₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,384 members, 8,522,756 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 11:09 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 2:05pm On Feb 19, 2013
Chrisbenogor: WOooooooooooooo 25 pages and we are still moving around in circles. How about we have a major debate about this existence of God thing self, where is Jesoulhuh

All this going back and forth, shifting of goal posts bla bla bla it would be nice to have one thread to debate this issue formally with control measures set.

cheesy cheesy cheesy?
My eyes are sore from reading all these things back and forth. Ngwa what do you guys think?
That would be good though I find that having discussions on that issue tends to provide more insight into one's thinking than having a formal debate.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 1:59pm On Feb 19, 2013
Deep Sight: I discussed this at length in a thread I opened a while back. Believe me, I have always held that the burden of proof rests with the Theists, until I had a conversation which caused me to think a little deeper on the subject.

Let me ask you a few questions.

1. When, contrary to accepted thought at the time, a Nicholas Copernicus asserted that the earth was in fact not the centre of the solar system, but that the sun was, and that contrary to the thinking of the church, the earth was in motion round the sun, and not vice versa -

a. Was the position of the church at that time a claim or not?

b. Was it not a default position?

c. Was the accepted thought right or was the scientist right.

b. Did the scientist have a burden of proof?

2. When, contrary to accepted thought at the time, Galileo asserted again against the idea that the Earth was static, in favour of the ideas of Copernicus -

a. Was the position of the Church a claim or not?

b. Was Galileo right or was the Church right

c. Did he bear a burden of proof?

In the event that you think either of the excellent gentlemen above had a burden of proof, why is that the case?

Or would you say that that they had no burden of proof?

Please address. And no, do not address it with "#Empty Rhetoric, debunked"

Many thanks.
The main problem here is that with respect to an issue like whether or not the earth goes around the sun, what should we consider as good evidence that would help us decide one way or another?

The church thought claiming that God created earth specially or that the Bible says or implies something along those lines were good enough. Do you think that such lines of thought are good enough to determine whether or not the earth goes around the sun?

Basically, what the church presented and thought was enough evidence to meet their claims actually wasn't good enough. They would have been better off saying they didn't know but it was the church after all.

Copernicus obviously discharged his burden of proof by turning to naturalistic means.

My basic point is that everyone bears a burden of proof in a discussion and it shifts from time to time in the discussion.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 1:48pm On Feb 19, 2013
davidylan: Dishonest idiocy. The atheist wants the right to "dismiss" religious theories while offering nothing of substance in return... all the while crowing about his superior intellect. How that makes logical sense to anyone beats me. If you dismiss a theory it must be because you have a more credible theory... that is the scientific process. Merely dismissing your neighbor in the name of "logic, reason and science" (ahem) that has no substance is why i have very little regard for most atheists here.

For the most part, you guys are just a bunch of reactionary id.iots who dont have much of a brain besides bleating about God's non existence.
Religious theories are theories in the colloquial sense not in the scientific sense so don't start trying to conflate them.

davidylan, you've started wailing and hurling insults again. I guess the flu delirium has totally worn off.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 1:47pm On Feb 19, 2013
davidylan: This is a senseless question that is leading no where.

Science, as interpreted by your likes, is evidence that the theory of God creating the earth is false precisely because you have scientific evidence to prove otherwise. It is this scientific explanation that we ask for... simple.
Surely you know that claiming that God did it isn't a scientific theory.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 1:46pm On Feb 19, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Any analogy concerning the issue about promises or whatever else in this scenario can only be valid as long as the two parties are in a creator/created relationship because it is based on that relationship that God is under no moral obligations[/quote]Come on that is just absurd. The concept of promises depends on minds and the ability of the one making the promise to fulfill it. The idea of making a promise doesn't need a God neither does it need this creator/created relationship you're talking about.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]I only accept that organisms adapt to their environment and change within their species and not outside of it i.e. man has always been man and not some other animal entirely becoming man.[/quote]Okay. So you basically reject scientific theories that you don't like.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]I think the problem here is that you have an inaccurate concept of heaven and hell. Heaven is not a reward earned by "good works", it is a gift God gives to us. Notice that Christ died while we were still sinners. God did not give us Christ as a reward for our goodness.
I'll give you an analogy. Please pay attention carefully to what I am trying to point out and not the straws[/quote]Whichever way you try to spin it, Heaven is supposed to be a reward from God given to some select few because they believed by faith.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Imagine eternal life was a car and Christ was the key to the car and God the father is the car owner and hell is the suffering of not having the car. God has given us the key(Christ) and He walks with us towards the garage to take the car(The Christian life). If we lose the key before we get to the garage(if we lose Christ before we die) we don't get to enjoy the car (eternal life).
Now while enjoying the car, it will be very unlikely that you will choose to give it up and trek but if for some weird reason you do, the very event of giving up the car is the suffering of trekking(to give up heaven is to choose hell)
[/quote]In that case, why doesn't he let everyone enjoy the car? He's doing it already by allowing criminals (even potential ones) into Heaven. Your God isn't allowing people to have an informed choice but he tries to force them into making such a choice behind the veil of death. So for all we know, it may all have been invented by a bunch of people just as other religions have been invented. If we're going to have such overwhelming evidence in heaven, why not cut it short by presenting the evidence to us here on earth?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]It is not the failure of the giver but the receiver who rejected the gift. You can't have it both ways[/quote]It won't be having it both ways if the choices were plain for all to see as according to you, they'll be seen in Heaven.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Your "sin in heaven" contention is like one upon hearing the promise of a happy ever after contends that the people happily ever after will have the choice to commit suicide. Of course they will but then it is extremely unlikely that one will choose to commit suicide if he is living forever in happy satisfaction.[/quote]Come on. Saying that you're tired of chanting Hallelujah isn't at all like committing suicide when you're happy. Then with the presence of many people interacting and freewill, won't sin still occur?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Knowing how poor your understanding of God is, I am not surprised you think that.[/quote]Hey what I know about your God, I got from you Christians and the Bible.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Well, if you don't see anything humbling in an almighty God taking the form of a man, then I really can't help you. Point of order by the way; Christ didn't die for saint and sinner. There are no saints other than those saved by grace.
Now to your unbeliever who dies for his friends. I'll argue based on the fact that he doesn't believe that there is anything beyond death; If it is true for him that there really isn't anything beyond death, then life is not necessarily better than death they become the same value i.e. existing is not necessarily better or worse than not existing....in that case he hasn't made a sacrifice, he has only made a preferential choice not to exist.[/quote]Yep maybe you can't but it still remains that the one with limited knowledge and a limited life has made a greater sacrifice since he'll not get anything back while Jesus got everything back and more.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]You really should have followed the argument before you butted in. I'll just have to ask you the same question that I asked omo tu dun which is: Is one bound by any moral obligation to preserve his/her creation or is one free to treat his creation as he/she likes?[/quote]You are bound by moral obligation to preserve this "creation" if the "creation" is sapient.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol, it is for that little taunt (highlighted) that I took the time to answer all your objections. . .also I'm a helpless addict easily baited into arguments... lol. Anyway, I'll say before you talk about "damaging Christianity" you first need to grasp it's underlying philosophy else you'll be scoring damage points against a strawman.[/quote]I know enough about Christianity to know how bankrupt it is. My points aren't against a strawman since there are Christians who believe what I was criticizing.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Feel free to respond to the above, I won't bother replying them. I'll only ask that we start from your answer to the same question I asked omo tu dun (which is only fair since you chose to pick up his baton)
So with that said, I'll say we keep our focus on this. Your response to the following is the only thing I'll reply to[/quote]Respond to what you will.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Is a creator under any moral obligations towards his creation? If no, then we are in agreement. If yes how so?[/quote]As I said before, the creator is under moral obligations if the creation is sapient and if the creator is said to be beneficent towards the creation.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 12:57am On Feb 19, 2013
all4naija: @ thehomer

