Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 (of 210 pages)
Deep Sight: This is one of the most brilliant posts I have ever read on Nairaland - provided that the poster (Anony) was hinting at what I think: namely improbabilities. Indeed if that is the case; it should trouble the atheist that the statistical chances of life within this universe are far less than the chances of 500 people walking over a keyboard and thereby creating a username, and using it to make posts.Well the statement in bold is false. The statistical chances of life in this universe is 1. |
Deep Sight: What I mean is that religion is not the issue in purely theistic debates such as most of those Dawkins is involved in. Proving the falsity of religion is not the issue in such debates: the issue is a purely cosmological and philosophical question as to the origin of the universe.Well you're wrong about that. In the clip under discussion, he read what he wrote about the Christian God in the God Delusion. Do you think that quote had anything to say about religion? Have you read the God Delusion or a fair review of what it contains? If you had, you'll realize that he tried to show that at least the Abrahamic Gods didn't exist and that even if they did, they would be tyrants and religions based on them would be expected to be tyrannical. To you it is harmless but to those who are denied proper education, are beaten or killed due to religious ideas, it is harmful. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]That is merely your opinion of what "they owe to themselves"[/quote]Again, it is not merely my opinion, it is what honest people do when they want to show that they were being honest. [quote author=Mr_Anony]All I saw was a question asked and a question answered.[/quote]Don't you think that the sequence or any intervening words could be important? [quote author=Mr_Anony]What evidence exactly?[/quote]The fact that intelligent design asserts that life came about by creation by some intelligent agent. Creationism says the same thing. [quote author=Mr_Anony]The bold is what you think their claim was and not what it is. If I recall correctly, the phrase Stein used was "legitimate pursuit" Not "serious contender". You a loading their claim to make it sound like something else.[/quote]No I'm not loading their claim. What you don't seem to understand is that what may be a "legitimate pursuit" to Dawkins may not be one to you and vice versa. If Dawkins thought it was a "legitimate pursuit", why do you think he hasn't devoted his own resources to consider it as he has considered his other scientific work? Isn't that what scientists often do when they think that something is a "legitimate pursuit"? [quote author=Mr_Anony]If a person says that something is possible he doesn't necessarily mean that such a thing is a 'serious contender' compared to another theory, but yes he definitely means that such a thing can be legitimately explored.[/quote]Come on. To a scientist, pretty much anything can be legitimately explored. If you think this was Dawkins point, then it is a trivial one and won't be news. After all, the prayer experiments among others were considered areas of legitimate exploration by scientists so would it have been news if that is what was actually meant? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Here's a transcript typed from Dawkins' "rebuttal video" posted on this thread. Now please read the above exchange carefully. 1. At no time did Ben Stein say that Dawkins believed in Intelligent Design. His voice-overs to me are an accurate representation of what Dawkins had just said.[/quote]I never said that he did. [quote author=Mr_Anony]2. At no time in the "rebuttal video" did Dawkins say that the clip was edited to change the questions asked to him. He posts the same questions and the same responses as they were in the video.[/quote]I didn't say this either besides, what you have there is a transcript of the text from the video. [quote author=Mr_Anony]3. All Dawkins is claiming is that they took his statements to mean something else other than what he intended. But then again, no one has said that Dawkins believed in ID. That's Richard Dawkins strawman.[/quote]But the implication of saying "Dawkins thinks ID is a legitimate pursuit" in the context of the video connotes that he somehow thinks that ID is good enough to be considered in the greater scheme of things. [quote author=Mr_Anony]4. To me I think Richard is only upset because the video was not championing Darwinian evolution propaganda. As for his comments on the video, they are there for all to see.[/quote]He said why he was upset himself. It is right there in the exchange you quoted. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Here is an exchange between Dawkins and Mark Mathis the producer of "Expelled" at the screening of the movie. My friend I see no dishonest editing anywhere. Perhaps you should show me what it is that you are seeing because I simply can't see it.[/quote]I've tried several times to show it to you but if you still cannot see it, then there's probably nothing more I can do. Edit: Do you think that Dawkins would consider a research for God a "legitimate pursuit"? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Not necessarily. They are under no obligation to provide raw footage to the public. There are many reasons why might want to retain the footage. The second part about your opinion of what an honest filmmaker ought to do goes both ways i.e. if Dawkins really had nothing to hide, he would have demanded the full clip be made public. Speculating over reasons lead us nowhere.[/quote]They owe it to themselves in order to be clear that they have nothing to hide. It is generally how honest people act in such a situation. What reason is more important than them here demonstrating their honesty? Dawkins isn't really in a position to make demands of them. [quote author=Mr_Anony]See 3:12[/quote]What do you think it shows? I ask because that is the point where the question actually posed was dishonestly edited. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol.....a form of creationism...yeah right.[/quote]Hey that's what the evidence shows. [quote author=Mr_Anony]But their narrative was NOT that he believed in intelligent design. Their narrative was that he thought it possible only he was against certain kinds of designers i.e God. You have given them a strawman narrative just to back up your bais.[/quote]That isn't their narrative. Their claim is that Dawkins thought that intelligent design by aliens was a serious contender. I haven't introduced anything that Stein himself wasn't attributing to Dawkins. Once again, I have to ask you if you think that when someone says something is possible, do you think they mean that it is a really a serious consideration? