Mazaje's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Mazaje's Profile › Mazaje's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 (of 290 pages)
The slaves of allah are patting themselves on the back after a nonsensical write-up that is filled with nothing but make belief DELUSIONS. . . .Interesting. . . . |
akered:Brilliant. . . . |
Abu Zola:And your evidence to show that what you have stated is not a LIE is what?. . . . |
ilosiwaju: . . . . . .Does any body know where the tomb of Jesus is located?. . . . . |
noetic16:You made a claim that you have empirical evidence to show that Yahweh created birds magically by uttering words. . .Why are you back tracking? I will love to see you empirical evidence that shows that birds were created from a combination of Hebrew words. . . .I did not even talk about how birds came about you did and you also claim that you have empirical evidence that establish that fact so will you provide it or will you keep displaying your usual antics . . . .I appreciate your honesty. . . u dont know how plants came about, but I do.This is a claim and it does not serve as an evidence. . . .This claim that god created the plants is nothing different from scientist claiming that plants evolve from simpler life forms which evolved from the primordial soup. You will first of all have to show where the garden of eden is first before any body can even take your hypothesis seriously. . . . . and how do u read the bible?. . .upside down or what?You are only trying to rationalize the two completely different accounts of creation that were written by two completely different authors IMO. . .The bible does not even talk about any of the creation accounts as god's account or man's account, It is you that says so and I believe that there are so many other christians here in nairaland like OLAADEGBU that will disagree with you because they do not see it that way. . .It juts gives it's own hypothesis. . .According to genesis 1 plants were created on the 3rd day and the sun and stars were created on the 4th day, That is what the bible says, Your redefinition does not matter at all here to me, The bible says so and so it remains. . . .You can throw the bible under the bus all you like but I will go by what it says. . . why then would God have to plant a garden and get it watered, as the verses above shows? why would the garden of eden be subject to the primordial definition of photosynthesis if your assertions are true?Where does the bible talk about photosynthesis? The creation account in genesis 1 which is different from the one in genesis 2 says that plants were created on the 3rd day before the sun was created. . .Your redefination is very telling I must say. . . Gen1: 11 And God said, Let the earth bring forth grass, the herb yielding seed, [and] the fruit tree yielding fruit after his kind, whose seed [is] in itself, upon the earth: and it was s[/b]o. Gen 1:12 [b]And the earth brought forth grass, and herb yielding seed after his kind, and the tree yielding fruit, whose seed [was] in itself, after his kind: and God saw that [it was] good. Gen 1:13 And the evening and the morning were the third day. with due respect. , . I find it absolutely ridiculous that I am being made to reconcile a scientific "attempt" at explaining the solar system with biblical accounts. I find this ridiculous simply because this "attempt" gives an order at which these elements came into existence by stating that the sun came into existence before the moon. . .yet this same scientific notion cannot explain just how the very origins of life as we see it today came into existence? how the pioneer concepts of life kick started? the very source of this life as we know it today? how then does the scientific notion of the sun coming first into existence become plausible?What has the god did it hypothesis ever explained? NOTHING. . . .What was holding the earth and the other planets in in orbit before the sun was created if we are to go by the genesis hypothesis? How were asteroids, dwarf planets and other bodies in our solar system formed? Did your god speak them into existence using Hebrew too? ![]() However, Let me indulge you. . . . . . .The biblical account does not mention other planets because the writers of the bible DID NOT KNOW that other planets existed. They did not even know what the stars were, They did not know that the stars were distant suns. . . . . 2. if we analyse the biblical accounts we would realise that there was no form of life on the planet, prior to creation, as such it is plausible to state that the earth (in a lifeless state) existed long before the sun. To state that the earth came into existence after the sun was made is to suggest that the earth consist some form of life at the point of inception. . . . .there is NO scientific notion that makes this claim. . . . .Pls read about planetary formation and explain to me how the scientific explanation agrees with the genesis hypothesis. . . .Your scientific evidence that the earth in its lifeless state existed before the sun is what?. . . .What was holding the earth and the other planets in orbit before the sun was created since we now know that it is the sun's magnetic force that holds the earth and other planets in orbit and provides them with energy. . .I can't believe that you are making this ridiculous claim. . . .Again what was holding the earth and other planets in orbit and providing them with energy before the sun was created if were are to go by the genesis hypothesis?3. whether the sun was made before the moon or they were both made on the same day as stated by the bible. . is of little or no difference if u consider the fact that the sun gives the moon its light. . .but the moon rules predominantly at night.The bible does not say that the sun gives the moon its light. . .The genesis hypothesis says that Yahweh magically created two lights at the same time. . . .How does the moon rule at night, what does it rule over? and on what basis do u make this assertion?Google how oil and gas are formed and show me where it says that magical input from a deity is needed for oil and gas to form. . . . from verse 16 we understand that greater lights were made to give light to the earth. . . . . .would this not imply that the stars had other purposes?Do the writes of the genesis account know anything about the stars? The answer is NO. . .do they know that some of the stars are just like our sun with planets revolving around them? It is absurd to claim that the stars were created to give light to the earth. . . .gazillion of stars many with planets revolving around them like our sun created just to give light to the earth? You musk be kidding. . . . by being the predominant "element" in the sky at night.What about the stars? And what about the days that the moon does not even appear in the night sky?. . . . .The moon is NOT the predominant element in the Night sky, there are stars so many stars that are also predominant in the night sky. . . .Again I ask how does the moon rule over anything? When I come out at night I do not see the moon ruling over anything. . . . |
