terrible reasoning.
Atheists can arrive at consistent moral decisions without appealing to a God as debosky already showed you.
Everyone not arriving at exactly the same answer doesn't necessarily lead to anarchy.
If you say in anarchy, there are no morals, then how can there be immorality?

You see, you've successfully confused yourself again. After all replace atheism with theism and you get the same result. This would lead to the conclusion that theism leads to immorality. Let me spell it out for you.

Theism cares naught for right and wrong, that is amorality. That leaves theists to come up with their own moral codes. And each one is as right or wrong as its designer says it is. That leaves everyone in a state of anarchy. Anarchy breeds immorality. Therefore, theism leads straight as an arrow to immorality.

Ihedinobi: You also just showed me that the lack of moral absolutes plunges everyone down the ravine of immorality.
And as you can see above, you made several connections based on poor reasoning.

Ihedinobi: C'mon, don't whine grin We just had us a jolly good ride.
It isn't whining to point out that the other party for some reason is unable to support their empty claims in a discussion.
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 6:19pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: No, I did not. You're welcome to try to clarify what you said above with respect to my hinting that debosky should not present his views even if it is against a Christian's view in order for me not to criticize his point.
You said he was fighting on the wrong side and that you did not want to attack him. Now will you clarify what you said? Or will you stick to repeating after me?

Ihedinobi: Did you read the quote from Enigma in the op? If you did, then can you tell me where he didn't refer to amorality?
The fact is that you do. If atheists don't appeal to some God how are they able to make moral decisions?
The very fact that he used the word immoral and not amoral.
Atheists make moral decisions based on the effects of their actions on others. Obviously, a God isn't needed to make these decisions.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 6:07pm On Mar 01, 2013
Image123: Ooops, sorry, i wasn't defining faith. iguess it(the sentence) would be rendered better as Faith is an evidence. i was replying to what you said that "What we have is reason and evidence." i showed that Reason may not be reliable or may be impaired, then i mentioned that Faith is evidence, or better still, Faith is an evidence. Christ appears to many believers today. Their witness(es) is evidence enough to you. Sorry for the mix caused.
i am not on a higher pedestal or opportunity than you are.You can pray, God wants you to.
Rev 3:20 Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me.
Rev 22:17 And the Spirit and the bride say, Come. And let him that heareth say, Come. And let him that is athirst come. And whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely.


Jesus has been calling you for years now. He invested His life on the cross of calvary for you. He died for you. All you need to do is accept it.
1Co 15:6 After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once; of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep.
This is not a literary technique that is often used in stories so that others would believe the claims made.
What's with these random colours you keep inserting in your texts? Anyway, you're still saying the same thing. i.e faith = evidence so you need to perform a better correction.

Image123: In context, i was picturing a thief, not an admirer. Like magnetizing other people's property, pick pocket stuff. The point been made was that some people are natural thieves, its in the blood/gene as it were. Some others learn theft, they naturally would not steal. They may do other stuff/sin like fornicating, even idolatry, but they may be principled and honest or hometrained. But due to bad influence, they join cults, bad gangs, become robbers. Theft can be picked up or learned, it can also be natural. The point again been driven is that being a natural homosexual doesn't make it right, just like been a natural deceiver, or a 'born killer'.
How about if God says kill persons C to Z? How about IF there is a God?
Why should you be picturing a thief when I (the person who brought up the example) was talking about an admirer? Wouldn't this be your own red-herring?

Based on what you were picturing, you're saying that there are some natural born thieves and natural born killers? Now why would God create such natural born thieves and killers yet decide to punish them?

Why don't you actually answer the question rather than trying like many other Christians on this forum to be evasive but still keep on failing.
Assume that your God exists. Now if that God of yours says kill persons C to Z, will it be a sin not to kill them?

Image123: You should enjoy biblical sarcasm. God will have mercy on all who confess to Him and give up sins.
Sure he will. That is why Heaven will be full of murderers, rapists and thieves.

Image123: Are you asking me for the reason of my hope?
No, I'm asking what you're to do when you're asked that question.

Image123: Do you think that one has to be like Jesus to be a true christian? Do you really think that anyone can live how He lived if one tried?
Now you mention any true atheist, i've given two popular sorry ones, Nietzsche and Russell. And give me a reason why they should be role models or mentors.
You do realize that Bertrand Russell isn't a God. Don't parrot my questions back at me, they're meant for you to answer. I never said they should be role models or mentors.

Image123: Is it not the seed that becomes the tree or fruit? The tree/man can be looked upon in retrospect as the seed. The mother is where the seed is planted into to yield as a man/fruit. Saul's father planted seed Saul into Saul's mother. It's the same thing your father and my father did. You are the seed of your father, and i am the seed of my father also.


Do you understand basic agriculture and biology?
Yes I do you obviously don't with the sort of ignorant bronze age explanation you're presenting here. JSS 1 students know better than to say that the father's seed is planted in the mother and imply that the mother doesn't contribute any genetic material. This is just shameful.

Image123: i'd rather be pro-active, and do what can be done from mine end. And at the end, i'll have done my best. What about you? God loves us all, but He can do without us.
Mar 15:32 Let Christ the King of Israel descend now from the cross, that we may see and believe. And they that were crucified with him reviled him.
God has revealed Himself and keeps revealing Himself on His terms. If you want Him hard enough, follow His terms.
Dan 4:35 And all the inhabitants of the earth are reputed as nothing: and he doeth according to his will in the army of heaven, and among the inhabitants of the earth: and none can stay his hand, or say unto him, What doest thou?
When you need a job, you look at the requirements and meet up, when you need a house to rent, you look at the agreements and conditions, when you need Heaven and God, you look at the Word of God and comply. You don't blame God, you have to be pro-active. If there is any blame(which is needless, it is man, your ancestors, Adam and you.
What you fail to understand is that the Qur'an too is the Word of God so the Word of which God is to be believed? Then there's the issue that if the terms and conditions are very atrocious, then they will be rejected and we will advice others to avoid that place too. Now if the place being sold looks like a scam, one would do well to avoid it too.

Image123: Eph 1:1 Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God, to the saints which are at Ephesus, and to the faithful in Christ Jesus:
Eph 6:23 Peace be to the brethren, and love with faith, from God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ.
Eph 6:24 Grace be with all them that love our Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity. Amen.
1Pe 1:1 Peter, an apostle of Jesus Christ, to the strangers scattered throughout Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia,
2Pe 3:15 And account that the longsuffering of our Lord is salvation; even as our beloved brother Paul also according to the wisdom given unto him hath written unto you;
2Pe 3:16 As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other Scriptures, unto their own destruction.

Add the facts that the contents of the epistles show that they contained instructions to all including men and women and youths. And the truth of history that these epistles were actually passed around different churches as scripture, not personal correspondence. Christians think and know that they are all scripture, you think it is personal correspondence, who is deceiving who? That's actually a rhetorical question, you are deceiving yourself.
Passing around personal correspondence as scripture doesn't make it scripture all it gives you is the idea of what the writer had in mind. Or did God come down and whisper to those who included it in the Bible? I hope you know that there are numerous letters that weren't included in the Bible and that some of them were even wrongly attributed. So to answer your rhetorical question, you're the one deceiving yourself and it looks like you've also been deceived by others too.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 5:54pm On Mar 01, 2013
Image123: All you need to do is go back and read my posts to confirm what i have said, that "Its a red herring and you are full of red herrings. i've consistently insisted on the point i was making but you seem more interested in talking about if the Bible is special or not." What are these other sources for reasonable instructions? Do you talk this much about these other books? If yes, please let me know what books those are. The NT is a completion of the whole book(the Bible). This is what i have been saying for weeks, that the books were in phases. The NT gives a clearer and more complete picture and meaning.
Why did you say anything about the Bible being special at all? The sources aren't books. I would say the NT gives a different picture and meaning.

Image123: You initially said that paragraphs and spaces were not there in the original manuscripts, didn't you? And you're going red yet again. You mentioned anything about english and other languages? Do you think that spaces and paragraphs are only found in english writings? Moral laws deal with right or wrong, ceremonial laws deal with cleansing of sin. Most of the laws are easily put under any of this two. Use your brain, or ask practical questions if you do not understand.
The colored is the issue being discussed, but i'll still not be dumbfounded if you're more interested in discussing lines and spaces.
No I didn't say that. Please go back and read what I actually said. The fact that it wasn't written in English means that the spaces could have been in places different from what you get in the English translations. Obviously, you're not using your brain because you seem to think that working on the Sabbath is a moral issue while tolerating slavery isn't a moral issue.

