Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 (of 210 pages)
[quote author=nl.official]Anyone that doesn't see anything wrong with Gay should be in psychiatric hospital. It's a mental illness and should never be allowed in our society and seen as normalcy.[/quote]How do you determine what should be classified as being a mental illness? |
aribisala0: Maybe it is highly unlikely who knows. Certainly this trend toward mainstreaming is a European one as is the idea of gay marriage which is not the same thing as homosexuality because it goes a step further . Gay marriage is a notion and practice that is disruptive to our established values and way of life.So what if it is disruptive of your established values? If your established values are harmful, shouldn't they be changed? aribisala0: Why should I put in the effort to make those arguments ? Am I gay police? Is that the most important issue in Nigeria today?If you think that there are better arguments, then I think you should be able to put them forward for intellectual discussions to occur at an elevated level. aribisala0: Is it worse than child prostitution or Pentecostal churches or Boko Haram?Sure you're committed to a good fight but I see no reason why one must limit themselves to those sorts of fights. I simply wonder what the intellectual basis of your opposition to homosexuality is. |
[quote author=mukolo_Andy]Logically(how man sees it), NO. Biblically(ow GOD sees it), yes D msg has been sent; argue all u lyk... It doesn't change ow GOD sees it. -av a blessed day![/quote]I wonder, what changed how God saw slavery in the past and how he sees it today? If you're advocating for a double standard in logic, then you simply have no idea what you're talking about and it is a good idea for you to leave the discussion to people who are better qualified. |
Pque: Mehn. What d gays and gay activist are saying here is absolutely bulshit. This makes me to feel dat d world is nearer 2 her end.The world is always nearer to her end but more excuses will always be found. You bring up Noah. I hope you realize that God failed in his attempt with Noah. He just succeeded in killing a lot of people many of who were innocent. I hope you know that gay conversion therapy doesn't really work. Pque: Personally, I don't think dat act (gaying) is normal. I see it as a disease, sickness nd abnormal incontrolable interest in what is nt normal. Ur brain is now use 2 dat act nd ur brain frequently gives 2 u d picture of dat act in such a way dat it makes u feel like u can't do without it.It is a good thing that we don't ask you to help us decide on what is normal. If prayers are so effective, why don't you go and pray that God turns all the gay people into heterosexuals? I'm sure you have more than enough faith for them. I suspect it won't work because as they say: nothing fails like prayer. |
Image123: God didn't create anyone with sin, why do you refuse to learn? you've been told this before?Please check the post I was responding to and advice your fellow Christian. When you guys have gotten your story straight, then you can come at me. |
pelezico: The problem with that statement though i believe its in good faith is that it'snot wise. The h o m o s e x u a l s (i refuse to call them g a y s since that word is a politically correct sanitized description of a promiscuous and debauched lifestyle) are playing for keeps and therefore want to either silence the critic by the use of Governmental force or manipulate the people thru the media as is the case in the US, Canada and Europe. The media is used to either intimidate or harass the critic or make h o m o s e x u a l i t y activity rather cool by showing "cool" h o m o s e x u a l s using films and music.I see no problem using government force to prevent discrimination. Do you see a problem with that? What do you think debauchery is? I hope you're aware that heterosexuals too can be promiscuous. pelezico: Marriage either has a definition that is rooted in the immutable God of the bible (unchanging character of God and his Word) or its up for grabs and is a subjective thing therefore rendering the word VOID.Marriage is a human institution and the God of the Bible isn't immutable. pelezico: Marriage therefore is null and void.I guess the empire that God tried to build but failed in building that kept slaves and waged numerous wars against its neighbours according to the Bible is a good one. And guess what? Women aren't spared in God's empire in that, the Biblical God has been consistent. |
Image123: you can't be a Christian and same time be gay, take itWhat does it mean to be a Christian? What does it mean to be gay? Image123: The Christian colour is white, not gray. I'm sure you know there's a difference.Why not black? Or is black now somehow evil? There are several shades of grey. Some lighter than others. |
Jezyfreezman: Shey d interview qo chanqe 9ja situation?.....mtcheeeew...abeg make i hear wordWhy do you think presidents and other leaders grant interviews? |
femi4: All sins r inborn and homo is not an exceptionWhy would God create you with sin and be ready to punish you for eternity? |
@ devour129 What a nice argument you presented. I'm just wondering is it supposed to be an insult to call someone gay online? If you think it is, I'll just like to let you know that it is childish and often demonstrates an inability to form sensible arguments. |
aribisala0: Yes we do not agree with same sex marriage but let us deploy the right argument to make our case.It is highly unlikely that there were no homosexuals in Africa before the arrival of the Europeans. If you think there are sound arguments against it, why don't you put in the effort to make those arguments? I don't think animals at least become extinct because suddenly all members of that species became homosexual. |