Abu Zola: ![]() |
beneli:Did Richard Dawkins really make those statements? I will like you to provide evidence from credible sources that he did. . . .I say this because creationist websites are known for claiming or putitng words into people mouths. . .As for the probability calculus assertion which claims that it is impossible for Abiogenesis to have occurred I will like to provid a rebuttal to that claim from talk origins. . . . . . http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/abioprob/abioprob.html and http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/abioprob/borelfaq.html |
Abu Zola:Atheist are animals just like all human beings are animals. . . .Nice try Mr Abuzo-lala. . . . ![]() |
Abu Zola:Your evidence to show that the Jesus talked about in the bible and the Isa of the koran is what?. . . . |
Abu Zola:Abuzo-lalalala. . . .PLS go and sleep you need rest. . . Tomorrow you can come and entertain us with more of your "la-la". . . .I bet Vairo will be expecting to see the revelations of the la-la. . . . . ![]() |
@ OLAADEGBU Where is the empty tomb of Jesus? Does it exist at all? If it does then where is it? |
Abu Zola: Abuzo-lala. . . .Kwana biu?. . .Gaisuwa nake, kuma ina fatan kayi bukin sabuwar shekara lafiya. . . . . |
Abu Zola:Vairo has exposed your ignorance over and over again and you are still talking about exposing his ignorance? No wonder you are a "la-la". . . Abuzo- lala the comedian that never stops giving. . . . |
noetic16:Same old noetic and his antics. . . .Here is what you said. . ."The "God did it" hypothesis has provided empherical and common sensical evidences which establish that God indeed did the things He did.". . . So your empirical evidence that establish that birds were allegedly spoken into existence is WHAT?. . . .I did not make any claim weather birds came into existence by chance, You were the one that says that you have empirical evidence that establishes the claim that Yahweh created the birds by magically uttering Hebrew words. . .Where is that empirical evidence? when did scientists become infallible? in your previous post u admitted the ignorance and limitations associated with science? did scientist not previously state that the earth was flat? what exactly do u understand by science, if i may ask?I don't know how plants and animals came about, You claim you do and I will like to see your empirical evidence that shows that plants were magically brought into existence with Hebrew words. . . . 1. The mere fact that the entire earth surface is dominated by 70% water is enough hypothesis to understand that the earth as described in genesis was contained with water until the creation began.The genesis hypothesis claims that there was water and plants on earth BEFORE the sun and the other stars were magically created on the 4th day of creation according to the hypothesis. . . .How does this hypothesis agree with the scientific position with regards to solar and planetary formation? 2. there is no where in the biblical accounts where plants are said to precede the sun (from human manifested point of view). I take it that u cannot find a comprehensive understanding of the accounts in the first two chapters of genesis to gasp the entire concept of creation.Are you redefining the genesis hypothesis or are you trying to throw the hypothesis under the bus by saying it does not say what it says? According to the hypothesis there was soil on the surface of the earth(The earth was created before the sun) and the plants were created on the 3rd day of the 6 days of creation and the sun and stars were not created until the 4th day of creation, That is what the hypothesis says and that is what I will go by not your redefinition of what it says. . . . 3. how does the creation of the moon and sun on the same day contradict the scientific explanation for the solar and lunar formation?A little study on the scientific explanation for solar and lunar formation will show you. . . .According to the scientific explanation the sun came first then the planets and after that the moon. . . .How do you reconcile that with the genesis hypothesis that says the earth came first and that the moon and sun were created on the same day?. . . . 4. would it not be ridiculous on your part to attempt to scrutinise the ability of the creator to create the components of the universe on the fourth day? at a point in time called BEGINING . . .the same creator made the heaven and earth. . . , .how do we decipher the time he created precious stones including gold and diamond, oil and gas? Since we cannot give these works a time-scale. . .would be meaningful to denounce the fact that they were created?The oil and gas all have natural explanations that does not require any input from any deity at all. . . . .Of course the sun, moon, planets and stars were created because we see them and we know what they are, we even have names for them that is not the issue, Do you know how the asteroids came about? If you do can you tell me? Did you god created the planets? How did he do it? Did he magically speak them into exsietence in Hebrew too?. . . .Saying that god did it explains NOTHING at all. . . .A better example lets assume that nobody really understands gravity or can provide substantial evidence for it. If I tell you that it exists because some invisible vacuum demons hidden in the Earth that cannot be experienced or seen by mere mortals put it there, What will you say? The fact that you cannot disprove that hypothesis, nor replace it with a better one, doesn't make it right at all. It makes it highly speculative at best, and more likely, just a convenient fiction. This my friend is the same with the God did it hypothesis. . . .It explains nothing beside the fact that it is only the default position of I don't know by the proponent of the god hypothesis as my man toneyb has said on another thread. . . . . 5. where in the bible did u read that the stars were created to give light?Gen 1:14 And God said, Let there be lights in the firmament of the heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, and for days, and years: Gen 1:15 And let them be for lights in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth: and it was so. Gen 1:16 And God made two great lights; the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night: he made the stars also and what scientific explanation prevents the moon from ruling by night?How exactly does the moon rule anything by night?. . . . happy new year mazaje.Same to you. . . . ![]() |