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Good Please watch the video again. See 3:12[/quote]I've seen it and that is one of the points where the dishonest editing took place. What do you think it shows? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol...at least one thing is clear Dawkins himself has said he was indeed talking about directed panspermia. (for the benefit of logicboy)[/quote]Of course that is what he was talking about. The question is what was the context in which he was saying it? [quote author=Mr_Anony]2. Dawkins is here desperately trying to back away from his statements because it is obvious through the video that Dawkins has no problem with intelligent design just certain kinds of designers. He even makes a point of stressing what the designer cannot be. 3. Did you notice the "We Are The Light" song at the end?[/quote]Through which video? You see the problem is that you're refusing to accept that context matters. Since the recording of Ben Stein posing the question to him on any conceivable type of intelligent design wasn't in the clip you posted, it makes that clip and the voice overs dishonest. So he wasn't backing away from the statements, he was providing the context for his statement. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]They aren't and as far as I know, Dawkins has not requested it either.[/quote]Maybe he has, maybe he hasn't but the thing is that if they were trying to be honest, they would release it without waiting for him to request for it. It is like someone accusing another of being dishonest. If the accuser wished to show that they were honest, what they do is to present evidence nullifying the accusation especially if they hold all the cards. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Actually no my friend that is inaccurate. The question was not edited out. Please watch the video. Again you are clutching on a strawman, I haven't claimed that that's what Dawkin's believes; I have made it clear however that he thinks intelligent design plausible. His only grouse is with the nature of the designer. That much is obvious[/quote]I've watched the video and I'm pointing out to you that the part where he was asked if there was any other possible option out there was edited out. Maybe you should watch it and read his own response about the clip. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I have told you before that intelligent design is not the same as creationism.[/quote]And I've told you that intelligent design is a form of creationism. The evidence also agrees with me. [quote author=Mr_Anony]No I obviously don't think it is an uncut video however I am contesting your suggestion that it was edited with the intent of undermining Dawkins that is what you have no evidence for. Dawkins answers to me already fits their "narrative" without much need for disingenious editing.[/quote]So Dawkins' answers already fits their narrative? Really? So why did it come as a surprise to him that he was being portrayed as saying that he believed intelligent design was a serious consideration? When people are talking about hypotheticals and they say something is plausible, you say that it doesn't mean they believe it yet you say that his statements already fit their narrative. I think that is inconsistent. |
davidylan: That is just absurd. Fear of what? thehomer and wirinet?Maybe. You're the one wondering about the onslaught of Nairaland atheists. |
davidylan: Again i reiterate... much of your "knowledge" really goes no further than what you can glean from the internet since you have zero real world experience with amino acids. Amino acids, as components of proteins, cannot be created in the lab on a routine basis. Please provide a recent peer-reviewed scientific paper describing in detail the process of amino acid generation in the lab. thanks.Guy don't embarrass yourself again. Wikipedia is your friend besides, haven't you ever heard of intravenous fluids that are given that contain all the necessary amino acids? Take a look at the protein part of total parenteral nutrition. Amino acids are one of the components given. You'll be surprised at the sorts of things modern pharmacies are capable of Mr. 100% real world experience with amino acids. |
davidylan: Just look down at the roll-call of NL atheists reading this page. you wonder what draws them like nervous flies to a thread about "God" time and time and time again especially since they spend half the time blabbing about how God is supposedly non-existent. you would think they had something better to do than recycling the same tired arguments about why the pink tooth fairy could not possible be real.Is this fear I sense? It costs little to rebut the God claims so why not do it at my leisure? |
Deep Sight: As to your last paragraph; religion is not the issue. The existence of a creator is the issue. And it is a harmless philosophical and theological question. Period.Religion is not the issue to who? Do you see God coming down to kill homosexuals and blow up buildings? The fact that you think it is harmless, doesn't make it so as many religious people will show you if you push them to it. Period. |
davidylan: . . . .Your quote in bold is false. We create amino acids in labs all the time. Some even exist in space. |
plaetton: . . . .Actually, people have stopped believing in God because of his work. You can take a look at this page. |
Deep Sight: Yes there are. They were made and I gave the link. If you disagree, go there and tell me whats wrong there. I will not pander to your laziness in simply saying "no there aren't". Read the thread provided and show what arguments are wrong. If you cannot do that, or perhaps you don't have the time, then you cannot expect me to write all over again here. That will "expose" my joblessness.That same thread that you eventually absconded from? Deep Sight: As to Logicboy, I hope, from everything in this thread, you can now see why I describe Dawkins (and everyone else who regards him as intelligent) to be a dunce. It is normal that dunces should follow dunces. Birds of a feather flock together. That is why Pentecostal dunces also follow Pastor Dunces. It is the very same thing.Ooh Mr. Deep Sight lays down the law on who a dunce is. Deep Sight: There is one aspect in which I would agree that he is smart though. Namely as a con-man intent on making money. This is no different from what a writer like Dan Brown does. If you really want to make money from writing, as a smart person, all you need to do is write something controversial. Best of all, hit out at what people hold sacred, and you become an instant hit, from the controversy generated. That is very clever. Dan Brown, Salman Rushdie, Richard Dawkins. All the same, vey old, very well known strategies of Con-Artists and those committed to sharp practices. As a business, it is excellent. I might consider writing something