Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,155,204 members, 7,825,771 topics. Date: Sunday, 12 May 2024 at 10:54 PM

Crayfish09's Posts

Nairaland Forum / Crayfish09's Profile / Crayfish09's Posts

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (of 28 pages)

Foreign Affairs / Re: Breaking News: Rockets Fired At Israel From Lebanon by Crayfish09: 9:31pm On Jul 20, 2021
Krismas:
coolSorry, I did not understand ur post earlier. I have liked it. My quarrel is with d person u quoted. Tanks


No P bro. Good job educating these kids that only see things through the lens of religion. It has gotten to the point where some people believe Israel is more powerful than Russiacheesy

2 Likes 1 Share

Politics / Re: Sunday Igboho Has Been Arrested In Cotonou by Crayfish09: 11:39am On Jul 20, 2021
Jerryherd:


Common sense should tell you lossing a son , wife, and mother isn't equating wining Presidency

People lose those all of the time. It can happen to anyone whether someone is good or bad but I don't see how can become a president and still be described as having bad luck
Foreign Affairs / Re: Breaking News: Rockets Fired At Israel From Lebanon by Crayfish09: 11:29am On Jul 20, 2021
vibre:
The likes of Amazontopaz, budaatum, krismas and co. Won't say anything about this o, the moment Israel starts bombing the shit out of these terrorists, you will see them running their dirty mouths all over the thread.


Syria also shot down Israeli rockets yesterday. Who gave them the right to do so? If you don't want trouble, stay away from it. As weak as Lebanon is, it's not Gaza. Hezbollah sank that into Israel's head in 2006 cheesy

1 Like

Politics / Re: Nigerian Arrested With Cocaine As India’s Narcotic Bureau Bust Syndicate by Crayfish09: 7:48am On Jul 20, 2021
Kill them all. They curse Nigeria everyday and then go abroad to display their nature. Soon, the idiots will start saying that India is jealous of their "achievements". They have attracted nothing but hatred for Nigerians in Europe, Canada, America, Asia, and even Africa. Bastards

1 Like

Politics / Re: Sunday Igboho Has Been Arrested In Cotonou by Crayfish09: 7:34am On Jul 20, 2021
Jerryherd:


In the end history would repeat it self and Buhari's people would regret his actions

In the 80s he was cruel and ruthless

Guess how it ended?!

Buhari was jailed 3 and half years

Lost his mother to sickness and couldn't attend the burial

Got divorced by his first wife sefinatu

Went from being a rich General to a penniless herdsmen

Lost his first son

Lost his first daughter


After all these, he then rose to become YOUR presidentcheesy.

Cry us a rivertongue

2 Likes

Politics / Re: Sunday Igboho Has Been Arrested In Cotonou by Crayfish09: 7:30am On Jul 20, 2021
lkillbrokehoes:
Mehn this is really true oh, I can see the infamous zone b up there celebrating already, I swear to God, anybody that is still supporting this wicked, incompetent and vile government will suffer and lastly be killed by bandits.

E pain am tongue

1 Like 1 Share

Politics / Re: Terrorists Not Bandits by Crayfish09: 10:01pm On Jul 19, 2021
ENIGMATIC2023:
People who have the will and the means to shoot down an Alpha Jet aren't "bandits"; they're terrorists. The Nigerian news media should stop minimizing the dangers these monsters pose to the country by calling them "bandits." This isn't mere criminality; it's well-practiced terrorism!


Igbo terrorists not unknown gunmen
Islam for Muslims / Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Crayfish09: 7:58pm On Jul 19, 2021
AntiChristian:


No hadith contradicts the Qur'an except what your brain can't resolve as I said before.

I asked How many of the authentic ones have you worked on? I think you should answer what the Qur'an meant by saying "obey Allah and His messenger" several times?

Let's analyze this explanation of yours now.


This is falsehood and illogical. A good historian of the Islamic narrations will know that the two verses didn't forbid alcohol till the last verse was revealed.

