PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 (of 287 pages)
But the really interesting thing in all of this is the realisation that everywhere that I've looked in the world, all religious traditions that have a basis in experience (mysticism) all come up with the same teaching. Namely that there is an Appropriation to the lives of every individual in this world. That there is a way things are meant to be, and that individuals can deviate from their appropriation, but it is when they reconcile back to it that they are reconciled back to God. This truth is articulated variously to various degrees of accuracy in different cultures whether they call it The First Adam, the Logos, Ori, Eleda Eni in yoruba land, Chi in Igbo land, Tao in China, or Dharma in India. |
[quote author=Mad_Max link=topic=264092.msg3779501#msg3779501 date=1240669840]What you're saying is, Christ might have been a member of the religious council of Pharisees,since a Pharisee at the time did not have the negative connotations it does today; they were religious elders who interpreted the Jewish Laws and preached in synagogues. You're saying they might be compared to Christians in that much of Christian religious activity- preaching, praying, giving to the poor, even some religious thought- mirrors theirs? If not for labels, they might even be categorised as the same? Is that what you're saying?[/quote]Yes and no. Yes he was a member of the Pharisees and was involved with the interpretation of scripture. But the Jews also had a council called the Sanhedrin which was made up mostly of Pharisees. The Pharisees controlled the Sanhedrin pretty much like the Sadducees controlled the Priesthood and the Temple. Jesus was not a member of the Sanhedrin (as far as I can tell). The Pharisees were defined by a certain set of doctrines that they believed and they practiced. Not by hypocrisy. It is wrong, confusing, and misleading to use the term pharisee to mean a hypocrite. There is nothing in the doctrine (which is what defines them) of the pharisees that is in anyway different from the doctrines of the early christians. So Yes, If not for some totally arbitrary label they might be categorised as the same. Early Christianity is not as different from Pharisiac Judaism as some would make out. |
My own inside all of this is: Tithe is supposed to be food, not money and further more the awuf is supposed to be shared in the presence of the Lord. This small detail that is being overlooked is more pertinent than it is being given credit for, I think. What do forum members think of the significance of the shared meal in religious worship? I'm not just talking about tithe now, but also about the Lord's supper which is one of the central rites of christianity but is funnily absent in most if not all of the pentecostal churches. How can christians, who claim to be practicing christianity come together to fellowship without awuf? How? This is terrible corruption of christianity. |
[size=16pt]Samuel Taylor Coleridge, a renowned writer, noted: "He who begins by loving Christianity better than truth, will proceed by loving his own sect or church better than Christianity, and end in loving himself better than all."[/size]QFT!! |
duduspace:Nothing I said involves an alternate timeline. Rather, I refer to No Time at all. Nothing I said involves parallel universes either. You obviously have a great fondness for science fiction etc and there's no harm there, but you don't have to force it into my posts and read it where it is not there. I am talking about existence without time. Are you saying that this is impossible? Or Gooblydook without proof etc? Is that what you are saying? |
I don't know how you can say that what I wrote did not even address your question. Did you read verses 25 and 26 of the hebrews chapter I quoted. I'll repeat it. 25 nor in order that he should offer himself often, as the high priest enters into the holy places every year with blood not his own;How do you reconcile the two contradicting statements in verse 26. a) . . . suffer from the foundation of the world. and b) . . .now at the consummation of the ages he has been manifested . . .? It seems to me that there is more depth to this than your shallow reading allows for, don't you think? |
huxley:I didn't think that I'd need to define them. I thought you were familiar with them. basically Time is what you experience as before, now and after. When experience is no longer arranged in terms of the passage of time then we get a glimpse of the eternal. Eternal is timelessness. I am not making this up. Many people have discussed this before me. Even in Science, your favourite Big Bang theory suggests that Time comes into existence at some stage of the Big Bang. Believe me, Cessation of Time is not my invention. Maybe if I was a physicists then you'll take what I'm saying more seriously but since I'm not you just dismiss it. I'd rather you actually addressed it and if it is not intellectually sound, feel free to take it apart. Now I know that you are quite capable of dissecting weak arguments. You do it all the time on nairaland. So oblige me, kind sire. |