repugnantly controversial and s.illy myself. Makes good bucks, in a repugnant and s.illy world.Of course. Ignore the pastors and prophets who haven't written anything controversial but have made more money. Though people like you simply miss the point. The main question is: why should religion be out of the realm of what can be honestly criticized? You now assert that writers are actually con-artists. Please can you tell me what concept of con artist you're using? I ask because anyone who understands the language and buys the book most likely knows what to expect. You go ahead and write your controversial book but before you do, please tell us why writing on religion is controversial. Deep Sight: Because other than that, it is very curious as to why a non-religious Biologist would bother himself to write a book about religious beliefs, and spend great energy and time on such religious fancies and myths. . .particularly when his object of attack is not the morals at issue but the existence of a creator - a notion which whether true or false; is harmless - - - when he should rather be more busy advancing his professional calling in the lab and in the field - doing biological research for the progress of humanity.Really? Are you aware that because of religion, people have been doing and are doing stupid and dangerous things that affect not only themselves but others around them? On Dawkins advancing his professional calling, why don't you actually take a look at his accomplishments on Wikipedia. Seriously, people like you sometimes make me wonder what you think scientists and education are for. You seem to think that scientists should simply shut up and work in their labs as if they're not a part of the society they live in or that they may have views that they may wish to express. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol, actually, they are under no obligation to release unedited clips and to the best of my knowledge, Dawkins has not asked that unedited clips be released. And also contrary to your claim, the video doesn't try to make it look like Dawkins believes in aliens. Anyone who watches the video will see clearly that Dawkins proposes aliens as a possibility and not as a belief. Your argument for dishonesty really has no basis.[/quote]They are if they wish to claim that there was no dishonesty on their part. Dawkins himself has made documentaries. In fact, when McGrath claimed that the best arguments for theism were cut out what happened? The full unedited interview was posted online for all to see. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Good so you could tell this much from the 'edited' video? Where then did you get the idea that the video was edited to make it seem that Dawkins was declaring a belief instead of a hypothesis?[/quote]Sure I can. When you consider Dawkins work and the methodology that Stein used for this film, it isn't a stretch. From you and Ben Stein. This was what you said. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Secondly, It was Dawkins himself proposing the theory that life on earth could have been a result of directed panspermia. At least he doesn't deny that he did this even if we allow (without proof) that he was tricked into into it by a cunning question. It doesn't change the fact that he considers 'alien reproduction' to be a plausible origin of life.[/quote]He wasn't proposing a theory, he was simply considering a hypothetical that was explicitly asked of from him. But the part where the question was being posed was edited to make it look as if he was spontaneously proposing it. If you think that Dawkins actually holds that view, then why does his extensive writing not support that it is actually his view? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Actually, directed panspermia is a form of intelligent design for life on earth.[/quote]And there are points against it too. Besides, do intelligent design creationists argue for panspermia? [quote author=Mr_Anony]You have provided no evidence for this[/quote]What? Do you think that was the entire uncut interview? What sort of evidence are you asking for? And who do you think should have it? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]My replies to individuals on this thread: . . . . @thehomer, you think the video was edited to make Dawkins look bad? I don't think so. First of all you have no evidence for this other than Mr Dawkins word. Unfortunately Mr Dawkins is under no obligation to tell the truth neither is there an incentive for him not to lie.[/quote]Actually, the evidence lies in the fact that they've been unable to release the unedited clips, they conducted the interviews by misleading the interviewees and that it is actually possible to dishonestly edit something to make it look as if someone holds a view they actually don't. We know Dawkins doesn't hold that view, he's written several books on this already. Which do you think is more likely that in this single edited clip he chucked out his written work or that someone with an ulterior motive who opposes his views tries to make him say something he doesn't actually believe? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Secondly, It was Dawkins himself proposing the theory that life on earth could have been a result of directed panspermia. At least he doesn't deny that he did this even if we allow (without proof) that he was tricked into into it by a cunning question. It doesn't change the fact that he considers 'alien reproduction' to be a plausible origin of life. My friend, your contention here holds no water. . . . .[/quote]His point with panspermia is that it is still more plausible than his God and it actually is more plausible than the Christian God. Dawkins wasn't proposing a theory, he was simply considering a hypothetical. It is something that scientists, philosophers and others do. The fact that panspermia can be thought of as being a plausible origin of life doesn't somehow make intelligent design creationism more reasonable. It still has lots of problems with it. The fact that something can be considered by someone as being plausible doesn't mean that it is what the person actually believes happened. Again, the evidence lies in the fact that the interview had to have been edited in multiple places at multiple times in order to get it to fit with their narrative. |
Image123: ^It is figuratively used to say that one person is another person's descendant. Not that the person was literally living in their ancestor's body. |