If you quote each of the first two only to an ignorant Muslim, he will of course be encouraged to drink it after Salah!
It was when the third verse was revealed that the Muslim poured all the alcohol away!



I'm amazed that these doubts exist in a mind! Things that are clear among the knowledgeable ones!
You really need to learn and unlearn! Even the Qur'an you profess to understand you don't understand any of it.
May Allah grant us knowledge!


I have an unlimited number of examples. Here's another one:

(2:222) They question thee (O Muhammad) concerning menstruation. Say: It is a vulnerable condition, so let women alone at such times and go not unto them till they are cleansed. And when they have purified themselves, then go unto them as Allah hath enjoined upon you.


And here's what "Sahih" Bukhari says

Bukhari (Ref: 1.299) Narrated Abdur Rahman bin Al-Aswad:

Aisha said: “Whenever Allah’s Messenger wanted to handle anyone during her periods (menses), he used to order her to put on an izar and start handling her.” Aisha added “None of you could control his sexual desires as the Prophet.”

Unless you have another meaning for "let alone", there is a clear contradiction here regardless of the use of Izar.


I have worked on countless hadiths but to save my time, I will give you a website where others like myself made a research on this issue.


On those verses, it's clear that they were not CONDONED but in the Hadiths, one clearly said Janabah is unnecessary while the other one said it is. Here's another example:

Rasool (S) said, “Renew Wudhu after eating anything cooked on fire.” (Muslim vol 1 pg 486)

BUT

Ibn Abbas says, “Rasoolullah ate a roasted goat shoulder and then prayed without ablution.” (Same vol 1 pg 488)



And what do you have to say about these Hadiths (some of which are categorized under Sahih)

If someone passes in front of a praying person, stop him. If he doesn’t stop, kill him because he is Shayitaan. (Bukhari vol 1 pg 68)


Rasoolullah said, “The prayer is broken if a woman, a donkey or a dog come in front.” (Muslim vol 2 pg 111) VS Abdullah Ibn Abbas said, “I rode a she-ass to MINA. Rasoolullah (S) was leading the prayer. I passed before some praying ones and got off from the animal and joined the prayers. None objected. (Bukhari vol 1 pg 107)

Rasoolullah never used to raise hands in prayers except when praying for rains. (Bukhari vol 1 page 125)

Rasoolullah used to offer prayers with shoes on. (Bukhari vol 1 pg 55)


Sahaba used to pray even when bleeding from an arrow. (Bukhari vol 1 pg 32, Ibn Majah, Muslim, Nisaai & many other sources) VS -Oozing of blood from anywhere in the body nullifies Wudhu and Salaat. (Same sources and Fuqaha)

Hazrat Anas states that Rasool (S) used to pray the briefest complete Namaaz. (Muslim vol 2 pg 86)
- The Rasool (S) used to scold people who led long prayers. (Two Ahadith, Muslim vol 2 ppg 84, 85)
- BUT, Hazrat Anas states that Rasool (S) stood still so long after bowing (rukoo’) that the watcher thought he forgot to proceed. The same used to happen after Sajdah (prostration). (Muslim vol 2 pg 87)
- Abu Saeed Khadri narrates: Rasoolullah’s prayer used to be so long that supposing the noon prayer has begun. A man walks to the graveyard of Baqee’, comes back home, makes ablution and goes to the Masjid. And he finds him still leading the first raka’at (unit). (Muslim vol 2 pg 48)


You should seek Allah's forgiveness for daring to compare the Qur'an with this book. "Sahih" Hadiths is good but it is extremely fallible. The fact that less than 5% of the total Hadiths during the time of Bukhari and other compilers were accepted alone is a big red flag. It means that even then, so many people tried to manipulate Islam and there's no way you can tell me that authentic Hadiths were not rejected and fake Hadiths were not accepted. Simple maths alone would tell you that.