Image123: You lack understanding. It's almost COMMON sense to see the inherent differences in the laws/instructions. Some laws are once (like walking around Jericho or picking 300 men). Some instructions are continuous. Some instructions are for cleansing or ceremonial, like staying some place for seven days, killing a bird or a goat. Some laws are simply moral, like don't kill, don't steal. how you cannot/refuse to understand that is baffling.
Actually, you're the one deeply lacking in understanding because you think that the Sabbath law is a moral one. I'm asking you to state where God stated the differences but you cannot that is why you keep trying to hide behind a blade of grass.

Image123: And a link would convince you right? You need Jesus.
And you need good reasoning.

Image123: Well, your point was poorly presented. All you need is to have hands and access before you actually touch a computer. You said 'interact with a computer'. Every human being can believe, we all have that capacity/ability. No special powers needed to believe. Faith is belief, i try to keep it simple and basic to help you understand and give you some perspective. i thought it pointless to speak 'lofty chinese' to someone who doesn't understand it. There was a time i did not believe in God, and every other born again christian. But we changed our minds. The reason why God will possibly make you believe a lie is already state and emboldened. It is because they received not the love of the truth, that they might be saved. Do you fit that picture yet? Again, God always reveals Himself to those who love the truth and sincerely want to know.
Do you need a hand to interact with a computer? You see, interacting with a computer covers more than just using your hand to touch it. Don't blame me for your incompetence. Wow. You just keep showing that you have no idea of what you're talking about when you say that faith = belief. In other words, he reveals himself to the gullible.

Image123: All that needs to be said are already in the Bible. The Bible was written in phases, not at once, it spanned hundreds of years like you're seeming to know. Then it was collated. There is nothing to be added that has not being already said. All that we need for eternal life are in it. It is finished.
So God has stopped inspiring people. Instead, he asks us to be gullible and swallow just any story that walks our way.

Image123: Good of you, you now see the changes and the differences i was talking about. You're picking up. smiley
i like your definition of a wise God. Fits the God of the Bible very well.
Are you willing to accept those instructions as commandments with imperatives similar to; don't kill and don't steal?
Yet the Biblical God keeps on making poor decisions.

Image123: The vision speaks of God telling Peter to eat formerly unclean animals. It cuts it. The book of 1Timothy and Acts are scripture, live with it.
Please go to a Bible school because you obviously don't understand what you've read there.

Image123: Funny that Ephesians is personal correspondence, except where it can be seemingly used to show that the Bible God approved slavery. You deceive yourself a lot, after satan has done his own part.
I said it didn't abolish slavery. Learn to read what I actually write.

Image123: Woah, are they different? The Bible translators seem to used them(slave and servant) interchangeably. Are you saying that the chief characteristic or quality or determinant of a slave is being bought? i know many sportmen who are being bought, i do not think they are slaves, well perhaps maybe. Is it the buying that is paining you, or the title? i initially thought it was the title/tag, hence my boring talk that was 'blurring the distinction' Not sure if Abraham bought his slaves, even the Israelites. Anyway, lemme know what is pinching you in the shoe.
Then you should get a Bible that had good translators because good translations use different words for them. Your ignorance knows no bounds. Those sportsmen aren't being bought, the money you see there is payment for their services. Slaves aren't paid a salary.

Image123: The two passages are relevant today.
If they're relevant, then why don't you discuss them?

Image123: Sorry dear, it's not easier than what i said. When you are ready to see Jesus, have faith. If you can believe, you will see. God wants a personal relationship with you. He's saying "Where are you thehomer?" He's knocking at the door of your heart. Whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved.
Rom 10:8 But what saith it? The word is nigh thee, even in thy mouth, and in thy heart: that is, the word of faith, which we preach;
Rom 10:9 That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.
Rom 10:10 For with the heart man believeth unto righteousness; and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation.
Rom 10:11 For the Scripture saith, Whosoever believeth on him shall not be ashamed.
Rom 10:12 For there is no difference between the Jew and the Greek: for the same Lord over all is rich unto all that call upon him.
Rom 10:13 For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved.
He can knock until his hands bleed. I don't know this God, you know him. Why don't you talk to him? You're giving me flimsy excuses to hide the fact that either he isn't there or he's going to ignore you.

Image123: Thank God for your life, the new testament said it was a warning. i sincerely thank God that you saw that all along. But this God's aim to remove evil from the earth, can you show me? Peter is personal correspondence but Moses is coming straight from God? Where did you get that? i've searched but i can't find this new revelation. All i found was this.
Gen 6:7 And the LORD said, I will destroy man whom I have created from the face of the earth; both man, and beast, and the creeping thing, and the fowls of the air; for it repenteth me that I have made them.
Gen 6:8 But Noah found grace in the eyes of the LORD.

nothing about God's aim to remove evil from the earth.
Well the writer in the NT was probably just as confused as you. The fact that he regretted the action while saving people he thought were God implies that. Unless of course you think God was just into pointless acts of suffering (well maybe he is). Peter was writing to someone else and some people just captured the letter and included it in the Bible while Moses was reporting what God told him (according to Christian legend of course).

Image123: i don't get this new reds about selections by some guys in a meeting. Were Jesus' and God's words also selected at this meeting that you seem to be unhappy about?
Then don't be lazy. Look up things like the origin of the Bible and the Council of Nicea. You can start with Wikipedia.

Image123: Shameful sentences. You need sackcloth and ashes, really.
Again, don't blame me for your poor understanding of the language.
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 4:55pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: I hope you're aware that you have just agreed with me that atheism recognizes no moral absolutes. Does this then show that you also agree that immorality necessarily follows from atheism?
And I hope you're also aware that you've just agreed with me that Christianity recognizes no moral absolutes.
Atheism doesn't say anything about morality. Atheism answers one question. Now if you were talking about atheists and their stance on morality, that would be a different question.

Ihedinobi: Er, you're the one to demonstrate that it actually does not follow since like I've said before, atheism does not recognize any moral absolute. If it doesn't, then immorality necessarily follows from atheism.
I just showed you that it cannot follow because there are atheists who perform moral actions. If it followed, atheists would always be performing immoral actions.
Atheists don't need to recognize any moral absolutes in order to act morally.

As usual, you've began once more not to hold up your own part of the discussion. It leads me to wonder whether or not you understand what you need to do in order to show that something follows necessarily from another or are you too trying to be evasive and as usual, failing at it. Would you like a reference or a coach to help you?
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 4:44pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: You seem to be deliberately misconstruing my words in order to set my brother against me.
No I'm not. You're welcome to try to clarify what you said above with respect to debosky being on the side of the enemy attacking God's army.

Ihedinobi: No, Enigma said that atheism is uncaring about right and wrong (amoral) and that such an attitude results in immorality. The basic error you're making is in assuming that we do not derive morality from theism. Sensible people do not agree with that assumption.
Did you read the quote from Enigma in the OP? If you did, then can you tell me where he referred to amorality?
The fact is that we don't. If atheists don't appeal to some God yet they're able to make moral decisions, then how exactly do they derive morality from this God that they don't appeal to?
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 2:55pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: The very fact that atheism recognizes no moral absolutes shows that immorality necessarily follows from atheism.
I hope you're aware that Christianity doesn't recognize any moral absolutes. Does this then show that immorality necessarily follows from Christianity?

Ihedinobi: Now can you demonstrate that immorality does not necessarily follow from atheism?
Err. You're the one to demonstrate that it actually does follow since like I've said before, not all atheists act immorally. If they don't all act immorally, then immorality doesn't necessarily follow from atheism.
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 2:46pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: There is an unspoken prayer in my heart all the time rising up to God, it is that I never for any reason raid the cities of the Lord and harm my own brothers and sisters even if only out of the need to be fair to unbelievers. Debosky, my brother, never let your David be found in the battle on the side of the Philistines striking down the perhaps erring armies of the Lord.
You seem to be hinting that debosky shouldn't present his view even if it seems to make a point against a Christian's view in order for you not to criticize his point.

Ihedinobi: Now, Enigma was saying that atheism is amoral. That is the conclusion. If atheism is followed to its logical end, it will be terribly immoral, not on its own standards, but on ours, because it recognizes no standards. Do you understand that?
No, Enigma explicitly said atheism was immoral. The basic error you're making is in assuming that we derive morality from theism. Atheists disagree with that assumption.
e.g to many atheists, commanding a genocide is immoral not amoral but to Christians, it is sometimes moral.
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 2:38pm On Mar 01, 2013
Ihedinobi: And any atheist who disagrees with that simply reasons poorly. If they disagree, then they should be able to actually show that immorality does not necessarily follow from atheism.
The very fact that an atheist can act morally shows that immorality doesn't necessarily follow from atheism.