Abu Zola:This guy has REALLY lost it. . . .Abuzo-lalalalalalalalalalalalalalalalala. . . . . . . . . . .vairo pls don't dare the Abuzo-lalalalalalalala. . . . |
noetic16:
|
viaro:Why baby? I just want to see the credible sources(Like the NAS) that declare that naturalism is in adequate to provide explanations or evidence as to the origin of life as you said. . . . .I am not interested in any debates about what the dichotomy between explanation and evidence is. . .I just want to see the sources. . . .Pls don't consider this proposal as part of the debate but as me asking you to provide something for me. That is the one point that I would like to see - how NATURALISM provides explanations for the ORIGIN OF LIFE. Please set forth your hypotheses, theories, models, laws, etc. for the naturalistic explanations of the ORIGIN of Life, thank you.The short answer is we don't really know how life originated on this planet in the natural sense. Scientist try or propose various hypothesis using natural explanations. There have been a variety of experiments that try to tell us some possible roads,(Like Miller–Urey experiment). These are the way naturalism tries to explain the origin of life. Are the explanations acceptable or convincing enough? To some they are and to some they are not but they are explanations nonetheless. . . . . Let's be objective now, if you may. True, he is a scientist - and even if we ignore the philosophical basis of his statement, let's move over to the materialist/naturalist who argues to the contrary. You also made an assertion:. . and I await your own evidence for that. Please note carefully, we are talking here about the ORIGIN of Life.You are trying to run way here. . . . .Where did I make any argument to the contrary? I did not even say that life evolved or did not evolve by chance. I only challenged his claims based on the fact that he did not provide any objective basis for declaring that life can never evolve but had to come about only by the magical interference of a deity. . . . . |
Noetic happy new year. . . . noetic16:Your empirical and scientific evidence that says that Yahweh magically spoke(supposedly in the hebrew langauage) the birds into existence is WHAT? 2. You have largely admitted the limitations and ignorance associated with science. And u have also attempted to excuse this ignorance on the premise that it offers the best explanation on issues. . . No I strongly disagree.The scientific explanation is not plausible according to whom? If it is not plausible then why do scientist agree with its plausibility? Your scientific and empirical evidence to show that a living being that is allegedly uncreated gave life to plants and animals is what? What is the supernatural explanation for the existence of plants and animals? How did your god create a toad?. . . .How did he create a baobab tree? what really is science? if we are going by the lay man definition of science, then both the muslims and xtians are allowed to use scientific notion to justify their inherent claims. , Noetic my man when has the biblical claim stood the test of time when compared to scientific claims? The biblical creation stories would have us accept that the earth existed (complete with liquid water and plants) before the sun existed, How does that agree with the scientific process of solar and planetary formation? According to the creation accounts in genesis the the moon was created at the same time with the sun and also produces it's light, how does this claim agree with the scientific explanation about the solar and lunar formation? It also claims that it took 6 days to create our planet but a moment on the 4th day to create the rest of the universe (all the uncountable stars, nebulae, galaxies, etc); that humans have existed on this planet for most of its existence. How does this agree with the current scientific understanding and explanation of the universe and the earth? Why and how did the bible god create the other planets? Why and how did he create the asteroids? Did he speak them into existence too? . The bible says that the moon and stars were created solely to provide light unto the earth and for seasons. . . . .How does this claim agree with scientific explanations? Are the stars really created solely for the purpose of providing light here on earth?. . . . .Was the moon solely created to rule over the night as claimed in the bible? How does a rock rule over anything? What about the scientific explanation of the Earth's ocean tides which come about as a result of the moon's gravitational pull on the earth? How does that agree with the claim that the moon was created to rule over the night? |
viaro:Pls just go ahead and provide your credible sources(Like the NAS) that declare that naturalism is in adequate to provide explanation as to the origin of life. . . . . In my view, I don't see it as baseless because I have not seen any sources where life is said to have evolved by chance with any shred of evidence. If he was reasoning philosophically, would it be baseless as well? If your answer is yes, by what philosophy? But even so, I have not argued for the God-hypothesis other than saying that it is 'not inferior' to any so-called 'science' of LIFE origins. If you do have any shred of 'evidence' for how life must have evolved by chance, would you like to share?My friend you are dancing around. . . .You should have had enough boogey at the club, church or where ever over the new year day celebration. . In my view I have NOT seen any objective source that says life can not evolve by chance and can only come about by the magical interference of a deity. I have not seen such a paper. . . .He is a biologist(scientist) so I believe he was not arguing philosophically but scientifically. His scientific basis for saying that life could never have evolved on this planet by chance but can only come about by the magical interference of a deity is what?. . . . . |
Abuzo- lalalalalalalalalalalalalalalalalalalalalalala. . . . . .The comedian is back again. . . . . . . . ![]() |