hisblud: @thehomer: in one of your post, you stated that the film was edited to give an assumed meaning. Was hopeful of seeing an unedited version of the youtube anony gave, alas i was disappointed by the link yes its darwins opinion on that link, i would have loved to see the "unbiased", "unedited" full clip, which wasnt there. So i may assume that would be the full clip, unedited video which MrAnony had posted?AbiThe only people who would have access to that unedited version would be those who made the movie and they have their reasons for not releasing the full unedited clip. The company that made the film mislead a number of people so they really didn't expect to be deliberately misrepresented. Usually when there's a complaint about how someone was presented in a so-called documentary, those who filmed would release a full uncut version online for your independent review but here, we don't see it. |
Image123: And what criteria qualifies them as figurative as against literal? i cannot exist without my granddad. i was in him, i am his DESCENDant. i descend from him. i was in his seed. Saul was in Jacob's seed. If Jacob was childless, there would be no Saul the seed of Jacob. The Israelites are the seed of Abraham.It is figurative because the man called Saul was not in the man called Jacob. If you disagree, what part of Jacob was Saul in? A man cannot literally be in their own grandfather. Please take the time to look at what it means to say that something is figurative and another is literal. e.g when Babylon is referred to as a LovePeddler, does it mean that Babylon actually is a LovePeddler? Image123: already addressed. i said in he above post that we are judged according to our works,and that we are sinners by default, hence we cannot be sacrificedd for others, as we are not sinless. i was in Adam as his seed. the whole of the human race was. On the bolded, you are very right. that is what should be done and that is what will be done. That's why we say Jesus is coming soon. he is coming to do just that. Wipe everything out, with the right asteroids, and bring in perfection. If you need the scriptures that say that, i will provide them.I'm not saying we should even be sacrificed for others. I'm saying that the whole sacrifice thing was pointless because God could have decreed otherwise. If Jesus is coming with asteroids, we'll actually see it. That is one of the things NASA does. And if we see it, then we will have time to prepare for it won't we? But my main question is why did he even make that attempt with Noah if he knew that an asteroid would have done a much better job? Image123: Actually, a pastor's child has free-will to decide for himself or herself. news making the rounds tell us that pastors children and people born in christian homes turn out as atheists. that is free-will at work. your assumptions do not always follow in reality.But how about the Muslims and Hindus? What are they to do? Their children are already condemned because God allowed them to be born at the wrong place. Image123: Man was given the ability to procreate before he fell in the garden of Eden. Is there anything that sprouts out of the ground on its own? Human beings are the crown of creation, we are more complex than you suggest. i assumed science should have taught you that? There is a process. there are laws. There are protocols, there is justice. And God is not in a rush, sorry. If you truly feel any sense of urgency, the best thing you can do is make sure that you stop being an hell candidate. i stopped being an hell candidate when i gave my life to Jesus, by believing in Jesus and repenting of my sins. The choice is yours still.My point is that God could do it can't he? If he did that, then we won't have to worry about Adam's sin. That is what an omnipotent and omniscient God who really wanted all the humans he created to go to heaven would have done. |
Sheesh. You really like long replies. Image123: sorry for the delayed reply, wanted to reply earlier but the computer i was using had issues while updating microsoft essentials. Had to quit the browser without ability to copy what was typed.The Harry Potter books weren't written all at once neither were the Jason Bourne Books. The fact that it was released in series doesn't make it special. If all books are special, then the Bible has no unique claim to being special. Image123: Yep, for example,Firstly, Jesus didn't talk about that. Secondly, if you agree that certain laws are to be discarded, why shouldn't the laws against homosexuality in the Bible be among them? Image123: That's the point. Gravity was there and the rack/hand was there. They can't float out of the hand for instance even if they were in space. the hand will hold it. Gravity is there and the living hand is there. Same way some of the laws co-exist and yet give way for the other.Where did the hand come from? If they were in space with no gravity, the shoes would float out. Image123: The airplane violates gravity all the time using a greater force ithink.No, it doesn't violate the law of gravity. Countering the action of gravity isn't violating it. Violating it means that the plane somehow annuls the effects of gravity. So you can pick another example or just accept that "law" has various meanings. Image123: Well, for you, but not for me. Yes, Adeboye's statement can be accepted. i believe you expect gay right activists statements to be considered and perhaps accepted when it comes to making policy decisions. It's only fair then that Adeboye's also be considered and perhaps accepted.That is why I ask on what basis he makes these statements. If he says the Bible, well that isn't good enough because not all Nigerians are Christians neither are they the same type of Christians. So what we need is a more general principle on which to make this decision. Image123: Clothing, dietary and slavery laws are not limited to the passages you have given. The laws are to be weighed in respect of the total, complete Bible, and then followed. Read other parts of the Bible that speak on clothing, diet and slavery and get a balanced view. The balanced view should not be ignored. You are selectively enforcing and accusing others of selectively ignoring.i say, do nothing selectively. Let's have a balanced view of the laws from the whole Bible, and 'enforce' the balanced view in that light.No they're not limited to those passages but is there a part of the Bible where Jesus says those laws are to be thrown out? Go ahead and try to balance it. You have your work cut out for you. Image123: i believe the people in the Old Testament before Christ(B.C) believed in an afterlife. they believed in punishment for the wicked and reward for the righteous. They didn't think that after death, it was nothing. i agree that Jesus made it more explicit, but they had the idea of a resurrection. The pharisees believed in resurrection.They believed in an afterlife for those that God has picked but that the rest would simply die and that will be the end of it. No hell or eternal torture until Jesus showed up. The last passage in your Bible quotes was referring to prophets. I still don't see anything there about an eternal punishment. Image123: Sure, God is