Image123: there is nothing like a gay Christian. a Christian cannot be gay. it's either light or darkness, they don't go together.Your first sentence there is false. Is there something logically contradictory in someone being both gay and Christian? Ever heard of the colour grey? |
okeyxyz: Christianity is hard. It is not easy, It is not meant to appeal to our human sentiments and anybody who believes otherwise, like I'd said before, You don't need to be christian if what you are looking for is comfort in your own sentiments. Christianity is not secular, though it respects secularity but keeps it outside of doctrine(ie: for non-christians). The new-testament is replete with these emphasis.With that quote of Matthew 5:30, are you saying that the recommendation there was to be followed literally? |
The statements of this pastor while ignorant are the sorts of things one comes to expect from faithheads. lekanolas: The General Overseer of the Redeemed Christian Church of God, RCCG, Pastor Enoch Adejare Adeboye yesterday described same sex marriage legalised in some countries as anathema to God’s will and instruction.Of course the same God who didn't think slavery and child sacrifice were anathema. lekanolas: Adeboye, who spoke at the New Year thanksgiving organised by the Joint Christian Mission of the Obafemi Awolowo University, OAU, Ile-Ife, described same sex marriage as anti- God and ungodly.For some reason, the things that darkness produces are very abundant in Nigeria where his prayers haven't really been helping. lekanolas: “Darkness is capable of wrecking havoc in the country, and Nigerian leaders should try to shun acts of darkness in 2013 for the nation to enjoy peace.”The multiple levels of ignorance implied by this statement is staggering. Where does he think homosexual people come from? Why does he think that if homosexuals are free to get married, they will somehow magically make everyone else homosexual. And does he think that producing children is the only purpose of marriage? These statements make no sense but he goes to a university to say it. I only hope that critical thinkers in that university were able to counter those statements. |
Hey davidylan where did you go? Don't let your voice be represented by certifiable dullards. |
Uyi Iredia: Darwin substituted Nature for man's ability to select. That much is evident from his book.Go and actually read the book. Or at least read and exercise your little brain at trying to understand what he meant. Luckily, it has been summarized for dullards like you in the very first paragraph here. A little reading won't kill you. Uyi Iredia: You are a dunce. I reserve the right to refuse to answer a question. But of course you wouldn't know that would you since you stup1dly assert that I'm failing at being evasive.This is why you fail at being evasive while demonstrating your gross imbecility. If you know anything about having a serious conversation, you'll know that making dumb assertions and densely failing to back them up, simply shows your incompetence. When you've actually taken the time to read and understand elementary principles in biology (referenced above) written simple English, you can get back to me. Till then, good luck dimwit. |
Uyi Iredia: He did substitute it. How can he draw a comparison between nature and humans when one has cognition and the other lacks it ?And this is just you being unable to overcome a language barrier. Haven't you heard of people drawing a comparison between birds and planes? Does this mean they're substituting one for the other? Uyi Iredia: This is you being plain foolish. You asked a question and I refused to answer it. Instead of leaving it at that you result to insults.Why did you refuse to answer it? Are you just dumb or failing at being evasive? You claim you have the answer but refuse to present it for analysis. So I guess people should just swallow whatever rubbish you say because the great Uyi Iredia said it. You're still suffering from the same problems that I've pointed out several times in our previous exchanges and show no signs of improvement. I may as well just wait for davidylan since the English Language is too difficult for you. |
Uyi Iredia: Actually it does mean that especially when i consider what Darwin wrote in that famous opus of his. He actually substituted nature for man's power to select certain characteristics in organisms.He didn't substitute it, he was drawing a comparison. Or do you think that Darwin met Nature and asked Nature to select certain organisms? Seriously, a little reading shows this basic fact. Uyi Iredia: I can but I won't.And this is the usual rubbish post you make that means you're trying to be evasive but failing at it. |
Uyi Iredia: How you can note this and not see that the concept of natural selection equally fails on that account (ie of reification). Nature, as you rightly noted, lacks volition and can't be said to select any characteristic anywhere, anyhow.And I've told you before that "natural selection" is a phrase with a specific meaning. It doesn't mean that Nature selects. I've told you and others on this forum that a phrase can have a meaning different from the words that make it up. Uyi Iredia: Simply the fact that he has the intelligence required to do such.How about you. Can you tell us the purpose for human existence and nature? |
davidylan: My question is very clear. Your responses are an example of hindsight being 20/20. So we ALREADY KNOW that water freezes... but my question goes way beyond... why did nature come up with precise laws to allow the freezing of water?This line of thought commits the fallacy of reifcation. You're using the word "nature" to refer to nature as if it were a conscious agent with volition as humans are. davidylan: What was the point of water in the first place and why does it freeze?Why should water have a point in the human sense? davidylan: Those questions are asked based on the backdrop of the atheist position that claims the earth and human existence are mere purposeless accidents of nature.Do you wish to assign purpose to human existence and nature? If you want to do this, what makes you think you're qualified to do this? |