5 Likes

Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 7:30pm On Jul 19, 2021
GodHatesBigots:


Sighs, Israel has defeated your Arab brothers in many wars, they will level Nigeria to ground level .

How many wars did Israel fight with Arab countries? Kai, Nairalandcheesy
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 3:51pm On Jul 19, 2021
Kandeed:


I was shocked to know and see Nigeria to possess series of surface to air missile system in different part of MMIA when I once visited a wing commander of the Nigerian Airforce in Lagos

Don't mind those illiterates please. It's because of Israel's exploits in Gaza (which has no military) that is making them run their mouths. There's no way a country like Nigeria wouldn't have AA weapons even if they are not enough to protect the entire country.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Crayfish09: 3:26pm On Jul 19, 2021
AntiChristian:


I think I categorically mentioned "Sahih hadith" and not just Hadith/Ahadith! You need to read more in between the lines. Sahih means authentic. Whatever is thrown away is not Sahih.

How many of the authentic ones have you worked on? I think you should answer what the Qur'an meant by saying "obey Allah and His messenger" several times?




I have told you to move closer to Scholars who can explain the ahadith to you in details.

I will give you a similitude in the Qur'an with three verses about intoxicants (Wine, etc.) , the first two permits it while the last one forbids it. Is there any contradiction in them?

They ask you about wine (khamr) and gambling. Say, "In them is great sin and [yet, some] benefit for people. But their sin is greater than their benefit."
Qur'an 2:219

"O you who acknowledge, Do not go near prayer, (Salat) while you are stupified (under influence), until you know what you are saying"
Qur'an 4:43

O you who have believed, indeed, intoxicants (khamr), gambling, [sacrificing on] stone altars [to other than God], and divining arrows are but defilement from the work of Satan, so avoid it that you may be successful.
Qur'an 5:90

Sometimes, a verse is explained by another verse while at other times a verse may abrogate another verse! This happens many times in the Qur'an and hadith. You need to search for the knowledge.

When I say Hadith, I'm referring to Sahih hadiths and yes, to even compare "Sahih" Hadiths with the Qur'an is an abomination because we are still talking about words ATRIBUTED to those who claimed to have heard the Sahaba saying something about what the prophet said.


I also clearly said that I do not reject the Hadiths but those that contradict/undermine the Qur'an.

Let's analyze this explanation of yours now.

In the first 2 verses, Allah says that the cost outweighs the benefit and that we should refrain from doing it before Salat. We can say the same about other sins of the world. For example, stealing has the benefit of worldly gains but it's bad. HOWEVER, THE VERSE DOES NOT IN ANY WAY TELL US TO DRINK unlike in the case of the Hadiths where one says IT'S FINE to do something and another says it's not.


I have many other ridiculous ones too. I know those that claimed pandemics can never enter Makkah and Madina but thanks to Corona, they have been proven to be false. There are also those that said the sun prostrate before Allah even though the Qur'an said a different thing. I know those that depicted Moses (AS) as the superior of prophet Muhammad and even suggested that he knows better than Allah (when the so-called 50 daily prayers were reduced to 5)

These so-called Sahih Hadiths are no Sahihs. I wasn't so sure as at when I created this thread but now, I'm fully convinced.

3 Likes

Politics / Re: Israeli Jewish Woman Makes Case For Another Jewish State In Africa by Crayfish09: 12:27pm On Jul 19, 2021
Let that happen. Even Hitler will condemn what we'll do to them.
Politics / Re: Israeli Jewish Woman Makes Case For Another Jewish State In Africa by Crayfish09: 12:27pm On Jul 19, 2021
Even Hitler will condemn what we'll do to them since the 1967-1970 memory has eluded them.
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 11:17pm On Jul 18, 2021
Mangekyo:



Trash! I can't recall how many times the army bodly came out and said that shekau had been wasted. On the long run, he always came out to debunk it. Boko haram was defeated before 2016 but the zoo military kept sending soldier to the north to fight who exactly? Almost on a daily basis did we wake up to see news like "Boko haram fighters kill nine soldiers after they attacked base with several guntrucks".
Note: that boko haram never attacks with Real tanks. The best they can attack with are with gun trucks, yet our military always pee their pants at the very sight of them.