Now can you demonstrate that immorality necessarily follows from atheism?
Politics › Re: 5 Lagos-bound Passengers Kidnapped At Benin-Ore Sagamu Road by thehomer: 1:51pm On Mar 01, 2013
jnr prof: My Colleague's younger brother was in that vehicle. He has been released after paying a ransom of 1.5m. And off course, the police have no involvement in the matter
It should be possible to track the money if the victims are serious about seeing justice done.
Christianity Etc › Re: Christians, Do You Agree With This? by thehomer: 1:48pm On Mar 01, 2013
Logicboy03: Do you agree with this analysis of atheism?


Enigma:
1. If you read proper philosophers, including atheist philosophers that are honest to some extent, you will know that immorality is a natural and logical corrolary of atheism.

2. The example of the atheists on this forum tells us that immorality and lack of morals go together with atheism.

smiley
https://www.nairaland.com/1198534/cowardice-atheism/10#14364222
Any Christian who agrees with that simply reasons poorly. If they disagree, then they should be able to actually show that immorality necessarily follows from atheism.
Christianity Etc › Re: Bionic Dance by thehomer: 11:43am On Mar 01, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]This is what it feels like sometimes.....


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nn-ZggPYmvg[/quote]What is your point?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Atheist Creed! by thehomer: 11:36am On Mar 01, 2013
Firstly, atheism isn't a worldview just as theism isn't a worldview. I will now go ahead to dismantle what you've stated point by point.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]We believe in Marx, Freud, and Darwin.[/quote]What do you mean by this? They were people who lived so we believe they lived. This doesn't mean that atheists have uncritically accepted their works.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]We believe that everything is ok, as long as you don’t hurt anyone, to the best of your definition of hurt, and to the best of your definition of knowledge. We believe in sex before, during and after marriage, we believe in the therapy of sin. We believe that adultery is fun, we believe that sodomy is ok, we believe that taboo’s are taboo.[/quote]I don't know how you arrived at this conclusion from people saying they're atheists. The main problem I have with the "creed" you've presented here is what you mean when you say: we believe . . . . Some atheists accept some things, others don't.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]We believe that everything is getting better despite evidence to the contrary.[/quote]Actually, things are getting better. We have managed to eliminate a disease like smallpox and we're on the way to eliminating others, we now have the tools to mitigate world hunger and as we know that violence has declined in the world.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]The evidence must be investigated and you can prove anything with evidence.[/quote]Sure evidence is important. If you disagree, then simply say so. Actually, it isn't that you can prove anything with evidence, but that you should be ready to provide evidence to back up your claims.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]We believe there is something in horoscopes, UFO’s and bent spoons.[/quote]Do atheists believe this as a creed in the way Christians believe Jesus is the son of God?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Jesus was a good man just like Buddha, Muhammad and ourselves. We believe he was a good moral teacher although we think his good morals were really bad. We believe that all religions are basically the same, at least the one that we read was. They all believe in love and goodness, they only differ in matters of creation, sin, heaven, hell, God, and salvation.[/quote]I can agree with the first three sentences but not the last because not all religions actually believe in love and goodness. At least not as we conceive them to be.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]We believe that after death comes nothing because when you ask the dead they say nothing.[/quote]This is just false. We don't arrive at that conclusion because "when you ask the dead they say nothing".

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]If death is not the end then there is heaven for all except maybe Hitler, Stalin, and Khan. We believe in Masters and Johnson, what is selected is average, and what is average is normal and what is normal is good.[/quote]These are just absurd.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]We believe in total disarmament, we believe there are direct links between warfare and bloodshed, and that the Americans should beat their guns into tractors and the Russians will be sure to follow.[/quote]Are you sure you're not confusing atheism with something else?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]We believe that man is essentially good, it is only his behavior that lets him down.[/quote]Another absurdity.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]This is the fault of society, society is the fault of conditions, and conditions are the fault of society. If man does what is right for him, then reality will adapt accordingly. The universe will re-adjust, history will alter. We believe there is no absolute truth except that there is no absolute truth. We believe in the rejection of creeds and the flowering of individual thought.[/quote]Yet you've gone on to formulate creeds for atheists who according to you "believe in the rejection of creeds".

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]If chance is the father of all flesh, then disaster is his rainbow in the sky. When in a state of emergency the sniper kills the child, the youth go looting, or bomb blasts rock the school, it is nothing more than the sound of man worshiping his maker.[/quote]I'm sorry but this final paragraph makes no sense to me.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 6:33am On Feb 27, 2013
Image123: I'd reply to your post later, but its rather pointless and difficult to discuss Christianity if passages can be freely taken in to criticize and blackmail but similar passages become 'personal correspondence' when used in defense or explanation. pretty hypocritical.
The fact that those passages are personal correspondence is "inherent" in the Bible.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 3:48pm On Feb 26, 2013
Image123: Fortunately, we both know that the problem is that what we know about people tells us that they can be fooled.
Reasoning can be impaired. People once reasoned that the earth was flat for instance, some reasoned that we evolved from apes. Faith is evidence. i told you already, Christ appears to many believers today. there witness is not evidence enough to you. Well, i've given you the conditions to see Him for yourself, believe. When you fulfill the condition and do not see Him, please get back to me.
Mat 21:22 And all things, whatsoever ye shall ask in prayer, believing, ye shall receive.
Thomas was a foundation in the church. Jesus had invested hree years of His ministry and life into him and to Peter. The 500 put was acknowledged by others. That is christian history.
According to you now, faith = evidence. Therefore belief = evidence. Yes Image123 has solved the problem. Sure you pray that I see him. Surely God would listen to you before he listens to me. The 500 is just a literary technique that is often used in stories so that others would believe the claims made. So Jesus cannot invest 3 days of his infinite life into me?

Image123: i'm telling you that stealing is theft. A thief is attracted to other people's property and takes them. Something that used to be a sin can stop being a sin. Sin is simply disobeying God. If God says not to pass place A, it would be a sin to pass place A. If God says not to eat tree B, it will be a sin to eat tree B.
Err this is exactly what you said.

Image123: . . . .have you also heard of people that just find themselves attracted [/b]to other people's money and property? [b]it's called theft.
A thief takes the property that doesn't belong to them someone who admires other people's property may then decide to work hard to get what others have.

How about if God says kill persons C to Z? Will it be a sin not to kill them?

Image123: Did you mean 'special' or beauty? Anyway, God will have mercy on all who confess to Him and give up sins.
No I meant beauty in a sarcastic way.

Image123: i never blamed you or anyone. The great commission is to preach the good news to all people. It is not to answer all questions posed at you.
Mat 28:19 Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost:
Mar 16:15 And he said unto them, Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.

A christian is very free at his discretion and leading by God's Spirit to leave you to yourself.
Mat 10:13 And if the house be worthy, let your peace come upon it: but if it be not worthy, let your peace return to you.
Mat 10:14 And whosoever shall not receive you, nor hear your words, when ye depart out of that house or city, shake off the dust of your feet.
Act 13:46 Then Paul and Barnabas waxed bold, and said, It was necessary that the word of God should first have been spoken to you: but seeing ye put it from you, and judge yourselves unworthy of everlasting life, lo, we turn to the Gentiles.
What are you to do when you're asked the reason for your hope?

Image123: Atheism is disbelief in God. What is ridiculous is the life of Bertrand Russell and other atheists. i can't hope to be like them, neither should anyone who loves sanity and peace.
Do you think that one has to live how Bertrand Russell lived in order to be an atheist? Do you really think that you can live how he lived if you tried?

Image123: The seed is the man because it is the seed that becomes the man. Just like it is the seed planted that becomes the fruit or tree. The tree/man can be looked upon in retrospect as the seed. Saul was in his father as a seed. The tree doesn't come without the planting in earth, watering and aeration. The mother is where the seed is planted into to yield as a man/fruit.
What is wrong with you? How can the seed be the man and become the man? You're just absolutely confused or just trying to support your ridiculous notion. How about the woman? Or does the man plant his seed in earth? Where did Saul's father plant Saul?

Image123: i'm relating it to something i expect you to understand, basic agriculture.
Agriculture has its basis in biology and what you're saying is just absurd.

