₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,390 members, 8,522,774 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 12:37 AM

Toggle theme

UGBE634's Posts

Nairaland Forum › UGBE634's Profile › UGBE634's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 (of 27 pages)

Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634:
[quote author=BanyXchi post=118728503][/quote]I just thought I should add this now, to show you how huge our diasporan population is, 40 % of Bini commenters on this culture section are outside the shores. Areafada2 is in Uk, Sam-Uk is in Uk, the Oza-nogogo maths teacher that comes around regularly is in france, bokohalal was outside the shores at the time, certainly would still be there, mulattoclaro was in spain,most likely would still be there, papabrowne was in one of these western countries,most likely going to still be there physics was undergoing his PhD program in one of these western countries at the time. There might be others that did not really disclose where they stay in their comments. It certainly would be more than this, this post is restricted to my knowledge.
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 2:50am On Nov 28, 2022
AreaFada2:
The thing is we have never had an accepted census since 1960.
By the way, there is nothing like "Bini". Edo people should avoid that word. BTC has repeatedly announced that the name for the tribe is Benin, capital is Benin City and the Language is Benin/Edo. We use the Benins to describe the people. You can get clarification from Frank Irabor. Outsiders can use "Bini" if they want, we nor mind them. But we shouldn't be using it.

If you listen to the Iyase speak or interviews of late Dr E Aisien, the surgeon turned historian, you will only hear Benin. Also listen to Izoduwa.

Even if Benin population is 1m or 6m, its enough to be a standalone state.

I have only ever read that Edo South has 67% of the population, never heard of 57%. Like I said, nobody really knows. I wouldn't even trust voters register.
When you have the free time, post your link, yes but voters register seem to point to where the population is geared towards. You see states with more Voters in their register are certainly more populated especially if it is not a negligible number like 50,000 to 100,000. Ekiti state that did nine hundred thousand in 2019 and repeated that same feat in 2022 with just a few thousand even with the timeframe that was given shows it is two times and half smaller than Edo state and at best the population strength of Edo central and north altogether. You can't give what you don't have. The voters register goes to show that she is indeed the smallest state in Nigeria.

How do you expect me to trust a census figure that allocated 3 million to Edo state in 2006, and 4 million was allocated to obviously smaller states such as Ondo and Osun. 13 years down the line, she did voters number above them with 400,000 and 600,000 above both of them in 2019. She repeated that same feat in 2022 with about that same population space except for Osun that just had her state election. it is far more authentic than our actual census and far a testament of people residing in a particular space than the census.

Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634:
AreaFada2:
Benin people move a lot, We always moved to form other places. Currently we move outside 9ja more now.
Edo South makes up 67% of Edo population. Of course around 20% of that population will be from Edo North/Central and outside Edo. Every State and senatorial district has non-indigenes, so Edo South is not unique.

In my opinion, Edo South should be around 2.5 to 2.75 million. More than enough for a State. I don't believe Obaseki clan is up to 100k. Ogbeide-Oyo followed Oba Osemwende from Anioma (Nsukwa, I believe) to take the throne in Benin. Looking at history, Oba Osemwende reigned from 1816-1848. His name as a prince was Erediauwa. I know descendants of Osemwende quite well in Benin. Ogbeide was an Omada to Oba Osemwende. It was Oba Adolor who first ennobled Ogbeide as Chief Ineh. His son Agho, grew up with Oba Ovonramwen when he was still a prince since Chief Ineh takes care of princes welfare as part of his roles, not just only head of Igun artisans.

Oba Ovonramen became Oba in 1888 and later purposely created the title Obaseki for his childhood Friend. He was later made a de facto Iyase (Prime Minister/administrator) by the British in interregnum . The British actually pressured Oba Eweka to officially make Agho Obaseki the Prime Minister/Iyase in 1914.

This history is vital to know the capacity of Ogbeide to marry many wives and have many kids/descendants. Yes, Agho had trade monopoly for cash crops sales from late 1890s and some imported goods and his kids became rich too. He even married two princesses. A daughter each of Ovonramwen and Eweka II. Yet within 8 generations (1816-2022) Ogbeide-Oyo's children can't be up to 100k. He came as a kid too. Pedro exaggerated a bit I believe.

For our SW friends, Oba Osemwnde sacked Akure and chopped off Deji Arankale's head in 1818 due to Deji of Akure's insolence and murdering of Oba's emissary Chief Osague. They won't know that history of course.
There are about 2.5 million registered voters In Edo state. There are still unregistered voters everywhere, unregistered voters in Edo state should still be up to 2.5 million let alone adolescent and children. If they should carry out a proper registration in Edo state, Edo state would do 3.3 to 3.5 million effortlessly

Besides I was talking about 1996 not 2022. Your analysis of the population of Edo south was for 2022 not 1996 which according to your analysis 2.75 million in 2022 would not have been enough to create a state in 1996

Lastly our diasporan population is mighty, I remember an Hausa man telling me that he went to Holland that the only Nigerian he met there was a Bini

Edo south is 57 percent not 67

Also don't underrate those penis o especially the rich ones grin . Osula even in today's world just died and he gave birth to 56 children and over 300 grand children.

