₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: RegisterLoginWith GoogleTrendingRecentNew

Stats: 3,325,248 members, 8,420,952 topics. Date: Friday, 05 June 2026 at 03:01 PM

Toggle theme

Avicenna's Posts

Nairaland ForumAvicenna's ProfileAvicenna's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 (of 17 pages)

Christianity EtcRe: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by Avicenna:
lagerwhenindoubt: I grow weary of this discourse and I wish to stop this perambulator in its petulant journey, it is like a poker game where all the players hold all 4 Aces but won't show their hand grin soooo; let us play a little, perhaps, I hold a joker (4 even grin)

Earlier on, I refused to be serious with this thread because the question reads like a dishonest Accountant grin yes, GOD's Nature (Authoritative Source) finally emerges after much mental cattle prodding tongue It is really a Fly in the Ointment for Atheists grin

Permit me to present the End-Game from this Theist's perspective which is.. Atheists cannot Rationally defend being Moral since God is the source of Morality tongue

I agree that It is possible to Define/re-define and Experience Morality without an Authoritative Source
Since "we" presume to know what cards you hold, let me deal mine.

Can humans discover on their own what is Right and Wrong? A simple Yes or No will suffice, but if you wish to lace it on with Scripture, be my guest
This is what I want to know. Can a baby discover what is right or wrong by his/her self?

This will require a very unethical study whose results will never be published.

Everything we can do here is conjecture after we have been influenced morally by other factors.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheists: Do You Believe In Extra-terrestials? by Avicenna: 7:18am On Jul 16, 2012
Pastor Kun: At the end of the day, we are all theist even though some people choose to live in denial primarily becos of their disdain for religion.
I think it goes the opposite way. At the end, we are all atheist to different gods..
Christianity EtcRe: Atheists: Do You Believe In Extra-terrestials? by Avicenna: 10:07pm On Jul 15, 2012
mkmyers45: Is it also logical to assume that God is likely to exist but has not been observed yet....?
huh
The conditions that sustain life on Earth is likely to be present in some other part of the universe.

A God should be readily observable like gravity. If he decides to hide himself(deism) then it follows he doesn't want us to bother about him.

See me, thinking you wanted an honest discussion on ET.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheists: Do You Believe In Extra-terrestials? by Avicenna: 9:53pm On Jul 15, 2012
UFO, no, no. Its more like USA.

The scale of the universe DEMANDS other life forms. I intend to leave my billionsgrin to NASA.

Or atleast support its privatization. Imagine discussing NASA of USA when I'm not even a citizen.
Christianity EtcRe: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by Avicenna: 5:02pm On Jul 15, 2012
lagerwhenindoubt: Can we please agree to one day (in earnest) recap all themes discussed so they are not continually recycled and re-thrashed year after year. with the same conclusions drawn from either sides of the participants sad
I'm always surprised when I go thru the archive. So many topics discussing same thing. They have same conclusion but thoroughly refreshing and different manner of debate.

I think it can be said to be a good thing.
Christianity EtcRe: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by Avicenna: 4:59pm On Jul 15, 2012
mkmyers45: My Friend....

I will like to hear your own thoughts...

Cheers
I wasn't quick to comment cos I'm looking for what you are also looking for. My thoughts are looking for validation or thorough debunking. This is a very good thread, I tell ya.
Btw, don't feed the troll.

Cheers.
Christianity EtcRe: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by Avicenna: 3:58pm On Jul 15, 2012
Mr_Anony: That was not part of the question but my answer is God.
by the way, do you think there must be an authoritative source for morality?
If yes, what is it? If no, how so?
My network service is bad.

The answer to your question is Yes and NO.
Let me explain.
Authoritative figures are really a source of morality. My parents, Vice-chancellor, lecturers to an extent influence me morally. so, in this case,Yes.

Gods( abrahamic gods) are not in my opinion a source of morality at this age and time. You can be like me and cherrypick the part of the holy books you want. For instance, I still give zakat to poor people. Not as a religious duty but as my personal goodwill( out of freewill). don't mistake, with or without the Quran, its something I probably will do. I ignore the rather violent remaining part. To be more clear, some part of the holy books happened to have morals I agree with. It is not a case for divine morals.
In this case, my answer is No. Divine Authoritative figure is not necessary to be moral.

As this is truth seeking endeavor, I will like you to point out where you don't agree with and why.
Christianity EtcRe: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by Avicenna: 1:29pm On Jul 15, 2012
Mr_Anony: Oh my God! This is so funny! It's happening all over again!