Image123: i care about what happens to others, you are only being sanctimonious. My advice to you comes from the Word of God
Ecc 7:16 Be not righteous over much; neither make thyself over wise: why shouldest thou destroy thyself?
The Bible's requirement is to love your neighbours AS yourself, not more than yourself. You should be concerned for yourself instead of thinking of the unknown folks. It's the classic case of a child given food who refused to eat after thinking of many unknown others who probably have not eaten and will not eat that day. Or a son you paid his school fees who became sanctimoniously worried about millions of illiterates in the world who are yet to learn the alphabets. What have you done with the chance you have to repent and receive Jesus into your heart and life. When are you going to rest from your endless labours and questions and search for truth and meaning? Jesus is still calling you gently, saying Mat 11:28 Come unto me, all ye that labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest.
God has revealed Himself through the man Jesus Christ.
Rom 1:20 For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:
The whole earth and the heavens and all that is in it declares there is a God. The blame is not on God but on our ancestors. It's like asking in 100years time why God allowed crude oil to finish in Nigeria. But i'll rather not pass blame, i'd rather be pro-active, and do what can be done from mine end. And at the end, i'll have done my best.
Nah you really don't because if you did, you'll notice just how ridiculous the notion of God you're presenting is. We're talking about a God that knew he was going to burn people in hell but deliberately set things up so that most of the people he loves will end up there. And most of those people will end up there for no reason other than the fact that they didn't know any better.

God can reveal himself today and end religious strife and division but he won't do it so that he will have the pleasure of cooking people in hell.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 3:35pm On Feb 26, 2013
Image123: Its a red herring and you are full of red herrings. i've consistently insisted on the point i was making but you seem more interested in talking about if the Bible is special or not. Do you talk this much about other books? If yes, please let me know what books those are. The NT consistently shows a 'change' from the OT. there is a new covenant and an old. If there were no differences, one would not be new and the other old. What are we to turn to for reasonable instructions? How is the NT judgement worse than the OT judgement?
Then actually show that it is a red herring. After all, you introduced the idea that the Bible being special lent some sort of credibility to it. There are lots of other sources for reasonable instructions but what is clear is that it isn't the Bible and that is the point I'm making. The NT is worse because it introduced hell.

Image123: You are boldening lines that say that original manuscripts did not contain the chapter and verse divisions in the numbered form. That is the exact thing that i am saying so i do not get your point. i said that the division is already INHERENT. Do you not know the meaning of "inherent"? i said the inherence was seen in the spacing and paragraphs in the original text before the numbering using verses and chapters. You initially said that paragraphs and spaces were not there in the original manuscripts. Now i gave you a link that states that they were there and quoted the part relevant to what i said, yet all you can come up with is talks about me not quoting some line. i expected you will quote the whole page in your 'full quote' and show us honestNESS.
Moral laws deal with right or wrong, ceremonial laws deal with cleansing of sin. Most of the laws are easily put under any of this two. Use your brain, or ask practical questions if you do not understand.
The colored is the issue being discussed, but i'll not be dumbfounded if you're more interested in discussing lines and spaces.
Obviously, you're the one who doesn't understand what words mean. Telling me that the divisions are already "inherent" is meaningless because as I'm sure you know, the Bible wasn't originally written in English but in several other languages. Now in those languages, did the writings contain spacing and paragraphs indicating where chapters and verses were to go? You dishonestly presented those quotes unless you think that the paragraphs indicated where chapters and verse were to be inserted.

Once again, you brought up the idea that God presented the Bible already sorted out in a certain manner but that claim is obviously false.

Image123: Others as in "others" LOST. Of course, i mean there are others who grasp, other persons, get a lesson teacher perhaps.
Do you have actual examples of these people who accept it when you present terrible analogies? Seriously, you need to read up on how to present relevant analogies so you stop looking like you need remedial lessons in English.

Image123: No, i wish to tell you that there are more people book literate than there are computer literates. faith is basically belief. Everyone can belief. i guess you believe in the big bang, or evolution. You believe in yourself, that is faith. Have faith in God. God did not take away your faith, you probably hid it or employed it in other ventures. However, it is possible for God to cause you to believe a lie. You can come out of that though the same way you enter it. i expect Your redherringness to focus on this.
2Th 2:10 And with all deceivableness of unrighteousness in them that perish; because they received not the love of the truth, that they might be saved.
2Th 2:11 And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie:
2Th 2:12 That they all might be damned who believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness.

God always reveals Himself to those who love the truth and sincerely want to know.
And what you wish to tell me is pointless and irrelevant. My point is that you do not have to be literate to actually touch a computer but according to your presentation of this supernatural, you need some special powers. Seriously how difficult was that to understand?

What? Faith = belief? This is the sort of muddled thinking that you seem to like. If you didn't think it was important, then why did you bring it up? Anyway, if God can make me believe a lie, how do you know he hasn't made you believe a lie? How do you know he isn't actually evil?

I'm sure that is why he has refused to reveal himself to those who would change their minds and believe him instead, he reveals himself to those who already believe.

Image123: It is not pointless. You said Jesus' disciples were said to have written God's words implying that only disciples' writings can be taken as God's words. So, i took the time out to show you who disciples were and how all t the scriptures are disciple's writings and therefore God's words. All the Scriptures are given by the inspiration of God.
Once more, your ignorance on the origin of the Bible reveals itself. I hope you know that the books and collections that made it into the Bible were selected by a bunch of people in a meeting. For some reason, God has stopped giving inspiration so that for the past 1000 years, no more books or written works can get into the Bible.

Image123: It was permissible to hate others, it was permissible to swear, it was permissible to divorce for any reason. What is your definition of a wise God?
If you seriously want to claim that these are commandments, then are you willing to agree to turn your other cheek, give more when you're sued and if you're forced to do something, you do even more? You need some consistency if you're going to seriously introduce those sayings as commandments.

A wise God would be one that had the ability to make a decision based on the combination of knowledge, experience, and intuitive understanding.

Image123: i did. i showed you two new testament scriptures talking about eating many things. Here they are again.
1Ti 4:4 For every creature of God is good, and nothing to be refused, if it be received with thanksgiving:
Act 11:8 But I said, Not so, Lord: for nothing common or unclean hath at any time entered into my mouth.
Act 11:9 But the voice answered me again from heaven, What God hath cleansed, that call not thou common.
Act 11:10 And this was done three times: and all were drawn up again into heaven.
And I explained to you that random collections of personal correspondence won't cut it. Neither will that vision (whose point you seem to have missed) cut it.

Image123: i also spoke on how the law you quoted from leviticus on slavery is rendered mute in the new testament by the uniting of nations.
Eph 2:15 Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances; for to make in himself of twain one new man, so making peace;
Eph 2:16 And that he might reconcile both unto God in one body by the cross, having slain the enmity thereby:
Eph 2:17 And came and preached peace to you which were afar off, and to them that were nigh.
Eph 2:18 For through him we both have access by one Spirit unto the Father.
Eph 2:19 Now therefore ye are no more strangers and foreigners, but fellow citizens with the saints, and of the household of God;
More personal correspondence that didn't actually free slaves or abolish slavery.

Image123: The passage you quoted was talking to general people, servants. Except you take servants as slaves. Paul, writing to the Ephesians was writing to people who gathered together to worship God. ithink servants can do that, i doubt about slaves(thinking in your perception of slaves). Every employee is a servant of the employer/boss. The word change is not what matters. That you call someone chief cook, personal assistant, secretary, supervisor and all that doesn't rule out the fact that that person has a master(superior) or Masters. Is it permitted in today's society, yes. Anyone working for anothe person is the person's servant basically. It is the relationship that God is more concerned about, not trivialities about names. There are so many HODs that are not as well treated as some master's dog. That is wrong. You see the name is changed. The man is an HOD, an accountant, a teacher, a driver etc, but the treatment he is receiving from his workplace is worse than many Bible servants ever received. Bible servants were so well treated that some could aford to say "I love my master, I will not go out free". I'd rather be Abraham's servant than work as an engineer in some factories in the country. It's not really the name tag servant/slave. Paul was a servant of God and a prisoner of Jesus Christ. So also was Peter, John etc. Elisha was a servant of Elijah. All christians are servants. And you are a servant of sin. How your master treats you is what is important and what God is particular about. Not about whether you are allowed by God to be called chief or slave.
A slave is different from a servant. e.g slaves are bought while servants are hired so your attempt at blurring the distinction fails woefully.

Image123: Unimportant to the discuss.
It suddenly becomes unimportant because it has you stumped?

Image123: When you are ready to see Jesus, have faith. If you can believe, you will see. It cannot be easier said than that.
Don't you have faith enough for me? Since you believe, why don't you pray and make him show himself? I think that would be the easiest option.

Image123: Finally, something to agree on, thank you God. So you now see that the new testament said it was a warning? i still cannot believe this yet. Confirm by saying it again. You initially said that God sent the flood to remove evil from the earth remember. Thank God, you are catching on at last.
Did I indicate otherwise? I said God himself didn't see it as a warning. This is why I keep telling you not to just take whatever was written as personal correspondence as coming straight from your God. God's aim was to remove evil from the earth.

Image123: Good of you, nothing about sanctifying all creation.
1Ti 4:4 For every creature of God is good, and nothing to be refused, if it be received with thanksgiving:
Not Jesus' or God's words but words of personal correspondence selected by some guys in a meeting to be in the Bible.