I met one of Adun's sons and I asked him how many are they. He answered and said his father said he should no longer disclose it to people. Why I asked, he said they usually laugh when he tells them, as at the last count with Bob izua, I am aware he had twenty-nine wives, if he had added more to it since that time I can't tell.

This man called Bob Izua cannot be with less than 70 children even in today's world. Let alone then, just imagine having the wherewithal to marry two princess, let alone how many commoners he must have gotten married to and how many would have given birth for him. We know Bini is a highly polygamous society, no men in Benin were getting married to one wife until 1995 or 2000 even in that era and in today's world, men with average capacity are still on with the Idea of two wives or more

My father gave birth to sixteen, his father gave birth to 25. Some men in his era gave birth to 70, 60 and more.

For the facts that there is no more political turmoil which enabled migration out of the land, rituals killings has greatly reduced, wars is no more there and survival fight to the throne which led to the death of many supporting both princes is no longer there since 1897, I still hold on to the fact that Bini cannot be less than 4 million today
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 7:49pm On Nov 27, 2022
AreaFada2:
True. I have been contacted by researchers over the years. Some needed information for their doctoral work and other reasons. I was able to direct and refer them as best as I could. Sensible people know how to sift through things posted here on NL. If only they will come with humility and ready to learn and exchange ideas. But may come with arrogance and the mentality of " Benin that has only 7LGAs, that small Benin, what is their population, how can they talk of empire, na we go school pass, etc"

They forget that Rome was only a village on the banks of River Tiber initially. As of 278BC when Pyrrhus of Epirus ( a Greek General/King) faced Roman soldiers in the Battle of Tarentum (Magna Grecia/Greeks living in Italian Peninsulas), the Greeks still called Romans Barbarians. Though Pyrrhus won against the Greeks, his personnel loss was so much that it became known as "Pyrrhic victory".

By 168 BC, Romans had conquered Greece. Small Rome had began its march to become a massive empire. By September of 52 BC, it has conquered Gaulle (today's France/Switzerland) in the Battle of Alesia. Romans were now calling French, Germans and others Barbarians. By the time Julius Caesar was born in 100BC, Rome was already quite powerful. Building a massive empire to rival Alexander the Great's massive empire as at his death in 323BC.

I have visited all these places mentioned and museums about these wars. I have also seen Benin Arts in Museums in London, Berlin, Quay Branly Museum in Paris, Amsterdam and other places. Of course arts from other parts of Africa. Benin arts has no pair in Africa, once you remove ancient Egypt. My quest to understand ancient societies, how empires grew, the driving force and so on began decades ago.

So when I see kids without much experience or proper training jump on to NL and start insulting their dad's or mother's agemates due to ethnic pride, I shake my head.
my argument now is that pedro Obaseki said his Obaseki lineage is over a hundred thousand on Either Arise or Channels tv, pedro Obaseki is obviously schooled and not a push aside, then Benin cannot be less than 4 million. He granted this interview two years ago, I have watched it, I don't know how to get it back, I might just go watch all his videos of that era. Supported with the fact that Otaru of Auchi asked for a separate state for Benin in 1996 and was intimidated by the Bini population because he thought that power might never get to his people
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 7:19pm On Nov 27, 2022
AreaFada2:
I was like UGBE634 9 to 11 years ago, believing that one can have a decent conversation with your likes. But no chance.

Chinua Achebe wrote that: "Aneke the bird said, ever since humans learnt to shoot without missing, it has also learnt to fly without perching".

The Wotowoto you are getting now is the result of the insults and abuse your SW people sowed here on NL trying to shout down Edo people. Enjoy the rofo rofo.
I am not doing it because of him but posterity who may come across his questions and my answers someday
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634:
[q
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634:
BanyXchi:
thanks for replying bro... No I'm not part of those that thinks Binis are part of Yorubas or they are seperate from other Edo tribes. I respect Edos and see Binis, Esans, afemais all as Edos. I've only seen and heard Esan people say they are esan are not Edo. Also I don't think we can use the numbers of voters registration to get the nos of Ekitis and Binis, because they are lot of non-binis living in Edo south. Also ekiti people are spread into Kwara. Is there any way we can get the population of Binis? Like maybe from past population census or something related? I do know that ekiti people are not less that 3million.
Binis themselves cannot be less than 4 million in population home and abroad. I don't think we can trust these censuses in Nigeria, a census in 2006 allocated 3.000,000 to the whole of Edo state in 2006 and 4,000,000 each to both Osun and Ondo which are Obviously smaller states cannot be trusted. Then just 13 years down the line, the state did Voters registration number 400,000 and 600,000 above Ondo and Osun state respectively. With even a lot of unregistered voters everywhere. voters registration is by far an authentic pointer to the population of these places, as there is nothing tied to it, there is nothing to gain In it as opposed to a population census which equals more figures,more resources allocated. Banyxchi



The voters registration in Ekiti in 2019 was about 900,000, that of Edo south was 1.3 million, the four hundred thousand more population is more than enough to suffice for the migrant in Benin city. The Edos in diaspora would take out the Ekitis in Kwara state.