duduspace:Is that your criticism? ![]() fair enough, . . . I guess? |
I thought that I'd already addressed this issue here: https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-265654.0.html#msg3796280 I was expecting a response. |
This is so tired now, I swear. Have you read any of the gazillion threads on tithe that have been going on for the last year or 2 and are still going on till today. I'm sure that you'll find all the answers to your questions and more if you read through these. |
The Yoruba have a diety called Sango. Sango is an axe wield, stormcloud riding, lightening bolt hurling, rain producing, badass warrior of a diety. His characteristics can be found in the dieties of other cultures and nations suggesting that there is something primordial and fundamental about the iconography of Sango. However when you look closely at the yoruba mythology as well as yoruba history, we learn something interesting. Sango was an historical figure. In fact he was the 4th King of the Oyo empire. He was a man who hailed from Nupe land and came to rule over the Yorubas in Oyo. He fought many wars and was eventually expelled from Oyo by unhappy subjects. Sango's existence is an historical fact. What does this say about the mythological Sango? Why the hell would the yoruba worship an old despotic ancestral king? But most confusing of all, how comes the ritual objects of his worship and the iconography associated with him can be found in the myths and religions of others peoples as far flung away as scandinavia and ancient greece? This is very interesting and I suspect can shed a lot of light on the JMT theories. |
I think that we are not taking into account that there are two regimes being referred to here. One is the temporal and the other is the eternal. It is a common mistake to look at eternal things and try to understand them with a temporal way of thinking, mainly because our brains evolved to deal with temporal reality. That is why we have questions like 'what precedes God'? or 'Who created God'? There is no before or after when we talk about eternal things. There is no time, so before and after do not come into play. Language fails to deal with the eternal because Language is designed to articulate temporal things that's why in grammar we learn the different tenses, past tense, present tense, future tense. Slain at/from the foundation of the world does not refer to a point in time. Time is a part of creation. We could also say slain at the foundation of Time. An event in eternity can have an avatar in time and it will not matter when it time it occurs, whether in the past, now, or in the future. That event already exists eternally in Eternity but will exist for a short span of time in temporal reality whether this is in the past or in the present or in the yet to come. In fact it was a common philosophical and religious idea that temporal events are just copies of eternal events. Plato was big on this, the idea that the physical world is but a likeness of the eternal world. So events in the temporal are just pseudo-manifestation of events in the eternal. Things are translated from Being to Becoming. Eternally they exist always as Being, but temporally they Become for a short span and then Pass away again. Literally THEY HAPPEN (in French ILS PASSent, in old english They come to PASS). The cruxifiction 2000 years ago was a temporal passing event, an avatar of an eternal event that IS prior to the foundation of TIME and CREATION. 23 It was necessary then that the figurative representations of the things in the heavens should be purified with these; but the heavenly things themselves with sacrifices better than these.Hebrews 9 |
In what language is he going to write the book, because I know that Obasanjo cannot even speak english properly. |
uzygirl:Why don't we just call him sir? Or even mister? Hey mister, who art in heaven hallowed be thy name |
uplawal:I wonder, as an african, can you call your father's name? Ever since I've been in africa, apart from Fela Kuti, I've never heard any african child calling his father by name. |
Lax75:There is no Satan in the Hindu religions. |
huxley:I don't know what is biting you, or who you're fighting with. Nobody is triumphing over anybody else. Me, I'm just having a a conversation/debate. If I'm wrong and you demonstrate that I will accept it without feeling lesser in any way. If I demonstrate that you are wrong, trust me, I don't take that to mean that you are lesser, or I've triumphed over you. |