Image123: i guess you mean to say Bible. If yes, i already showed you na. When we talked about God having mercy on children.
Luk 18:16 But Jesus called them unto him, and said, Suffer little children to come unto me, and forbid them not: for of such is the kingdom of God.
Luk 18:17 Verily I say unto you, Whosoever shall not receive the kingdom of God as a little child shall in no wise enter therein.
I'm sorry but presenting these quotes as meaning that Jesus says all children will go to heaven indicates to me that you're either ignorant about metaphors, unable to consider abstract thought or just ignorant about Christian thought. After all, Jesus said "Suffer little children to come unto me . . . " by your reasoning can mean that you're supposed to torture children then kill them in order for them to get to heaven.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 9:59am On Feb 24, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Lol, dude I must give it to you. You do enjoy your merry-go-rounds don't you?

Let's cut the chase shall we?

The question before us is: Is a creator under any moral obligation to be benevolent to his/her creation?

My answer is "No"[/quote]Is your answer still "No" with respect to the Christian God? Please answer with a yes or no. Basically, the answer changes with the example of the creator. If it is different, then you've clearly seen the contradiction with respect to the term "creator" here and are just failing at being evasive.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Your contention: If the creator and creation are sapient, then it puts an obligation on the creator.

My rebuttal: Sapience places no obligation evidenced by a deist conception of the creator vs a Christian concept of the creator. Both sapient yet one is indifferent and the other benevolent. Therefore sapience doesn't impose the obligation to be benevolent.[/quote]And this is the clear reason why you have to specify what creator you're talking about otherwise your answer is contradictory as I demonstrated to you using your own syllogism.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Your contention: If the creator is said to be benevolent, then His very nature of benevolence places upon Him the obligation to be benevolent.

My rebuttal: This would only be true if the creator had no choice in the matter i.e the creator could not be any other way. If this is true, then such a creator could not be said to be sapient if he lacks the ability to choose whether to be benevolent or not.[/quote]Could the Christian God have been another way? Careful with your answer because you could conclude that your Christian God isn't a necessary being.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]This is how far we have come. You have not yet given me reason to believe that a creator is under any obligation to preserve his/her creation[/quote]I'm sorry but this is just you trying to be evasive and failing as usual. I asked you direct questions and once again, to avoid answering them, you bracket all the important issues and attempt to summarize because you've been cornered. It simply won't work with me.

The best way for us to have a serious conversation and avoid fallacies is to start with some common grounds and I think these direct questions will help us clarify and begin with common grounds.

Is acting morally synonymous with doing good deeds?
Can you please define what you're referring to as a creator with examples?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 4:38pm On Feb 23, 2013
seyibrown: thehomer, Mr_Anony having already addressed the rest of your post, I have the following to add:
He's still trying to address them and isn't really succeeding.

seyibrown: God DOESN'T sit back and allow diarrhoea (or anything else for that matter) wipe out helpless children; Men (and women) like you (and I) DO!
No I don't because I'm neither omnipotent nor omniscient. I'm not even beneficent to all humans but the Christian God is all of the above.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 2:53pm On Feb 23, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]By your argument, are we to call a farmer a creator of plants? How about the child who is not raised by his biological father? Who is his creator? His biological father or the one who raised him? You are stretching this argument to absurdity by throwing in irrelevant parameters and you know it.[/quote]And that is my point. Without properly defining what a creator is, then your entire argument fails. That is why I ended that paragraph with the question: what is a creator?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]How does this relate to what I just said?[/quote]It relates to the fact that you have to define what a creator is.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Again we play on words. My comment was quite clear[/quote]Having clear definitions isn't a game in philosophical discussions.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]And my point is that inserting the nature of the creator as you are requesting makes the argument redundant because we don't learn anything new.[/quote]It clarifies the argument which will enable the determination of what conclusions follow from what premises.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]On the contrary, it is you who is being slippery. I specifically asked you if by acting morally you meant acting good. If you didn't mean acting good, then you have allowed the possibility for acting moral to mean acting evil[/quote]This is the sort of slipperiness that bothers me. I expected you to answer the question based on whatever you understood acting morally to mean rather than you attempting to ask me the same question that I just asked you. I'm doing this to avoid making any assumptions for you but you just refuse to be clear about whatever you mean.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]I hope you recognize how redundant the above sounds. Basically you've said:
"That isn't a recommendation that the unmarried man be unmarried as you were implying, that is a description of the state the unmarried man has to be in to qualify as being an unmarried man."[/quote]What is the redundancy? You seem to be having a difficult understanding that a clear definition isn't a redundancy.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]I have not provided an avenue for contradictory conclusions[/quote]Actually, you have. I'll illustrate it using your syllogism.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Premise 1: A creator is bound by a moral obligation towards his creation.
Premise 2: God is a creator and man is His creation
Conclusion: Therefore God is bound by a moral obligation towards man.[/quote]If we substitute the Christian God into (2) we get the conclusion that he is bound by a moral obligation towards man. If we substitute the deist God into (2), we get the conclusion that he too is bound by a moral obligation towards man which is wrong because (1) is wrong since that God isn't bound by a moral obligation.

Those are contradictory conclusions and as you can see, whether or not the conclusion follows depends on the particular God you're talking about so which God are you talking about?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]This is a misreading of what I've been saying all along[/quote]Then define what a creator is with an example for clarity.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]How did you reach that conclusion?[/quote]Based on the fact that you asked me for the context in which acting morally would be not be synonymous with doing good deeds. There is no context in which it is so therefore you're agreeing that acting morally is synonymous with doing good deeds.

Now, are you accepting that acting morally is synonymous with doing good deeds? Please a simple yes or no will suffice.

Secondly, will you be defining what a creator is with examples? Please answer this too with a yes or no. If yes, please go ahead and do so.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 12:36pm On Feb 23, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]I do not regard as a creator one who makes something without an intended outcome. For instance if I was going to bake a cake, I know exactly what kind of cake I set out out to make and I make it with careful precision according to my liking I don't just throw random ingredients into an oven and hope for the best. A father doesn't make a child, he merely shoots out a seed and hopes a child shows up. He has absolutely no control on what the child will be like. Therefore, he cannot be said to be a creator. Get my drift now?[/quote]By your reasoning, am I to expect that someone who makes something with an intended outcome is a creator? If so, then the father who doesn't merely shoot out a seed but also takes the time to raise the child would be a creator.

If not, then what is a creator?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]No it doesn't because as you said, the creator might well be indifferent. If you allow the creator freedom to be indifferent, you cannot disallow him the same indifference simply because he chose to be benevolent of his own accord.[/quote]Are all creators by definition, indifferent?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]And as I said earlier, sapient or not, the creator is not under any moral obligation to be benevolent. The mere fact that one can recognize morality doesn't impose upon him an ought.[/quote]He is under a moral obligation if by definition, he is moral.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Good, since you agree that the two sapient creators are different in the sense that one is benevolent and the other isn't. It is now very clear that sapient or not, creators are under no obligation whatsoever to be benevolent. You've made my point for me. You cannot allow the creators free choice and deny them the same free choice at the same time. that is logically incoherent.[/quote]My point is that unless we agree on the particular nature of the creator, then using your premises will lead to contradictions i.e it will lead to creators being moral and not moral.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]That is not what I'm saying. I asked you specifically if by "acting moral" you meant "acting good". You made it clear that's not what you meant. So perhaps I should turn the question back on you.
Are you seriously saying that to act morally may actually be to act in a way that is evil? What do you mean by acting morally?[/quote]Come on this is just childish. It looks as if you're once again trying to be slippery to avoid answering a direct question.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]There you go:
https://www.nairaland.com/1198534/cowardice-atheism/33#14420056[/quote]That isn't a recommendation that the bachelor be unmarried as you were implying, that is a description of the state the bachelor has to be in to qualify as being a bachelor.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]I have[/quote]You've not shown it to be unnecessary because substituting different creators into your premises leads to contradictions. Or do you think that having contradictory conclusions is a good way of doing philosophy?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]This is why I said I had a problem with your bachelor example in the first place because all the premises are redundant. I was willing to play along and assume we were trying to verify what it means to be a bachelor but here you are again pointing me to precisely what I pointed out to you previously. Are you really interested in reaching a conclusion or are you more interested in playing a game of Round-And-Round-The-Village-As-We-Have-Done-Before?[/quote]Then you need to establish that creators are by definition, amoral, immoral or moral. You've not done that. How on earth can a definition be redundant in a philosophical discussion when you're clearly showing how important it is? If you think that a clear definition makes things redundant, then I'm sorry but I have no idea what you mean.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]that is not true

