Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,194,273 members, 7,954,069 topics. Date: Friday, 20 September 2024 at 11:51 AM

HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD - Career (6) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Career / HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD (51399 Views)

Can You Hold A First Class Degree And Be Jobless? / See How This Hausa Lady Who Is A 2nd Class Bsc Holder Makes Her Money In Abuja(p / Did You Graduate With A Pass Or Third Class? Here's A Word Of Advice For You. (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by hana1: 11:28am On Jul 08, 2016
yes,true talk.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Babysho(m): 11:30am On Jul 08, 2016
YOLO1:



I wonder which polythecnic gave u admission in the first place with this ur catastrophic grammar....... Now I think we now have a clue of what we are talking about. To me even a PASS in the university is better than being a HND holder


LOL, I know that guy's written grammar and probably spoken too is formidable but you cannot generalize that all Polytechnic students are poor students.

Although, Universities have lesser amount of poor students than Polytechnics but there is always that Polytechnic student that is as good as the best University student.

Some people just get fucqed over in this Barbaric Nigerian Educational System.

I got 223 in Jamb i.e (when Jamb was Jamb o) but I flopped my post ume in UI. They delayed the exam and I fell sick. So, I had to go for the Polytechnic that gladly welcomed me.

Right now, I'm probably going to graduate with pass. Over 1,000 students in one class without microphone, sometimes they lose your exam script and that's the end, it's a permanent zero. So you can see it's not that some are not smart but the situation in Nigeria is just fucqed. It's freaking fucqed.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by vickylala239: 11:30am On Jul 08, 2016
hotwax:


[size=15pt]You are right. It might be that your brain could not comprehend what I wrote.

The question you should be asking is:

Why can't BSC perform better than HND?

They were given the same task/project to complete. HND was able to deliver in a timely manner whereas BSC struggled.

How is that my fault? Get your little man sentiment out of here[/size]

And you are an employer of labour and your here exchanging hate, abusive wrds..

You Jst came here to claim this or that,no one knw weda ur saying d truth or not..

Cuz u culd actually fabricate story so are to push praises to ur own hnd....

Jst as anyone culd cum here to claim same....

Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by hotwax: 11:31am On Jul 08, 2016
Babysho:



LOL, I know that guy's written grammar and probably spoken too is formidable but you cannot generalize that all Polytechnic students are poor students.

Although, Universities have lesser amount of poor students than Polytechnics but there is always that Polytechnic student that is as good as the best University student.

Some people just get fucqed over in this Barbaric Nigerian Educational System.

I got 223 in Jamb i.e (when Jamb was Jamb o) but I flopped my post ume in UI. They delayed the exam and I fell sick. So, I had to go for the Polytechnic that gladly welcomed me.

Right now, I'm probably going to graduate with pass. Over 1,000 students in one class without microphone, sometimes they lose your exam script and that's the end, it's a permanent zero. So you can see it's not that some are not smart but the situation in Nigeria is just fucqed. It's freaking fucqed.


Says who? What are you talking about?
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by histemple: 11:32am On Jul 08, 2016
bozy4real:
Those in the university is just an opportunity to be thereis now as if those in tthe polytechnic at more brilliant.
Most polytechnic student that went back to university through direct entery are doing far far better than those the meet. His not my choice or our choice to go to polytechnic but when that was our best bet rather than wasting out time and been useless to our their nation n the world at large .
Am proud to be an HND holder if u have any problem with that go n join BH cheese,........,.

Bros, you need brighter grammar. The book will help you to improve on your understanding and use of English language.

I doubt if those arguing in favour of HND will be proud that you are one of them.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Bertogreg(m): 11:38am On Jul 08, 2016
All boils down to Nigerian factor. I got a job wth my HND, the requirements was frm second class upper/upper credit no chance for a third class graduate. The fact is that Bsc is over hyped in Nigeria and nothing is in it. To avoid the discrimination i had to pick up a direct entry form wth my HND into 300L(Engineering). I got a 4point sandwiching job and studies. A bad 3rd class can never be better than a good Lower credit hnd holder except if the 3rd class has another reason why he got it.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Babysho(m): 11:38am On Jul 08, 2016
hotwax:


This is it.

[size=15pt]I personally will take an HND Mechanical Engineer, Computer Scientist over their BSC counterpart.

However, Law, Medicine, accounting e.t.c is for University no doubt[/size]

Ofcourse.

The cause of the inbalance is clear. You don't see Polytechnics offer Law and Medicine then why should Universities offer Engineering and Technical courses.