Isn't it funny the way some people here are ready to defend imaginations drawn out of fairy tales as though they are real?

I think I am more reasonable than these Gods in most areas, if we are to go by what their believers are trying to say here.
I think it is funny and tragic.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 12:51am On Feb 19, 2013
Image123: i don't understand what you mean by 'tried'. Tried what? i'm in christ Jesus, and shielded but need to be careful still. Evil communications corrupt good manners.
1Co 15:33 Be not deceived: evil communications corrupt good manners.
Tried not to feel attracted to people of the same sex. Do you think that talking to a homosexual would make you start feeling attracted to people of the same sexual orientation?

Image123: Actually, you are the one choosing to misunderstand God's words. Check the passage(initial) and check the context. Moses was asking God for a favour based on Israel's 'specialness'. And to paraphrase what God told moses, He said " Moses, I will answer you, but I will have mercy on who I will. mercy is not only for Israel. god can have mercy on thehomer, his case is not hopeless. but thehomer needs to fulfill the conditions given for mercy.
You're just repeating yourself. Can God have mercy on thehomer the way he currently is? If he can, then you're wrong by talking about fulfilling some conditions.

Image123: 1Pe 3:15 But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts: and be ready always to give an answer to every man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you with meekness and fear:
i don't see anything in this passage telling anyone to give an answer for the questions they'll be asked. It says to be READY always to give an answer to every man that asks you a reason of the hope that is in you. Jesus is the reason of the hope that is in me. If you ask me the reason of the hope i have, i will gladly and meekly tell you that it is Jesus. He is the One that put the sugar in my tea. You have clearly tried to twist this passage to mean that the christian must answer every question/number of questions that every thehomer and harry presents to him. NO! i already showed you the example[b]s[/b] of christ, and how He was conspicuosly silent and answered nothing sometimes when asked many questions.
Joh 19:9 And went again into the judgment hall, and saith unto Jesus, Whence art thou? But Jesus gave him no answer.
Joh 19:10 Then saith Pilate unto him, Speakest thou not unto me? knowest thou not that I have power to crucify thee, and have power to release thee?


Let me show you other scriptures that plainly allow christians to ignore you.
Rom 16:17 Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offenses contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them.
2Jo 1:10 If there come any unto you, and bring not this doctrine, receive him not into your house, neither bid him Godspeed:
Titus 3:9 But avoid foolish questions, and genealogies, and contentions, and strivings about the law; for they are unprofitable and vain.
2Th 3:14 And if any man obey not our word by this epistle, note that man, and have no company with him, that he may be ashamed.
2Ti 2:23 But foolish and unlearned questions avoid, knowing that they do engender strifes.


Read the fineprint.
Jesus wasn't being asked the reason for his hope. Are you seriously saying that the only question you can answer is "What is the reason for your hope"? Come on get serious. In Acts 6:9, Stephen was debating.


Image123: The Bible is not the source of anyone's confusion as you have displayed. Many like you, have not sat down to thoroughly consider and understand the things that are written, they have refused to believe the things that are written but have only held on to parts that SEEM To support what they want. Any honest, sincere, and diligent believer would not be confused. Nietzsche is a class all time example of aconfused man, have you readup on his sad tale? Try wikipedia. Many atheists are also confused BTW. Nietzsche lived a confused, sad and sick life. He ended up in the assylum with his level of confusion. Yet he is the mentor of many a serious atheist. Try that for a perfect example to follow.
Christians themselves disagree on the Bible so who can be said to be more confused than them? They disagree so much that they've formed thousands of splinter groups. Again, what does Nietzsche have to do with anything? A number of intelligent people have ended up in asylum and some who deserved to be there weren't put in. Why not address the confusion of Christianity that is right before you rather than introducing an irrelevant issue?

Image123: Of course a seed becomes a person. Did you not do any Biology related subject? It is the seed that becomes the tree/crop/fruit. the seed becomes the person. Without the seed in the man, the man would never BEAR children.
Is the seed the man? That is what I've been asking you. And can this seed become the man without the woman? Where was Saul before his father and mother had intercourse? Was he in both of them or in his father alone? Stop trying to evade the question. I won't let you.

Image123: It boils down to the individual's personal decision. It's sometimes called free will. It's not God's choice, but your choice, man's choice. God is not to be blamed for your father's or fore-father's wrong decisions to serve other gods/no gods. He is not to be blamed for their laziness which led to their impoverishment, which birthed your poverty. He is not to blame for their sickness or genetic deficiencies or blood groups either. We all make choices, and our daily choices may have far more weight than we imagine. You still have your choice to make.
God is to be blamed if he says that someone's eternity depends on what they believe here on earth yet when they're most vulnerable, he deliberately places them in places where they'll get the wrong information.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye - Same-Sex Marriage Against God’s Will by thehomer: 9:22pm On Feb 18, 2013
Image123: Perhaps they are special. i don't think i disagreed on change of 'laws'. What i have continued to say is that there is no contradiction. i explained to you about grace and punishments/judgement and the variations between the old and the new. The 'çhanged' laws are affected either by grace, or by Christ fulfilling them already, or by their not been necessary again.
If they're all special, then telling me the Bible is special doesn't really add much to the discussion. If God changed those laws, then how do you know that he hasn't changed the law against homosexuality?

Image123: i never said God divided the Bible into chapters and verses. It's either you have an issue with comprehension, or you are deliberately misinterpreting my statements. i said the division into chapters and verses is already inherent in the passages and naturally emerges. i already answered you on diet and sabbath, i don't understand why you are echoing your questions. What are moral laws?
No, you have an issue with expression. You were implying that God divided the laws into moral and ceremonial laws in the same way that the Bible is divided into chapters and verses. The problem is that you're yet to show where God divided the laws into moral and ceremonial laws on the other hand, we know that the Bible's division into chapters and verses was done by men. You didn't answer on diet and the Sabbath. You simply said they were moral laws. You're the one to say what moral laws are since you're the one saying that God divided the laws in some way.