For me, this quote brings it into perspective. https://onlyhdwallpapers.com/wallpaper/pale_blue_dot_quote_added_kinda_meh_on_desktop_1680x1050_hd-wallpaper-859348.png |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]You are not getting me. I allow for the possibility of the values differing. But if someone is going to counter by proposing a multiverse, then he/she must show that it actually exists. A possiblity does not automatically translate to an actuality.[/quote]Wait someone else who agrees that the values may be different has to show that this multiverse exists but you don't? Now isn't that a double standard? This means you'll have to either produce your God or accept that the values cannot vary. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol, you'll really have to explain exactly what this "void" of yours is. because the only way we infer space is relative to matter. Our universe is basically pieces of matter hanging in a void so telling me that there is a void between clusters of matter doesn't score you any points. You haven't shown me how this void is different from very large space.[/quote]Our universe is permeated by fields of all sorts but this void isn't. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Happily[/quote]So how do you justify the non-physical aspect of your worldview? Where would God and Heaven be? [quote author=Mr_Anony]I am willing to grant multiple unvierses, all I am saying is that they cannot possibly be in the same spacetime as ours because these cosmological constants are what describe our spacetime as we know it. Any universe with differing constants cannot possibly exist in our space time. Now I am not saying that other universes can't exist, all I am saying is that for them to have different constants, they must exist in different space and this gives rise to the question "what exists between any two universes in the multiverse?[/quote]No one says they're in the same spacetime as ours. That's the whole point. There's nothing between the universes in that multiverse. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Good so now we pin down the multiverse theory you are proposing. So that we don't keep rambling over the place in many directions, would you agree to us focusing on this model as an alternative explanation than the Intelligent Design explanation for a fine-tuned universe?[/quote]Sure we can focus on that model. Although Intelligent Design doesn't have an explanation, it just declares by fiat that God did it. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol, and your opinion that intelligent design = creationism is now a fact? Abeg no use laugh wound me this afternoon.[/quote]It is a form of creationism whether you like it or not. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol, If there is no conscious observer, is there a universe? Isn't it funny is so finely balanced such that it gives rise to beings conscious of it?[/quote]Sorry but this is just more arrogance. You do realize that there was a time in the universe when there were no conscious observers in the universe. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I am still wondering how two things can be in separate locations and not be in spatial relationship. For clarity: Imagine space as a large infinitely vastly stretched fabric. any particle you put on this fabric will deform it according to how heavy it is. If you drop in a lighter particle, it will roll down the deformed fabric towards the larger particle. The rate of the objects accelaration is constant such that the closer the small object is from the larger object, the faster it will come rushing towards it. This constant rate of accelaration is what we may call gravity The only thing that can change this rate of accelaration is if the nature of the space fabric itself were to change such that a particle of the same mass inflicts more deformation than it normally would and hence make smaller particles accelarate faster towards it. I.e. for the gravitational constant to change, the nature of space itself must change.[/quote]The nature of this fabric would be for you to consider it as being no fabric connecting the points of universes. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Almost anything is a mathematical possibility. The question is; is it actually how it is?[/quote]Well we don't know how it actually is all we have so far determined is that the universe emerged from a singularity. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Remember me again....I am not the guy presenting the motion I am the guy contesting the motion. I agree to a mathematical possibility of these universes existing what I don't see is how they can exist in space and have different constants that will require the nature of space itself to be changed.[/quote]Wait are you saying that you would agree to a possible multiverse with all the universes within it having the same constants? [quote author=Mr_Anony]I don't think so. The fact that we have not observed any such universes takes away the credibility of a multiverse argument because while fine-tuning allows for the mathematical possibility of multiple universe configurations, the multiverse argument requires that these universes must actually exist for it to be true.