Most people will think attending a University is their only way of getting education which is very wrong and what's with the allocation Giving Universities higher allocation than Polytechnics. Bull.

Please, for the sake of fixing this goddamned country. Govt, scrap Techinical and Engineering courses from Universities and make them exclusively available to Polytechnics.

It'll kill 17 birds with one stone.

1 Like

Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by humbleself242(m): 11:41am On Jul 08, 2016
vickylala239:



So What is your point then

Cuz I Dnt understand you...

You also posted you picture how do we connect this...

Does that picture mean that you are rich or What?

Thats What I don't get...
Did I need to say anything again than for u to knw that HND is far better than 3rd class Degree
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by SirAlfred(m): 11:46am On Jul 08, 2016
TonyRoland:
bt I can be a PRESIDENT with SSCE. we people sha stay dere dey tell me story for d gods.

Presidency is never a career office, you can go in there with ssce because it only requires political will to enforce. You can't head accounting department with ssce because it requires training
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Babysho(m): 11:52am On Jul 08, 2016
hotwax:


Says who? What are you talking about?


That is it! There's no platform for Polytechnic students to showcase how intelligent they are.

All countries need different sectors to grow. Nigeria needs from Uni---Medical Practicioners, Doctors , Lawyers as well as it needs from Poly---- Engineers , Technicians , Mechanics etc.

When Universities offers courses with better equipment because of greater allocation, that Polytechnics should offer, then there is a great inbalance.

If you continue to support that University students are better than Polytechnic students...I'll say you act as a fool will. The colonial masters left the educational system that way because it favoured the economy then, it means it can be changed to favour the economy now.

It's probably the inbalance in importance between Poly and Uni that's causing most Nigeria's problems sef.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by yinkobert(m): 11:52am On Jul 08, 2016
Fairgodwin:
I guess it all depends on the class of the HND (degree). If the HND is a distinction, then I will agree it is far better and more considerable/commendable than a BSc in the 3rd class category. But if it is lower credit HND (or even an upper credit at times) then I'll completely tell you the BSc 3rd class is more considerable/preferable to the HND.

Of course a distinction in HND is [supposed to be] better than a 3rd class BSc degree, but in any case, the average Nigerian person might not see it in that light.

My humble opinion, though.

PS there's a huge difference between 'being' and 'been' sir. The write up is very nice I must confess, but you used 'being' where you were supposed to use 'been.' I'm sorry I couldn't overlook it, because it always troubles me to see such mistakes.
weldone,you have eyes for details
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by teawhy2788(m): 11:53am On Jul 08, 2016
I'm proud to be an HND holder. I tutor many B.sc holders as far as my specialisation is concerned.It's a pity that all what I learned in my ND2 days,the so-called B.sc holders don't know anything abt it,so what are u nw saying? I read an application letter written by a B.sc holder,I was astonished. Imagine,a b.sc holder wrote this: I look forward to hear,I wish I can. It serves as a stigma to university and Nigerian Education

1 Like

Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by 9ise(m): 11:55am On Jul 08, 2016
around 90% of lecturers in Polytechnics are University products.. diz 1 of d reasons y d dichotomy still persist..
cool
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Nobody: 11:58am On Jul 08, 2016
Edubrazilnwa:
lol all these things still boils down to who you know.mehn but for me oo I rather have HND distinction than Bsc.3rd class..mehn shame ma sef no go dey gree me present d result
the funniest thing about this is that its harder to get a distinction in a polytecnic than first class in a uni
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Nobody: 12:04pm On Jul 08, 2016
histemple:


Bros, you need brighter grammar. The book will help you to improve your understanding and use of English language.

I doubt if those arguing in favour of HND will be proud that you are one of them.
the book will help you to improve......and u thought that is a better english.u need to check urself out first
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by tosyne2much(m): 12:05pm On Jul 08, 2016
HomoSapiien:


Truth is, I have passed through the wall of polytechnic (OND precisely) and I never for once observe this practical and theoretical aspects that people shout about, as one of the merit of going to a polytechnic.

The lecturers mainly dictate the content of their handouts in class and repeats same questions every year in their examinations. Even project; you just copy and paste it, pay 5k to your supervisor and you will earn your A or B.

I swear to God, if you end up with anything less than upper credit, then I believe the winch in your village are playing kiddo in your head.

I'm not pestering you to admit this but you know this is the truth.
Clap for yourself sir. You have spoken wisely
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Tmercy(m): 12:16pm On Jul 08, 2016
Fynestboi:
Most probably, contrary to your belief, this is no fight between HND and Degree, we are just here to check and balance. Having an HND and having a Third Class BSC Degree, which one is better concerning regards for each in the employment market.