Image123: It's the same person casting the judgement in the OT and in the NT. the person is God. He can use whatever instrument He chooses in casting His judgement. Analogies are given to help you understand or relate with what is been discussed. Continued attempts to fault analogies is your loss, not mine. You are the one trying to understand, or asking to understand why this or that. i already understand.
If your analogies are irrelevant or simply fail in the crucial point being attempted, then it is your failure in passing across the relevant information.

Image123: Your loss, not mine.
Your failure in self expression.

Image123: And what esoteric principle is that, that the majority do not know or practice, only thehomer is bringing it up as the principle they should use? All humans have access to the supernatural. Whosoever wants to/wills, let him come. that's what the Spirit says. It all hinges on if you want to come into the spiritual or supernatural, or no.
I showed you the principle. It is right in what you quoted me as saying. Again, I said it is rooted in this natural world that we all have access to. Can you show that all humans have access to the supernatural? The mere fact that you can type what you've typed on a computer of some sort means that you and I have access to this natural world. Can you show me the supernatural?

Image123: When do you know that God is talking or not talking again?
You didn't answer my question but I'll answer yours. Please don't forget to answer my question. Recall that you were the one who quoted the Bible passage in Hebrews I was referring to there. As far as I know, God didn't write the letter to the Hebrews.

Image123: It's your lucky day, i'm being generous here. 1 Timothy 4v3-5
Come on. This isn't what I asked you for. I asked you to show me where God himself or Jesus as his spokes man said they had changed the dietary laws? Do you think Jesus ate pork? You're showing me Paul's letter to Timothy. Are Paul's letters more highly placed than God's words to Moses?

Image123: i'm in doubt as to whetherr you read that Leviticus passage. Where did you see anything about church in the Galatians passage? And where did you see slaves in the Ephesians?
Doubt all you want. The fact that in the passage you quoted, he ended it with "for ye are all one in Christ Jesus". Check Ephesians 6:5. You really should be more familiar with your Bible.

Image123: i agree with the interpretation you gave to verse , and we should not cross dress. Very relevant and important today. The other passage is also relevant and important. So, search for the interpretation. The Word of God is a treasure mine, sometimes you justy got to dig. Dig thehomer, i'm not your skydaddy.
Come on. Don't be lazy. Show me your interpretation. Unless you think your words are written in the Bible or that I can read your mind, I think you should hold up your own part of the bargain.

Image123: whatever. i'm not interested in useless arguments over nothing simply because i'm right.
Then show you're right. Merely saying it doesn't make it so.

Image123: Jesus visits Lagos all the time. i live in Lagos, and ive met Him. Countless others can testify to meeting Him too. Look for Him, you will meet Him. Did the Ninevites see Jonah inside the fish, or you think he was telling them stories about fishes? Read the passages again mr. All they heard was a warning about judgement in 40days, and they repented. You have heard more lucid and convincing stuff. You either have overheard or not to have paid enough attention. Work on these weaknesses.
You met Jesus? Wow. What did he look like? What station was he on? Did he give any interviews in English, Yoruba or Aramaic? Sure he would have talked about living in fish. Who wouldn't talk about that? Heard that from who? If I believed every fantastic story I was told, then I would probably be worshiping every God I ever heard about.

Image123: It is a warning to US, and other generations that followed the flood. Read 2Peter2, the sentence starts from verse 4. A proper sentence doesn't start with 'And'. Read what is before AND, the conjuction.
Hey. You're the one presenting the quotes. It looks as if you've still failed to understand why I brought up Noah and the flood. God flooded the earth to wipe out evil on earth. You presented 2 Peter as a claim that it was actually a warning but right there in Genesis where supposedly God was talking, he said it was a warning. Are you now telling me that Peter is allowed to second guess God?

Image123: grin you will soon see the all true Kaduna fallacy, nonsense. Read the scriptures and be wise. Sinners are children of the devil, and like the passage says, will be children of God when they fulfil the given conditions. Which one is sanctifying all creation BTW?
So if someone is baptized, is it possible for them to still tell a lie? It was you who quoted a passage talking about it to me. Have you forgotten so soon?

Image123: The point again is not how difficult or easy. that seems to be lost on you. The point is WHO has it. You can't give what you don't have. Only Jesus had what it took to pay for sins. A sacrifice is an offering to God, whether it costs much or little is not the point.
I brought it up to make the point that it was easy.

Image123: Perhaps you might need to define God. The One in the Bible has shown clearly that the soul that sins will die, as was told Adam. The One in the Bible sticks to His Word and is faithful.
I'm talking about the God of the Bible. The one that says he loves everyone but does nothing to help them when he can. That isn't a faithful God.

Image123: Eyaah, like i said, Jesus has been sent into all the world. Many people can testify to that. God has a plan and will of His own that you are to subject to. He is not to subject to your whims and whimpers. Jesus coming every 33years to die is not what will make people believe in Him. Some folks lived when He came and crucified Him. Some folks saw His miracles and didn't believe but betrayed Him. Some folks watched the resurrection live but were paid not to believe. God has spoken once, you had better pay attention for your own good.