Countries like Isreal, their ground troops won't attack you with mere gun trucks or just armored vehicles, but rather tanks. You struggled as hell when you went toe to toe with less trained militants with guntrucks, what makes you think you'd even stand a chance against more skilled and well equipped soldiers with tanks in Israeli military personnels?

the difference is, we don't hear Sudden news like "Isis fighters kills 10 us soldiers in a surprise attack". Theyve been defeated and have returned to their caves. FACT!

Lol I never mentioned hamas into the argument. Those guys are as weak as Nigeria if not even stronger than Nigeria.
I'm talking about Israel's battle against the Arabs nations who joined together to attack Israel but failed,threy suffered a humiliating defeat. I'm not even sure if they've gotten over with it grin

Nigeria doesn't stand a chance at all. You should try convincing me or try enlighting me more on how that brain of yours think we do stand a chance


*yawns*
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 11:15pm On Jul 18, 2021
Last last, Israel will have to beg for their sons' release and Kanu will continue languishing in jail. Good night
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 11:13pm On Jul 18, 2021
Mangekyo:


What a clown. Okay so because USA couldn't do shit against Vietnam now mean a zoo like Nigeria can go and repeat history?

Abdul, it's ridiculous how that Abōki brain of your actually thinks a zoo like Nigeria would stand or last more than a few seconds against a country that single handedly defeated a united Arab abokey nations. Defeating and crippling their military. Look, Isreal lost no more than 800 soldiers, while their opponents lost nothing less than 10k men minimum.

Nigeria doesn't even compare to Egypt. Egypt teamed up with other nations and were defeated as if they were Nigeria. Ridiculous how your brain thinks Nigeria is actually doing shit.

Oh lol, I don't think they'd be any need of deploying a nuclear weapon to get the job done, son.

It would be as easy as ABC. Isreal attacks with their navy team. They Launch countless missiles with their submarines into Lagos. Takes over Lagos and the airport, and then deploys in tanks into the zoo through the airport. All happening under 2hours or even less lol


It's meant to educate you because I can see that you are brainless. You think war is all about having paper advantages when world history is there for any dumbo to consult. Is the difference between USA and Vietnam not greater than the difference between Nigeria and Israel?

If not an Inyamuri idiot and his usual madness, who has ever heard about a nation winning a war in 5 hours? That's the most stupid thing I've ever heard but I'm not surprised, it's coming from the same fools that were waiting for Donald Trump to divide Nigeria for themcheesy

I won't say anything about the Israeli wars again since you have chosen to be daft as usual. Whenever Israel faces any nation without American financial assistance or ammunition then we can talk.

That you are comparing a country which was still in he clutches of western powers with the Nigeria of 2021 is yet another indication that you are not just a fool but one that is out of his mind. Well, let me tell you some fun facts. As at 1967;

Britain was far stronger than China
Iraq was better than Iran
France was militarily stronger than Indiagrin

I hope you are not in any way ever going to be considered for leadership position in biafran army because this is the most bizarre analysis I've ever seen. You don't even know where the capital of Nigeria is located.

But since it's a video game, here's my own: Nigeria sends 18 DSS spies to Pakistan who will hack their systems and launch a nuclear warhead to Israel. EODcheesy

I'm done dealing with this clown

2 Likes 1 Share

Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 10:55pm On Jul 18, 2021
Mangekyo:


You are talking trash! Any competent military would've defeated boko haram under a few years. It's been 10years now and these terrorists still get the better of us.
Wasn't it the ISWAP that entered Sambisa forest the other day and killed shakau, dismantling all his men and left as if nothing even happened? Your shitty army knew all along that the terrorist resided in those forest but couldn't man up and go get the job done lmfao it's very shameful.