In the same context in which you have acting morally as not synonymous with doing good[/quote]To be clear, you're admitting that acting morally is synonymous with doing good.
Note that you're the one who has now introduced the idea that acting morally is synonymous with acting in a way that is good.
Politics › Re: Wazobia FM Kano Closed Down. by thehomer: 9:16am On Feb 23, 2013
manny4life: After all this big English, what the hell are you trying to say? undecided undecided undecided

Anyway, @topic,

How do they mean by "inciting"? This is wrong, how can you silence freedom of expression? angry angry
If they actually did the inciting, then it won't be wrong. Freedom of expression doesn't permit you to incite acts of violence against people.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 8:30am On Feb 23, 2013
Image123: And what do we have for the disbelief in God again? Do you think that non-theists cannot be fooled? Thomas was a disciple, a worthy investment. Jesus showed Himself resurrected by many infallible proofs to more than 500 people before His ascension. Luke was an historian.
1Co 15:6 After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once; of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep.
What we have is reason and evidence. Sure they can the difference is that the non-theist is willing to admit it while the theist isn't. Wait so no human living today is a worthy investment? Non-theists aren't worthy investments? And that reference to 500 people is the sort of thing that we put in stories and fairytales to convince people who weren't there. And I hope you know that the actual author of the Book of Luke is unknown.

Image123: Homosexuality is sin, and in Bible parlance, folks use the phrase on "falling into" sin. You seem to have ears for hearing stories. have you also heard of people that just find themselves attracted to other people's money and property? it's called theft. When a person feels the urge to sin, whether sponteneous or spurred, the person should try to overcome such TEMPTATION with the help of Jesus. Sin is man's biggest problem, and homosexuality is a sin. Different individuals have their different softspots and weaknesses. Some folks naturally detest stealing and are NATURALLY disciplined enough not to steal. Other folks are so principled and honest and would not tell lies. Some other person values his honour and will never sleep with another man's wife. This doesn't negate the fact that these despised sins are what some other folks cannot do without, or must give in to frequently. It's natural, and they 'find themselves just attracted' to these despicable acts. It's a similar thing with homosexuality. Trying to force a natural angle on it doesn't absolve the sinner. Sin is sin and must be dealt with and frowned at.
Are you seriously telling me that desiring wealth is theft? Where do you get these laws from? Can something that used to be a sin stop being a sin?

Image123: Pro 28:13 He that covereth his sins shall not prosper: but whoso confesseth and forsaketh them shall have mercy.
i re-quote this. Mercy is conditional.
The beauty of the Bible lies in the ease of quote-mining it. So will God have mercy on all who confess and give up sins?

Image123: the worth of a christian is not by his debate ability or non ability. Jesus Christ is the worth of the christian, if you can understand that. humans can be swayed, the media shows that often by making you hate a character, and then love the same character in no time after. Visit the courtroom and wonder at the force of argument, and how a good lawyer can convict an innocent man of murder. Ability to argue well, or express points articulately is not a proof of veracity. And BTW, christians are sheep for the most, and may not necessarily possess the power to defend themselves against stubborn goats and wolves. They need shepherds, try to understand my brethren's state cheesy. like i told you earlier, not every fisherman needs to,knows how to, or is interested in catching a shark. Now that you've been shown, try not to blackmail christians next time with one misconstrued passage, remember the numerous other passages which give them the liberty to ignore you, thanks.
I'll agree with you that they are mostly sheep. Jesus should have known that and been more circumspect in delivering his great commission instead, he did what he did. So, don't blame me, blame Jesus.

Image123: i'm surprised because atheism is also filled with confusion. Confusion amongst your role models, confusion among new atheists, confusion everywhere. And they are always hoping to disprove the existence of God even though they say that has been done. Why should any sane person want to join the likes of Nietzsche an epitome of confusion, and a top atheist model. What of logicb of NL? Or should we go to Bertrand Russell? That one too lived a confused life. Think up any top atheist, and look into his life and home and end. It's always confusion all the way. i'm not gloating or happy about it, just stating the facts. Russell also had a confused home. Kept on confusing love and lust, married and divorced about four times, confused many in his home to the point of derangement/mental disorder. Come on, i'd rather have Jesus.
What do you think atheism actually is? By answering that question, you'll clear up a lot of the confusion you're showing here. You seem to think that atheists are to conform to one book (like the Bible) or follow one person (like Jesus). So getting married and divorced is a sign of confusion of love and lust? Sorry but that is just ridiculous. What makes you think that love is the only reason for marriage?

Image123: i'd rather say you do not agree with my answer, not that the answer makes no sense. i showed you also from the Bible the same answer.
Heb 7:10 For he was yet in the loins of his father, when Melchizedek met him.
1Ki 8:19 Nevertheless thou shalt not build the house; but thy son that shall come forth out of thy loins, he shall build the house unto my name.
Gen 35:11 And God said unto him, I am God Almighty: be fruitful and multiply; a nation and a company of nations shall be of thee, and kings shall come out of thy loins;

i told you and i am saying it again, the seed is in the man. The seed IS IN THE MAN.
No, your answer literally makes no sense at all. You said here that the seed was the man. Now you say the seed is in the man? If the seed is the man and the seed was in the man, then how was Saul living in his father? If the man couldn't have come about without the mother, then how did the contribution from the mother get in? Or was the mother too in the father?

You Christians are the first to shout that the Bible isn't a science text but here you are quoting it at me as if it was one.

Image123: If i were you, i would be most worried about myself, having been born in a christian environment and exposed to christian teachings and to the Bible. What have you done? Like i already showed you, life/reality is not an exact science. that your parents are poor/rich is not a guarantee that you will be poor/rich. It's a factor, but not the only factor. Attitude is a major factor in life. God in His mercy reveals Himself to the sincere and honest hearted, He finds a way, He makes a way. When He does, it is still your call to walk in the way or no. A man's habit, decision, and lifestyle may influence and hinder his children's future, i'm not in disagreement on that. Still, the question comes back to you, Wht have YOU done with the chances you have?
Well you're not me since it seems that I care more for what happens to people than you do. I'm not so selfish or conceited that I only worry about myself. God with his power doesn't need to limit himself to those people that he's selected as being "sincere and honest" he can reveal himself to all people at once. Since you're not in disagreement on the issue of a parent's religion, then why should God have allowed multiple religions in the first place? Knowing the effect it would have on children?
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 8:06am On Feb 23, 2013
Image123: discovered? The two passages are relevant . Now if you have anything important to say, its time to say it.
I've said before and I'll say it again. What is your interpretation on the cloths with mixed materials?

Image123: Bad for you. He that cometh to God MUST believe.
Heb 11:6 But without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him.
Joh 4:24 God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth.

When you are ready to see Jesus, have faith. If you can believe, you will see. It cannot be easier said than that.
Well you claim to have seen him in Lagos recently speaking English. I hope you weren't lying about that. If you weren't, then you were probably hallucinating.

Image123: Go and mistype no more then. And learn to read me more slowly and carefully.
I'm still telling you that he Noah thing wasn't a warning but all you've been able to say is that it was a warning using what some guy said in the NT but God himself said it was because he regretted his action of creating people in the first place.

Image123: Nothing in acts 10 talks about God sanctifying all creation. learn to read me more slowly and carefully.
It referred to some animals being clean and others unclean. Now are there still clean and unclean animals?

Image123: i don't do blind arguments as pastime.

Your child dying of cancer will die and go to Heaven which is far better. You are only trying to whip up sentiments.
Sure you don't. How do you know that? Can you show me where that is written in Heaven? Or do you just believe it to make you feel better?
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 7:55am On Feb 23, 2013
Image123: i don't need to be absolved or no. i never argued about who first mentioned 'special'. Your bringing that up is again one of your many fallacies so we can argue on that also. i've consistently said that my point is not abouty the Bible been special or no. Like i said, you are free to re-read. i mentioned that homosexuality is also repeated in the NT for emphasis. i didn't say that anything not mentioned in the NT is no more valid like you are trying to imply/deduce. i don't need to show that God changed any laws. You are the one insisting that God changed them. i'm only explaining to you that there is no change or contradiction. i also said that there are what can be called 'changes'(the inverted commas put to speak your language). i gave the 'changes' to be in matters like judgement, or what was no longer necessary, as in the laws put while constructing a street road and when construction is complete, and other analogies. The Word of God(Bible) is intricate. It's like a simple looking human body that has layers of systems; digestive, nervous, reproductive, circulatory etc. The different systems are inter-related, not contradictory.
How on earth is it a fallacy to point out that you were the one who first brought up special? Since it isn't that special, why should I care about what it contains? Actually, you need to show that God changed any laws if we're to believe that some laws no longer applied. I'm not the one insisting that he changed them, I'm saying that we shouldn't even turn to it for reasonable instructions. The changes in the matter of judgement simply became worse.