viaro: , The atheist does not post a disclaimer and beats a retreat, Its you who always assumes wrongly and tries to force the atheist to accept things as defined or contextualized by you .Consequently, in all the attempts that have been made in scientific progress, scientists are leaning towards the position that naturalism is inadequate to provide explanations or any 'evidence' for the origin of life. This does not mean that they are necessarily delving into the metaphysical (although metaphysics is also part of the systemics approach); and we understand why - because naturalism does not make grand statements about what is beyond its explanatory philosophies.I will like to see credible sources from authoritative scientific bodies(like the NAS) that declare that scientific naturalism is inadequate to provide explanations for the origin of life. I agree that scientific naturalism might not be able to provide evidence but explanations? I will like to see such sources that make that declaration. . . . I posed that question from this part of your previous response:[list][/list]. . because it suggests to me that you know far more than you can assert by claiming that someone else's statement is 'baseless'. That being so, it would be nice to see the basis of your own ideas that inform your assertions - otherwise what you are at pains to argue is as baseless as anyone could imagine.I said it is a baseless claim because he did not provide any objective basis why he made that blanket statement. . .On what objective basis did he come to the conclusion and authoritative assert that life could not evolve and could only come about through the magical wonder of a deity? Well, I am not in a position to defend his original thesis; but I reckon that your hasty assertion was ill-informed.I my assertion was not ill-informed IMO. . .I say this because he did not provide give an objective basis for declaring that life could never evolve on this planet. . . .I am not saying that life evolved or did not evolve, Why should he make that forceful and blanket statement without providing any objective basis for his assertion?. . . .That to me is a baseless claim. . . . |
viaro:You my friend are a very funny person, I said that theist sometimes use the natural scientific explanation to discredit the explanations of those on the opposing side because the god hypothesis is not self evident and you come up with this rejoinder? Are you confused? . . . . .According to wikipedia Atheism can be either the rejection of theism, or the position that deities do not exist. My atheism is the rejection of theism and also the position that deities do not exist how is that not a rational atheistic position? ![]() Oh puhleease!Naturalism tries to provide natural explanations for the origin of life NOT answers to the origin of life. . . .I notice that you have changed you assertion from answers to the origin of life to explanations about the origin of life. The point is naturalism has never claimed that it has the answers to the origin of life question, it only tries to explain the origin of life. . . . . . You said that "The philosophical paradigms driving origins research have not even come close to controverting the plain fact that naturalism does not have ANY answer to the ORGIN of LIFE." and I asked you to tell me when naturalism claims it has the answers to the origin of life? |
viaro: ![]() Your evidence that life could have evolved by chance is WHAT?I didn't even make any claim about life evolving by chance or not evolving by chance. You are assuming what I did not even say, Did I say that life can evolve by chance? Some guy made a blanket statement that life can not evolve on this planet, Do you agree with that? If you do then you can consult him and the two of you should provide us with evidence to show why life can not evolve by chance on this planet and can only come about by a deity supposedly Yahweh. . . . . No, but I would like to see your own evidence that life could have evolved by chance completely on its own. This does not make any appeal to the God-hypothesis, but please show me the scientific evidence you have for the -life-evolved-by-chance hypothesis.Your evidence that I said life can evolve by chance is?. . . . .I did not make any blanket claim or statement about the the evolution of life. . .He did, he should then go ahead and provide evidence to show that to us life can not evolve by chance on this planet but can only be created by Yahweh. . . . |
viaro:When atheist are debating atheism between themselves non of them tries to use the supernatural argument to buttress his/her position they just make their case and move on, What about conflicting god hypothesis?. . . . .Knowing very well that their god hypothesis explains nothing they try to use natural scientific explanations sometimes to discredit those on the opposing view side, Why? because they KNOW very well that the god hypothesis CAN NOT stand on its own and is not self evident. . . Evolutionist do not leave the realm of scientific naturalism and try to use supernatural explanations to explain the validity of there assertions when debating each other do they? The FACT that the various proponents of the god hypothesis sometimes drop their god explanations and use natural scientific explanations when discrediting each others assertion is very telling. . . . The God-hypothesis is NOT inferior to any so-called 'science' of LIFE origins. The philosophical paradigms driving origins research have not even come close to controverting the plain fact that naturalism does not have ANY answer to the ORGIN of LIFE. The best anyone could argue is mere conjecture/speculation - which is nothing more than an inferior 'science' (if it could even pass for 'science' at all).And when did naturalism ever claim that it has the answer to the origin of life?. . . . |
beneli:I believe that all the gods of man made religion are man made, and there are so many evidence to show that men created all the gods they worship and espouse. No god can be shown to exist outside human cultural traditions, mythologies and stories. Lets take the christian religion, The christian hypothesis does not just say that god created the universe and everything and stops there, It goes further and claims that this god has certain attributes, but the problem is that these attributes are incompatible and make it impossible for this said god to exist. . . . . This god is also said to have attributes or does things that can be objectively observed. But the problem is that non of these attributes have ever been objectively observed at all. Personally I can accept the deist position but that claim it self has a lot of problems and is not self evident. . . . . . . . The deist assert that god created the universe, They refuse to tell us the nature of this god, why he created and his purpose of creating the universe and how he/she can be detected. In fact they refuse to tell us how these god can be seen, known or encountered, They just make a non evidential claim and that's it. . . . . . . . “Life could never have evolved by chance on planet earth." -Nobel Prize winner Dr. Francis Crick (co-discoverer of one of the most important discoveries of 20th century biologyAnd why should we believe this baseless claim? His evidence that life could never evolve by chance is what?. . . . His evidence that life was created by a god to show that it can never evolve by chance is?. . . . . . . We should accept this blanket statement because he said so? ![]() |