And also to suffice for the migrant population in Benin, we have alot of Migrant Bini population outside the country with a population of about 1.2 to 1.5 million. There are about a third of Binis outside the country, you know this already. The Obaseki family alone according to pedro Obaseki, is over a 100,000, regardless of the census conducted in Nigeria, we are aware of our population

This was the Otaru of Auchi canvassing for a separate state for Etsako and Esan people, In his own words, he said Edo south was big enough and Populated enough to stand alone. This was in 1996, Benin was never this urban, There is something the educated Otaru knows about the population of Bini that you an outsider is not in the know about. I am telling you if Edo state had been divided in 1996, 3 million would have still be allocated to Benin state and maybe 2 million to afemesan state which comprise of Esan and Afemai people, it would have been created if not for Anenih.

Before 1991, Bini would have been over 12 or 13 local government,in fact there was a scuffle in Benin- at the time between the Esama of Benin and the Oba of Benin, he had wanted the Obaship position over Benin, Then he asked for some separate local government, in his area, Okada and Environs obviously to reduce the strength of the Oba and make himself King in his environ. The Oba wade in and asked Aikhomu not to do any of such.

There is a pattern In Nigeria skewed towards subdueing the population of the minorities to allow for proper exaggeration of majority population. Read this article and see how Bini state was to be created in 1996! And how it was thwarted by Anenih, the same Bini you feel is not up to a million in 2022.

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://guardian.ng/sunday-magazine/otaru-of-auchi-how-we-lost-out-in-the-bid-to-create-afemesan-state/&ved=2ahUKEwjpk5Ot_OL0AhWNxYUKHfaDDmoQFnoECAQQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0LaFfDTyS-rnpL90Yyv0Qu
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 6:50pm On Nov 27, 2022
BanyXchi:
bro you're very different from thag guy that went straight to insults, I want to have a healthy conversation with you bro, pls I genuinely want to know the answers to those questions.
you can use this link to check the number of voters register in Ekiti in 2019 and check that photo for the number of voters register in Edo south in 2019 which consist of those seven local government you are talking about, There is something I seem to notice about the yorubas especially the ones which seem very naive about Benin. I have seen a yoruba before who asked me if I am from the Oba's family because I told him I am a Bini. They do have this feeling that there is a tribe called Bini separate from Edo and they speak a mixture language of yoruba and Edo and they own the city, I think you are one of them. Yes the Oba's family is not up to a million, I know that is what you are talking about. But it cannot be less than 300,000 https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.pulse.ng/news/politics/this-is-state-by-state-breakdown-of-total-registered-voters-across-nigeria/4nr0720.amp&ved=2ahUKEwiU25X_8877AhXJN-wKHVOaAEEQFnoECCYQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0I6c5nOCVRweu0wfPU8H9Q

Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 6:25pm On Nov 27, 2022
BanyXchi:
pls show me the Yorubas claiming Benin people, just send the link here, you claim everyday right?? Pls send me the ones you've seen the last week.

Also where's the proof they are Edo, all the Esans I know claim they are Esans and are not Edo.
How are Binis big enough to have their own state when their population is not up to a million?
oh I see you are a joke, you should not be taken seriously
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 6:17pm On Nov 27, 2022
BanyXchi:
pls don't let me go that lane with you, I love and respect my Benin people and I only believe in a peaceful seperation where they can have their Bendel or Niger Delta. I lived in Edo for just 3 months and I know they are the cheapest thing to Bleep, it's not even a insult. You can Bleep the average Benin girl for just a plate of Omi ukpoka. They dominate both local and international and you know that yourself.
Not you talking about skullminers when your state is the HQs of witchcraft, ritualism and other barbaric practices that are not even reported in the media. The numbers of skulls and heads being hacked in Edo every week by cultists are more than the number of skulls mined in my region every year.

'You broke away' from our region not from the country, I want my people to seperate from your kind.

Yorubaland was neutral until the east tried to invade us, at the same time some Yorubas fought on biafra side. You were not neutral. Your people protested and supported 'One Nigeria' on the streets of Benin during the war and there were also Benin Soldiers in the Nigerian army.

Also you didn't see anything in 1897,you were bombarded and defeated by the British.

If you had any sense and knowledge of history you'd know about the ijebu-anglo war. And you didn't fight the Brits, they invaded you and defeated you mercilessly, and your Oba ended up fleeing to Calabar. If Yorubas are Hausa slaves, then imagine what a minority tribe with 7LGA like you are lool.

Tapa descent? You think I'm like you a Igala turned edo claiming a imaginary Benin empire? I'm a proud full blooded Ondo and Yoruba man and yes I'm of ife descent I have nothing in common with your kind. You should be ashamed that you want to force yourself on people that don't want you. You will always remain a minority no matter how much you delude yourself.
I would not respond to the others, I see it that you are pained, but I would respond to this. A 7 local government tribe with one senatorial district which did more Voters registration than a 16 local government state ( Ekiti state) with this you should already know local government is not a yardstick, it is not even close to. If Orhiowmon was in Ondo, it would have been partitioned into three local government, and it is not even Urban
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 5:55pm On Nov 27, 2022
BanyXchi:
you don't even have population up to Uhrobos in your Niger Delta region. You people know this and that's why you're desperate to gumbody with everyone, you want the esans, afemais and even Uhrobos to identify as Edo and you are desperate to create a imaginary Benin empire in your head. Where can your Oba come to in eastern Yorubaland and claim as part of his kingdom. I don't hate Benin people, I just don't understand the obsession you have with Yorubas, 99.9% of Yorubas frankly don't give a Bleep about Edo people trust me. And when your people wanted the Midwest region we allowed you to go unlike other premiers. All we seek and pray for is peaceful disintegration of One Nigeria where my people don't have to be in the same country with your kind.
It is actually the other way round fool, you guys are the ones "guming" us according to your English. Everyday stories that litters this thread about Benin from yorubas.