huxley:So much is lost in translation, Huxley, it is also important to bear in mind the intentions of the translator as well as the intentions of the original writer. I cannot really answer your question as to why they had to use the word fool. Perhaps they were trying to be insultive to the critics of Jesus. It is also important to note not only what the denotation of words are but also the connotations. Connotations are so mercurial, they change so fast. If I saw a car I liked in 1966 and I said 'that's groovy baby!' I am merely expressing my approval but there are other connotations, eg that I am a young hip guy. If I said the same thing in 2009 it is still an expression of approval but also connotes that I'm an old fogey out of touch with the times. Or I could be saying it like that as a reference to the style of the car which could be 60's car. Context is very important to understanding and translating words. What connotations did the word anoetic carry in Jesus' time? Or in the time of the person writing Luke's gospel. What connotation did the word moros carry? It helps if you could reference other contemporary texts and consider the sense in which these words were used. I laugh to myself, Huxley, cos something tells me that you don't care enough to do all that research. But you've got to admit that it would be an interesting line of inquiry if someone could do it. |
Bastage:I totally agree with you which is why I've told Huxley in the past that he starts with a bias and then looks around for evidence to support this bias. This is not a logical process. If this was regarding one of his Humanist philosophy books I'm sure that Huxley would have done more background research into the works used. Heck, if this was any other matter I'm sure Huxley would look into it deeper rather than clutch at straws just to diss Jesus. This is what makes it hard to trust any information that Huxley may present about christianity. It seems when it comes to Christianity Huxley becomes totally Anoetic. ![]() |
Pastor AIO:As almost everybody knows the prefix a- in greek means the negative or opposite of the word following. The word phresin means to think in greek as in 1cor 14:20 Brothers, don't be children in thoughts, yet in malice be babies, but in thoughts be mature. So to call someone A-phrones would simply that the person was without thought. In other words Jesus was telling them to think, rather than be thoughtless. Pastor AIO:Again we have A- and then Noetoi. Noetoi is derived from Nous which in greek is often translated as Mind. Noetoi is to exercise the Mind. There is even a guy on Nairaland called Noetic which suggests that he is a guy who likes to exercise his mind. Put A- in front of this and you have anoetoi which is someone that is Not exercising his mind. This is all different from Fool as a put down or a suggestion that someone is unworthy. |
In Matthew the greek word used is μωρέ (more). Moros means foolish but would be used more like a diss. In luke 11:40 the word used is aphrones which means to not be wise but is not used in the sense of a diss. It just suggests that someone isn't being sharp or being intelligent. In Luke 24:25 the word translated as fool is different again. This time it is anoetoi which again just suggests that someone is slow to get the gist. I hope this resolves things for you Huxley. |
Well the bible states explicitly that he was a rabbi. Well the Rabbis were pharisees. Too many of their religious doctrines not to mention the rhetoric with which they articulated these doctrines were the same. Where perhaps there may have been a difference between christians and Pharisee is in whether or not Jesus was that Primordial Adam, the Messiah. (And also the Pharisees did not necessarily see the messiah as a military leader either. ) |
Now the following is very interesting. It looks at three different sources of the christological belief. The basic gist of it is that the Pharisees believed that two Adams were created. The primordial Adam was the one through whom the world was given form. He was the Messiah and it was also believed that this primordial Adam would one day incarnate as a human being, flesh and blood. This first Adam was quite different from the Adam made of clay that became our progenitor. There was also a Jewish philosopher from Alexandria called Philo who went on to equate this Primordial Adam with what the Greeks called the Logos. Again the Logos was seen as the Form or the Order of the Universe. Or in other words the Ordering principle of the universe. Then a few decades Later St. Paul, who remember claimed he was a pharisee that studied under Gamaliel, goes on to articulate in 1Corinthians chapter15 a christology that relies heavily on the idea of 2 Adams. The second Adam (ie the primordial) having incarnated in the person of Jesus Christ. In other words the difference between Paul and the Pharisees, presumably, is that whereas most pharisees were still waiting for the incarnation of the primordial Adam, ie the Messiach, Paul was saying that he had already incarnated. And then a few more decades laters the writer of John's gospel doesn't mince his words and states straight that Jesus was the Incarnation of the Logos. Remember that the Greek Logos and the Pharisee Primordial Adam had already been equated by Philo. Philo.From here: http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=761&letter=A |
