Lawani's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Lawani's Profile › Lawani's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 (of 277 pages)
Kukutente23:In a civilized settings you can not say the person with the biggest guns should be ordering other people around. That does not happen in any civilized society. The only thing that makes a constituency ahead of another in a civilized setting is the economy or the size of the GDP which is a direct result of the population other things being constant. The constituency with the larger population will have a larger GDP and a larger government revenue as a result other things being constant. We are no longer in that era of might is right. Again if you give all the oil in Nigeria to the states that bear them, Bayelsa will still have like one tenth of Lagos or Kano GDP. Yes cattle can be more than oil. There are countries making more from cattle than Nigeria makes from oil. Cattle consumed in Lagos per day will be close to ten thousand heads, all over the country per day will be up to seventy thousand heads and there is still dairy products. You can pick taxation to determine representation at the center because revenue can not be faked unlike census figures. I wonder why you can't see this |
ProudlyLagos:Non Yoruba in SW states apart from Lagos is not up to three percent of total population. If population is 30 million then non Yoruba will be less than one million across the five states and they will be from all non Yoruba states across the country. It Maybe even two percent. Even Lagos isn't that much. Anybody can sponsor a research to estimate the percentage of non Yoruba in Lagos by selecting at random like one hundred classrooms in different local governments of the state. The ethnic composition of the students will approximate the ethnic composition of the state as a whole. If we go by who is winning elections then Yorubas are over ninety percent of Lagos population |
WhizdomXX:Then there are some Yoruba in Kwara North. Right? Like Moro and Jebba. Am I correct? What Bariba control will be the Northwestern part of the state and it may be half of the sixty percent you mentioned or thereabouts. The King of Jebba has under him like 33 towns and villages spread from North Kwara to South Niger. |
Kukutente23:Natural resources are not human beings. I am not talking of resource control here but taxes. Should oil be a substitute for human beings?. Mind you I am not against giving people all their resources, that is another matter entirely. If Kano is organized with everybody paying tax, they will always have ten times the GDP of Bayelsa even if you give all the oil to Bayelsa. They will therefore generate comeasurate revenue. After all Kano can produce and export 5 billion dollars of farm produce per annum and Bayelsa cant. Cattle alone in Kano can rival oil in Bayelsa. Therefore whatever they have whether farm produce, oil or cattle let them use it to generate revenue and that revenue should determine the representation at the center. Or are Bayelsa and etc not making money from oil already? Oil is an industry already in oil bearing states and it adds to their tax revenue. It does not add to the tax revenue of non oil bearing states. The FG is only taking what the constitution allows it to take. If there are two thousand oil workers in Bayelsa, they all should be paying income tax to Bayelsa and it will shore up their revenue. Military personnel are workers and they should pay tax like other workers as they use social amenities. They don't need special privileges. Only to be paid well. Are military personnel more important than farmers or teachers? No. All are important. Productivity is what should determine representation in a federal state |
Kukutente23:The tax you pay is your weight. For ten years you pay half the tax I pay and you want equal representation? That wouldn't be fair |
A non Yoruba has been governor in Kwara but not during this dispensation and they will still be governor Ilorin is not an ethnic mix more than Ilesa or Ibadan or Kano The ethnic groups in Kwara North actually need to have their own state that they control which they can then align as they wish but those ethnic groups don't control 75 percent of landmass because parts of southern Niger contain towns that are under the king of Jebba so if South Niger is Yoruba land how can those ethnic groups control up to 75 percent of Kwara land mass? What they control is the northwestern part of the state which can't be up to 75 percent of the landmass |
The NJC and the NBA have not done well for Osun state. Why is it difficult for the judiciary to say clearly who are the legitimate local government chairmen in Osun state? The federal government has refused to release over one hundred billion naira of local government allocations as at today. What is the work of the judiciary that they are being paid for if for three years they can not resolve this simple matter? The judge or judges involved are affiliated with the NBA and the NJC and there is no reason why these bodies should not call them to order. Let the judges involved give a clear and unequivocal ruling no matter who it favours because atimes even injustice can be better than no ruling at all as it will at least bring closure. The people of Osun state want closure over this matter. |
Juren:I have joined. |
Kukutente23:The idea is that many metrics can be manipulated but revenue can not and I don't think it is ever possible for a constituency of 5 million people to pay more tax then a constituency of ten million people if revenue drive and cost of living are the same. So leave people to do their census by themselves and weigh them by their revenue. Then resources is not population. I am looking for a metric that is an indicator of population size and natural resources don't qualify. |
Beautifulday:Post the waec registration data for peer states and you will see the same thing. One thing about waec the last time I saw it was In the NW more boys than girls and in the SE more girls than boys. That was many years ago. On the overall it will reflect what is in the census. You can't open a bank account or proceed beyond high school without a NIN, you can't even register a phone to your name. Therefore if you are over 18 in Nigeria, you probably have a NIN number even if you have no BVN |