Isreal won't need the help of USA to decimate a zoo like Nigeria, trust me. Maybe you should tell me how Nigeria is actually standing a chance because I barely think it's even going to be a battle. Israel pummels, bullies and dominates from start to finish!


Anybody that looks at the activities of boko haram between 2012 and 2016 will agree that they have been defeated. During those days, nobody in the north was living at peace. They were taking over entire LGs and bombing areas on a DAILY bases all over Northern Nigeria. The kind of defeat you are looking for (total eradication) has never been easy for any "competent " military in the world. Your US went to Afghanistan with the aim of wiping them out and ended up going against their doctrine of not negotiating with terrorists. The combination of Us, Russia, Syria, Kurdish Fighters, Iraq, etc are still facing ISIS till date even though ISis has been defeated. You guys don't pay attention to reality.

ISWAP as a group member will naturally have more information on Shekau's wearabouts than soldiers. How many years did it take USA to find Bin Laden? Lol. I love using USA to open your eyes since you think Nigeria is the worst thing in the world.


How many wars has Israel fought for you to be saying this trash about how she fights? Bombing a territory that has no army, no autonomy, and no allies (and killing far more civilians than Hamas fighters) is no sign of strength. But hopefully, a day will come when Israel will face Iran without the west to save their asses.

1 Like

Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 10:30pm On Jul 18, 2021
Mangekyo:


You're a clown if you think Nigerian Military would last more than 5hours against the Israeli military.
Maybe you haven't heard of how they defeated your abokey brothers from the Arab nations who all joined their forces together but still couldn't do shit.
Isreal have long range missiles that can they can shoot thousands of kilometers away.

Like I said, Israeli can dismantle and decimate Nigeria within the twinkling of an eye. A few nuclear weapons should do the trick


Who is this fool? I just finished addressing this noise about the 6-day war. Theres nothing soecial about a country backed by a superpower defeating a disunited group of countries that had recently gained independence. They should have repeated that feat against Hezbollah in 2006cheesy

And where in the world have you ever heard about a country beating another in 5 hours? You remind me of how USA was so confident about easily beating Vietnam or about Nigeria vs Biafra. If Israel uses Nuclear weapons on Nigeria, it will only lead to global proliferation of such weapons and I promise you, Israel wouldn't last another decade before one of its enemies drop one on them and annihilate them so they wouldn't try it.
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 10:22pm On Jul 18, 2021
observanc1:
be there and be deceiving yourself. Did u read or watched how isreal went all over the world and killed all those that killed isreali athletes in "Black September"? Do u see how they have been killing iranian scientists involved in iran nuclear project?
Hezbollah in lebanon. The same Lebanese economy that has completely crumbled?
Do u know that if u engage isreal in war that u have technically engaged US in same.
U cant fight boko haram, northern bandit and fulani terrorists, u want to fight isreal. Goodluck to u.


What's so special in carrying out assassinations? In fact, that the world is even hearing about it means they are not good enough. Rescue missions are entirely different from assassinations and abductions (which even female agents can carry out). Nigeria could have easily assassinated Namdi Kanu in Kenya so there's nothing super about it.

Secondly, do bandits and boko haram fight directly? You guys should learn a few things about warfare rather than coming here with your Hollywood fantasies. USA battling Nigeria for the sake of Israel will only add to its ruined international reputation and set the citizens against them. Also, since you know that Israel needs the backing of NATO why do you love hyping it?
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 8:58pm On Jul 18, 2021
GodHatesBigots:


Hatred for ?

You think they will allow their citizens to be tortured or detained indefinitely ?


You hate your own country. That's a fact.


They won't allow their citizens to be tortured, but the best thing they can do is to seek diplomatic approach which may or may not work. If US citizens could be held and tortured by third world Asian countries, who is Israel? Lol. The irony is that they have been capturing and even killing citizens of other nationals illegally and you are here ranting.
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 8:50pm On Jul 18, 2021
GodHatesBigots:


The Ugandan army was already splintered , so there was no cohesive force available to repel the Tanzanians. Besides who told you Israel will use ground troops for an invasion ? It will be a pin point strike with overwhelming force and then a rescue.