[quote author=n_o_e_t_ic link=topic=264092.msg3772324#msg3772324 date=1240520436]u postulated that Jesus was not different from the Pharisees, thats my bone of contention. I ask u what was the major difference and bone of contention (apart from the status of Jesus) between Jesus and the Pharisees?[/quote]I didn't just say that Jesus was not different from the pharisees. I said that Jesus was a pharisee. As a pharisee there cannot really be a major difference between Jesus and the pharisees. As a pharisee Jesus has every right to criticise his own. As a nigerian I have every right to criticize and complain about the rampant corruption, superficiality and idiocy of nigerian society. That does not make me not a nigerian. |
Bastage:I hear you but there are some differences there. The Essenes did not interact with the world and get involved with politics. Jesus was out in the world and also Jesus was part of the Rabbinic tradition. He was a Rabbi and taught in the synagogues. On the other hand it is thought that the Essenes were the real original Jewish priests that left Jerusalem in disgust after the Greeks imposed a puppet high priest. They called their community the New temple. The pharisiac tradition on the other hand tried to blur the distinction between Priests and laymen. Laymen were called to perform the purification rites and live purely like the Levitical priests were supposed to do. Pharisees called on every one to be priests. The Rabbinical tradition belonged to the pharisees. Jesus was a Rabbi. Jesus never baptised. His disciples did, but he never did. Baptism was mainly practiced by the Essenes, but I don't think the pharisees baptised. This matter of baptism is the main point that you could say could distinguish early christians from pharisees. Although there is no record that the pharisees didn't baptise. However the bible says clearly that Jesus didn't baptise. |
[quote author=n_o_e_t_ic link=topic=264092.msg3771877#msg3771877 date=1240511868]@ AIO To some extent u have a point but have refused to identify the main purpose of Jesus coming. Jesus expects us to be "holier" than the pharasee`s like He was. but the difference is that while the pharasee condemned those who are unrighteous, full of sin and not of God, He commanded us to love them. so in reality Christianity is holiness, humility, love kindness and all the other goodies the Father teached about.[/quote]A number of things . . . First, the title of this thread is 'What is the Difference between a Christian and a Pharisee?'. Not 'What is the Main Purpose of Jesus Coming?'. So I have not refused to identify anything. To make a refusal one must first hear a request. If you are making a request I think I can oblige you and yet satisfy the topic of this thread, but first let me answer a couple of other things you've said. Second, You need to show me where pharisees 'condemned those who are unrighteous, full of sin and not of God'. If that was a part of Pharisee doctrine then can you please show me where they said that. Yes they wanted to preserve Jewish culture and not mix with the Greeks and adopt greek customs, but that is not a condemnation of Greeks. Love your neighbour as your self is in the Jewish Torah and the Pharisees upheld that. They are the ones who first articulated the Shema as the most important law: Hear O Israel, the Lord thy God is One, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all your strength and all your might. Thirdly you have not showed me one place where Christian doctrine differed from Pharisee doctrine. Perhaps first you need to find out what the doctrines of the Pharisees were. |
[quote author=~Lady~ link=topic=264092.msg3771585#msg3771585 date=1240507804]There has never been a Pope that sits on the chair pf Peter (remember the chair of moses from the other discussion?) that has ever issued a decree ex-cathedra, that is from the Chair of Peter binding upon all christians as a belief, that is atrocious. If there ever has been let someone cite a source for it. Let me remind you that you will have to post that the Pope called for it ex-cathedra, not just that he stated it, but that he called for it ex-cathedra.[/quote]I'm sorry, but that's a really tall order. How is anyone supposed to know whether the popes were sitting in the kathedra or not when they were using their authority to order all manner of atrocities? How would I know whether the sale of indulgences was done from the Cathedra or not? Heck, how would you know, as a catholic which orders are binding and which are not? How do you know if the pope was giving it ex-cathedra or while he was on his toilet seat? All you know is that the pope has said such and such. |