We don't want them to Be Edo, they are! They have no other Identity and yet we leave them to live their lives as separate groups. We are not forceful people.

Urhobos are only slightly larger than the Binis of today my brother. Bini was already big enough to divide as a state in 1996. Go and ask the Otaru of Auchi who has proposed that the state be divided in 1996. With Binis been given a separate state in 1996
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 5:42pm On Nov 27, 2022
BanyXchi:
I said no sane Yoruba gives a Bleep about your kind. We don't claim or have anything to do with y'all and we can't to seperate from your kind when Nigeria disintegrates.
No part of Yorubaland belongs to a minority tribe that can't even claim more than 7LGA. I'm from Ondo state and I don't have anything to do with your kind.
You claim that Yorubas wants y'all and you still want to gumbody to some of us. Focuss on your women wasting away in Italy and your sons getting wasted away by the cultists in your state. Why do you think a ethnic group like Yoruba will care about your kind? You're so deluded and pathetic.
And you are not schooled enough to know local government is not a yardstick for population strength. And you only need 50,000 as population strength to create a local government in Nigeria, Urhonigbe, Abudu and Oza are each beyond 50,000 and they are in one local government let alone the several towns and villages in Orhiowmon alone
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 5:41pm On Nov 27, 2022
AreaFada2:
Whether sane Yoruba, slave Yoruba, alloy Yoruba, impure Yoruba, mixture Yoruba or whatever Yoruba, you guys should just stop dragging Benin into your history. It was your Alake of Egbaland ranking Oba of Benin among Yoruba Kings last time. Please go and handle it with him if he is pure Yoruba or not, I don't care. It you promise no sane Yoruba claims or associate with Benin, then your region must be full of Aro and Yaba Left. Because your people are doing it daily, even here on NL.

Remember that Benin led referendum in 1963 to breakaway from colonial contraption called Western Region. Know your history first. Benin distanced itself from you guys. We have not only waited to separate but have actually done what has been legally possible to separate.

By the way, we know which parts of Yoruba historically belonged to Benin Empire. The history, culture and norms confirm it. Not the other way round. Go and ask Oba of Lagos, Obanikoro, Eletu odibo, people of Upele and swathes of Eastern Yorubaland and many more their history directly. Go to the palaces directly to ask.

Just stop your obsession with claiming Benin is part of Yoruba. Please begin with telling Alake. Once you guys stop being arrogant, believing that nobody else went to school, forming being over-sophisticated, only then there will be peace.

Thank you.

Samuk, EGBE634
You quoted me with Egbe, how do you expect me to see it, don't roll with the pig. He is obviously pained
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 1:10pm On Nov 27, 2022
macof:
Well they can cry on the Internet all they like, serious work has been done and is still being done by scholars
They can't change it grin
A very poor explanation that took you time to bring out, na you be the scholar, you be Ozour abeg
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 12:03pm On Nov 27, 2022
macof:
not only do we have but it can even be broken down. Yoruba has even done a better job at retaining the use and meanings of the etymons of these common words.

Ùgbé from Gbé - to live /reside
Mímọ́/Mímá - holy, goodness. from mọ́ - to be clean, without blemish
I don't think I agree with both but it's fine
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 11:12am On Nov 27, 2022
macof:
Every word here (except Ndo) has been established by historical linguists to be relics from Proto-YEAI
Nobody borrowed anybody any of these
do you guys have Ogbe and Oma
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634:
RedboneSmith:
Yes, I know. I will not be surprised if Yorùba also has a similar 'du' word for Lion as well. Because all these are sister-languages.

If you look at linguistics, you would know about something called YEAI languages. These are Yoruboid (of which Igala is a branch), Edoid, Akokoid and Igboid. Linguists tell us that these languages all descend from a common language in the distant past called Proto-YEAI. Thus, there are cognates found throughout the languages.

Now having cognates doesn't mean that there are no words that were still borrowed across these sister languages in later times.

For example, Igbo borrowed the word ugegbe for mirror from Edo. The etymologically Igbo word for mirror is enyo. Ugegbe was borrowed. Igbo also borrowed several titles from the Edo.

There were also linguistic items that were borrowed from Igbo to Edo, even though people never seem to want to talk about that, and get agitated when it is brought up, and think you're attempting to attack or belittle their culture/civilization.

Etymological analysis of the Edo word for skirt, (ubuluku) for instance, suggests the word has Igbo roots. If you ask an Edo person to break the word ubuluku apart and explain it, he wouldn't be able to. But an Igbo person can. To a linguist this would suggest the direction of diffusion of the word

Which brings us to Idu. I am still to meet an Edo person who can etymologically explain it, the way it is explainable in Igbo. All I have been told by you all is that it has a very long antiquity among the Edo. A lexical item might exist in a language community for 20,000 years and still have its roots outside that language community. Antiquity is not really a counter-argument against foreign provenance.