Science tries its best to offer natural explanations for most of the phenomena and events we see around us, does science have limitations, Yes it does and science even acknowledges that it has its own limitations, despite its many limitations science still offer the best explanations for most of the things that we see around. Take any event or occurrence which explanation will you prefer? The scientific one or the so called supernatural one? Having no explanation for an event means nothing more than we don't know. We don't know yet means we don't know It is ignorant to conclude or claim that god did it.If you say that god did it then be sure to provide empirical and scientific methods of showing that it was your own particular god that did it and not other gods that have also claimed to have done it. God did it has never explained anything at all. Even those the subscribe to the god hypothesis very much prefer natural explanations because it is more reasonable and makes much more sense than the god did it hypothesis that makes no sense at all. I say this because you will realize that the god did it hypothesis is only a claim that offers no explanation, and is unverifiable at all. The only way to know that the god did it hypothesis is inferior to scientific explanations is when you have two different proponents of the god hypothesis(e.g a Christian and a Moslem) trying to show that their own god hypothesis is the true one, They sometimes try to use science and the scientific explanation to show that the assertions of their opponent is invalid because it does not agree with science and there by declare it invalid, If a Muslim claims divine healing from say cancer and tells the Christian that it was allah that healed him the Christian will try to look for natural and scientific explanations to show how the cancer was healed and show the Moslem that it was not allah that really healed him. If the Christian points to the creation accounts in the bible, The moslem will point to all the scientific inconsistencies that are found in the creation account to show to the christian that Yahweh did not really create the earth and the universe because that creation account does not agree with the scientific explanations. Christians use the scientific process and knowledge to show moslems for example that the method of conception explained in the koran is false because it does not agree with modern scientific explanations. The Christian accepts the christian hypothesis and all its ridiculous claims but tries to use science sometimes to discredit his opponents who also subscribe to a different god hypothesis. The problem is that things are not done that way. The god hypothesis explains NOTHING at all, because it explanations are not self evident, The god hypothesis only offers claims and counter claims but it explains nothing to any body apart from those that subscribe to the particular version of the god hypothesis they subscribe to. We don't know means we don't know, saying that god did it and offering no explanation with regards to how he did it is just a baseless claim. If you claims that god created the universe then you should be able to explain how and why god created the asteroids and why and how he created planets like Jupiter and Saturn. Saying the god spoke them into existence makes it highly speculative at best, and more likely, just a convenient fiction. |
Happy New Year!!!!. . . . . |
beneli:We don't even know what the universe is and you are here labeling it a closed system? Since the second law of TD is applyable to finite systems only, we can not state that immediately. Some argue then that the universe had a beginning, but such can not be conceived of IMO. A universe can not pop into existence from nothing, and this would also break the first law correct me if I am wrong. The way I believe we could conceive of the universe as a closed thermodynamic system is to start with a known finite and closed TD system, and add to that a surrounding part, which still match a closed TD system, and repeat that untill we cover all of the universe.But since the universe is probably infinite, we could never conceive of it as a closed TD system IMO. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_law_of_thermodynamics. Another way of putting it, is that in a closed system, things go from a state of higher organisation to a state of lowest organisation. I am too lazy to google. It's all there at the click of your mouse!I want you to provide respectable sources that say " in a closed system, things go from a state of higher organisation to a state of lowest organisation". . . It is my understanding that entropy in a closed system is constant. Seriously though, the understanding-from a scientific point of view-is that the universe, as a 'closed system', should be answerable to the laws of thermodynamics but from the very beginning something interfered with the 'natural' processes of entropy!The universe is a closed system in the sense that it is self contained, but it is expanding so that more and more states are made available to the particles in it, so it definitely isn't closed in the thermodynamic sense. Unless of course, as some suggest, the 'universe' is no longer a closed system, which would be giving creationists like myself more guns for our arsenal!If the Universe is infinite in all dimensions including time, can it be accurately described as a closed system? Even Big Bang model does not predict a finite universe. . . . . |