i'd reply to the rest later.
If you believe just anything "some folks" say, then you're just looking to get scammed. Some folks say that Mohammed is the last prophet, some folks say that Jesus went to the U.S after flying away in Jerusalem. Some folks say that zombies roamed the city when Jesus died. Who are we to believe?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 8:19pm On Feb 18, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Not necessarily. Your child is not your creation so it's not quite a fitting analogy. The reason God keeps a promise is the same reason God doesn't lie which is because it is His nature not because He is morally mandated to.[/quote]An analogy isn't supposed to be identical to the situation under consideration. It is only supposed to be significantly similar with respect to the issue under consideration. Here, the issue under consideration is the making and breaking of promises not who created what. After all, the child may just be a nephew or the child of a friend. Does God have any moral obligations at all?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]First of all, eternity may be conceptualized in two ways: firstly as an endless sequence of time chunks or as a timeless state. Secondly, I don't accept that whatever it is that you are referring to as incapable of thought 500,000,000 years ago is my ancestor.[/quote]Which of those concepts of eternity do you want to go with? Okay. So are you saying you don't accept the theory of evolution?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Now to the point that you are making, sin sprouting up in Heaven apart from the fact that it will be very unlikely, it will not reflect a failure on God's part in much the same way that a person refusing to enjoy a gift does not reflect a failure on the part of the giver but on the receiver. Heaven is God reconciling us to Himself for our own good. Hell on the other hand is the result of separation from God. If a person willfully chooses hell after living in heaven, God will not force him to stay in heaven against his will.[/quote]Okay so what you're basically saying here is that people can actually still go to Hell after arriving in Heaven. I do think it is a failure on God's part because the point of earth was to separate the good from the bad. It then turns out that some of those bad people still ended up in Heaven. It means that he could have accepted everyone into Heaven and then actually allowed them to make the properly informed choice rather than having them gamble behind a veil.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]If God did that, it would contradict His nature[/quote]It won't be the first time.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]If you can fathom how humbling it is for the one by whom the universe was created to take on the form of puny little humans and allow them to kill Him, not for His benefit but for the benefit of His murderers, then you'll begin to understand the magnitude of Christ's sacrifice.[/quote]I don't see anything humbling in it at all. According to Christianity, he wasn't doing it just for the benefit of his murderers, but for the benefit of anyone who would be born after his resurrection. i.e for saint and sinner alike. And after all that, he went back to being a God while the mere human who died has no chance of even coming back to being a mere human.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]As we have established earlier, God is not under any moral obligation to appease their parents.[/quote]No we haven't established this yet. So as I asked before, is God under any moral obligation at all?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]P/s: From my experience, arguments with you tend to branch into multiple tangents and branches that it becomes somewhat tiresome. I wouldn't want this one to go that way so please when you reply, highlight the one you would want us to focus on so that we can commit ourselves to it and hopefully be watch dogs to each other not to stray from the confines of the argument.[/quote]Long discussions often branch out from some set topic. If you think addressing those three points that I think clearly damage Christianity will be too stressful, you're free to ignore them and address whether or not God has any moral obligations and the issue of sins in Heaven.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 12:58pm On Feb 18, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Of course you may[/quote]With pleasure.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]And what moral obligation requires this? What you have done here is propose a moral law higher than it's law giver. What is this moral law based upon? If God by definition is the highest possible being, then there cannot possibly be a higher moral law which He is subject to.[/quote]The moral obligation of what it means to make a promise to someone that you can easily fulfill. e.g if you promise a child a present, is there some moral law that mandates you giving the child the present? Unless you wish to alter what it means to make a promise, then God is still bound the concept of promises.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Well, I believe it is possible to sin in heaven else the devil wouldn't have been able to sin. Will people still sin in heaven? I don't suppose so because they would have yielded to the influence of the Holy Spirit else they won't have made it to Heaven in the first place. Sin would be totally unnatural to them.[/quote]Excellent. What you've managed to show here is that God could still fail in his aim of Heaven since sin could easily sprout up once more as according to you, it did in the past. Sure sin may be unnatural to them in the first 300 years but what happens at the 301st year? As they say, eternity is a long time especially towards the end and with such a long span of time, who knows what would happen? Thinking was unnatural to our ancestors 500 million years ago yet here we are thinking.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]1. The death of Christ is not pointless. What makes you think that it is?[/quote]The fact that with a decree, God could have made the death unnecessary.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]2. Jesus coming as a man alone was a huge sacrifice in itself talk less of His death and resurrection[/quote]Then maybe we disagree on what it means for an act to be a sacrifice. Jesus came to the earth, performed a lot of magic, had followers, died, got resurrected and went back to heaven while being worshiped by billions of people for a long time. The best part of all this is that he knew what he was getting into and he knew what the outcome would be.

Compare that to the non-believer who just happened to be in the vicinity of a grenade who jumps on it to save his other 6 comrades. All he knows is that if he does this, he'll die and will be forgotten by most of the world in 50 years.

Who would you say is making a greater sacrifice?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]3. If God created life and has the ability to take it and give it back as many times as He wishes, then you should know that death is not a tragedy to Him since it is not irrevocable.[/quote]Sure it isn't a tragedy to him but it is to the parents who live and care about these children. Or doesn't he love their parents too? This is the sort of point that bothers me in Job. God allows Job's children to be killed and as reward, he gives Job more children. Having the privilege of knowing people who have lost children, do you think they'll accept these new children as actually replacing the dead ones?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 12:12pm On Feb 18, 2013
@Mr_Anony if I may . . . .

[quote author=Mr_Anony]I read what you wrote. But then you miss my point which is that even if God broke a promise to you (and He doesn't) it wouldn't still make Him evil because He is under no moral obligation to make promises to you in the first place.[/quote]If he breaks his promises, then at the very least, the is being immoral because the could have fulfilled the promise but chose not to do so. Even if he had no obligation to do it, once he made the promise, as a moral being, he becomes bound by it.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]I hope you do realize that for God to make you morally perfect, He will have to take away your ability to choose evil and as a result your ability to choose good will go as well because even though you will be doing "good stuff", it wouldn't be your choice. Essentially what you are demanding is that God should take away your freewill.[/quote]I personally have no problem with that because if he could make heaven with freewill and an absence of evil, surely he could do the same here on earth. Or is it that there is no freewill in Heaven? Or that people still sin in Heaven?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]The full verse is: "For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son so that whoever believed in Him will not perish but have eternal life". (John 3:16)

Apparently, God has shown His love by giving you His Son which is your key to eternal life. I find it funny that you should reject God's gift of eternal life and yet accuse Him of hypocrisy for not delivering the eternal life He promised. Would you prefer that God forced eternal life upon you against your will?[/quote]Several points here.

1. He could have given humans eternal life without the pointless death of Jesus.
2. Jesus' death wasn't that much of a sacrifice given his foreknowledge and the personal outcome to him. Many people have sacrificed much more than Jesus did for much fewer people.
3. Based on that passage, God is supposed to love the world. Yet he sits back and allows diarrhoea to wipe out helpless children. I don't think that shows love to humans.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 12:27pm On Feb 17, 2013
vedaxcool: Yawns and his family and friends are muslims right? Dude, the point I was making is very clear, I was responding to a particular aspect of the op, your response simply jump off track! But know I see nothing wrong in being the cowardly lion of wizard of oz fame as long as the person finds fulfillment in doing so!
Is it cowardice to avoid or prevent conflict in your family?
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 11:33am On Feb 17, 2013
vedaxcool: The op was speaking of this guy and certain kinds of coward in this section (off course being careful when dealing with people is very good but unless this certain coward believes his family and friend are viciously violent, then the picture below from the wizard of oz captures the op - the guy who is a HOUSE NIGGA and worships the white man behaving not different from Samuel L jackson role in Django, quite well)
This is just a stupid response. Did you read the original post on this thread? Did you notice how heavily it referred to adherents of your religion? Do you know why? Here let me tell you; it is because he like many people in the rest of the world, think that your fellow Muslims are willing to murder atheists.