One question to keep in mind is: Why your other neighbours don't use that word for you. Why is it only recollected by your Igbo-speaking neighbours.
the yoruba name for Lion is kuniun, it is not even close to .I see it as every group has a name for Edo as at the time they related with her. Urhobo-Aka
Igbo-Idu
Esan-Edo

Same way we cannot interprete Edo sufficiently but it was the name of a Bini servant at the time
and so on, why don't the Igbos used the naming pattern of the Urhobo for us. a peculiar name for Edo is not restricted to Igbo. and as have explained before, it has to do with the dominant activities or name of the person that was on ground, there were different epoch in Bini history. Igbo is ancient, Edo Is ancient, it certainly is for the fact that they know the Bini or Edo "founder" or ancestor by name that's why they call us his children

take for example, the name Esan call Bini today which is Edo was given to Benin just some years before Esan migrated enmasse out of Benin by the person under whose reign they migrated

I have been called Ndi-Idu by Igbos when I was in Sabon-gari when I was in Egbe and we know what that means child of Idu or Offspring of Idu as they interpreted for me. This is my take on this matter.

Idu as a word is not what we don't know, Idu as a word is not close to Idun at all or people, it would not make any sense given the fact now that it was the name of a person in Benin, and the fact that there are lineages tied to him which is undeniable evidence that he lived. Idu as a word would mean something mysterious
IDU-AGBON- It means the deep mysteries of the world
ODU-AGBON-it means the deep mysteries of the world
You cannot wish the undeniable evidences that abound in Benin, if you were not watering down the civilization, you would have considered these evidences and shift your ground a bit. I don't think the Binis would name any shrine, there are lineages after him,and you would now start looking at the fact that the Binis have a shrine, two mighty lineages because the Igbos called us Idunoba
It is rather the other way round. They saw that Idu was our principal man at the time, and his lineages are evidences that he lived, then he evolved into a shrine as with great individuals. The relationship between Edo and Igbo is very ancient, it predated the Oba's dynasty, he came in 1200.

The fact that Idu as a word means a group of people and Igbos started calling us a group of people does not really tally. There were several kingdoms and towns around, Idu as a word would not have been specific to anybody if that was the meaning.

They called us who we are. Cc samuk, Areafada2
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 7:55pm On Nov 26, 2022
samuk:
Now imagine asking some of the younger Benin people to read that list, it will probably sound foreign to them.
certainly that's why the person sponsoring it used an Old man.
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 7:51pm On Nov 26, 2022
samuk:
Did you notice how some of the family greetings in that YouTube videos you shared sounds. When you listen to them being read out, you can hear sounds similar to modern Igbo and modern yoruba words. It seems old Benin goes back to the root of most modern southern languages. Most of these family greetings can't be properly pronounced by some present day Benin people and most will struggle with some of the meanings and how they were developed. It's probably only unique to Benin in Nigeria, if not rest of the world.
The man pronouncing it is old, there are some pronunciations,if you watch the video, there Is "go slow" in his speech, and he gets surprised about how those family names sounds. That man can not be less than 70
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634:
samuk:
It just goes back to my earlier point of the older kingdoms of Benin and Igala influencing modern day Igbo. Ovie-Udu also means strong hearted or lion heart in Benin. Ovie-udu, udu, Oduma all references lion in Benin. The root du will seem to be from same Benin and Igala source from antiquity because it seems to have similar meaning in both Benin and Igala. I hope our Igbo friend is learning. grin imagine people that know nothing about Benin history trying to tell it. The Benin themselves are still scratching the surface of their vast history.
The Benin language is deep, it is not what anyone can define, that's why I normally use pidgin for my translation,and many a times I will still feel I have not pushed my point home enough. There has been scenarios where I will understand somethings in my mind, if I cannot really bring it to bare in english or pidgin, I will just leave it so I will not alter the meaning
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 4:40pm On Nov 26, 2022
RedboneSmith:
Idu in Igbo means "a group of people" or "a bush". When we refer to Benin as Idu n'ọba, what it literally means to us is 'The Oba' s people' or 'the people under the Oba'

I'm aware that in Igala, Idu could mean a lion or a task.

Note that in Igbo, lion is odum or eduke. Notice the du root, which also found in the Igala word for it, suggesting that the Igbo and Igala words for lion are cognates.

Anyway, it appears that the Igala 'idu' is cognatically different from the Benin 'Idu'.
Do you also know the word Oduma means Lion in Benin. cc samuk.
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634: 3:32am On Nov 26, 2022
samuk:
Ogiefa family palace is in Benin. Benin history is too deep for some of these guys.
Yes I know I mean origin, where there are two or more families having the same lineage greetings, it shows strongly that they are related. No matter where they are today in the world. The descendants of the Enogie of Ehor and the Oba of Benin both greets Lamogun. I don't need a soothsayer to be told that the present Enogie of Ehor (that is if there is any dynasty in Ehor before now) descended from the Oba's family even if they are both recognized as separate lineages in the 74 Bini lineage.