viaro:Same here. . .Nothing at all from you have proffered has any substance or addresses anything at all. . .apart from running around in circles and trying to impose your meaningless assumptions as knowledge. . . Your atheism has nothing to show for what it calls evil other than ascribe it to naturalism and then lamely claim that it does not deal with evil. That is dense - if you cannot deal with it, then shut up and stop pretending to KNOW when you don't.Tell me how any kind of atheism deals addresses the problem of evil. . . . I wasn't forcing anything on anyone - that point has been repeated far too often, which was why I have offered nothing about my personal views. Your own claims are in view here, and so far you're making heated and reactive assertions that say nothing at all. The definition I pointed to from Michael Martin shows that you're running from pillar to post and adjusting your assertions far too often that it beggars intelligence. Not all atheists are agreed what atheism is - and that is why they come up with the absolute nonsense of 'weak' and 'strong' atheism to placate their irrational beliefs. Martin only throws out that compromise to pat you guys on the back by showing both sides of the wabbled definition. Yes, you may argue all day long about that - my name is not Michael Martin.Atheism is the lack of belief in gods, anything beside that can be termed as agnosticism and what is Martins definition of atheism? Rubbish - then you should have shut up instead of trying to assert initially that you could do so. If your atheism does not try to explain why people hold their beliefs, just shut the bleep up instead of pretending to know anything and fetching weak quotes from people who are in their own cublicles complaining about what they do not know. This was why I asked if you would invite me to show you the shallowness of the quote you offered for that 'explanation' - you did not; rather, you just made the same empty say-so-and-leave-it-at-that.I can do that but you can open a topic and I will show that to you. . . .In details. . . Precisely. Then shut up. End of story. Please mazaje, I am not trying to be rough in my tone - I just have grown weary of your pretences on this thread. In my own way, I have noted that my theism does not depend on any thing atheism argues. Nada. Zilch. That is why I don't try to be assertive about anything nor make lame excuses in retrospect to shift goal posts that theism does not deal withn this and that - and yet come back making assertive statements about what it does not deal with. How do I recocile your convoluted argument that atheism does not deal with this and that and then read you trying to explain things psychologically like your atheism has any answers thereto? What tail-chasing exercise are you on to?Atheism depends on theism. . . .If there are no theistic claims there wont be atheism. . .Its as simple as that. . .Atheism is simply a lack of belief in god. . .The god hypothesis has been put forth as a hypothesis with claims it has a lot of answers. . . .Which when scrutinized properly seems to fall on its face. . .What has atheism claimed apart from disbelief in the existence of god? Excuse me? Did I make any such claim? Are you beginning to get all wired and confused? Did you read what I said or just decided to glance hastily to read your own misgivings into them? Sorry, I cannot answer roll-call for what I did not argue. My engagement with you has been precisely on your own empty pompous claims - that is all. If you cannot show beyond your assertions any substance that is reasonable enough for your worldview instead of leaning on a worldview that you don't subscribe to, why should that be my responsibility?You said atheist blame religion for the problem of evil and I asked where atheism has done that. . .Will you answer a simple question? You provided no evidence but repeated yappings. End of story. I could also yap and play the exact same games you've been playing. . it is the easiest thing to do. But what use would it be, really?My evidence still stands NO god can be shown to exist independent of human stories, hypothesis, cultural myths and what humans have attributed to such gods. . .That is not and evidence because? Yes, that is why I have contextualized your own type of atheism all along - which is to say that atheism is not the same thing for all atheist. Has that point not sunk in yet? Your own atheism is loud and empty, and that is because I have seen atheists who do not necessarily base their arguments on whether theism says this or that. These atheists know and understand that matters like this do not necessarily require the exact same experience across board for everyone, because we are not clones of one another. But what your atheism does is to try to narrow everybody and everything to your brash assertions and turn round asking me to give you 'physical evidence' for what I have not claimed is 'physical'.Example pls. . . .Atheism I base my atheism on the claims of theism anything wrong with that? I noted also that some atheists do not narrow down their atheism merely to the simplistic question of just the existence of God/gods. That is not all that atheism rests upon. Pardon me for not having pointed out any source (as I felt you had closed the door for any dialogue on the subject when you declared that all such claimants are liars even before seeking to consider it). But there are many today who are atheists and do belief in certain supernatural phenomena - ghosts, spirits, etc. This discussion is currently receiving increasing awareness and concern among atheists, and you will find them on many fora and blogs.My atheism rest solely on the existence of gods as describe by theist and there is nothing wrong with that I do not care what other atheist believe or chose to believe, My own atheism rest mere on the non existence of gods of man made religions. . . . .Where is the evidence for ghost, spirits alien etc? No body has ever provided any claims for ghost, spirits alien abductions ect apart from subjective claims. . . .What can be asserted without evidence deserves to be dismissed without evidence. . . . Indeed, some atheists hastily dismiss such possibilities; which makes me wonder that they ('they', not personalizing it to you, mazaje) do so on no other basis than an idiotic commitment to atheistic naturalism. It leaves us wondering: what researches have these idiots conducted about these phenomena that are being reported by other atheists before drawing the assertion that thus and thus do not exist? For me, these atheists are far gone in their idiocy to even make any sense, if they do not even take the time to consider what other atheists are saying on such phenomena without reference to theistic claims.Does the spirit realm exist? The idiots that claim it does should provide empirical evidence for it apart from just stating their belief or forever shut their dirty mouths up. . . .What conclusive researches and empirical evidence can the idiots that keep crying about spirits existing provide to show for their delusions? Will they present their conclusive research and empirical evidence and stop their deluded special pleadings? What can be claimed without evidence deserves to be discarded without evidence. . . Now where did viaro see these things? I said you would find them in many websites - blogs, vlogs, forums, etc - apart from a few other published sources that are not well known to atheists. Let's even consider that such atheists make these claims