good, have you not heard? You ought to know why He changed His decision against Nineveh. They repented, remember?So he gave the small town of Nineveh the chance to repent but he cannot give say the state of Lagos a chance? God himself couldn't make the entire world do that so he sent Noah and the flood which of course failed. Now, you're asking me to trust a being so powerful and knowledgeable that he failed at such tasks? He failed so much that his best option is to deliberately create a torture chamber to torture most of the beings he loves for eternity? I'm sorry but that doesn't make sense. When you love 100 people, you don't place them in a situation where you have to torture 99 of them forever. Image123: Every mere person had a sin of his own to die for. An innocent sacrifice was required for atonement. Sinless and spotless.Again, what Jesus did was a simple sacrifice not a difficult one. That is my point. Image123: Jesus' resurrection was not the payment/atonement for sins. Atonement was done on the cross and declared to be finished before Jesus died. Jesus resurrected to defeat death, to technically take the power from death for us. The death of Jesus gave us forgiveness of sins. the resurrection gave us the victory. The victory is what gives the shout of a king, we are made not just pitiful forgiven sinners/debtors but champions and conquerors over the enemy by the resurrection. You i trust to fight to the end for your right instead of dying for anybody, so don't even start.I didn't say his resurrection was a payment for sins. My point is that if I knew that I would be resurrected if I died for my family, I would be happy to do it and I won't even consider it a major sacrifice just an inconvenience. Image123: The human life is precious, more precious than all of the earth's material thing. Jesus quantified it as greater than gaining the whole world. A sacrifice had to be made. There are laws already set and consequences faced for actions. god doesn't just decide it no longer needed. there are steps and protocols. The soul that sins shall die.God decided the consequences were no longer needed for Nineveh why didn't he do that for the whole world? Why should the whole world have to be punished together when he can simply declare that people born in Lagos State would be born without sin? Image123: Adam chose his nature. He was the first man/human being. He was given the choice. You and me as his descendants have to benefit from that choice, as it were. It's like a man born normal but who grows and lives with a loose life of immorality and dirty life. If he gets infected with sickness like HIV, or develops an habit. the sickness and habit can be passed to his descendants. his mannerisms can be inherited. Heck, even his physical possessions can be inherited. We unfortunately inherited the sinful nature of Adam. He had a choice of obedience and disobedience, life and death. he chose death, and was driven away from the garden. You are not held responsible for Adam's sins or anybody else sins. you are held responsible and punished for your sins. We are all sinners by nature at birth. as we grow, we become sinners by nature and by works/deeds. Every man is judged/punished according to his WORKS/deeds. that's one of the reasons why the baby is not much of your worry.Did you choose your nature (not your actions)? Couldn't God have made this sinful nature non-genetic? Physical possessions can be inherited but they're not necessarily passed from parent to offspring. Image123: God chooses to have mercy on who He wants to have mercy. He has chosen to have mercy on the babies and i have given you scriptures on that and the very words of Jesus Himself. If you feel cheated, well, bad for you. His condition of mercy for you is repentance.Oh now he will have mercy on just any random person. Yet he's the one that cannot break his own rules but here, you're saying he can break it whenever he likes. This is just your God being inconsistent then. You should look at what I'm doing as pointing out the inherent inconsistencies within the Christian doctrine rather than me trying to get right with your God. Image123: No, they are not disobeying Jesus. They are only been wise. Not every fisherman needs to try to catch a shark. If you lack the tools and 'courage', the shark will catch you instead. Jesus did not require us to do what you are insinuating, whatever it is.The "Great Commission" was for them to preach his gospel. The apostles and others tell them to defend the faith but those Christians run from it all. How isn't that disobedience? Image123: Many of my fellows also agree with me. The scriptures agree with me, v.important. Search the scriptures.And that is why there are so many denominations and so much confusion in Christianity. I've read the scriptures and as Christians keep demonstrating, you can read into it anything you want. |
davidylan: So i decided to watch the entire video as Anony suggested and i will start with these general observations...Well, he isn't since as I'm sure you know, atheists don't go around deifying people. Most prefer to think for themselves. davidylan: 2. Even Ben Stein noted the BLEEDING OBVIOUS - Richard Dawkins AGREES that some form of intelligent design was REQUIRED to create the type of complexity that we see in nature today (watch from 4:00)... his only problem really isnt about intelligent design JUST CERTAIN TYPES OF DESIGNERS SUCH AS GOD!And what you saw there was an effect of dishonestly editing the film. Dawkins' opinion on the entire incident can be seen here. davidylan: The problem with Richard Dawkins is quite obvious, he hates God QED. Every other argument is an excuse to wipe God out of the equation. It is amazing that someone who mocks christians for placing blind faith in myths is fumbling in the dark with ridiculous myths such as "some super race somewhere that evolved in another planet by some darwinian mechanism and then seeded our planet with life...". Incredible! For someone who insists on science, logic and reason... the above explanation for life (that he honestly admits he cannot prove even though he keeps bleating at christians to prove God exists) is an exercise in eye-popping demagoguery.How can someone hate what they don't think exists? That is just absurd. Think about it. Do you hate Woden? Actually, panspermia makes more sense for an origin of life on this planet than the Christian God does. davidylan: Note how very little confidence he himself has in the idea that somehow life is merely a product of some self-replicating DNA... I suppose as a scientist himself, he understands how unserious that notion is. We fumble around with RNA molecules all day in the lab, no serious scientist worth his salt believes we can create life our of primordial soup.How can you note that from this video? Yet life on earth had to come about somehow from non-living materials especially when you know that at some point in time, there was no life in the universe. |