[quote author=~Lady~ link=topic=264092.msg3766437#msg3766437 date=1240415839]Sitting in Moses' chair means one has the authority to interpret scripture and define law for the people. Sitting in Moses' chair gives them the authority to interpret the scriptures. That's why they have the authority to interpret the scriptures.[/quote]What you've given above is an extrapolation, an interpretation. I was referring to the translation not the interpretation of what the verse said. The word official does not occur in the greek and neither does the word interpreters. (I know I said I wasn't sure about the interpretation of the verse, what I meant was the translation of the verse.) The direct translation says that they sit in moses' chair. That could also be taken to mean not just that they interpreted Moses but that they wield the same authority that Moses wielded. Interpretations extrapolate from the text, while translations should try to stay as close to the text as possible. [quote author=~Lady~ link=topic=264092.msg3766437#msg3766437 date=1240415839]I think we all have a grave misunderstanding of the system of that time. The Pharisees and the Sadducees all had their respective roles in the Jewish religion and they were supposed to stay within the constraints of their roles, but couldn't. Instead of realising that they each had their roles. The Pharisees for interpreting the law, and the sadducees for carrying out the law. They were to work together and not against each other. They couldn't comprehend that, call it elitism. But it's the human nature.[/quote]This is quite wrong. What are you basing what you've said here on? There were no Sadducees or Pharisees originally in Jewish religion. The Sadducees emerged when the Greeks conquered Israel and instated their own puppet High Priest in the temple. The Sadducees rose in support of this new priesthood and were in favour of Israel becoming hellenized. This is all history, not a matter of opinion. The pharisees rejected this hellenization and they had the popular support of the people. That is why they were as powerful as they were. To the point that the Sadducees had to compromise with them to keep the peace. They were not just different parts of Jewish religion. Their beliefs and ideologies were different. I don't know how you arrived at your notion. Perhaps you can provide sources. However I know it not to be true as a matter of historical fact. [quote author=~Lady~ link=topic=264092.msg3766437#msg3766437 date=1240415839]You'll have to map out the similarities between Jesus and the Pharisees.[/quote]I've already given a few outlines above. I'll repeat them. -Jesus was a Rabbi and taught in the Synagogues. This is what the Pharisees did. - Jesus actually endorsed them (ideologically) when he tells us to do as they preach because they sit on the seat of Moses. He only tells us not to do as they do, because even they do not do as they preach. - Jesus also demoted the importance of the Temple as the Pharisees did. He told the samaritan woman that God would be worshipped neither in the temple nor on the mountain. He dismissed the magnificence of the temple saying one day not one stone will be found on top of another. This was a typical pharisee attitude. Actually it was found more so with the Essenes, but the pharisees had a similar attitude. - the Christian doctrine that we are all priests is a pharisee doctrine. The laws of cleanliness that they upheld were originally actually only meant for the levites and priesthood initially but they interpreted it apply to all the israelites, a people to be set apart for God. [color=#000099]The Pharisees believed that the idea that all of the children of Israel were to be like priests was expressed elsewhere in the Torah, for example, when the Law itself was transferred from the sphere of the priesthood to every man in Israel (Exodus 19: 29-24; Deuteronomy 6: 7, 11: 19; comp. 31: 9; Jeremiah 2: 8, 18:18). Moreover, the Torah already provided some ways for all Jews to lead a priestly life: the precepts concerning unclean meat were perhaps intended originally for the priests, but were extended to the whole people (Leviticus 11; Deuteronomy 14:3-21); the prohibition of cutting the flesh in mourning for the dead (Deuteronomy 14: 1-2, Leviticus 19: 28; comp. Lev. 21: 5). The Pharisees believed that all Jews in their ordinary life, and not just the Temple priesthood or Jews visiting the Temple, should observe rules and rituals concerning purification. -And indeed Paul's letters are full of Pharisee doctrines. (This very same Gamaliel it was that Paul claimed with pride was his teacher. ) -When asked what was the greatest of the laws Jesus responded that it was the Shema. That is 'hear o israel . . . '. This is pharisee doctrine as taught by Hillel the grandfather of Gamaliel, probably the most influential pharisee ever. [/color] And I would add to that also very importantly the belief that there were[b] two adams[/b]. There are just too many similarities when you look closely at it. |