With respect to friends and family, read my post responding to the OP.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 10:14am On Feb 17, 2013
vedaxcool: Someone has been watching prometheus . . . David nice one there, I stopped taking these people serious because they try hard to sell themselves as scientist, in fact they would make more sense disapproving religion by its theological argument than always yapping about what they do not know, . . . But after all cowards die a thousand death (funny they live a thousand lives), but a coward who faces no danger and remains a coward must be innately a coward in every sense of the word COWARD!
Some say a living dog is better off than a dead lion. This is what the Bible that Christians carry about says. Make of it what you will.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Cowardice Of Atheism by thehomer: 10:03am On Feb 17, 2013
davidylan: The impetus for this post was a surprising comment that i read from a popular militant atheist around here...
Okay.

davidylan: This was particularly shocking to me. How is it that "atheists" who claim to have such an overwhelming evidence of the mythology of religion be completely unable to discuss these points with their families and friends with the same zeal with which they attack christians here?
There are numerous reasons e.g atheists have been kicked out of their homes for being atheists, they've been discriminated against and due to how the religious people hold their beliefs, such discussions may be avoided to "let peace reign".

davidylan: Are atheists guilty of living a double life?
Not really.

davidylan: One of affected supreme knowledge of the science that disproves God online (where they have the safety of anonymity) and are complete cowards to their real friends and family outside of here?
Avoiding conflict in your own home isn't cowardice.

davidylan: While reading through some writings by other prominent atheists, i realized the idea of atheist cowardice isnt quite new... take this for example - In 2010, Christian apologist Mariano Grinbank wrote:
“ The New Atheists have expressed that the proverbial straw-that-broke-the-Atheist-camel's-back was the group of attacks on the United States of America on September 11, 2001 AD. That is not to say that some of them were not Atheist activists before then, but 9/11 fanned the flames of their activism.
The attacks on 9/11 where primarily caused by Islamic extremism (with a long list of other causes such as maintenance or gaining of power, wealth, popularity, etc.). The question is: what have the New Atheists done in response to this particular event, this particular threat? Surely, they would focus their efforts primarily, if not exclusively, upon confronting this threat, this cause, head on.
Well 9/11 was a driving factor but it is also widely accepted to be a symptom of a larger problem and not the illness itself so attacking superstitious thinking in all its forms meets that threat head on.

davidylan: Yet, what have the New Atheists done? What they have and have not done makes one wonder if their appeal to 9/11 is a reason or an excuse. After all, why 9/11? Are they not aware of similar atrocities throughout history? Are they not aware of the recent chronicles of the most secular century in human history also being the bloodiest-with millions upon millions being murdered not only during war, but also by their own regimes? (see here).
This accusation is no more sensible than wondering why anyone bothers fighting poverty in say the U.S when there are lots of poor people in Africa and Asia today and in the past. What religious people making this argument forget is that today, the threat of nuclear arms has made it necessary to push for more reason in our interactions with others.

davidylan: Have any of the New Atheists toured Islamic countries giving lectures in which they condemn Allah, Muhammad, Islam, or Muslims?
I'm not sure but what is this supposed to show? As far as I can tell, it shows that atheists realizing that they have one life to live don't want to waste it by getting martyred in those Islamic countries. Although there are atheists in those countries.

davidylan: Have any of them debated Muslims in Islamic countries?
Again, what is this supposed to show? Though it looks like one will take place soon.

davidylan: Have any of them been interviewed on Al Jazeera?
Yes.

davidylan: Have any of them written entire books in which they condemn Allah, Muhammad, Islam, or Muslims? Have they done anything of the sort at all?
Yes. Take a look at the works of Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Ibn Warraq.

davidylan: The answers to all of the above are: "No."
So the above answer is false.

davidylan: Rather, what they have done is sit within the comfort and safety of countries based on Christian principles and conveniently launched condemnations which are roughly quantifiable as being 90% anti-Christian and 10% anti-other religions (and this may be being too generous an estimation).[33]
And why does this bother you so much? Is Christianity to be spared when it is most prevalent where they live? And today, those countries aren't based on Christian principles. Christians don't even agree on what Christian principles are.

davidylan: think about this... how many "atheists" do you see loudly proclaiming that islam is a myth? why do they prefer to sit within the comfort and safety of the christian section of Nairaland conveniently launching vitriolic tirades at God (i.e. Jesus Christ) while paying complete lip service to allah? when questioned on this... why is the puerile excuse usually that "most atheists" were formerly christians anyway?
Actually, many atheists have said that Islam is a myth. Atheists criticizing what they're most familiar with isn't puerile, it is intellectually honest. Or do you go about criticizing things you don't know? (Oh sorry you do.)
Christianity Etc › Re: Logicboy's Successes And Failures On Nairaland! by thehomer: 10:52am On Feb 15, 2013
Image123: you should know how i know. The Bible says so. am i supposed to show fake colours?
The Bible also says a lot of things like God being happy with killing children, finding slavery acceptable, talking snakes, a global flood etc. Turning to it for generally good information I think is a bad idea.
Politics › Re: Soyinka Leads Protest To Fashola Over N4bn First Lady House by thehomer: 10:30am On Feb 15, 2013
Anyone very concerned about this can contact their representatives from this page. Just locate your representative at each level and voice your opinion rather than simply shouting on an anonymous forum.
Christianity Etc › Re: Logicboy's Successes And Failures On Nairaland! by thehomer: 8:32am On Feb 15, 2013
Image123: philosophically, socially, spiritually, one thing i know. The fool has said in his heart, there is no God. obviously the same qualifications.
Hmm our Christians showing their true colours. But, how do you know?
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 8:27am On Feb 15, 2013
Deep Sight: Let me lay this matter to rest: and in doing so I certainly will not permit you to change the pith of the discourse. I really do not know what fancy gymnastics you think you are deploying when you state that we are to show Dawkins saying that the theory of evolution disproves God and not that it doesn't need God. In the first place there is minimal difference between both statements. In the second and more important case, the second statement is that which I advanced as his position: which is definitely the case as quotes below shall show. Nevertheless I must highlight the fact that the one statement implies the other, especially given the overall gamut of his arguments.
There is a huge difference between those two statements. The first can be compared to saying that the theory of gravity doesn't need God and the second to saying that the theory of gravity disproves God. Now you wish to run from your previous claim that Dawkins said the theory of evolution disproves God but this is what you said here.


Deep Sight: Explaining photosynthesis and thereby concluding that Trees are self existent. Or explaining how nutrition helps babies grow and thereby concluding that they weren't born.

That's what makes someone a philosophical dunce.
You said that was the meaning of Dawkins' statements but as I showed you before, it isn't.

Deep Sight: Now please for the last time settle down and understand the sequence of this matter properly. Dawkins' works under reference have been directed at disproving the existence of God. Now in so doing, he devolves into the theory of evolution for large parts of the article under reference to show that God is not needed for living things as we know them to exist. He goes so far as to adduce proof and arguments for the theory. In the first place, I might ask straightway what he was doing that for if not to disprove the existence of God - his stated mission anyway?
Your mind seems fixated in the idea that whenever Dawkins critiques the idea of a God, the conclusion he must be drawing is that he doesn't exist but that isn't what he was doing at that point. How many scientific theories lead us to the conclusion that God doesn't exist? How many say that God isn't needed as an explanation of the phenomenon under consideration?