about spirits and ghosts, etc. . what evidence does your type of atheism have to present from scholarly research to then declare that those other atheists are LIARS? This is not about me - I had been trying to discuss with you and see just how sound your atheism is and see also if it has anything different and refreshing to add to other atheistic ponderings that I'd perused. All I see is you getting personal and shouting about where my own evidence is, and if it is not 'physical', you just close the door for any discussion. That for me sounds quite fundamentalist in attitude.The problem is that neither you or any body has ever provided any conclusive empirical evidence for the existence of spirits beside your special pleadings and subjective claims. . .My type of atheism does not have to provide any evidence to show that those that believe in the spirits are liars because they have NEVER provided any conclusive and empirical evidence for their postulations beside anecdotal claims. . .Those that lay claim to the non physical existence and interaction like spirits, ghost and supernatural realm should very well explain what it it and how it can be know measured and detected else failure to do that mean they are jokers and time wasters. . . .What have their unsubstantiated beliefs got to do with reality? Some atheist believe in ghost so? does that mean that ghost exist? Over a billion muslims believe in a paradise with river of wine flowing in it, does that make it true? Why should I or any body accept these unsubstantiated and meaningless claims? Just because some people believe in it? ![]() These are just a few of the concerns that I was trying to put across to you, with examples showing the three things I had tried to highlight:You can keep trying to twist my postulations all you like, that's your business. . .What is this nonsense called atheistic religions? Do Hindus and Buddhist believe in gods or supreme beings? If yes then they have nothing to do with atheism. . . .Just because Martin says something doesn't make it true. . . .Atheistic religion is an oxymoron. . .My type of atheism depends solely on the theistic argument and there is nothing wrong with that. . . . . and I should add: this is not about my own 'evidence', which understandably could be discarded because it is subjective. But on the whole, for those atheists who claim they "KNOW", my concern is this: are those atheists who report these experiences all LIARS as well? Remember that these atheists do not make any claim based on any religious text or culture - and atheism for them is not all about arguments for the existence of God. . it is far more than that! It is not rested on what viaro says - they are not making those claims based on my own subjective evidence or based on any religious text or culture.They are LIARS because they have failed to provide any empirical evidence for their various claims about spirits apart from their assumptions and subjective conclusions. . .What is a spirit and how can it be measured, known, seen, and detected without the personal and subjective claims and assumption of the person that is lying claims to it and what he ascribes to it? Have they provided conclusive and empirical evidence to show that spirits exist independent of their subjective beliefs and assumptions? The haven't provided any empirical or conclusive evidence to show that their assertions should be taking seriously. . .Extra ordinary claims require extra ordinary evidence. . .If they claim they have these experiences and are not able to provide any empirical and conclusive evidence for it then their claims are no different from those that talk about alien abduction and deserves to be discarded, all they have stated is their beliefs and those beliefs are false IMO unless they can provide empirical and conclusive evidence for them. . . . You see, mazaje, my discussion with you, as I said earlier, was just to see what sort of atheism you espouse. The idea that all atheists agree to this and that about atheism is simply not true, and risks being consigned to the bin of idiocy. If I were to merely be an observer of your type of atheism and wonder what it bears on its own independent of theism, I find nothing other than heated personalized reactive statements - which just simply do not consider the very fact that there are atheists who have experienced what they cannot explain within the matrix of their own atheistic naturalism. This is not to disparage anyone; and that is why I would not dismiss those other atheists by calling them liars as you brashly asserted earlier without having even considered that there are issues which your own imposition has no clue about.My type of atheism like that of so many others depends solely on the theistic claims and postulations. . . .And there is nothing wrong with that. . .I don't have to be the type of atheist you like or fit into your own definition of what atheism is. . . I did - one and all. You, on the other hand, are just running in deep circles repeatedly without calmly paying attention to what I had said.Actually you did nothing. . .All you have done so far is tell me that there are atheist that believe in the supernatural or try to explain that there are atheistic religions hence my atheism is simplistic. . .The evidence for which you or them making the claim have provided nothing worthwhile beside mere beliefs to support your positions and postulations. . . |
Deep Sight:Now terrorism will be added to our myriad of problems. . . |
viaro:Actually I am already tired of your running around in circle and your inability to make ANY sense at all to me. . . .You are just typing away without making any sense at all. . . .All you are doing here is evading what I have written and then saying that I have nothing of substance when it is you who have nothing meaningful at all to say so far. I asked you a question that drew out several concerns:How does atheism know for a fact that there is no god? My answer is this. . .No god can be shown to exist on his/her own independent of cultural stories and mythologies. . . That is a FACT and that is how I know that all the gods of man made religions do not exist. . . .Can any god be shown to exist independent or outside of stories and cultural mythologies that are constantly evolving? Atheism has nothing to do with the problem of evil because evil is the absence of good. . .Human morality that is constantly evolving deals with the problem of evil not atheism or theism. . . If there were other concerns not as important, these two above have constantly received very simplistic and circular answers from you to the point that you seem to be changing your goal post every so often. Please