Beautifulday:They have been doing census, what they didn't do is add ethnicity and religion to it. Then NIN, voters register, BVN, number of internet subscribers, number of active sim cards for voice and etc are also census. If one state beats another in all then it is safe to say it also beat that state in population. State igr is also an indicator but the revenue drive is not uniform is the only drawback. If revenue drive were uniform then the state with the higher population will often have the higher revenue |
gidgiddy:The main reason appear to be that they depend on revenue from oil and gas from the south but that dependence has greatly reduced now. If no oil money more Northerners will support the breakup of the country. Last year oil was 45 percent of revenue and I believe it will not pass thirty percent this year. If it were ten percent, they will not agree to be ruled with the current constitution. |
How can a federal state be fair? A federating unit must be weighted according to the tax it pays. Not according to the population or according to any other metric but according to it's revenue. A federal state is a corporate body and if a corporate body is being funded or expecting revenue then stakeholdership will be determined by contribution which is a form of shareholding The revenue will then be spent according to the wishes of the federal government which will be influenced by need and etc. Such a system will only make the federating units to be competing among themselves in a fair manner leading to a stronger union and more development. The representation should also be reviewable from time to time say every five to ten years. It should not be static so that every unit will be seeking ways to increase their stature. The tax you pay as a constituency is something that can not be faked unlike other metrics. However what you get by using taxes is what you are going to get by using census figures if the cost of living in all federating units are the same. The difference can not be substantial. This also is how the United Nations should be organised |
SixSeven:Who will the opposition unite behind?. All the candidates have their baggages and to unite behind one person is hard for their followers. It was easy for Buhari because the two biggest zones with a simple majority of voters were behind him. What is best for everybody now is to push for the division of the country so that the unhealthy and unending rivalry will end |
Macphenson:It is just like saying Awo betrayed Zik and stopped him from becoming the first premier of the West when they were not even in the same party. Tinubu was not in the PDP and he should not have been expected to work with them to make anybody speaker whether the person is Yoruba or not. The PDP can not install a speaker on their own despite controlling the house?. Then GEJ could have found other ways to compensate the Yoruba with other posts given that they are around thirty percent of the country's population but there were virtually no Yoruba on his team. If this country were being run by taxes the Yoruba will not agree to less than forty percent of the positions. All of you should join hands together to seek the dissolution of the country instead of the unproductive going back and forth |
Svoboda:I just pointed out that Tinubu's margin of victory isn't the lowest in the country's history and that the person with the lowest won his second term bid. When four strong contenders compete then nobody can win with a wide margin but someone will still win |
SixSeven:Alhaji Shagari got a lower percentage than Tinubu in his first term yet won the second term. The percentage one person can get depends on incumbency factor and the number and weight of contestants |
A welfare state can't be affected by automation A state where the government looks out for everybody can not be affected by automation because there are already programs like unemployment benefits. They only need to add the right to a means of livelihood as a fundamental human right. It is important to add this right to the list of fundamental human rights because it is a basic right and a human being should be expected to commit crime if no other way to earn a living. In a communist state, automation will be a positive for them. It will be a welcome development since it is a no one left behind society and it is only a full fledged capitalist economy with no regulations that have anything to fear from automation. The more the automation in a communist state the more it favours the workers because they will simply have more free time Robots can not compete for managerial jobs. Robots can not do research and robots can not lead, robots can not innovate, so robots are not really competition for human beings in a sufficiently advanced society. Robots can also not take all non managerial posts. Academic work alone can employ all human beings but it will not be possible in a country with an abysmally low tax to GDP ratio. In what I call a free market communist economy where employment is guaranteed and overtime increase in net worth is also guaranteed by statute, automation will not be a problem and government policy will actually be geared towards expanding automation. |
9japride:So the NIN registration and voters registration are fake? The VAT and CIT they now pay are fake? Nigeria is no longer depended on oil money as it was and it is now easy to compare the population of regions using the tax they pay |
Beautifulday:The Northwest alone is more than triple the population of the SE. Why are you even asking this question when NIN and voter registration data is in the open? It is sad that educated people with internet access are asking this type of question |