Deep Sight: CLEAR POINT NUMBER ONE: God's existence is a question that arises from the philosophical conundrum: why something instead of nothing. It thus is a question that faces the very existence of the universe itself, and the commencement of life. Given that the theory of Evolution does not address either of these questions, then it follows that the theory of evolution cannot be held up as a reference point for disproving the existence of God in the first place. Simple.
The theory of evolution wasn't developed to address them but you have decided to saddle it with those questions.

Deep Sight: Now the question which I will now put to rest is whether Dawkins does in fact hold up the theory of Evolution in disproof of the existence of God. I believe that this is the question that you have repeated here ad infinitum, ad nauseum, and which logicboy has asked as well. I have ignored the question because it seems to me that it could only be asked by persons who have not read the article under question, and particularly have not followed the overall gamut of Dawkin's arguments in all his works. The emphatic answer to that question is Yes, he does indeed hold up the theory of Evolution in disproof of the existence of God.

And as I have shown you above, and in my penultimate post, it is rationally and clearly philosophically mis-footed, to even set out the theory of evolution in disproof of the existence of God. But Richard Dawkins does this.

And here is the quote you have been waiting for:


Yes, the foregoing is Dawkins-speak, straight from the same article I referred you to, but which you sir, have been too blind to read. And in the event that there is any doubt about his meaning, he launches immediately after that statement into long passages seeking to prove and substantiate evolution (hardly necessary in light of the core questions). At all events, by this statement it is apparent that he says that the theory of evolution effectively dispenses with the requirement for a creator. And the painful point that you yet fail to appreciate is simply as I said earlier: the theory of evolution does not, has never, and was not meant to ever touch on the questions apposite to the existence of God - namely the commencement of the universe and the commencement of life. It is thus benumbing for the good professor to argue it as a factor that shows that evolution is doing the job that "once upon a time was the prerogative of God."

The prerogative of God rather has always been argued as the factor that caused things to come to exist. Evolution does not address how things came to exist. It addresses how things grow and change. As such it is completely irrelevant in the question of the existence of God.
Sorry but this is either you just being dishonest or failing to understand what the quote you posted above there was referring to and that would be an example of quote-mining.

The paragraphs preceding that quote clearly show what that statement was referring to which is how different species appear to clearly fit in with their environment. It then follows that what he was referring to as "the prerogative of God" is the apparent existence of design in living creatures and not the existence of the universe. How on earth could you have made such an error?

You've read what Dawkins was referring to in that article, then you decide that God's real prerogative is in the existence of the universe and conclude that evolution hasn't been used to show that God doesn't exist when that isn't what it was being used for in the first place. This is just embarrassing.

Deep Sight: This is why I have set out that which I have set out to you; and it is simple and self evident to see.

POINT NUMBER TWO: Now I should go further to state that when people start out on such a badly mis-footed line of reasoning as I have shown above, they inevitably end up in deeply twisted contradictory conundrums. For that is exactly what happens to le professeur in his article: as he is forced to immediately acknowledge that evolution could not have commenced from nothing. He is forced to recognize that which I argue to you is and always has been the real root of the matter - namely how anything came to exist in the first place. In doing this, le professeur begins to trace backwards the existence of things and ends up with a plaintive plea that he is not a physicist but a biologist, and as such is not concerned with the core of the matter - the beginnings of the universe!
Can nothing actually exist? Merely saying that God did it isn't an explanation. Wait so Dawkins himself said he isn't concerned about the beginning of the universe yet you think that the point of his article was to address it?

Deep Sight: Now this is just a simple way of saying and admitting exactly what I have argued: namely - that evolution does not and cannot disprove the existence of God (whereas Dawkins wrote that "Evolution, then, is theoretically capable of doing the job that, once upon a time, seemed to be the prerogative of God" ) - and then turns around to effectively admit that his area of expertise, biology, cannot address the question - but that the question must be addressed by physicists!
I'm sorry but how could you have failed to understand that article to this extent? What do you think is the "prerogative of God" that Dawkins was referring to? Not what you think it is but what he was referring to in that article?

Deep Sight: Hear him in the same article -



Of course the foregoing to the the nuanced mind clearly elucidates everything that I am saying in this respect: namely that whereas Dawkins has advanced Evolution as a factor that dispenses with the existence of God, he, at the conclusion, is forced to admit that his arguments in fact have no place whatsoever with respect to the God question. That in fact, it is the physicists cosmological question that properly addresses the argument. For which the fellow says this is not his area of expertise! What the f/uck then, was he busy writing epistles on evolution about, for which he concludes that the functions of God are therewith "theoretically" obviated?
If you don't understand what he was saying then obviously, you cannot argue against it because all you've done here is to either construct strawmen or show your failure to understand what he wrote. You clearly haven't heard about the argument from design that is held up as evidence for God. Please take the time to look at it. That argument was destroyed by the theory of evolution.

Deep Sight: I can only end this little intervention with one of his last lines where he states that if there is a cause, it will have to be irreducibly simple. My friend, God is not argued to be complex. God is actually that very irreducibly simple element that is the core of all existence.
God is simple? Is your mind simple? How many simple minds do you know of?
Christianity Etc › Re: Logicboy's Successes And Failures On Nairaland! by thehomer: 10:13pm On Feb 14, 2013
MacDaddy01: I only see you with the real elitist douchebag called DeepSight. Debating about time and numbers and some imaginary shyt like that.

Thats why i assumed that you werent into the social issues.
Obviously, there are more posters on Nairaland besides Deep Sight. So you may have to look beyond Deep Sight to see my posts responding to others.
Christianity Etc › Re: Logicboy's Successes And Failures On Nairaland! by thehomer: 8:24pm On Feb 14, 2013
MacDaddy01: Good.


My point is that the philosophical issues are the most intelligent because you need deep thinking but they are also useless to practical life and reality. The paradox of omnipotence is not going to save the child that is accused of witchraft in some fundamentalist church which is a social issue. Everytime you remind people that beating/killing a defenseless child in the name of religion is still assault or murder, you could be stopping a potential supporter of witch beating.This is why the social issues at time carries more weight
Actually, the philosophical issues aren't as useless as you think neither are they simply about esoteric things. In fact, the consideration of morality can be and is often done philosophically.

MacDaddy01: Why I call you an elitist douchebag (which of course you are not) is that you seem to care mostly about the philosophical issues, you are hardly into the hard stuff like practical morality and removing religious laws from society etc. Sorry for calling you an elitist douchbag by the way.



Thanks for proving me wrong. Sorry about the Hitler reference too! smiley
And what makes you think that I haven't spoken about morality and pushing for a secular nation?
Christianity Etc › Re: Logicboy's Successes And Failures On Nairaland! by thehomer: 7:30pm On Feb 14, 2013
MacDaddy01: . . . .