Mymyers45 asks if morality is truly possible without an authoritative force,
Zodiac creates a strawman by deciding that he knows what mkmyers45 is asking better than that mkmyers45 himself.
From then on, everyone throws in their biases and the real question is ignored.

Una too much! obfuscation-a-plenty!

@mkmyers45. My answer is that: There cannot be a morality without an authoritative source.
And the authoritative source is.....??
As usual, I expect divine nonsense.
Christianity EtcRe: Is Morality Possible Without An Authoritative Source? by Avicenna: 10:09am On Jul 15, 2012
frosbel: Atheism is by definition a no God existence, but there still resides within these ingrates that gift of conscience and awareness of right or wrong , therefore it is not unusual to see some of these creatures exhibit some flashes of goodness from time to time.

However , when a state is founded on atheist ideologies like Maoism and Stalinism, what we have is a pretty much 'lawless' society where human life is devalued and morality becomes a relative term.

Just look at Russia and the effect of decades of atheism, Vodka addiction, violence, the most horrendous kind of racism and gross intolerance for the ideas for a democratic society.


Atheists without Christ are a lost cause and of all men to be the most pitied.

Only Christ can deliver them from their almost seemingly impenetrable blindness.

This is harsh but true.
Just keep wondering how this guy makes false assertions with a bold face. See what decades of religious brainwashing can do to a normal rational person.

Just look at Nigeria and the effect of decades of religiosity, corruption, alcohol addiction, religious violence, and the most horrendous kind of tribalism and gross intolerance of for the ideas of democratic society!

Learn to be objective. Communism not atheism caused those countries to be like that.
Christianity EtcRe: Michael Faraday Believed In GOD, So Why Do Atheists Use Electricity by Avicenna: 7:06pm On Jul 14, 2012
frosbel: How ironic !
Only to you and your fellow turn-logic-on-its-head religionists.
Christianity EtcRe: Michael Faraday Believed In GOD, So Why Do Atheists Use Electricity by Avicenna: 3:18pm On Jul 14, 2012
frosbel: Again , shameless illogical hypocrisy !!!
How so?
Cos what that mean is I don't care who discovered electricity(incase you have a problem with the phrasing).

Can't blame you tho. You think atheism is a religion. So, you must think atheists are discriminatory to other religions.

Apologist.
Christianity EtcRe: Michael Faraday Believed In GOD, So Why Do Atheists Use Electricity by Avicenna: 2:36pm On Jul 14, 2012
I couldn't care less if a satanist 'invented' electricity!
Useless biases by 'Holy' books has corrupted minds of religionists.

BTW,it is incredibly dishonest to compare of Mark Zuckerberg's social site with the discovery of electricity by Faraday.

Your holy book tell you not to associate with unbelievers. Stop using unbeliever's technologies and let's see how you survive.
Christianity EtcRe: The Outsiders Test For Faith: Stepping Outside The Box by Avicenna: 11:12pm On Jul 04, 2012
ea7: Try and divorce yourself from the situation, approach your faith as a disinterested individual with no vested interest in its falsity or truth.
This may be a little bit impossible for some people or even abomination.
Anyone that does this will not be so religious soon after.
Christianity EtcRe: I Abandoned Religion And God Today. I'm Free. by Avicenna(op): 10:51pm On Jul 04, 2012
I expect the goal post to be shifted again as usual.

Very irresponsible statements/predictions from a supposed science PHd holder!

Sheesh, embarrassing Doctors everywhere.
Christianity EtcRe: Believers In God Have Nothing To Lose, Unlike Atheists ??? by Avicenna: 3:38pm On Jun 28, 2012
A insightful post made by Cyber999
aren't you tired of using Pascal's Wager which states that
"God can't be proved. But if God exists, the believer gains
everything (heaven) and the unbeliever loses everything
(hell). If God doesn't exist, the believer loses nothing and
the unbeliever gains nothing. There is therefore
everything to gain and nothing to lose by believing in
God."
listen all of you, this argument, first formulated by French
philosopher Blaise Pascal, is sheer intimidation. It is not a
case for a god's existence: it is an argument for belief,
based on irrational fear. With this kind of reasoning we
should simply pick the religion with the worst hell.
It is not true that the believer loses nothing. We diminish
this life by preferring the myth of an afterlife, and we
sacrifice honesty to the maintenance of a lie. Religion
demands time, energy and money, draining valuable
human resources from the improvement of this world.
Religious conformity, a tool of tyrants, is a threat to
freedom.
Nor is it true that the unbeliever gains nothing. Rejecting
religion can be a positive liberating experience, gaining
perspective and freedom of inquiry. Freethinkers have
always been in the forefront of social and moral progress.
What kind of person would eternally torment an honest
doubter? If their god is so unjust, then theists are in as
much danger as atheists. Perhaps god will get a perverted
thrill from changing his mind and damning everyone,
believers and unbelievers alike. Or, inverting the gamble,
perhaps god will only save those who have enough
courage not to believe!
Pascal was a Catholic and assumed that the existence of
god meant the Christian God. However, the Islamic Allah
might be the true god, which turns Pascal's wager into a
riskier gamble than intended.
In any case, a belief in a deity based on fear is not a belief
that produces admiration. It does not follow that such a
being deserves to be worshipped.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 9:30am On Jun 25, 2012
fellis: I'll see if I can get it free online, but not now cos I'm browsing on someone else's laptop for now, when I get mine back from the repairer's that's when I'll be able to do all the downloading I want.