Cross incarnation between cultures According to the research I did with the Ifa oracle, there can be cross incarnation between cultures ie the same spirit incarnating in different cultures at different times if and only if there is interaction between those two cultures. Otherwise you can only incarnate as a spirit where you have incarnation rights ie among your own Earth family or spiritual family members. If you are within one hundred filial generations then you are spiritual family. Interaction between cultures can be in many forms including marriage and war etc. All the spirits of German soldiers killed by Russians during the second world war would have reincarnated as Russians in the Earth family of the Russians that killed them and vice versa. After they live out that incarnation they can return to their original line in their old country while they retain incarnation rights in their new line. Cross incarnation goes on like that indefinitely for two interactive cultures. The Biafran soldiers killed by the Nigerian soldiers during the Nigerian civil war reincarnated as Nigerians and vice versa. One marker is that if their new country is at war with the country of their last incarnation then it will benefit them in some way. However, fully matured spirits who are primary protectors are not affected by this rule as they will always go back to their own line that they can lay claim to to be reincarnated. An English man with a German spirit will tend to be sympathetic to Germany naturally because of past incarnations but being raised by English parents will ensure it does not matter a lot. However the maturity level of a spirit is what matters most and there are eight levels of God like managerial ability according to my research. A spirit is due for promotion at every third incarnation but it is not impossible for a spirit to rise through the ranks in just one incarnation. To be promoted to the next level of Godlike managerial ability, your two primary protectors must agree. |
dettolgel:He wasn't more desperate than GEJ who lost. He can't rig by himself if he wants to rig. There is nothing he can do to win if he does not have enough people supporting him. |
EponObi:If you do that then put zoning clearly in the constitution then it can work. The hurdle left will be if the Yoruba will accept to be treated shabbily by Northerners |
dettolgel:Nothing will happen more than a few protests in a few places but a INEC that can not rig election against Obi in the SE or against Kwankwanso in Kano can not in reality rig elections for any candidate. It is politicians that rig and not INEC and you can't rig where you are not popular, where you don't have any big shot supporting you |
dettolgel:The INEC can not rig out a candidate that is popular. They are powerless to do that. |
dettolgel:If people vote him out he will lose. Jonathan lost. The question is can they unite and do it? Another question is will his Yoruba supporters agree? Given that they supported Buhari for eight years despite that he ran the country down. |
DoTheNeedful:In today's world any section of the country can do what the North did in 1960. Give us the Presidency or we leave Nigeria. They are just not conscious. Rotational Presidency is good because without it the NW and SW can continue monopolizing the Presidency but it must be fair and equitable too and if it is fair and equitable then the SW and NW will still have more slots than others. The North have to wake up and smell the coffee. They have nothing to bargain with. They need to have their own revenue and that is most important. There is no state in the North where IGR is more than allocations and that is very sad. |
He could have become the President of Nigeria if Herbert Macaulay had chosen him as NCNC secretary. |
happney65:Put zoning in the constitution first. Then a region of over 50 million will not accept to take the same number of slots as one of under 20 million. A region generating 500 billion will not accept to take the same thing as one of 100 billion. Work it out somehow and put it in the constitution or else there will always be complaints. |
Wealth tax? There is an ongoing quest especially in the USA for wealth to be taxed. However not all wealth deserve to be taxed. Somebody owning multiple vacation homes can be taxed above average on those homes but somebody who merely own stock can not be realistically taxed in the same way because stock is a means of production and only profit gotten via a means of production ought to be taxed and not the means of production itself. If you tax stock every year like you tax a luxury vacation home then it is possible that the stock will continue reducing until it becomes zero. Stock is like a business owner owning equipment and it should not be taxed. However the best way to get more money from the rich is to outlaw CEOs paying themselves one dollar per annum. No CEO should be allowed to pay self a wage lower than someone reporting to them. Whatever will be their remuneration in total, it should include wage at a level higher than their highest paid employee. This can considerably increase personal income tax revenue in any country and it is a surefire way of ensuring high net worth people pay their fair share of taxes. There can be up to five million CEOs in a country like the USA that avoid personal income tax by paying themselves one dollar per annum. Making them pay personal income tax at the same rate as their subordinates is a form of wealth tax too. |
9japride:The late President George H W Bush took it upon himself to make sure I make it out alive. He even signed up his first granddaughter to marry me right from the year 2000. President Bush junior was contacting me as at 2007 as an American named Mr George based in Nigeria. When others who are evil both locally and internationally attempted to neutralize me by assassination, the US government went to other nations starting from Russia, China, India and then many others. That is why I am still alive today. There have been over thirty attempts on my life. Of course there are bad people who believe I should be silenced even among the westerners and the main person is the late Queen Elizabeth whom I used to publicly eulogize. Win some lose some. That being how life is. Without the initiative of the late President Bush I would not be alive today. So your notion that all western nations have the policy to run others down isn't accurate. It is not the truth. There are many non western nations that developed without hassles and that are even doing better than the average western nation |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 (of 277 pages)