davidylan: I stopped watching at 2:25, i couldnt help but notice that even Richard Dawkins is NOT sure that God does not exist. Why is he uncomfortable just stating that God doesnt exist and moving on? I think this strikes at the heart of why atheists "violently" push their ideas at all costs. Deep down, there is that gnawing nervousness... that just maybe....Dawkins is saying that he isn't absolutely certain that God doesn't exist because the sort of evidence we have simply suggests that he doesn't. I'm sure you know that scientific theories don't work with absolute certainty. So, the nervousness you think you're seeing isn't actually there. I guess it is a good sign that you put "violently" in quotes because you know the different sort of violence the religious are capable of. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Hey guys, here's a quick experiment please oblige me a bit; I'm quite interested about how two different people can observe the same thing and yet come to two different conclusions on the same thing Please watch the video below and tell us your thoughts. Which parts of it feel most compelling to you and why? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GlZtEjtlirc Knowing me, you'll probably have rightly guessed what I think of it however I'll share my views later after a few people would have shared theirs. The reason is so that we can focus more on the video itself than on responding to comments.[/quote]Actually, that video was dishonestly edited. I'm sure we know that with proper editing, anyone can be made to say anything at all so on the whole, I didn't find it compelling. |
Does anyone know if she was a Christian? If this happened in a Christian household, it would be claimed for Jesus. |
Image123: Inside my father. See and compare this case from the Bible.Huh? I thought those sorts of sayings are taken as being figurative rather than literal. Your great grand father didn't give birth to you, neither could he have given birth to you so the only way someone can say you were in him would be in a figurative manner and the passages you cite clearly demonstrate this. Otherwise, what part of Adam were you in? What part of Jacob was Saul in? Image123: The fall of Adam in genesis 3 is what is inbetween. Adam got corrupted with 'the sin virus'. Thereafter, every file/human in him or put into him also got corrupted. And whatever is corrupted would be removed. Only Jesus can save any file/human from this corruption.So because of Adam, you're going to hell. Now what sort of God who wants most of his creations to go to hell would arrange things in this way? Secondly, if you believe in Adam, then can you tell me what part of Adam you were in? As I said above, such sayings are to be taken figuratively not literally. Finally, why didn't God start over properly rather than doing a Noah's Ark and a Jesus sacrifice? He could have wiped everything out with the right asteroids and created more perfect humans. Image123: Then came freewill, remember? you only decide what you want to be when you are born, not before. We are all hell candidates by default, but we all choose whether we want to remain so or no. Judgement day is coming. There is already a time appointed for that, exercise patience.If you want to use freewill, then my question is why should God have allowed so many different religions out there and multiple sects of Christianity? Surely he must have known that the chances that someone follows the religion of their parents is very high. In that case, he actually has minimized those people's freewill while granting mass murderers more freewill over those they kill. So you don't decide what you'll be when you're created. In that case, why didn't God have people sprout from the ground rather be born by other humans? Even we humans know enough to prevent infections by preventing contact with carriers why didn't God do something better? If he had done that, then maybe we won't all be hell candidates according to you and remember, when you say we're all hell candidates, it means that the 2 day old child is also a hell candidate so where would that child go? And how did you arrive at that conclusion? |
Image123: If it is not special, please produce a book like it. Lionel Messi is a special soccer player, usain Bolt is a special athlete, the Bible is a special book. If i write it this way, perhaps you understand better. The Bible is not like your everyday literature. It is followed by billions of people for thousands of years. All the laws of the Bile hold. If there is a law that doesn't hold, it is because it has been fulfilled or done with or a greater law of God is in place. For instance, in a street, there was a time when a place was barricaded and it was illegal for cars to pass there because of ongoing construction work. Now the consruction work is completed. Cars now pass there. This is not a case of inconsistency or contradiction on the part of the law maker. the previous law had to go seeing that it was no longer necessary. Consider another case on the law of gravity in room. My bag or shoe would obey the law of gravity and come down to the floor. But if a shoe rack was introduced, or i held it up with my hand, the shoe/bag stays up. The law of graavity is still there but has been superseded by the hand holding it or the rack from which it is hanging. there is no imaginary law fighting with or contradicting one another. it's a similar thing with the Bible commands that you think to be contradictory. BTW, i repeat clearly again, there is NO CONTRADICTION in the whole Bible. The problem is misunderstanding.By that reasoning, everyone is special and every book is special. It means that the Qur'an is special, the Book of Mormon is special, the novel Things Fall Apart is special. So what if many people read the Bible? Many people act out and have acted out Shakespeare's plays so I guess his works too are special. Did God say any of his laws were no longer necessary? Your analogy with the shoe rack is wrong for two reasons. 1. Gravity doesn't stop acting on the shoes otherwise they would float out of the rack if not stuck in place. 