The Homer; This guy doesnt know but I truly HATE the kind of atheist he is. He is more into addressing the philosophical issues with Deep Sigh and Anony rather than the social issues. To me, he sounds like an elitist douchebag. Atheists like him are very reserved in condemning religion.
And what type of atheist do you think I am? And how did you arrive at that conclusion? You speak as if addressing the philosophical issues should be less important than addressing the social issues. What you need to realize is that they're all important but from my point of view, addressing those philosophical issues are more likely to reach the person than the social ones because religions are very different and their practitioners are also very different.

How exactly does a non-elitist douchebag address religion and its adherents? Do they all do it the way you do?

What sort of condemnation do you want to see? People defacing churches or their billboards?

MacDaddy01: The best way to put it is an example with hitler. Many politicians and scientists knew that Hitler was dangerous but they didnt care because hitler couldnt hurt them as some of their services were necessary to the nation. Some of these guys left germany because they were smart. Now the question is that, if you know something is wrong, why avoid it or run away? Explain yourself, Homer. I will change my views about you.
I don't see what bearing this example you've presented with Hitler has to do with anything since you already agree that I address religion in my own way while you're trying to castigate people who according to you, didn't do the right thing and just ran away.

I don't really care whether or not you change your views about me since these are just words written by faceless people online.
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 7:18pm On Feb 14, 2013
Deep Sight: I did quote you. I quoted the answers you gave to the questions I asked. I asked you if any of three options has any bearing on the origin of life. You answered saying none of them did - including evolution. I then went on on explain why that answer shows Dawkins arguments to be philosophical tomfoolery. I also showed that you could not possibly agree with those arguments going by your own words. Here is what I wrote -
Surely the English language isn't difficult for you based on how much verbiage you enjoy generating. I asked you to show me the contradictions using my own words. You didn't show any contradiction there. Let me try direct questions.

What is the contradiction in someone accepting the theory of evolution and accepting that the theory of evolution doesn't need God as an explanation for what it (the theory) explains?

You didn't show Dawkins making the claim you said he made. I've asked you several times already to actually quote him saying it in the article he wrote to which you referred. So far, you've been unable to do it and a word search shows that you just made things up.

Deep Sight: So my friend, I really don't know what is unclear to you. As expected, and as usual, you want ten explanations before you see the very simple points made. I don't have the strength for such nonsense please.
Sheesh. I ask you to show me my contradictions by quoting me and what do you do? You go ahead and quote yourself generating a lot of words. How hard is it for you to actually catch me in a contradiction? Or don't you know how to show that someone is being self contradictory? All you've shown is that you either have no idea of what you're saying or you're just deliberately being dishonest.

Deep Sight: Oh, and yes, Dawkins has severally held up evolution as a factor that obviates the requirement for God.
What is wrong with you? I told you before that biologists agree that the theory of evolution doesn't need a God for its explanations to work and you're repeating it back to me?

What you're supposed to show is Dawkins saying that the theory of evolution disproves God not that it doesn't need a God. Don't start dancing and vomiting lots of words, just demonstrate your claim for once.
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 6:45pm On Feb 14, 2013
MacDaddy01: He has been cornered into a claim without proof. He is trying every escape route.



Speaking of claims, please address this claim I made about you;



https://www.nairaland.com/1194798/logicboys-successes-failures-nairaland
That was a curious assertion that I didn't see. I'll address it on that thread.
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 6:42pm On Feb 14, 2013
Deep Sight: I wrote it all up there. If you refuse to reason, and more particularly, refuse to be sincere, that is your kettle of fish. I cannot spend all day repeating myself.
Your dishonesty knows no bounds. I'm asking you to quote me. Show me the contradictions using my own words right on this thread. Don't just sit back, type a lot of words and lie.
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 6:21pm On Feb 14, 2013
Deep Sight: ^^^ I see you have failed to read anything that I wrote. Worse, you have now surreptituosly retreated to defending yourself whereas the discussion and the thread was about the views and statements of Dawkins - which you defended - and now eminently shown to be reetarded. Later boy.
This is the sort of dishonesty that I find really frustrating. You just throw out assertions like a religious fellow and when asked to back them up, you run away. This is a pattern of behaviour with you and it is terrible.

Why don't you show how I've "surreptitiously retreated" by quoting me? I know what the thread is about but you're yet to actually show me doing anything you're accusing me of by quoting me on this thread.

You've not shown me to contradict myself, you've not shown me to be retreating here and you've not shown the problem with Dawkins' statements. And the article you cited as being damning to Dawkins, doesn't appear to be so since you're unable to actually show the quote that you think is problematic.

I usually expect better from you but you're regularly putting up a very disappointing show.
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 5:49pm On Feb 14, 2013
Deep Sight: Compassionate, patient, merciful and kindly to his wards indeed is thy tutor. Master of the school of the deluded, to thy master alone you look for help, he will guide you to the straight path, and not the path of those who have gone astray.

This logic is not to be doubted. It is a guide for the deluded, who must now have faith in logic.
Hmm.

Deep Sight: Do you seriously mean to assert to me that you know of nothing, no concept, no idea, no common denominator whatsoever that these three have in common? Not even the fact that they are all processes of development? Not even the fact that - as you already said - none of them is an initiative phenomenon? Not even the fact that they are all represent the change of living things over periods of time? Not any other thing?

It can only be concluded by any sane observer that you dishonestly refused to see any common denominator. And it is useless engaging in a debate where parties willfully make such lamentable pretensions.

Must I painfully break down every thing for you? Please don't give me deja vu.
I cannot read your mind. If that is what you wanted to say, why didn't you say it in the first place? How does what you've said added to the conversation?

Deep Sight: Lol, you really do bring a smile to my face all the time. A wry one though.

You and I are very well acquainted with the fact that the theory of evolution does not touch on the origin of life. THAT is exactly the point - namely that since evolution has nothing to do with the origin of life, then it cannot be a reference point for dismissing that which is referred to as the origin of life! Simples!

In fact, I elaborated on this in the thread I referred logicboy to - the thread which his quaking fear and congenital epilepsy has frigtened him from reading up till now. It is in fact not just the origin of life at issue. It is the origin of the entire universe at issue.

Because the cosmological question of God's existence centres around the existence of the entire universe. And the cause for that. It is therefore starkly unimaginable that one would state that the evolution of species on a speck of a planet - obviates the need for God! - When that need, arises from a question about the existence of anything at all - as opposed to nothing!

It thus beats belief entirely, that as we very well know, the TOE does not address either the origin of life or the origin of the universe - and was never meant to - and yet it is held up as sufficient reason to obviate the questions that it was never meant to address! - - - and does NOT address.

Amazing, my son, amazing! I hope you can clearly see the illogicality here.

