patches689: 1. Why waste your most maneuverable assets for area denial & security - thats what MBT's are for
2. Your fleets of all of the above seem to have suffered serious attrition
Base security can 100% be conducted by effective use of indirect-fire as well as direct-fire crewed weapons. Provided, of course, your fortifications have been properly conducted.
Mortars + HMG's + ATGM's = a secure base Mortars + HMG's + ATGM's + CAS = Fort Knox
I always preach mortar, mortar and more mortar.
A remote base should have a dozen mortars. Shell them while they advance, it breaks their formation, slows them down and if you hit them so hard they might even think of aborting the assault.
However, if they advance then as you say HMGs, ATGMs and MGLs should welcome them. This forms a perfect defensive solution. They'll be pinned down, while you slaughter them with mortar shells at close range.
It's one of the reasons why Seleka couldn't take the SANDF Bangui base.
To add... The African market is not crazy about drones. Their Treasuries want something they can paint their military colours on, something they can pose PR photos for, something they can say "look we bought an airplane for the country, you'll see it flying around" to justify spending their tight budget on.
I agree, the market is saturated but they did their market research and have a better chance of selling the SARA than with a MALE UAV.
frumentius: I have absolute confidence in the technical skills to produce SARA. My question is this: why should we bother in a saturated segment of the market? Shouldn't Denel have used those funds to complete other more promising projects, like the Bateleur MALE UAV? Mark my words, all those young engineers working on SARA will all be poached by the big players once the thing is finished. As has happened before.
Engineers will always be poached, that's how it is but they'll leave behind a legacy for Denel.. As much as the Bateleur MALE is great, the Chinese already offer plenty of cheaper options. If Denel wants to play in the big league, they must build big - literally.
frumentius: And yet the Yanks continue to support our Hercs. Hell, they even fund our pilots going over there to maintain their currency when we don't have enough C-130s flying for whatever reason at any given time.
You and that abortion of a vanity project, the SARA.
On paper there's no problem between us and them... But history has shown unreliable they can be, them and the Brits.
As for SARA, it's going full steam. Expect a prototype in 3 - 4 years... Once we fly off this one, we will have confidence to build something bigger with 4 engines then we stop begging.
frumentius: Reminds me of when the Yanks were seriously enticing us to buy it at the Cape Town AAD !
They don't know the politics? South Africa doesn't buy from the Yanks.. You don't see eye-to-eye with those guys, the spare parts stop coming.
If the Brazilians were using turboprops, we'd probably buy from them.... But anyways we're just decades away from our homemade medium lift if it goes well with baby SARA.
andrewza: Migeria did notbi g to end apartheid. The only Nigerians that died fighting aparthief forces died in nigeria as the result of SA forces support of Bifar. Yes south africa sent solders to nigeria.
The number of gripen pilots changes every year as pilots get qulified. It takes years to become a gripen pilot by the way.
fabselad: nigerians always trying to pull the blanket on their side.being first on this or that.you guys sang about the JF-17 for years and years but yet we have not even seen a wing of the aircraft.
The manufacturer can only produce 10 a year, I read. Pakistan ordered a large number of them.. The factorline is kinda busy.
frumentius: When's the last time you read of a dog-fight? But should you get into one, A-Darter's got you covered. Plus, after completing your mission with either Umbani or dumb bombs, should you encounter targets of opportunity like enemy choppers, either cannon or A-Darter will do nicely. Though you'd better have a good excuse for using a missile on a chopper instead of the Aden.
Unless you encounter an AH with AAs but that's less likely to happen in Africa unless you went looking for trouble in the Sahara
All this effort just to kill a helicopter? Disappointed
Think about it, the A-Darter is such a great AA missile, it wouldn't matter where it's launched. It doesn't need a radar so Hawks can sneak in behind a target especially those old MiGs and Sukhoi Su's with older mechanical radars then bang.
Patented: well said dude. i rarely contribute but i get irritated by some of these arguments. most of them soun like arguments i had back in early school, like who will win if robocop fights terminator or who can dance better MC hammer or MJ or my fathers car is better than your fathers own at an age when i did not know a fuse from a relay?
this ish is just sickening and nobody seems capable of rising above it even when they should know to.
We (South Africans) provide proof. Your folks claimed we have an "x" number of Gripen pilots, we showed them a pic of a number greater than the "x" then they moved the pole.... It's a clear effort to spark an unnecessary debate.
We don't make statements like "giants of blah blah" or the "biggest in yadah yadah". If people need to be called in order, it's a handful of your countrymen.