First of all, Definition of Terms for some of us who might not be so sure of what HND and Third Class BSC are :

HND Holder is one who has completed a course program at a Polytechnic in Nigeria. The certificate awarded upon completion of the program is the Higher National Diploma (HND).

BSc Holder is one who has completed an undergraduate program at a University in Nigeria. The degree awarded upon completion of the program is a Bachelor Degree (BSc).

Now, my own opinion :
Since time past the HND has always being considered inferior to the BSc. This, at least, was the idea inculcated in us by the colonial masters and this mentality is what many of us still hold onto today, which is not supposed to be.

It is also important that we know that the university is an internationally recognized higher institution of learning all around the world. As such, a third class BSc holder may sometimes have the opportunity of furthering their studies in a way that the HND holder cannot because a BSc is recognized everywhere while same cannot be said for the HND. Besides, we look down on the HND ourselves in Nigeria, why then would international bodies regard it any more than we do.

Many employers today may not even include HND as one of the qualifications required for job vacancy positions. In light of this, HND holders may sometimes get automatically disqualified before even getting a chance at interview.

Another key point is, an HND holder may secure a good job real quick compared to a third class BSc holder, but the effect of this is that in the long run, a HND holder who fails to upgrade his certificate to a BSc may find himself bowing to that third class BSc holder (who has now added to his qualifications) whom he had left behind all those years ago.

Well, not to sound bias :

Over the years, Polytechnic graduates have proven themselves to be in no way inferior to their counterparts in the university.

Today, a polytechnic student can stand shoulder to shoulder with an undergraduate in the university and even surpass him/her. Besides, Polytechnics have being known to conduct more research and practical works than the university. This prepares the students adequately for what is needed to face the outside world.

In conclusion, it would be wrong of me to declare a third class degree as better than the HND.

So here we are, what's your view.

Graduating with an HND or a Third Class BSC Degree - Which is better?


SOURCE : http://eduregard.com/hnd-holder-vs-third-class-degree-bsc-holder/
Op some universities accepts HND for masters direct if u Ave a distinction or an upper, but I haven't seen d university dat will accept a third class without a PGD
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Godson32(m): 12:18pm On Jul 08, 2016
IstandWitBuhari:

Check most international scholarships what you see there is 1st ,2. 1 or 2. 2 , you will never see 3rd class or Hnd so stop disgracing your self in public by saying hnd distinction is better than a 2. 2 University graduate. A cgp of 3.4 9 is still a 2. 2 graduate.
Na so u hate HND holders reach? So person wey get HND no fit receive international scholarship for ur eye abi,clap for ur self,na wah to u o.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Globallords(m): 12:26pm On Jul 08, 2016
Hmm, a HND qualification with upper credit or distinction should be much considered
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by ademasta(m): 12:37pm On Jul 08, 2016
Following this
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Nobody: 12:44pm On Jul 08, 2016
histemple:


Good Question!

If you are conversant with the Polytechnic environment and the curriculum, you will observe that the main focus is on technical expertise. However, some of these course can't stand alone as some element of management is required.

A mechanical engineering student for example, need to understand what is Project management and project financing. This was basically why you have those departments as Bus. Admin and Accountancy. If you check the course outline of any engineering student, you will find management and computer courses in it.

There are also other areas where technical assistance is required. Such areas are Zoology, SLT, etc but such graduates are only needed to provide technical assistance and not to head the organization or departments.

The foregoing notwithstanding, you can still find students of Mass Communication, Entrepreneurship, Psychology etc in the Polytechnic-------perhaps due to admission challenges or frustration.

thanks for the enlightenment..
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by hotwax: 12:46pm On Jul 08, 2016
vickylala239:


And you are an employer of labour and your here exchanging hate, abusive wrds..

You Jst came here to claim this or that,no one knw weda ur saying d truth or not..

Cuz u culd actually fabricate story so are to push praises to ur own hnd....

Jst as anyone culd cum here to claim same....

[size=15pt]
Let me explain how it works. I am not the employer of Labor.

There is HR department...

And there is my department. I must ensure whoever HR department is bringing possesses technical abilities required to deliver projects.

Cooked up story or not. Ask any IT employer around you. Same is the story.

HND/BSC does not count when it comes to Engineering and Technology.