And no - the argument is not that which you have tried to rephrase it as - namely that God is not necessary for evolution to take place or continue. God may very well not be necessary for that (not my position though), just as Bill Gates may not be needed in your bedroom for your computer to make automatic updates. That is neither here nor there; for the question of God's existence has never been about how things work, but about from whence they started to exist and work in the first place. And thus, to the extent that evolution is not about that, then it is philosophically dumb to hold it up as a factor that obviates God's existence.

And this is exactly why I have said he is effectively arguing that demonstrating how photosynthesis works or how a child grows means that neither the tree nor the child needed a cause.

Haba, thehomer, did I really need to spell all this down word for word for you?
Wow. You really love being verbose but you've not said anything cogent. Did anyone say that the theory of evolution disproves God? Earlier, you claimed to be quoting Dawkins but you're yet to provide the quote. Why?

Deep Sight: As above.
You didn't show any contradiction. You just threw up a lot of words as a smokescreen or a strawman. I never said or implied that the theory of evolution disproves God. What I said was that God isn't needed in formulating the theory. I also said that biologists agree with me but you've somehow gotten yourself confused about what I said. Please go back and read it then please show my contradictions by quoting me.

Deep Sight: Now now, you best be careful for I have purchased a new and excellent whip specifically for you and your ilk. You don't want your family asking you where those scars on your back came from, do you? They just might conclude that you are into kinky stuff. Your arguments are certainly kinky enough.
It looks as if you're going to be whipping yourself again Professor Deep Sight. Just let me know when you're done whipping yourself so that the hospital will be ready to receive you.
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 12:30pm On Feb 14, 2013
Deep Sight: Wise and patient indeed, is thy master; the compassionate, the merciful.
Ooh. Deep Sight the merciful.

Deep Sight: Come now, and practice the sincerity I have drilled into you since you were a child, but for which I and your parents forever remain exaperated not to ever see in you.

That question was written in English, and very simple English to boot. You give me to believe that you are terrified of the calamity that answering the question must necessary bestow upon the head of Dawkins, and I verily suspect that you already see clearly exactly why he is a philosophical dunce within that very light and simple question alone.

Gird thy loins: do not be paralyzed by fear my son.

The question again - What is the common denominator between these: (a) evolution (b) the growth of a child (c) the growth of a plant

Now answer me, or the rod awaiteth thy back.
Repeating the question won't make it clearer. What you need to do is to either rephrase the question or let me know what answer you're looking for because I don't see any common denominator other than something as trivial as saying that they're all described by humans. In the same way that speaking slowly in a language foreign to someone won't make them understand you any better.

Deep Sight: END OF DISCUSSION.

This answer singularly teaches you why Dawkins is a Philosophical dunce.

When you say that Evolution does not explain the origin of life, how can you then not see the flawed reasoning in Dawkins holding up evolution as that which renders a cause of life such as God, unnecessary? It surely cannot be that which renders such a cause unnecessary, if it is, as you say, no explanation for the cause of life!
Actually, what you're showing is that you are deficient in your knowledge of biology. The theory of evolution isn't supposed to explain the origin of life. And in developing the theory of evolution, God hasn't been necessary.

Deep Sight: And with this my dear Homer returns to his long history of vicious and wildly contradictory notions.

- - -He says in response to me above that NONE of (a) evolution (b) the growth of a child (c) the growth of a plant - explains the origin of life

- - -He then says that indeed "Dawkins and the vast majority of Evolutionary Biologists" believe that evolution renders God unnecessary - in spite of the fact that thehomer acknowledges that evolution DOES NOT explain the origin of life.

As such, it is either that theHomer does not agree with "Dawkins and the vast majority of Evolutionary Biologists" - - - or else, as usual, he is wildly confused.
What exactly is the contradiction you're trying to demonstrate? How does anything I've said contradict the other?

Deep Sight: And finally, if "Dawkins and the vast majority of Evolutionary Biologists" believe such a thing, they must be mad, because the theory of evolution says nothing about the origin of first life.
Once again, you're just confused. Evolutionary biologists do believe that and say so all the time so Professor Deep Sight has declared them all insane. Wow. Haven't you seen your confusion yet?

You agree that evolution says nothing about the origin of life. Biologists say that God isn't needed to explain what the theory does explain so what is the contradiction?

My advice to you is that if you find yourself going against the experts in a field when you're not an expert in the field, you should be very careful so you don't just embarrass yourself.

Deep Sight: Student, Capisce??

Need thy master say more? Stop embarrassing me. Do not let people know that my years of tutelage have been wasted, son.
I'm sorry but it looks as if you're one of those teachers teaching nonsense, professor.
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 11:20am On Feb 14, 2013
MacDaddy01: Anony thrives on false analogies
Maybe or maybe it was just an honest error.
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 11:09am On Feb 14, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]That is just as bad as saying that upon coming across a murder, we cannot conclude that a someone is responsible if we don't know if the person is blonde or brunete[/quote]This is a false analogy. When we conclude that an incident was a murder, it means that we know something about the entity that caused it. It means that we've decided that the cause was a human.

But when we're asking about the origin of the universe, what are we postulating about the entity that did it? You need to have some idea of the being to say that it could even do what you're claiming it did don't you?
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 11:04am On Feb 14, 2013
[quote author=Mr_Anony]For the exact same reasons that there is a good and bad political strategist even though two political analysts may disagree on strongly on which strategy is right. Also even as 'expressive' as theater art is, the difference between good and bad art is almost always obvious to trained practitioners.[/quote]Political science is quite different from political strategy and political science has a lot to do with political philosophy and political history. I'm quite sure that even though I didn't study theater art, I can notice the difference between good and bad acting or presentation even if not as well as trained practitioners can.

But is Islamic theology bad theology or just factually incorrect? How about Catholic theology and Aztec theology? Are they just bad theology or factually incorrect? How do you know?
Christianity Etc › Re: "Religion Has No Place In The 21st Century"-Cambridge Debate-Dawkins vs.Williams by thehomer: 10:59am On Feb 14, 2013
Deep Sight: Thou wicked and slothful servant, thou playful minion of thy master, thou proddest thy master into teaching you what thou ought to know?

Thy master is patient, benevolent indeed.
It is good that master Deep Sight is patient.

Deep Sight: Now, lesson 1 - Answer thy master this -

1. What is the common denominator between (a) evolution (b) the growth of a plant (c) the growth of a child?
I don't understand the question.

Deep Sight: 2. Which of these three processes explains the origin of living things?
None of them.

Deep Sight: 3. Does Dawkins not argue, that on account of the process of evolution, "God just isn't necessary"?
Yes he does and the vast majority of evolutionary biologists agree with him. Do you agree or disagree? And why?

Deep Sight: When you are done with this lesson I shall take you to lesson 2 on Physics vs Biology.

Run along now little Peter, will you, and catch the school bus. Don't forget your sandwiches.
Please master answer my questions and I can't wait to see the lessons you have on physics vs biology.

Thank you master Deep Sight.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 (of 210 pages)