[/quote]Your analogy doesn't work for the very reason that we've not observed such universes. [quote author=Mr_Anony]It is a mathematical possibility that there are 3x1064 possible combinations of the words used in the paragraph above but those words are arranged in such a way that they are intelligible to me therefore, I'll say it is fair to assume the statement was designed with me in mind. For the statement to be down to chance, there has to actually be 3x1064 alternate paragraphs with different combinations of the same words lying side by side. That's the difference between the fine tuning and the multiverse arguments. The burden is on the multiverse proposer to show at least 1080 universes (conservative estimate)[/quote]Actually, it is the person proposing the fine tuning that has to show that there is a multiverse in which these values can be different in order to conclude that this one was specially made for them. You need to realize that the idea of the multiverse wasn't arrived at because some Christians were thinking of making arguments for fine-tuning. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I got you the first time but then your argument is similar to saying that "20 bullets consecutively fired at you all missed you by literally half a millimeter but hey it isn't such a big deal because within a half millimeter there are an infinite number of points." It holds no water.[/quote]No my point is not similar to that at all. I've already told you why my point is nothing like what you're saying there. Let me see if I can make this clearer. How do you calculate the probability of someone getting hit by a bullet? How do you calculate the probability of other universes out there being fit for life? The answers to those two questions should show you the fundamental problem with your analogy. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]You are not paying attention. Remember me....I am the guys asking the multiverse proposer why he thinks that the speed of light will differ in another universe and why he thinks that the gravitational constant will become a different between any two objects in the same space.[/quote]No, you're the one not paying attention. If you're going to talk about fine tuning, then you have to allow for these values being able to differ. [quote author=Mr_Anony]My friend between every two particles in space there is a void. A larger void does nothing change the constants that govern the behaviour of the particles in space. You have told us nothing.[/quote]False. There are virtual particles, radiation and other fields then there's the issue of light traveling at a certain speed. So it isn't a larger void, it is a different one. [quote author=Mr_Anony]In my worldview, the physical is not all that exists. I hold that there is a non-physical aspect to reality. Your worldview doesn't allow for non-physical existence. So the burden is on you to show how the constants that define space and time itself are subject to variation within space and time.[/quote]Well in your worldview, you'll still have to justify the sort of non-physical aspect you're proposing so the burden is on you to show that this heaven and its God do make sense. In what sense am I to show you this? Are you willing to accept mathematical possibilities? [quote author=Mr_Anony]I think I have been clear on which concept of the multiverse I am criticizing and that is the one that claims a "void" between universes which allows for varying cosmological constants, My contention remains that the burden is upon this person to show how the same constants that define the relationship between the particles and the spaces between them will suddenly define different relationships for other particles within the same space.[/quote]The very notion of a multiverse means that you're allowing for these constants to be different from universe to universe. For you to begin this criticism, you have to grant that. If you're refusing to grant that, there is no discussion. [quote author=Mr_Anony]The space between any two of the smallest particles bearing the same charge and repelling each other is a void since there is no matter within that space. but yet these two particles are still subject to natural laws. Why should your universes be exempt since it is the exact same void except that this time it is bigger[/quote]That space isn't the void I had in mind because there are fields in this space. What I'm saying basically corresponds to what is being talked about here i.e the Level 2 classification of a multiverse. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]You are entitled to your opinion[/quote]But you aren't entitled to your own facts. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Actually you are once again misconstruing the argument. The point is that the universe rests on a knife edge. It turned out one way as opposed to a near infinite number of ways it could have possibly turned out. Even more shocking is that the universe is intelligible to us. Why should it be so?[/quote]Please when you say I'm misconstruing the argument at least try and understand what I've said and show that I've misconstrued the argument. How do you know it could have turned out another way? Why shouldn't it be intelligible to us? We evolved in the universe and understanding the universe aids our survival so why are you surprised? [quote author=Mr_Anony]It might well be fine-tuned for crocodile life or bananas or diamonds e.t.c. but these things are not conscious of the existence of the universe so it is a bit silly to infer a "why" for something that has absolutely no conception of a "why". That is why the argument is stated the way it is with conscious life as the object. The fact is that the universe rests on a very very narrow range of values that allows it to permit conscious life. . . .that is not a fact that you can just write off as nothing.