todak:LOL! not only does he butcher the bible but he butchers the English language too, in the process. |
domwas2:And herein lies the problem. Pharisee has become synonymous with hypocrisy to the point that we probably think that the qualifications for becoming a pharisee is that they had to demonstrate how hypocritical they could be. Yet that is not the case. You cannot have an association of people for hypocrisy. They had their beliefs and tenets. There are hypocrites in all walks of life. Pharisee does not equal hypocrite. Dictionary definitions will not help you none. If you want to know anything about the pharisees you'll have to do some research. The following is taken from a christian website that talks about their history and then about their doctrines and characteristics. The history is factual but then when talking about their beliefs they miss the facts. History of the PhariseesFrom here: http://www.christinyou.net/pages/pharisaism.html The part that I've marked blue is filled with many inaccuracies. Let us look at what a Jewish website has to say about the Pharisees. Of the various factions that emerged under Hasmonean rule, three are of particular interest: the Pharisees, Sadducees, and Essenes.From here: http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/History/sadducees_pharisees_essenes.html I've put in bold the key points and words. The Christian websites makes many grave errors as follows: But during the ministry of Jesus, almost one hundred years after the establishment of their influence and power, the Pharisees represented almost everything that was the antithesis of what Jesus came to reveal in Himself.This is unfounded, in fact the contrary seems to be true when you study what the pharisees believed. Some of the priests were Pharisees.If there were any pharisees in the priesthood then there were very few, I actually think it is unlikely there were any. The Sadducees had the priesthood locked down. The pharisees were organised around the synagogue. External behavior and "appearances" were important to the Pharisees. Coleman refers to them as the "How do we look" cult.2 "The ethical side was more important than the theological side. They were far more concerned with orthopraxy than with orthodoxy." 3 But, they didn't practice what they preached!This is a grievous and totally erroneous thing to say. The same can be said of christians or of any group. There is actually no citations of this but the website is quoting a contemporary writer who we've never heard of, we don't know what his research is based on. [size=14pt]Even the Jews themselves recognized the hypocrisy and false piety of the Pharisees. In the Talmud there was a list of seven kinds of Pharisees.[/size]And this bring us to the crux of my point. The Talmud is a Pharisee book. It is the Oral Tradition written in a book. So what we have here is Self Criticism. If a pharisee is upbraiding another pharisee to stop being hypocritical does that mean that the definition of pharisee is a hypocritical person. The pharisee tradition was a very democratic tradition. There were many debates and varying viewpoints. The tradition developed from this dialectical approach. Jesus could be a pharisee and still upbraid other pharisees. In fact as a pharisee he would focus his teachings on his fellow pharisees. This was the pharisee approach. In fact the pharisee tradition at the time of Jesus can be seen as a dialectic between the Hillel viewpoint and the Shamma viewpoint. It is the Shamma pharisees that are strictly ritualistic and the Hillel pharisees are more liberal. Hillel the Elder’s friendly adversary was Shammai, a native of the Land of Israel about whom little is known except that he was a builder, known for the strictness of his views. He was reputed to be dour, quick-tempered and impatient. Both lived during the reign of King Herod (37-4 BCE), an oppressive period in Jewish history because of the Roman occupation of the Land of Israel. Shammai was concerned that if Jews had too much contact with the Romans, the Jewish community would be weakened, and this attitude was reflected in his strict interpretation of Jewish law. Hillel did not share Shammai's fear and therefore was more liberal in his view of law.From here: http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/biography/hillel.html |
Where does my black ass fit into all of this? Let's talk about African civilization jare! |
IFA - International Forum for Advancement. or Instrument For Advancement or Intelligence From Above |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 (of 287 pages)