2. The laws of gravity aren't the sorts of things that can be "violated" since they're descriptive laws unlike laws that people give to others to obey which are prescriptive. Image123: the laws are not subject to debate. It is the interpretations that are subject to debate. This thread is talking about Adeboye's statement on same-sex marriage being against God's will, which is true. you are suggesting we launch into a back and forth on slavery, diet and clothing. If you say so, no wahala for me. i don't know about the moderators and others. What are the clothes laws, dietary laws and slavery laws?Actually, for me both the laws and the interpretations are subject to debate. The thread can also be used to discuss on whether Adeboye's statement should actually be accepted when it comes to making policy decisions. Clothing laws are the sorts of things found in Deuteronomy 22:5 and 22:11, dietary laws in Deuteronomy 14:7-10, slavery laws Leviticus 25:44-46. My point is why should they be selectively ignored while enforcing others? Image123: i want to believe that the Old Testament is also Judaic teaching, whatever that means.None of the passages you quoted above talk about eternal punishment. Just that people will be destroyed and that will be the end. With Jesus, we have continued punishment forever. Image123: Well, that's God's requirement as seen in the Bible. He is the owner of Heaven and earth and He decides the criteria and requirements to enter His Heaven and live with with. Earthly organisations have their own requirements for employment and entry. Countries and even residences have their terms and conditions for people to come in.So God's requirements must automatically be good? Can he not do better than that? He could change his decision against Nineveh but not against the entire world. Isn't the world bigger than Nineveh? Sure countries and residences do but they don't then decide that anyone not in their country must be tortured forever. Image123: It is someone who has money that can talk of paying debt. your death would not have been accepted as you can only die for yourself. Jesus was not born of a man but of a woman. He is not a child of Adam but a child of God. He was not infected with 'the sin virus' by default. While He was on earth, He stayed away from being infected by overcoming temptations to sin. Adam was created good, without the sin virus. He did not overcome his own temptations. If Jesus had sinned, He would have been disqualified too, as a sinless, spotless 'lamb' was what was required. You and i were born with the sin virus.My point is that the so called sacrifice that Christians keep making noise about isn't something that a mere person cannot do. When we then consider that Jesus got to be resurrected and float away to heaven while someone like me would be willing to do it even if it meant never being resurrected at all tells you that maybe I have more compassion for my people than Jesus and God. Then the sacrifice won't have been needed if God decided it was no longer needed. Image123: Adam made everyone start with a debt, not God. Adam is the father of all mankind, he is the beginning of the human race, and we inherited what he had. Just like you inherit something of your father's name(surname), blood, nationality, looks, sickness/prone sickness, character traits etc. We all inherited from adam the sin nature and the characters of a human being. A 2day old baby cannot choose. He/She cannot be punished as all sinners would be punished according to their works. The 2day old has no works.Who gave Adam his nature? Sure you inherit physical characteristics but I don't think you inherit your father's punishment. After all, if one's grandfather was a killer, it doesn't mean that the person would also be a killer neither does it mean that the person should be branded for what their grandfather did. How much more Adam and you? Why should you be held responsible for what Adam did? Remember you're saying that even before you actually commit any crime at all, you deserve to roast in hell forever. How can children be guaranteed Heaven? Aren't they born with sin anymore? That looks to me like Jesus and God contradicting themselves. Image123: And what you have said is not your own interpretation? Have you considered that you are speaking to someone who is 'finally' answering your questions, instead of dodging it or disappearing?Oh I'm aware that it is my interpretation and that you're not running away like many other Christians would. And I hope that other Christians reading this realize that when they run, they're disobeying Jesus. My point is just for you to realize that many of your fellow Christians would disagree with you so how do you know that your own interpretation is correct and theirs wrong? Other interpretations are from the Bible too. |
Sure they must pay after Nigerians keep vandalizing the distribution pipelines to cook in crude refineries and kill themselves. I've frankly become disillusioned about the Nigerians that are supposedly going to be helped by the judgement. |
Image123: i was created when Adam was created. We all were.Really? So where were you stored until your birth? And what is it that happens between this "creation" and "birth" that makes you deserve to be in hell? Now God knows that more than 98% of humans will be going to hell so why doesn't he destroy those of us that will be going to hell before we're born? Why doesn't he at least destroy the terrible people like serial killers and mass murderers before they're born? |
Image123: Yes, the revelation of God's will to man was progressive. It was made complete in the new testament. In the new testament, all things are ready, and nothing is needed for addition again.I know you think it is special but you understand that I do not agree with you. But it is reformist if some previous laws are declared to no longer hold. If the steps are not reasonably connected, then you shouldn't be surprised that you conclusions won't be agreed with. Image123: Any law that was given by God still stands as His law. there is no change. The problem many in this our generation have is the understanding of those laws and their context. Another thing is to know the purpose of each law and if that purpose has being fulfilled or still needs to be served. When i was a little child, my parents gave a limit to where i can go by myself, who i can collect stuff from, what time i must be back home and in bed etc. As time has gone, the laws are not exactly the same in our relationship. Not that they changed or made a mistake or have now 'repented'. If i had a ki.d sibling, the law would still apply fully to him/her. One/You may unreasonably argue at partiality or contradiction, or you may reasonably understand in maturity, the reasons and the contexts. Your renderings of tattooing and wearing clothes of mixed fabric and slavery are subject to debate, perhaps on another thread.No, they can be addressed here. If you say that any law given by God still holds, then you need to say clearly whether or not those clothes laws, dietary laws and slavery laws still hold. If the Bible wasn't progressive in the sense of being reformed, then why should the laws be subject to debate? Image123: The punishment had been there already. the whole world was already under the threat of wrath and judgement, read your OT and study the prophets. The people in the time of John the baptist were "fleeing from the wrath to come". It wasn't Jesus that brought