Image123: It's either you are been dishonest here or ignorant. Paragraphs and spaces were already there. how can one write without spaces? Permit wiki to help you again http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chapters_and_verses_of_the_Bible. The article says these ( In antiquity Hebrew texts were divided into paragraphs (parashot) that were identified by two letters of the Hebrew alphabet. Pe indicated an "open" paragraph that began on a new line, while Samekh indicated a "closed" paragraph that began on the same line after a small space.[1]). This was before chapter and verse divisions.
Moral laws deal with right or wrong, ceremonial laws deal with cleansing of sin. Most of the laws are easily put under any of this two. Use your brain, or ask practical questions if you do not understand.
Wow. Did you even read what you've presented up there? I think you did since you quoted from it but for some reason, you skipped the very first line in what you were quoting and that is clearly dishonest. This is the full quote. Note the parts in bold.

Wikipedia: The original manuscripts did not contain the chapter and verse divisions in the numbered form familiar to modern readers. In antiquity Hebrew texts were divided into paragraphs (parashot) that were identified by two letters of the Hebrew alphabet. Pe indicated an "open" paragraph that began on a new line, while Samekh indicated a "closed" paragraph that began on the same line after a small space.[1] The earliest known copies of the Book of Isaiah from the Dead Sea Scrolls use these two Hebrew letters for their paragraph divisions, although they differ slightly from the Masoretic divisions.
This is from the introduction of that very article that you were quoting.

Wikipedia: The Bible is a compilation of many shorter books written at different times and later assembled into the biblical canon. All but the shortest of these books have been divided into chapters, generally a page or so in length, since the early 13th century. Since the mid-16th century, each chapter has been further divided into "verses" of a few short lines or sentences. Sometimes a sentence spans more than one verse, as in the case of Ephesians 2:8-9, and sometimes there is more than one sentence in a single verse, as in the case of Genesis 1:2. As the chapter and verse divisions were not part of the original texts, they form part of the paratext of the Bible.
How the NT got its verses from that same article.

Wikipedia: The first person to divide New Testament chapters into verses was Italian Dominican biblical scholar Santi Pagnini (1470–1541), but his system was never widely adopted.[10] Robert Estienne created an alternate numbering in his 1551 edition of the Greek New Testament [11] which was also used in his 1553 publication of the Bible in French. Estienne's system of division was widely adopted, and it is this system which is found in almost all modern bibles.
Image123: Others passed. You're not the first person i've used analogies with. There are others who grasp, get a lesson teacher perhaps.
What "others" are you talking about? You may have used analogies before but the ones you've been using here are terrible ones.

Image123: How many people can interact with a computer? Are you on this planet at all? There are more adherents of religion than there are literates, not to mention the fewer number of folks who can interact on a computer. Religious folks believe in access to the supernatural. They talk of communicating with ghosts, gods, anscestors, dead relatives, God etc. Everybody has faith, faith is your access to the supernatural.
Rom 12:3 For I say, through the grace given unto me, to every man that is among you, not to think of himself more highly than he ought to think; but to think soberly, according as God hath dealt to every man the measure of faith.
Are you serious? Do you wish to tell me that you have to be literate before you can touch a computer? Clearly you have no idea of what you're saying. Actually, not everyone has faith so you're factually incorrect. Then how did God deal this measure of faith to people who used to believe but stopped? Did he take it away?

Image123: Did God speak to Moses? On what base do you believe that, but disbelieve that Hebrews or Paul's epistles are not the Word of God? Who are Jesus'disciples? Is Paul not a disciple of Jesus, do you even know the meaning of the word? In case you are thinking that Jesus' disciples are just 12 like i'm tempted to perceive, consider the below too.
Mat 27:57 When the even was come, there came a rich man of Arimathaea, named Joseph, who also himself was Jesus' disciple:
Act 9:10 And there was a certain disciple at Damascus named Ananias; and to him said the Lord in a vision, Ananias. And he said, Behold, I am here, Lord.
Act 9:36 Now there was at Joppa a certain disciple named Tabitha, which by interpretation is called Dorcas: this woman was full of good works and almsdeeds which she did.
Act 21:16 There went with us also certain of the disciples of Caesarea, and brought with them one Mnason of Cyprus, an old disciple, with whom we should lodge.
Mat 8:21 And another of his disciples said unto him, Lord, suffer me first to go and bury my father.
This is all pointless. Was it Jesus or God that was talking to Paul as he wrote? Or was he just writing to people and his words to those people were then collected? Besides, some of those letters being passes as being written by Paul weren't actually written by him but by unknown people.

Image123: Also, to indulge you yet, see Jesus in the book of Matthew giving a 'change'(s)
Mat 5:21 Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not kill; and whosoever shall kill shall be in danger of the judgment:
Mat 5:22 But I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment: and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be in danger of the council: but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire.

Mat 5:27 Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not commit adultery:
Mat 5:28 But I say unto you, That whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart.

Mat 5:31 It hath been said, Whosoever shall put away his wife, let him give her a writing of divorcement:
Mat 5:32 But I say unto you, That whosoever shall put away his wife, saving for the cause of fornication, causeth her to commit adultery: and whosoever shall marry her that is divorced committeth adultery.
Mat 5:33 Again, ye have heard that it hath been said by them of old time, Thou shalt not forswear thyself, but shalt perform unto the Lord thine oaths:
Mat 5:34 But I say unto you, Swear not at all; neither by heaven; for it is God's throne:
Mat 5:35 Nor by the earth; for it is his footstool: neither by Jerusalem; for it is the city of the great King.
Mat 5:36 Neither shalt thou swear by thy head, because thou canst not make one hair white or black.
Mat 5:37 But let your communication be, Yea, yea; Nay, nay: for whatsoever is more than these cometh of evil.
Mat 5:38 Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth:
Mat 5:39 But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also.
Mat 5:40 And if any man will sue thee at the law, and take away thy coat, let him have thy cloak also.
Mat 5:41 And whosoever shall compel thee to go a mile, go with him twain.

Mat 5:43 Ye have heard that it hath been said, Thou shalt love thy neighbor, and hate thine enemy.
Mat 5:44 But I say unto you, Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you;
You can also check the passages on divorce and on judgement of an adulteress. Those are some instances where you can observe 'changes', not to forget the instances i showed you on diet and slavery, which you decided to play tombo with.
While those are changes, they're not changes making something that was once permissible impermissible or vice versa besides. And that is the sort of change I'm disputing. I don't even see those changes as worthy of being taken to come from a wise God.

You didn't show me any serious instances with respect to diet and slavery. In fact, you seem to be running from it.

Image123: Maybe your translation uses the word 'slaves' in equal vein as 'servants'. In such a case, almost everyone is a slave. Public servants are public slaves, God's servants are God's slaves, civil servants are civil slaves. Oyedepo says he is a servant of God, meaning he is a slave of God. Abraham is a slave of God, i am a slave of God, angels are slaves of God, the disciples are slaves of Jesus, Paul was a slave, Elisha was a slave etc. i'm vey much in support of and satisfied with such forms of slavery then. i verily doubt if this is the sort of slavery that freedom fighters fought against for the abolition of. The servant-master relationship i find in the Bible is very much applicable to the modern day employer-empmloy elionhipp
Rubbish. Read that passage and consider the times they were living in. It was referring to a slave-master relationship not the ridiculous notion you're presenting here that wherever we use servant, we replace it with slave.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:02pm On Feb 22, 2013
Ihedinobi: You guys, where is the proof off-Nairaland, among real, living Nigerians not hiding behind anonymity, atheists are discriminated against or face any kind of danger for their disbelief?
You can try what this guy did and get your information first hand.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer:
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Since you are emphasizing sapience, I'll treat your answers accordingly.

True. In this case the sapient creator is not under any moral obligation to his non-sapient creation[/quote]Yes.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]A father and child are not in a creator/creation relationship. The father is a channel and not a creator.[/quote]I'm sorry but saying that the father is a channel and not a creator when it comes to the child is meaningless to me here. Are you willing to be probed on your notion of what a creator is? Or will you say it is besides the point? The way I see it, it would be important to clarify.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Here both the creator and the creation can both be sapient and yet indifferent. I can't see any moral obligation imposed on the creator.[/quote]Good.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Here again both the creator and creation are sapient and the creator benevolent. Still yet I see no obligation imposed on the creator to be benevolent other than his personal imperative.[/quote]Then you're clearly wrong because the very notion of acting morally imposes an obligation.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]And by this statement you have shown that the creator can either care or not care. Sapient or not.[/quote]And that is the problem with you not specifying what can be called a creator. Because as you can see from the above examples, while the creator is always sapient, the issue of morality may not even arise.