[/quote]So you're once again implying that the purpose of the universe is not just the presence of life, but the presence of conscious life. This is the sort of hubris I've been talking about. And that is what makes for puddle thinking of a sophisticated kind. I'm sure you'll agree that the universe was here before intelligent life. [quote author=Mr_Anony]If this is true then it will be very far-fetched to say they will have different cosmological constants since our cosmological constants are descriptors of the behaviour of matter in space, I see no logical reason why other matter in the same space will be described differently.[/quote]Not in the same space, they're in different locations entirely. For clarity, what do you have in mind when you're talking about cosmological constants? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Ok my bad...you can modify that to "life permitting"[/quote]Modify away but you're yet to actually separate the two conceptually. [quote author=Mr_Anony]That is more or less what the multiverse argument is all about. The only difference is that it tries to pass of a mere mathematical possibility as real.[/quote]Are you accepting it as a possibility? [quote author=Mr_Anony]I am not really saying it shouldn't be considered, I am just saying it is a very poor explanation[/quote]If you're going to present the multiverse as being contradictory to the big bang, then you're admitting on some level to the possibility of other universes existing in some way for your argument to begin to be considered. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Exactly....That is why the multiverse argument fails to explain away fine tuning.[/quote]No that is why your analogy doesn't work. [quote author=Mr_Anony]The fact is that the universe could be configured in an infinite number of mathematically possible ways, yet it is exactly like this such that it permits life to exist which is conscious of it. The response that there might actually be an infinite number of universes is merely a forced argument with no evidence whose sole attempt is to force a chance explanation for conscious life.[/quote]So you're starting with the idea that the universe could have been configured in various ways. Starting with that idea, why are you surprised that you exist in one with values that permit life? The thing is that if it is actually an infinite number of mathematically possible ways, then life is actually due to chance. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Good..................now read your statement again and notice the very tiny range your tweaking has to stay in for life to exist. It can only range between 3.000000000000000000001 to 3.000000000000000000002 That is the level of precision and accuracy you must maintain. After this you must also tweak some 50 other tuning knobs to similar precision. And all of them must be in that precise relationship to each other for life to work. Do you get it now?[/quote]I wrote the statement and it doesn't look as if you've actually noticed the point I made. The point I made is that between 3.000000000000000000001 and 3.000000000000000000002 There is an infinite number of values between them that would still permit life. i.e 3.0000000000000000000011, 3.00000000000000000000101, 3.000000000000000000001001 that would basically be 3.000000000000000000001... Do you get it now? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]I don't think you quite realize what is meant by these cosmological constants. The gravitational constant for instance simply defines how matter deforms the fabric of space so that smaller objects are pulled towards it. It doesn't matter how far away the other object is as long as there is a larger object in the space it will pull the smaller object. The effect of the pull may vary by proximity but the strength of the pull will remain constant.[/quote]Actually, I think you're the one that doesn't realize what is meant by the constants e.g one of the factors making up the constant is the speed of light. Now are you saying you think it is possible for it to be different in a different universe? Actually, the strength of the pull varies with a square of the distance between the objects so for very distant objects, the force of attraction is very small. [quote author=Mr_Anony]As long as any two universes remain within the same space, the same constants would apply to them. The gravity that acts on the earth from the sun that acts from the andromeda galaxy to the earth. The only difference is that one is further away so we feel it's effect less. The gravitational constant remains the same. So for your multiverse model to have many universes tuned differently, they cannot occupy the same space because if they do then the same constants will apply.[/quote]There is an idea of the multiverse in which gravitational effects are present between universes but still how does this then mean that the speed of light or the other factors that make up this universe must be the same? Secondly, they're not in the same location and are separated by a void without particles and all that. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I hold that God by nature is spaceless and timeless so I don't have any problem with a supernatural reality. The person who has that problem is the one who proposes physical universes with varied constants. He has the burden of showing what is inbetween any two universes. If it is space, then the same constants apply and he can't have varied universes. If it is not space, then he can no longer write off the notion of God for being a spaceless entity.[/quote]Then does he actually exist? Because you're saying that he is in no place and is in no time so in what sense does he exist? And where would heaven then be? Only in your mind? Sure you say you don't have a problem with a supernatural reality but that doesn't mean that there isn't a fundamental problem with it. The person proposing that may have that burden and can always say that it is a sort of void, they don't know or that the question is malformed. It simply depends on the concept of the multiverse under consideration. Something you keep glossing over is that when we generally talk about space here in this universe, we realize that it isn't actually empty. [quote author=Mr_Anony]If by this you mean a space with no matter occupying it then your work is still cut out for you.[/quote]What work would that be? Given that this "space" doesn't have time or matter and all that. |