I am also aware there is a mighty Eriwmin-Idu shrine in Udo. Most persons I have seen with the La-Idu lineage greeting, are from Udo, that shows the Origin is undeniably Udo, Except for the La-ovbieze lineage, which is not really a lineage, as one can be assimilated into the La-ovbieze group when one becomes an Iyase. The others are essentially brothers and if a lineage is not so large, they will even refuse you marrying from them
Culture › Re: Fact About Pa Idu by UGBE634:
RedboneSmith:
Idu as a historical person is very unlikely. Idu is an exonym, a name given to Benin by Igbo people. It is an Igbo term (with Igbo meanings), and not an Edo term. It's re-invention as a person is likely the result of latter-day mythopoesis.
I don't think so, there might just have been a pa Idu. He is certainly one of the father's of Binis oldest families. There is a family in Benin that has Laidu as their mode of greeting. I don't know if this helps in anyway

It would be hard to say there was not a pa Idu when about two solid families that might be in their hundreds of thousands greet La-Idu.

This is Edo language greeting 4 on YouTube, on time stamp 9:35, you will see where the man there talked about the family of Ogiefa greeting La-Idu.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5LCaxmPdxQU

This is Edo language greeting 5 on youtube, on time stamp 7:45, you will see where the man there talked about the family or descendants of Idu himself greeting La-Idu.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BOBY3QxokR0

Hence it would be hard to say there was not an actual Pa Idu when he has descendants everywhere using his name to show that he was once here and alive. These families are majorly from Udo. One of Binis most ancient community.

He must have been the earliest to settle here in Bini that is why they call him our father pa idu. but his descendants are strong uncontested evidence that he was once alive.

There are more to this things than meet the eye, I believe that's why the Igbos call us Ndi-Idu. The eldest family they met on ground as at the time they related strongly with Benin was this pa Idu. cc samuk

I believe most other Bini indigenous lineages were breakaway lineages from him
Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634: 8:42pm On Nov 23, 2022
Igboid:
So why do your Bini brothers not apply the same principles as the above when they start meddling devilishly into Western Igbo issues telling us they're no longer Igbos despite their Igbo language, because of few insignificant and irrelevant non Igbo migrants into the area that were drowned by the sea of indigenous Igbo speaking population they met?

Why would Bini people not let Ndiigbo in the SE and our brothers in Anioma discuss our in-house issues in peace without trying to meddle? If you were Igbo, wouldn't you find the Edo interference into Igbo speaking territories provocative?
I consider Ika igbo, I am a realist.
Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634: 8:31pm On Nov 23, 2022
Igboid:
Well, Binis have had the audacity to tell Western Igbo history and even Eastern Igbo one through their Edo tinted glasses, so much that Ndiigbo have been forced to start telling Edo and Bini stories through our own glasses.
What is good for the goose is also good for the gander.

Bini to me is a mixture of different groups. Bini is a hybrid relatively new ethnic group made up of indigenous Edoid tribes which includes the Oza, Esan, etc. Some migrant Igbo clans, Ijaw, and the rulling class which is of Yoruba origin, there is also some sprinkle of Portuguese there as well.
That's Bini for you.
It not a single ethnic group. It's an amalgam, heck they are still speaking Yoruba in Usen, Igbo(Ika) in places outside Igbanke like Owariuzo etc, and Ijaw in Olodiama, and all these places are still considered part of Bini ethnicity.

Here is what Agbor historian Chief E.A Iduwe had to say about Agbor and Bini relationship with Ozara people.
You are up in arms at my suggestion that Oza are independent from Bini according to Ika history,your argument is that it can't be since Bini and Oza speak mutually intelligible language, but you have no problem when your mischievous brothers run amok telling us how Aboh and parts of Anioma despite being Igbo speaking are not Igbo.
Talk about dishing out what you guys can't take.


Well, here is what Agbor historian, E.A Iduwe had to say about Ozara.
guy your idea about what Bini is is messed up. We don't consider Olodiama and Owa-riuzo as Binis, we consider Usen Bini because of Some Factors, these factors are 1. They speak Bini alongside with their dialect. 2. They did not migrate to Bini today, they migrated alongside with the Oba, and they have a family mode of greeting, which is Lahuihe, to show they migrated from Ife, there are seventy four families in Benin, each or most greet in a certain way.
3. They celebrate the Igue festival. These are what cement a man as a Bini. You must have a family greeting, you speak the tongue, then your community must celebrate Igue festival.

I have discussed that Esan before, I don't intend going back there. Esan, Oza are all dialects of Benin and they migrated from Benin. There is no group that did not receive migrant precolonially, The Oba and his family has been submerged into the large Edo sea they met and today Edo speaking. Benin is not an amalgam of groups, we received immigrants, quite alright, but they are in the super minority and they all submerged in the large Edo indigenous sea they met on ground

And also Igboid, go and tell an Aibiokunla man that he is not Bini, I can promise you that you will get a black eye, I promise you that. You have to be specific about the Oza
Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634: 7:37pm On Nov 23, 2022
Igboid:
Ugbo Ozegbe and Ossai are not Edo names.