Oh no I didn't ignore them. I didn't think you were serious.
So you said;

Yes you're correct, I am afraid of the afterlife but that isn't the only reason I'm still theist. Reading the Qur'an also played a big part. And lastly, most of the time, I get premonitions that are shockingly accurate so I believe that a spiritual realm does exist, even if we cannot proove or explain it.


.
I'm carefully perusing the Quran again. Trying to see whatever I missed.

I m planning something. Hope you will still be here to defend.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 12:29am On Jun 25, 2012
fellis: [size=2pt]Lol, fcking weeaboos[/size]

I think I'll try to watch the stuff on TV instead, seems merely reading it online will not do justice to it. smiley
And you ignored my inquiries. Maybe some day sha.

Hajime no ippo manga won't do justice at all. Watch the anime. Even if you don't like boxing, you will feel drawn in. How those mangakas( manga writer) do that, I will never know.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 12:26am On Jun 25, 2012
logicboy01: Hajime no ippo is crazy! You have to see the fights. However, there was only one black boxer who was quite fake.
Bloody jason ozuma! Fall ma hand o.
I don't follow it anymore. The manga is slow and frustrating. Hope they complete the anime.

Favorite part-oh man, all the fights are my favorite. Dempsey roll, gazelle punch,liver blow and you are finished!
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 12:19am On Jun 25, 2012
logicboy01: Hardcore ps3 gamer indeed! Nairaland is the only thing keeping me off my ps3 now.


As for pork, I hardly eat pork but it is sweet. It is just like beef but a slightly different taste.
Haha,
Birds of a feather sha.....

Pork, here I come.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 12:18am On Jun 25, 2012
fellis: I went through a few pages of hajime no ippo on mangareader.net and it looked ok. There was no suspicious anything about it, so why did you say 'no ulterior motives'?
It won't deconvert you or something.........I dunno
Christianity EtcRe: If God Knew Satan Will Rebel And Adam And Eve Will Sin, Why Did He Create Them? by Avicenna: 12:03am On Jun 25, 2012
@cyrexx
You are really a patient man. I would have lost it at 'you are not worthy of God's response' or something like that and the so many insults being thrown at you.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 11:17pm On Jun 24, 2012
logicboy01: Me too!
I assume you will also be a hardcore Ps3 gamer!!
Seems like things like that are common among atheists.

One more thing,
Is pork sweet?grin
I have never eaten it before, you see
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 11:14pm On Jun 24, 2012
fellis: What if am actually some old alhaja? Can old alhaja not also watch Naruto? huh huh tongue

Naruto is the one eating ramen noodles with pork not me, so that isn't going to stop me from watching it.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 9:51pm On Jun 24, 2012
fellis: ^^^O
Ha ha. So you remember what I said in that thread? You seemed so sober back then, now your mouth don dey sharp anyhow.



Hm. I started taking interest in Naruto some time ago but am having second thoughts now, since it converts people to atheism. tongue tongue tongue grin
Blame Nairaland. When you are faced with unnecessary insults and arguments that are sheer insult to the human intelligence, it grows on you.

I remember what you said perfectly. You were the only one that seemed to understand a little bit. But I was surprised that you believed so strongly. I wanted to know exactly why. It seems you are afraid of the unknown and a believer in the afterlife. I am sorry but there's no evidence for both. I refuse to take them on faith.
If you have any other reason(s) for your faith, I'd like to know.

Watch Naruto and bleach and all the other animes. I will recommend hajime no ippo if you are into boxing. They are very good. No ulterior motives, I swia
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 9:36pm On Jun 24, 2012
logicboy01: What is with atheists and Naruto for christ sake?