Right now, they are listening to all the DSS communications - LMAO


Yet somehow, you think they can be equated with Nigerian troops? Invasion is not possible without ground troops unless you just want to bomb a place and go back home.

Like I said again, Nigeria is weak but you guys are extremely underrating it. Unless they are going to use ICBMs, they need to bring their planes here which a few can be struck down and the moment these things start happening, the prisoners will likely be even more guarded.


Can you show me some of the audio of DSS' communications please? You guys live in fantasy
Islam for Muslims / Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Crayfish09: 8:48pm On Jul 18, 2021
falopey:


Hadiths were written by Muhammed’s close companions, those that walked, ate and spoke with him. You that was born yesterday want to disapprove the first hand account of the followers of the prophet

No, they weren't. They were written by those who heard some people that heard from a scholar who heard from a scholar that claimed that the companions of the prophet said that the prophet said something.


That's how Hadiths are. I can also use the same logic to tell you that all of those 500,000 hadiths that were rejected by Imam Bukhari were also denying the claims of the companions of our prophet.

Even in court, Hadith will be rejected because they are not direct sayings of the sahaba. Mind you, there are still some that are authentic but any Hadiths that goes against what the Quran has clearly specified (freedom of religion, 100 lashes for both adultery and furnucation, etc) and those that contradict one another will always be discarded by those who are objective

11 Likes 2 Shares

Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 8:42pm On Jul 18, 2021
Kandeed:


Infact o wanted to quote GodHatesBigots but just decide to shun it. these guys really don't know the country they in. shey na because of bandit n Boko Haram they relegate Nigeria to one chick without wings?? I was recently shocked to read/know Nigerian Army was once acknowledged as the best land Army is what these nigga are looking down on as scout. I just laugh sha


There's a certain amount of hatred that makes one to lose his sense of reasoning. That they are expecting Israel to bomb Nigeria because of their citizens alone is enough stupidity
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 7:09pm On Jul 18, 2021
GodHatesBigots:


LMAO.

Israel has taken on all the Arab countries and single handedly defeated them. Who is Nigeria ?

Arab countries who had recently gathered independence (and were even at loggerheads with one another) against a country backed by a superpower.

Let's talk about Hezbollah vs Israel in 2006.
Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 7:07pm On Jul 18, 2021
GodHatesBigots:


Uganda was 4,879km from Israel , but Israeli commandos still flew all the way to Entebe to rescue their citizens. It's not going to be a war but a rescure mission if it comes to that.

You mean the same Uganda that was flawlessly beaten by Tanzania?

I understand that Israel is better than Nigeria, but you guys are taking this madness out of proportion. Any Israeli troop that lands here will be beaten. The best they can do is to employ airstrikes (which won't save their citizens). Their ground troops have been repeatedly humiliated by ragtag Hezbollah

1 Like

Politics / Re: Anger Of Israelis Increasing As Buhari Refuses To Let Their People Go by Crayfish09: 7:03pm On Jul 18, 2021
So many fools on this forum.
Politics / Re: Ganduje, A Governor In Kano Or A Taliban Mullah? By Saminu Aliyu by Crayfish09: 6:54pm On Jul 18, 2021
FoolishBoy419:
Kano is one of the few northern states that stand a chance to be our pride but unfortunately, religion is tarnishing it. Islam and Christianity must be kept where they belong if this country is going to ever smell development because we take them too seriously.

I was following BBC Hausa the other time when a report about the murder of a Pakistani man who had been ACQUITTED from the charges of blasphemy. To my shock, 70% of the comments praised the killer even though he was found not guilty. And then you wonder why the north has so many terrorists.