Ugbo means farm or boat in Igbo depending on pronunciation.
Essumai two sons are Ugbo( farm) and Ogwaezi ( home founded on the road).
Both are Igbo names.
The children of Ogwaezi who constitute the rulling house of Aboh are "Ojugbeli, Ossai, and Ozegbe.
Only Ozegbe sound Bini there, and who knows, Ozegbe might actually be a shared word between Agbor ( where I suspect to be hometown of Essumai) and Bini.
E.A Iduwe stated that the few words Agbor share with Bini were as a result of both Bini and Ika absorbing the ancient Oza people.
So it might be simplistic to assume that Ozegbe is a Bini name, when Ika bear it as well.
Aboh got it from Ika.

I should be posing the Opute of Ozoro question to you.
Igbos have never played the ancestry game. It's common sense that Oputa settled in Isoko dominated land and hence he and his Descendants naturally lost their Igbo language as it should. They are now Isokos just like Igbide people who left Igboland to assimilate as Isokos today as well. Igbos respect Isokos and don't go about talking about Isoko being a hybrid of Igbo and should not be called Isoko.

Apart from Opute, there was also Etim and Osu-mili who accompanied Essumai on the journey from where I believe to be Agborvand and not Bini. They all ventured into Isoko dominated territories and lost their language.
I might just think you are delusional, Oza is one of those Bini group that left Bini to seek protection under Agbor, there is no word that is Edo in Agbor that Ika people can interprete. There is nothing like a shared word, it is a borrowed word 100%. How will Benin absorb Oza people, guy stop speaking on these issues, you sound delusional, Oza is at best a dialect of Bini and the closest for that matter, we can stake a bet maybe we see real life, there is nothing an Oza man will say that I a Bini man will not comprehend, We have a different version of that history, Oza is an offshoot of Bini. They ran away to Agbor for protection because they offended the Oba at the time. Oza Aibiokunla consider themselves full Binis I don't know about nogogo. If they do or do not, they are! Chris Idahosa, a music maestro in Benin, Fabomo, Richard Ugiagbe, Stanley Iyonawan, Naomi Ehigie, and others are from Oza, and they are music maestros in Benin in the Bini native tongue. Infact they make up the largest chunk of Edo music.

Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634: 10:55am On Nov 23, 2022
RedboneSmith:
Excuse me. You say Ugbo, Ozegbe and Ossai are clearly Edoid.

Ozegbe, I know to be Edo, meaning patience.
Ugbo is a shared word meaning farm in both Igbo and Edo. Both languages are related Niger-Congo languages and share a good number of words in common. It cannot be taken for granted therefore that the Ugbo in question indicates Edoid roots.

Now, how did you come to the conclusion that Ossai is an Edo word? This is a name/word that exists as Ossai/Ohai/Osayi across a number of Igbo-speaking spaces (including Nsukka in the East) and which also penetrated Igala as Ochayi.
According to an Igbo dictionary by professor Echeruo, it means Juju.

Can you explain what it means in Edoid and also find one Benin/Edo person who answers Ossai.
We bear Osayi strongly but I don't know of Ossai and it means God create

The etymology is this Osa ore yi- which means na God dae create or na God create
Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634:
AreaFada2:
We Benins are not even claiming anybody. We just say what history says. Does anybody admitting or denying that they migrated from Benin puts food on your table or removes money from your account? No, it doesn't! In fact, I would like Edo State population to grow big enough that Edo State can be divided. Benin/Edo State and Edo Central & North can form their own State. Internal cohesion is vital for development. The more homogeneous a State is, the better long term.

Since Delta State was created, there is more distance between Edo People and Urhobo, Isoko and Itsekhiri. At some point in the future, all can decide if they want to co-operate or not.

With gradual distancing, co-operation will be more a matter of genuine desire to do so or forever let it be.
I am for purity too,but the truth must be said. Edo is already big enough for division, it was to be divided in 1996, the Benins on their own, Esan and Afemai on their own. The Otaru of Auchi was already intimidated by the population of Binis and asked for a separate state but for Anenih that thwarted the plan.Edo state cannot be less than 8,000,000 with the Binis about half the population of the state.

Edo was rated 3,000,000 in 2006 with obviously smaller states such as Osun and Ondo being giving 4, million as figures and Edo was rated 24 largest in terms of population in 2006, this same Edo did number 16 in terms of voters registration in the country in 2019 trumping both Ondo and Osun with about 400,000 and 600,000 respectively with even a lot of unregistered voters everywhere. though the other just conducted her state election.

Go on youtube, search for Itv and see people in various registration centres not registered. With the present registration, it should be about 14 highest and people are still not registered in large numbers, if it is to reduce Obi's vote in Edo, I don't know. In the Otaru's words, he said Edo south was big enough to stand alone
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://guardian.ng/sunday-magazine/otaru-of-auchi-how-we-lost-out-in-the-bid-to-create-afemesan-state/&ved=2ahUKEwjpk5Ot_OL0AhWNxYUKHfaDDmoQFnoECAQQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0LaFfDTyS-rnpL90Yyv0Qu
Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634:
Igboid:
Go to Esan blog on Facebook and tell them they originated from Bini and see what their reply would be.