Were we all converted by Naruto or something?
You like Naruto too?!! Ha, seems every atheist here is a naruto fan. I m addicted to the freaking thing.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 6:55pm On Jun 24, 2012
You know, fellis, if not for under the condition we met, we would have made great friendsgringrin

There is this advice you gave me once ' the mind is a powerful thing'. The effect was profound. But for a guy like me who through logical thought escaped brutal brainwashing by religion, I will forever remain fairly objective with new information. I will keep this as a guiding principle.

I implore you to take your own advice and critically examine your faith.

Hirashin no jutsu. Disappear!
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 4:13pm On Jun 24, 2012
fellis: Ok. We believe that our religion serves as a means to determine how we will spend our eternity in the afterlife. It encompasses a set of rules or guidelines that the person following the religion must adhere to.
These rules give directives on how to live our lives and are meant to make the world a better/convenient place for us while we spend our time here and how well we follow these rules determines how well we spend our afterlife.
If you follow these rules, you are considered a Muslim. There is no way you will follow the tenets of Islam to the letter and still consider yourself an atheist, so if an atheist does everything I do as a Muslim, he is no longer an atheist. He is a Muslim.

I hope you understand that explanation.
I usually assume theist's personal experience made them believe in God. I did not know YOU are a follower of second hand fairytales.
Taking a story narrated by a schizophrenic,sugar boy plagiarized from older fairytales as genuine is something else. I do not believe Islam is the way to heaven even if heaven exists. No religion is divine. No afterlife exists.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 4:05pm On Jun 24, 2012
fellis: There is no post to dig up.
Based on what you wrote before, I think this is the post you were referring to;

From this thread: https://www.nairaland.com/971666/muslim-love-christians-condemn-boko#11199066
^^^See, still blameless.
I take extreme care not to generalize when I write, you won't find any post of mine on Nairaland where I claimed that all atheists are immoral.
I have said some atheists are immoral, the way some theists and agnostics and deists can be immoral. But I won't claim that every single one of them is like that.
You probably read my post wrongly.
But whatever, it's all good.
I wish you well. cool
And this,
www.nairaland.com/971666/muslim-love-christians-condemn-boko#11198653
hmmmm. Can an atheist really be a wonderful person? is
it possible?
Well, you said you admire logical thinking of atheists, admire this one, it is called logical deduction.

You did not generalize in the first post but your second post betrayed your bias. Framing it as a question to deflect accusations. We know all that.

It seems you can no longer defend your position on the imprisonment of Alexander Ana. We are done.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 2:43pm On Jun 24, 2012
[quote author=fellis]Please don't accuse me falsely. What do you mean 'even if we were to agree'? I have never said a thing like that. Not once.
Avicenna, I used to admire atheists for their ability to see things logically, please don't make me start seeing you guys differently.


I am surprised. You keep avoiding the crux of the matter. The unjust incarceration of a innocent man under a immoral law.
Your justification is all about 'he's an adult, he should obey laws of the land'. I posted MLK jnr quote exactly to counter that. If it had been the reverse i.e you are jailed for believing God exist, will you accept that as a just law? Don't tell you will leave the country, we both know that is unrealistic for everybody.
Finally, I am sorry. It was a mistake accusing you of that when I do not have time to dig up that post.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 12:37pm On Jun 24, 2012
fellis: Where have I ever said that atheists are immoral? Show me the place.



I don't intend to argue with all of you by myself, I no get power lipsrsealed lipsrsealed tongue

Secondly, I don't think the man is entirely innocent in the matter, but believe what you will.
I m not going to go thru your posts to find that.
But from what I know about you, you implied it before. Something along the line ' if I wasn't religious, I will be evil or something like that.
Okay, even if we are to agree you have never implied or said it before, you are still supporting immorality. The immorality of an unjust law.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 12:08pm On Jun 24, 2012
fellis: I agree. I didn't expect an atheist to have this point of view . . . . . smiley





grin See how all of them just gathered to attack me like hungry hawks that want to tear a prey apart. Lmao.
I don't want to argue this thing any further. Feel free to believe anything you like about this issue.
It is funny how you like saying atheists are immoral and I'm the one arguing for morality here!
One who breaks an unjust law that conscience tells him is
unjust, and who willingly accepts the penalty of
imprisonment in order to arouse the conscience of the
community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the
highest respect for law.
Martin Luther King, Jr.


An unjust law is no law at all.

It is disturbing how religion turns a perfectly rational and intelligent person into evil and injustice apologist. It is so sad.
Christianity EtcRe: Atheist In Indonesia Jailed For 2 Years+ Because He Doesnt Believe In God! by Avicenna: 12:01pm On Jun 24, 2012
mkmyers45: Was he modest or didnt know the law? I think that the man shoulders some level of blame anyway..

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 (of 17 pages)