don't take that as accusative; but your definition of atheism (which you claimed all atheist agree with) is simply a redaction - those who are informed know this. But I'd guessed you won't answer the questions offered and instead show again and again that atheism - your atheism - leaves room for a lot of issues. Simply put: you just don't KNOW anything and only hope to make claims assertively like you have experiential knowledge about what you claim.Who are those that are informed? Atheism is the disbelief in the existence of a supernatural beings or gods. This definition all people that are atheist agree too. Can you make your own point without ever trying to force people to agree with your own position? So far you have been unable to show me that you know anything apart from going off tangent and explaining nothing at all. . . Let me give you a clear example of the circular interjection in yours: ''When does atheism claim it has explanation for anything?' In this very thread you had tried to assertively demonstrate that very same thing - to try to "explain" something, viz: 'the psychological reasons people develop beliefs like yours', and went on to quote someone else's complaint that rather explains nothing.Explaining why people hold their various beliefs is not atheism. . .Atheism does not try to explain why people hold their beliefs. . .It is just the disbelief in the existence of gods. . .There are so many fields of human endeavor that try to offer explanations for various phenomena and atheism is not one of them. . .A theism is the lack of belief in gods based on theistic claims and postulations. . . I wondered what essentially that quote offers as reason to that claim, and you returned with: ''The post properly addresses the reason why people chose to believe and the physiological benefits associated with religious beliefs' - nothing more than the usual claims. . just claim it, and you hope it is so. That is just why your atheism leaves no room at all for reason or rationale, it does nothing, no research, no depth. Why do atheists like you often make jest of their atheism? I could as well make claims that I "know" thus and thus, and boast about offering an explanation or reason for certain things, yet when the article I post addresses absolutely nothing in my previous claim, I act like you and exclaim: 'when does theism claim it has explanation for anything?' That is just so cheap.My atheism has done all its research and has more than enough evidence to show that all the gods of man made religions can not be shown to exist on their own outside cultural stories, mythologies and societal acceptance. . .No god or gods can be pointed to or shown to exist independent of human construct, human stories, human mythologies and what ever humans choose to ascribe unto their various gods. . . . If atheism does not deal with evil because it does not know anything about life other than a commitment to atheistic naturalism, it should just shut up about what it does not deal with. It is quite hilarious for any atheist to constantly point to any worldview - religious or otherwise - as reason for any evil when your atheism says that it is only part of the natural world! The real problem with your type of atheism is just this: it is just loud about what it cannot address. That is all - and that is just what you have demonstrated in this thread.Will you answer a simple question and stop dancing all over the place? When does atheism point to religion as the reason for evil? ![]() Coming back to ask for my own evidence is a non-starter: it was not about what evidence I have, but it was all about your own non-evidence for your claim. It is analogous to a scenario where any two people could arrive at some totally different idea about a particular phenomenon and yet be wrong - being wrong does not prove that the phenomenon in itself just doesn't exist and it's impossible. For a third person to come and claim that he KNOWS for a fact that such a phenomenon does not exist would require that person to adduce proof for his claim. It would be a laugh for the day for this third person to offer no proof and just turn round to shift responsibility to the other two who have made attempts. This is why you don't understand atheism at all and are making simplistic arguments from a very funny and compromisive definition of that term. If your atheism stands or falls on theism, it has nothing at all to stand upon on its own.I have provided good evidence for my claims and let me repeat it again. . .All the gods of man made religions have all evolved from people's superstitions and what they founders of the religions made up and wanted people to believe or accept no god can be shown to exist independent of this human construction with comes in the form of stories which are filled with mythologies, and cultural influences . In all, I would say I've enjoyed the discussion more because there was nothing new you presented in substance for your atheism. Forgive me - I have been looking around so many different quarters to see what essentially atheists have for their own worldview, and yet none has been able to stand atheism on its own without reference to theism. The difference is only that the atheist deliberately wants to deny theism for any and all theistic phenomena - and the reason is simple: the typical atheist is simply committed to atheistic naturalism, and very often within that matrix does not have any substance to issues which it argues and yet claims it does not deal with. If I see something new in yours that could be of interest (rather than repetitions addressing absolutely nothing), then I would be delighted to once again engage you on this subject. Cheers.What is my atheism apart from the belief that all the gods of man made religions are man made? I have provided my own evidence for that assertion. . . . You did not even bother to address any of them at all. . .You ran off talking about things that have nothing to do with what I have said or trying to show me that I might be wrong because some atheistic religions exist or some atheist believe in spiritualism, How about dealing with the fact that atheism is the denial of all the gods of man made religions because all the gods are man made? |
[quote author=tpia. link=topic=372394.msg5197791#msg5197791 date=1261962718]do their own stories and myths tell them not to hate others? [/quote]I wonder why we discard our own myths and stories for foreign mythology. . . . . and do atheist stories and myths encourage tolerance of people with other beliefs?And the atheist mythologies that encourage intolerance can be found in which books? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 (of 290 pages)