HND even have an edge when it comes to practicals.[/size]
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Synthase(m): 12:48pm On Jul 08, 2016
Ask those working in a polytechnic, monotechnic and maybe colleges of education whether in federal or state, they will likely tell you that they belong to the same cadre and would follow same line of career progression. This may be different in a private sector where given a level playing field, the sheep may be separated from goat...
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Abdul4trust1(m): 12:58pm On Jul 08, 2016
Thanks To God The Giver Of Knowledge And Wisdom. I'm HND Graduate, I'm Far Better Than A Lot Of University Graduates. I'm Talking From Experience.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by oloworulz(m): 1:02pm On Jul 08, 2016
tosyne2much:
Dey dia dey deceive urself grin grin
am serious, Dats d truth, I was shocked when I saw my colleagues appointment letter. many things are happening under ur Nose. o boy, u better start connecting yourslf. bsc degree is d deal right now
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by nnaemekanwachuk(m): 1:04pm On Jul 08, 2016
tosyne2much:
I don't think there's a general rule that a university student will definitely be better than a polytechnic graduate. I think it has to do with individual differences and perhaps
, how you're able to develop and equip yourself


Though, I can't speak for others but I can at least speak for myself.. I have HND in view and to the glory of God, I can confidently compete with any university student (area of specialization apart) It without being sidelined. I have had the opportunity to do certain things with many university students and my influence is greatly being felt that it keeps them misconception they have for polytechnic students.

Both university and polytechnic students can both be half-baked, they can both be dumb heads, they can both be unproductive and unemployable in the labour market, they can both goof when put to test, they can both be grammatically deficient. In fact, an SSCE holder may even perform better than both of them

So, in a nutshell, a university graduate can be better than polytechnic graduate and vice versa

The fact that others were not privileged to attend a university is not enough reason to unjustly rule out discriminating conclusion just because you want to look superior in their presence. Only broke and jobless people bother themselves with such an uncalled juxtaposition in order to bring other people down just to feel superior.


My 2cent cool
lt just the real fact...

1 Like

Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by oloworulz(m): 1:09pm On Jul 08, 2016
olatunji390:


How did u do that?
am not saying bsc products are better than HND products. but the truth is u have to have what the society demands. the person that helped me asked if am a university graduate or polytechnic. and I told him am a bsc holder. he said very good. he didn't even complain abt my 3rd class.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by gbagyiza: 1:17pm On Jul 08, 2016
EduRegard:
Having a third class degree doesnt necessarily mean one isn't brilliant.

I can't pass tru university n graduate with a third class, to me is n insult.

You might want to see : How A Nigerian Got A Job With His Third Class Degree

And it's not all about good grades, See : Reasons Why First Class Students Hardly Become First Class People In Life

And also as a thrid class graduate, See : 7 Solid Tips On How To Make It With A 3rd Class Degree


Thanks.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by Darnyel: 1:17pm On Jul 08, 2016
As much as people have made brilliant comments, many have derailed from the actual context. I think the Mod actually relate the topic to the perception or opinion of most of the employers.
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by olatunji390(m): 1:19pm On Jul 08, 2016
oloworulz:
am not saying bsc products are better than HND products. but the truth is u have to have what the society demands. the person that helped me asked if am a university graduate or polytechnic. and I told him am a bsc holder. he said very good. he didn't even complain abt my 3rd class.

That's god help
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by tosyne2much(m): 1:36pm On Jul 08, 2016
oloworulz:
am serious, Dats d truth, I was shocked when I saw my colleagues appointment letter. many things are happening under ur Nose. o boy, u better start connecting yourslf. bsc degree is d deal right now
Alryt thanks bro cool
Re: HND Holder Vs Third Class Degree Bsc Holder: Which Is Better? - EDUREGARD by SirAlfred(m): 2:01pm On Jul 08, 2016
I respond for the third time to this matter because I am a career civil service. If you have good grade in HND, you maybe better positioned to securing job than the one who has third class in BSc. But the issue is on what happens at the workplace when you must have been given the job. The public/civil service rule says that on no account should an HND holder direct a BSc holder at the workplace. HND stops at level 14 while BSc stops at level 16 & 17 as the case may be.
It will interest you to know that in my office, the head of department is in level 10 while the there are many with HND who are in level 14 but due to the rule they weren't given the opportunity to head the development.
For private sector especially banking sector, it may favour the HNDs as I have seen many who rose to manager though they have backups. This should not discourage you from obtaining you HND though.

1 Like

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply)

Doctor Threatens His MD With Resignation Letter. Shares His Reaction. / Gal Pissetzky: 5 Things To Know About Hushpuppi's Lawyer / Is My Boss Forcing Me To Marry His Only Daughter?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 69
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.