davidylan: I asked the question first... i much rather follow that to a logical end. We cant have a conversation dealing with two issues at the same time...The first question you asked, I answered and asked mine which you seem to be evading while asking another question based on faulty assumptions. Come on. I'm sure you can walk and chew gum at the same time besides, I think they're related. davidylan: If water didnt evolve then where did it come from and how?Water is formed by the chemical reaction between Hydrogen and Oxygen. Now, please tell me what the purpose of water is. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Actually they are different but that's by the way.[/quote]And I disagree with that claim. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I think you are missing the point. The point is that not only will life not exist, the universe would be so radically different from how it is. This is not merely about the amoeba but puddle and land around it as well as the entire planet that hosts this continent that hosts this peice of land that holds the puddle that holds the amoeba. All will be gone because of a very small fractional variation. I'd say that's a bit more than puddle thinking wouldn't you?[/quote]No, the amoeba thinks that because it finds itself in the puddle, then everything was designed for it to come about. That is the view that those who think that the fine-tuning argument actually works take because they say it was made for life and they sometimes go further to say that it was made for human life. [quote author=Mr_Anony]If they are in separate distinct spaces, then whatever is inbetween them cannot possibly be space. Are you conceding to a spaceless entity?[/quote]They're in distinct locations. There is nothing between them unlike within universes where you have matter and space-time. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I said it was life permitting[/quote]No, you said here that it was for life. This is you actual quote. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Characteristics which if they differed in accuracy by as much as 0.000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001 (120 decimal places), conscious life wouldn't exist. Yeah I'd say the universe was fine tuned to give rise to conscious life.[/quote][quote author=Mr_Anony]Oh yes we can. All you have to do is vary the number of any of these constants ever so slightly and mathematically you have an entirely different universe[/quote]By that reasoning, we would then have an infinite number of universes since these constants have numbers and we know that numbers are infinite. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Hey remember me. I am not the guy claiming that there is a multiverse, I am the guy saying that it is very implausible and highly unlikely.[/quote]I know that but the fact that the idea is multifarious and complex doesn't mean that one cannot consider it. Neither does it then mean that it is wrong. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol, let me give you an analogy. Assuming I had a gun and was aiming at a target and if I shifted my aim by as little as 1 millimeter I would miss the mark by as much as 1 meter, I believe it is a safe to put my probability of hitting my target to roughly 0.001% (one in a thousand) especially if - I like the natural laws of the universe - don't necessarily have any motivation to hit the target in the first place. Now assuming I took 20 shots and hit the same target all of the 20 times......It becomes even more improbable doesn't it? Now imagine there were 10 of us and we all hit the exact same target 20 times with bullseye accuracy.....even more improbable isn't it? I think at this point it will be irrational to say that we don't have any motivation for hitting it and that it just so happens that our bullets are repeatedly hitting this target.[/quote]Why don't you see what I'm saying? Your analogy simply doesn't work because so far, all we have information about is this one universe. We've not had the opportunity to observe 20 universes. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Think of it. you tweak gravity by as little as 1x10-20 your have a totally different universe, you tweak the cosmological constant by as little as 1x10-120 an entirely different non life permitting universe shows up, the same for the stong nuclear force, weak nuclear force, speed of light e.t.c. There is no reason why those numbers have to be that way and in such precise relation to each other. Mathematically the universe can take a myraid of other forms but it just so happens to be like this and permit life. The odds that the universe just happens to be so is not a good explanation at all.[/quote]Here's an example of what I was saying about the infinite possibilities you've brought up. Rather than tweaking gravity by 1e-20, how about tweaking it by 1e-200? i.e if to permit life, the number at the 21st position were to be say 3, you leave that and tweak the 22nd to 200th number after the decimal point or tweak the 22nd to 2000th number etc till infinity. What you have is an infinite number of universes with slight variations that support life as long as the 21st number is 3. This is one reason why I don't buy these spurious probability calculations. So was the universe created for life or not? |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Lol this does not help you at all. . . . . . . .devoid of matter means nothing because even if it were just empty space, the same cosmological constants will still apply. gravitational pull from matter in our universe will still reach across the space to have an effect on the matter in the other universe and vice versa so that essentially you really only have one massive universe larger than we once thought and all our known universe would be is one mega-galaxy with smaller galaxies, stars and planets all in the same space. You would have only succeeded in pushing the question back one step.