it. Jesus had not even begun His ministry as it were.Actually, according to Judaic teaching, people aren't sent to hell, when they die, everything ends but with Jesus, you get to be punished for eternity according to most Christian beliefs. Image123: Spot on. That is God's view. All have sinned, all are debtors by default. Every man, both the honest and dishonest, christian-born and pagan-born, 'good' and bad, everyone is born into sin. There is no amount of good deed that can pay for our debt. The wages/ result/reward of sin is death. The only way you or anybody is not going to die is if another person dies for you. The only person(according to the Bible) that is qualified to die for you or anybody is Jesus Christ. And He has already done that. What is left is for you to accept that He paid your debt, or decide to pay it yourself. All these is in scriptures. I'm trying to explain without using the many passages, but i can give them if you want.Why should someone dying for someone else be the only way? What even makes what Jesus did so good? I would have done it for my own family how much more the world and all future humans? But why exactly should God make everyone start with a debt? It doesn't make a lot of sense for a 2 day old baby to be considered to be a sinner deserving of death and eternal torture. I've read the Bible and what you're saying is simply your own interpretation. There are Christians who have a different opinion on these issues. |
Image123: No, we were not created as sinners. We were created perfect, good. That's what the Bible says about the creation of man. We were created in Adam, after Adam, we are simply born. So we were created good, Adam lost that good in the Eden, and took the evil nature. Now, we are all born with the nature of Adam, which is a sinful nature, we are born as sinners. i can oblige you if you need scriptures for that.When were you Image123 created? And when were you born? |
Image123: sorry for probably keeping you waiting. the Bible is not self contradictory, it is rather progressive i.e in stages. It only behooves you that you try to understand the view point and the panorama, instead of choosing what seems to please you. You are picking the OT and avoiding the NT to try to paint God as wicked. It's not so, there is no change in law. It's not that God now approves of what He earlier disapproved, no. He introduced grace, so that man can repent without being judged. If man doesn't repent, He will still be judged.Please take as long as you like. So the Bible progresses? If it does, then you're agreeing that your God has changed to become more progressive. In the past, he would command your own people to kill you now, he just leaves that to a realm that we don't have access to. Image123: You need to be aware of the times that you live in. A.M doesn't contradict P.M, they are both different times in the 24hr day. that the 24hr day is divided into day and night is not a contradiction if you understand what i mean. The NT doesn't condone homosexuality or murder, or adultery etc. But it allows for grace. Grace allows the sinner opportunity to REPENT. Its like a parent and child relationship. See this analogy for instance, It's popular(at least here in lagos) for a parent to spank a child for carelesness if for instance the child is about 4yrs old. if a 4yr old breaks a plate carelessly or even injured himself, the parent may be displeased and spank him. In 20years time, when the child is 24years old, and the same child breaks a plate carelessly or injured himself, the same parent will be displeased but is not likely to spank the child. that is what time can do, there is a progression. It's not that the parent are now contradicting themselves. If the 24yr old had a 4yr old sibling, that one may still be spanked by the parent, but the 24yr old is not spanked. In a similar vein, God treated the human race as 'children' in the OTHow about tattooing and wearing clothes of mixed fabric? Are those also under grace or have they been totally discarded? And slavery? Even the New Testament never rejected it, instead, it urged that slaves be subservient to their masters. Image123: In the process and progression of time and God's revelation to man, God sent us Jesus, and grace came with Jesus.Jesus also brought his eternal punishment. Image123: Now the sinner has the chance of mercy, turning a new leaf as it were. Now we do not condemn i.e final sentence people, but God will do that on the day reserved for that. Of course, we still recognise wrong and sin and discourage and preach against it. No one, or at least, i'm not arguing for homosexuals to be killed, but i can well speak against it, like i can speak against r.ape, murder, wickedness, theft, corruption and other sins. No one is forcing them not to get married. the thread title says it is against GOD'S will, and we will continue to tell them that anywhere and everywhere.So the criminal mass murderer sins today, asks and gets forgiveness. But the honest non-Christian who has helped people round the world gets eternal punishment. Now that is getting your priorities wrong if there's a Heaven. |
Huh? A crippled kidnapper? |
Chubhie: my brother, you said that your doctors make mistakes and should be forgiven even when such mistakes lead to death becouse they are humans and prone to suchNo I didn't say that. In fact, some mistakes aren't forgiven. That is why there's a justice system and medical ethics committee that looks into these sorts of cases. Chubhie: On the level of success, you said docs are 50% right??Thats 50% failure right?I didn't say that either. I said they're generally right more than 50% of the time. Chubhie: For you,pastors prayers fail often cos they dont have any special trainning and yet your docs that are professional in their fields have 50% failure rateI didn't say this too. I said their prayers fail and that they don't have any special training. I didn't say one caused the other. Please don't put words into my mouth. Chubhie: Even if the docs sucess rate is 99% why put 'medical' faith in something thats not hunderd percent when lives are at stake?If the success rate were 99% (which it is in some cases), where else would you place your trust? I hope you're aware that people die everyday whether or not some pastors pray but you can be sure that more people will die if those medical professionals were to close up shop. What system do you know that assures you of 100% success even when lives are at stake? Is it the pastors prayer that will fail? Or is it relying on God who has already designed the world to kill you? Or is it the medical professional who has made it his duty to save lives to the best of their abilities? You should also slow down and read what I've actually said so your responses would be more relevant. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 (of 210 pages)