Basically in examples 1 and 3, morality doesn't arise but in examples 2 and 4, it does. And the differences there hinge on what you're referring to as the creator or creation. This is why your syllogism will always lead to contradictions unless you clearly specify what you mean by the creator and creation.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]As I said earlier I am not asking you to read my mind. You don't need to. I am only asking you to follow the logic step by step. We must first establish if creators are morally accountable to their creations before applying the template to any specific creators.[/quote]We cannot establish that because the creators are intrinsically different. This means that attempting to apply any template and trying to generalize from it will always lead to a wrong conclusion.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Then the answer you received is apt. If I define morality as distinguishing between good and evil, then it follows that to act morally is to act in such a way that may be good or evil.[/quote]I'm sorry Mr_Anony but are you being serious? Are you seriously saying that to act morally may actually be to act in a way that is evil?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]From you sir. Read your comment again[/quote]I've read it. Why don't you show me by actually quoting me verbatim where I used the word "ought" with respect to the bachelor's being married.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]As I said; not necessary[/quote]You've only said so but you've not shown it to be so.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]The highlighted is precisely the reason why it is unnecessary to specify Mr A from the onset


Yes but you can only legitimately specify Mr A and check if he is indeed unmarried after you must have established that "all bachelors are unmarried" and not before.[/quote]That all bachelors are unmarried is already established by definition. Since it has been established, can we now specify Mr. A and see if he fits with the definition?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Now you are talking about to act good but you initially said that's not what you meant by your question. I am trying to prevent you from playing with words. I want you to focus on their contextual meanings instead[/quote]I'm the one focused on their contextual meanings while you're playing with words.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]The question I asked was "what does it mean to act morally?" This is very different from asking what morality is here. And I didn't want to be the one to introduce "good" or "right" so there won't be any distractions.[/quote]If you're focused on the contextual meanings, then in what context do you have acting morally to be synonymous with doing evil?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]No It wasn't hijacked, just abandoned.[/quote]Okay.

Edit: Proper quotes.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 9:18am On Feb 22, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony2]My apologies, I was too hasty in reading the comment the first time. I missed the "if" preceding it.[/quote]Okay.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Surely you are being disingenuous here because you well know that I meant

Premise 1: A creator is bound by a moral obligation towards his creation.
Premise 2: God is a creator and man is His creation
Conclusion: Therefore God is bound by a moral obligation towards man.

or...

Premise 1: A creator is not bound by a moral obligation towards his creation.
Premise 2: God is a creator and man is His creation
Conclusion: Therefore God is not bound by a moral obligation towards man.

Basically I was pointing out that once we can settle whether or not a creator is morally bound to his/her creation, the rest of the argument will immediately fall into place[/quote]Do you still not see the problem with not specifying what the creator and the have to be for you to determine that? Let me see if I can make it clearer. Without specifying who the creator and creation are, you can easily run into contradictions. e.g

If the creator/creation pair were a sculptor and an artwork of his that he doesn't like, he can damage it since the artwork isn't sapient. If he liked the artwork while he can still damage it though it is unlikely that he will damage it.

If the creator/creation pair were a father and his child, even if he doesn't like the child, he cannot simply harm it if he is to be considered moral since he is sapient and the child is at least sentient and will likely become sapient.

If the creator/creation pair were an indifferent God and a man, the creator will not bother helping or harming the man. Note that Christians will not accept such a being as God.

Now if the creator/creation pair were the Christian God and a man, the creator cannot simply harm men because he is considered to be moral, sapient, benevolent etc and the man is at least sentient or sapient.

To say that the God is the Christian God and that this God may not care about humans is to contradict the basic tenets of Christianity.
To say that the God is indifferent is to say that it is maybe the deist God since this one may not be bothered to be moral.

Obviously, substituting these Gods into the syllogisms you've presented will lead to contradictions. That is why you need to clearly identify the God you have in mind for us to proceed with determining whether or not it is bound to be moral. I presented the Christian God due to its popularity, you rejected that God then tell me the God you have in mind because I cannot read your mind.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]It means to act good or evil. Perhaps the question you mean to ask is "what does it mean to do good?" or perhaps not.[/quote]Come on. How can you say that to act morally can be to act in an evil way? The question I meant to ask is the one I asked.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]I actually quoted you verbatim.[/quote]If you quoted me verbatim, where did the "ought" you claimed I said come from?

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]I got that loud and clear[/quote]I really hope you do.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Good, the highlighted therefore makes it unnecessary to insist that the creator be specifically described. Since the question seeks to find what obligations are imposed on him and according to you his description doesn't impose anything.[/quote]We need an idea of the creator in order to see whether or not the description is appropriate.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Good, but first of all I have a problem with your "all bachelors(unmarried men) are unmarried". Anyway I'll play along

It is a loaded question because what you are asking me to do is specify at the onset which bachelor I have in mind. So basically you are asking me to do something like this

All bachelors like Mr A are unmarried
Mr A is a bachelor
Therefore Mr A is unmarried.

See the problem now?[/quote]No I don't see the problem. Mr. A is an example of a bachelor. A bachelor by definition is unmarried. Mr. A is not unmarried by definition, he is unmarried because he has not performed a marriage ceremony with someone. He can always become married later but once someone is married, that person ceases to be a bachelor.

When you specify that you're referring to Mr. A, we can then check to see if your example (Mr. A) actually fits the definition of being a bachelor.

[quote author=Mr_Anony2]Answered above[/quote]Sorry but your answer is wrong. To act morally is not to do evil.

Ps: What happened to the original Mr_Anony? Was that account hijacked?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer:
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Really? So you seriously can't see that numbers 2 and 3 are merely two halves of number 1?[/quote]What?! shocked Is this Mr_Anony or did someone hijack his account?

This has to be one of the most philosophically naive statements I've received from someone who claims to have some knowledge of philosophy. I should have seen this from when you tried to construct your syllogism.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Premise 1: A creator is/is not bound by a moral obligation towards his creation.
Premise 2: God is a creator and man is His creation
Conclusion: Therefore God is/is not bound by a moral obligation towards man.[/quote]What you cited as premise 1 isn't a premise but an assertion that is illogical. You're saying a creator is or is not bound by a moral obligation towards his creation i.e a creator can be both bound by a moral obligation towards his creation and not bound ... towards his creation.

For you to show that it is circular, you'll have to show that I'm saying A is true because B is true.

There's the common one

Socrates is a man, Not Socrates is/is not a man
All men are mortal,
therefore Socrates is mortal. Not Socrates is/is not mortal

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Morality is To discriminate between right and wrong. . . .and no I don't see how the mere concept of discriminating between right and wrong imposes upon one an ought to do either right or wrong.[/quote]Good. Now what do you think it means to act morally?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]If you really can't see how your argument is circular then I really can't help you. A bachelor by definition is an unmarried man. So your argument really was:

"an unmarried man ought not to be married because to be an unmarried man means to not be married" See the problem with it now?

Upon looking at it again, I see an even more profound problem which perhaps will help you see the difference between an ought and an is. Compare these two following statements and tell me if they mean the same thing to you.

"an unmarried man ought not to be married"

"an unmarried man is not to be married"

My point(if you got it) is that you don't derive an ought from an is i.e. Concerning the creator; A description of him does not automatically impose an ought upon him.[/quote]This is just absurd. I didn't say "an unmarried man ought not to be married", I said to be a bachelor means to not be a married man. So if someone is described as being a bachelor, then for that description to be accurate, that person won't be married.

From the way you're speaking, it really doesn't look as if you understand what a circular argument is.

Once again, [size=14pt]a description is not an argument[/size].

A description of God can be accurate or inaccurate. I never said or implied that the description imposes anything on what is being described. The description doesn't make the entity the way it is, the way it is influences the description.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]1. I have told you before that it is unnecessary because it would be assuming an answer before asking the question. Basically you are requesting that I ask you a loaded question. That is not how it is done.[/quote]Wait identifying the creator means it is a loaded question? That makes no more sense than saying that identifying Mr. A as being a bachelor makes it a loaded to substitute Mr. A into the syllogism:

All bachelors are unmarried.
Mr. A is a bachelor.
Therefore Mr. A is unmarried.

Hell am I not the one to complain about loaded questions?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]2. I have already agreed with you that the concept of morality applies to sapient beings but I made it clear why it doesn't impose an ought upon them.[/quote]Yes you have accepted that and now, can you go one step further to say what it means for such a being to actually act in a way that is moral?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]3. I have now. See above[/quote]Good.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 (of 210 pages)