[/quote]No the same cosmological constants won't necessarily apply because each universe is different. There are some ideas of the multiverse in which this gravitational effect is present but once again, if they were far enough apart, it would be negligible. [quote author=Mr_Anony]The only way you can have universes with completely different natural laws is if this void you are talking about is a spaceless entity for which I'll ask you to explain exactly what the nature of this void is.[/quote]What is the nature of where God is? I think your basic conception of the variability of the natural laws is flawed. The laws themselves and the constants that are used to formulate them are supposed to be considered to be variable in your conception so why are you now claiming that they must be fixed in some other universe? Finally, the nature of a void is simply that. It is a void devoid of matter. |
lagerwhenindoubt: it doesHmm I don't know. Maybe its purpose was to sink the Titanic because God didn't want people building big ships in 1912. |
davidylan: If there was no purpose then why did it evolve?Who says water evolved? And please try to answer my question too so we can have a conversation. So, what do you think is the purpose for water freezing. |
[quote author=Mr_Anony]First of all, Intelligent Design and creationism are two different things plus I'll be really interested in this "test" you are talking about. Care to tell me about it?[/quote]No they're not really different things. They're generally the same idea simply made to look different. "Irreducible complexity" of the eye has been shown not to be so. [quote author=Mr_Anony]Characteristics which if they differed in accuracy by as much as 0.000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001 (120 decimal places), conscious life wouldn't exist. Yeah I'd say the universe was fine tuned to give rise to conscious life.[/quote]You cannot make that conclusion unless you've actually examined enough of the universe to know this. How do you know that the universe wasn't fine tuned to give rise to say diamonds? Given the fact that there are some characteristics that if they differed by the small figure you've given above, it would have made no difference how do you know it was made for life? [quote author=Mr_Anony]Good Good too Really how so?[/quote]It is puddle thinking because the fact that we find ourselves in a universe and think that it suits us so well doesn't mean it was made for us. Just as it is justifiable for an amoeba that finds itself in a puddle think that the puddle was made for it. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I can't understand how you can talk of "far apart" outside the universes if space only exists within the universes[/quote]I'm using it as a relative term i.e they're not occupying the same space that this one is occupies. [quote author=Mr_Anony]I think you have misconstrued the argument ever so slightly. It is a fact that the universe permits life. It is also a fact that if the initial conditions that govern the universe were even slightly different to the tune of 0.000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001 (a very conservative estimate by the way) life simply wouldn't exist and not only that, we would also have an entirely different kind of universe.[/quote]I haven't misconstrued it. You claimed that it was made for life. [quote author=Mr_Anony]In order to legitimately write this off as chance, one must propose a world of an infinite number of universes (multiverse) all tuned differently so that ours just happens to be the one that permits life. The problem with it is that not only is the theory untested, and has a few problems, It is also a very unreasonable way to argue and seems that its sole purpose is not to follow the evidence but to grasp for any reason no matter how far fetched that helps it deny the evidence and wriggle out of it's implications. As Alvin Platinga puts it and I paraphrase Assuming you Cyrexx and I were playing poker and I consistently got 4 Aces consecutively over 20 rounds of dealing, would you accept it if I gave the explanation that the same poker game is currently taking place in an infinite number of alternate realities and this just happens to be the one where Anony gets 4 aces 20 consecutive times? or would you infer that I was cheating i.e either I designed it to be that way or someone else designed it to be that way for me? By the way, the odds of me getting 4 Aces 20 consecutive times is roughly 1 in 1011. The odds of the universe being how it is so that it permits conscious life is more than 1 in 10120 You be the judge.[/quote]No, one doesn't need to propose such a world because because you simply cannot calculate these probabilities that you're claiming. You don't even know that there is a multiverse in the first place. You are assuming that the values that we've calculated must be mutable because we've assigned numbers and units to them but guess what, it may not be so. We simply don't have enough information to make such conclusions so the probability claims simply go out the window. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 (of 210 pages)

had this nasty wipe-out learning how to ride a bicycle as a kid.. fell between the bars.. frozen water provided a whole lot of relief