As a muslim, I'm supposed to be offended by this but I have to agree with you. I saw the report you are talking about and it was unfortunate to say the least. Even Arabs are not as fanatical as northerners and it's disgusting. Funny enough, we mostly pretend to care about the religion without following commandments like contentment, honesty, seeking of knowledge, etc.


Any educated person that goes through the Hadiths will find serious fault there and while some genuinely came from the prophet, a great chunk of them are mere fabrications
Politics / Re: Ganduje, A Governor In Kano Or A Taliban Mullah? By Saminu Aliyu by Crayfish09: 6:45pm On Jul 18, 2021
Clearly, Kano is going downhill. Challenging fake hadiths that have done nothing but to make our religion look like a gang of bloodsuckers and cavemen has now become a crime punishable by the statecheesy.

I'm sure they will try to sentence him to death based on the same fake hadiths even though the Qur'an has provided the only situations that can warrant killing (blasphemy and apostasy are NOT part of them).


Checkout this post of mine on the issue

https://www.nairaland.com/6629016/should-sahih-hadiths-really-100
Islam for Muslims / Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Crayfish09: 6:39pm On Jul 18, 2021
AntiChristian:
Sahih Ahadith are as reliable as the Qur'an cos they were all transmitted by the Companions of the Prophet salallahu alayhi wa salam.

You will have to meet those scholars that understands to explain your doubts to you.

Once you have it in your mind that the Ahadith are doubtful then know that you'll soon disbelieve in the Qur'an too as Allah refers to the Ahadith by saying in many places "Obey Allah and His messenger" i.e. we obey Allah by following the Qur'an and we obey the Messenger by following his examples.

Allah says:
Indeed in the Messenger of Allah (Muhammad SAW) you have a good example to follow for him who hopes in (the Meeting with) Allah and the Last Day and remembers Allah much. (Qur'an 33:21)

The Ahadith are the records of his examples. So casting aspersions on them is also doing same on the Qur'an.

Sometimes the Qur'an gives the complete ruling and sometimes the hadith gives the complete ruling. At other times the ahadith explains the Qur'an and the Qur'an can also explain the ahadith. The Qur'an and Sunnah are what the Prophet left behind.

And there's no contradiction between an hadith and the Qur'an as the Prophet practice the Qur'an while alive.



First of all, you are completely wrong for even saying that the Hadith (with all its glaring faults that I've mentioned) are as reliable as the Quran. I mean, let's face it. Even the compilers threw away 90% of the hadiths so how can you even compare such with the Qur'an?

I think your comment is the exact problem I have with the hadiths. First of all, how do you equate disbeliving parts of the hadiths with disbelieving the words of Allah even when there are strong evidences that many of them are false?


Kindly explain the differences between these hadiths for me (for starters)

Is Ghusl (bath) mandatory after intercourse?
- Hazrat Usman said: If a man withdraws before ejaculation, let him wash the genitals and make Wudhu (No bath necessary). (Bukhari, vol 1 Kitabul Wudhu pg 164 Hadith 176)

Rasool (S) said: When a man sits between the woman’s legs and pushes hard, Ghusl (bath) becomes mandatory with or without ejaculation. (Muslim vol 1 Bab-il-Wudhu pg 485)


This is just an example of so many others. Don't ever equate Hadiths with the Qur'an. Salami Alaikum

15 Likes 2 Shares

Islam for Muslims / Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Crayfish09: 6:30pm On Jul 18, 2021
Alhajiemeritus:

I'd like to point out something to you, Hadith isn't just the collections about the prophet, it's also collections about the followers.
Having said that, it's important for everyone to understand the Science of Hadith. Get the knowledge of Hadith.
Usulul Hadith most importantly.
I won't tell you whether all Sahih Hadiths are reliable or not, but I know only the Quran is infallible

Most of the hadiths I mentioned were actually attributed to the prophet but yes, I agree that the Qur'an is 100% accurate

2 Likes 1 Share

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (of 28 pages)

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 95
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.