Like I said earlier, I only started getting interested in Edo history because of the meddling of Edo people into Western Igbo history.
Nobody has said they originated from Benin, but that we were actually one people before their migration, I can understand Edo language, as a result to a large extent, I understand Esan too. Infact my paternal grandmother was Esan from Edenu-irrua

What I am trying to say Is this, would an Esan man now tell me that did not migrate from anywhere that I met him on ground, where exactly? The Binis they are referring to are the yoruboid sect which in all their glory would not make up more than six to seven percent of the population of Binis. Many persons have this belief that all of Binis migrated, it is not true, infact we indigenous Binis are the majority. When you hear of a Community like Ugo, Urhonigbe even with all its "localness" should be about 100,000 or more do not have an history of migrating from anywhere. Infact Urhonigbe is close to Abavo and about 855km square in size, about seven percent of Binis lay ancestry to that town and migrated from that town to other new Towns in Benin kingdoms. Even Udo, you must have heard of it. Many Binis hold ancestry to it too. That Concocted tale from Ife or from a northerly origin are just for a few set. That idea that we met Esans on ground are for those foreign Binis who migrated to one of Bini towns which is known as Benin- city today and has however grown in size to incorporate other Bini towns around.

Whether they are comfy with the name Bini or not. They were one and the same item with the people called Bini or Edo today who were residing in an area called Benin city. Many Binis are not even comfy with the name Binis, so it depends. But the length and breadth of the whole issue is that their name Esan was gotten from the fact that they ran away from Benin city which we call Edo in our local dialect. And they were one and the same people with the inhabitants of this city.
Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634: 6:17pm On Nov 21, 2022
Igboid:
The Esans don't recognize history of origin from Bini.
They don't suffer same Stockholm syndrome as some Western Igbos.
The Esans claim that you Bini people met them on their land.
I don't know which is which.
I'm not Edoid and don't have interest in wading into Edoid issues.
I'm only concerned with Igbo ones.
That's a lie, some Binis might have met Edos on ground but those Edos were certainly not Esan, as Esans are part of a product of the mixture. I am one of those Edos they met on ground, not every Bini or Edo migrated. I am from Ugo, the same with other Bini indigenous communities,eg urhonigbe, Udo and others. These communities are Indigenous and their inhabitants thereof. And they are Bini speaking.
Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634: 6:05pm On Nov 21, 2022
Igboid:
The Binis are a mixture of Igbo, Ijaw, Yoruba, Portuguese and Esans.
The Ijaws are a mixture of Edo, Igbo, Ibibio and Izon.
The Isoko are a blend of Igbo, Ijaw and Urhobo

So Binis are no longer Bini because they had admixtures in them, and the Ijaws are no longer Ijaw Ijaws and Isoko are no longer Isokos.
Or does this mixture thing only work for Igbo speaking groups outside SE? grin
Is there any group in this world that didn't accomodated and assimilate non indigenous migrants?

Aboh Igbo denial has not helped them.
Instead it has made them backwards, while ASABA has taken their place in terms of leading place in Western Igbo land where Igbos from SE happily invest in.
Whatever non Igbo admixture in Aboh is not even up to 1% of their population, which is why their culture, language, names and traditional religion are Igbo rooted.

However, each to his own.
Any thing that would make Bini mixed already came to Benin before the 15th century. It was these mixed Binis that later went on to become Esan. We call them Edo ni san fia( meaning Edos that fled into the Bush) Edos that could not withstand the harsh laws made by Oba Ewuare after the death of his two sons. Esans themselves are a product of the mixture you talked about

The dialectical similarities show that Bini and Esan were actually one group before their migration to their present abode from Benin in the 15th century.

The Esan dialect is a feed off of The Bini language, the difference between the two is more on intonation and pronunciation than actual words. Infact when you get a hold of a Bini and an Esan dictionary, the similarities of word in the word bank is up to 75 to 80 percent in most of their clans. It is certainly more but I can defend 75 to 80 percent.

The little difference in dialect today is as a result of being away from the mother stock for about 600 years. Hence the saying in Benin, Edo na ma ze se ore Esan. Edo not spoken well is Esan. A further proof to this is the igueben dialects which is the last to migrate is considered Bini by Esans themselves
Culture › Re: The Igbos From Benin by UGBE634: 6:26pm On Nov 20, 2022
Igboid:
There are no such "irrefutable" evidence of anyone migrating from Bini to Aboh.
What we have are unsubstantiated oral histories.
The Igbo area on both sides of the River Niger was always more populated than Edo areas even up to today.
Population movement is usually from area of high population to area of lesser population.
The chances of a Bini speaking people migrating to a highly populated Western Igbo lands is very minimal.
Look at the name of Aboh founder, Essumai, his son was Ogwaezi, and all villages in Aboh bear Igbo names for ancestors and all prefixed with the usual "Umu" naming pattern of the Igbos.
Aboh founder migrating from Bini is not same as being of Bini ethnicity.
Aboh founder was probably an Ika man who lived close to Ika-Bini border.
we cannot vouch for the western side, there were issues that warranted migration out of Benin, close to 30% of what is Ika today are Benin migrants, up to 20% or more of What is known as Ukwuani are Bini Migrants, Aniocha and Oshimili are not spared, they received even though in smaller numbers. As historians, we know these issues, they included high-handedness of the Oba, and others which enabled migration that has rendered your postulation of high populated areas to low populated areas useless

And even today, we cannot so vouch for the population of western Igbos in Delta as being more numerous than the Binis, you have to quote actual proof, not just comment from arse

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 (of 27 pages)