SIRTee15's Posts
Nairaland Forum › SIRTee15's Profile › SIRTee15's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 (of 208 pages)
LordReed:then u dont understand morality. Is killing moral? any killing at all? I think u appealed to philosophy- something like deep thinking I already answered that- if atheist deep thinking led them to conclude teenage sex is ok, why is your deep thinking in the opposite direction. |
Neoteny:U ARE SIMPLY CONFUSED. U INITIALLY FAILED TO UNDERSTAND THE POST BUT WHEN U FINALLY DID, YOU U REALISED YOUR NONSENSE ARGUMENT HAS NO LEG TO STAND ON AND HAS EVENTUALLY COLLAPSED. MY CHALLENGE RIGHT FROM THE GET GO HAS ALWAYS BEEN SHOW ME THE SOURCE OF YOUR MORALITY NOT WHETHER MY SOURCE OF MORALITY IS BETTER THAN YOURS. Neoteny:SHOW ME WHERE I WROTE THAT MY MORALITY IS THE ONLY SOURCE OF TRUTH, SHOW ME. I DARE U TO SHOW WHERE I SAID THE BIBLE IS THE SOURCE OF MORAL TRUTH ON THIS THREAD. U MADE A CLAIM, BRING THE EVIDENCE. THIS IS A PASSAGE FROM MY INITIAL POST....The truth some atheists conveniently ignore is that all moral frameworks in society have historically been influenced by religious traditions. People draw from these values in how they live their lives, build families, and relate to their communities. Yet, some reject the existence of God while still engaging with moral ideas that have been shaped by religious thought. DOES THIS LOOK LIKE A POST SAYING GOD OF THE BIBLE IS THE BEST MORAL SOURCE. OR YOUR BRAIN THOUGHT THE WORD RELIGION MEANT ONLY CHRISTIANITY. INSTEAD OF U TO TAKE TIME AND UNDERSTAND THE POST, U JUMPED INTO THE ANTI CHRISTIAN WAGON AND NOW SHAMLESSLY SWALLOWING YOUR VOMIT AFTER I HAVE FINALLY BEEN ABLE TO HAVE YOUR BRAIN REBOOTED. saying that 'claiming religion precede philosophy is my undoing is lafable' I DARE U ONCE AGAIN, SHOW ME ANY ESTABLISHED PHILOSOPHY THAT PRECEDE RELIGION.JUST ONE. RELIGION THAT STARTED EVEN BEFORE HUMAN LEARNT TO WRITE OR BUILD FIRE. There are archeological evidence of spiritual behaviours and ritualistic practice as far as the upper paleolithic humans which is more than 50,00 years ago. He will come here and tell me these dont count because religion started when the bible was written or when God spoke to Abraham. OLODO. Neoteny:THIS IS WHAT I WROTE...STOP EQUATING THE WORD RELIGION WITH CHRISTIANITY, THERE ARE OVER A THOUSAND RELIGION The truth some atheists conveniently ignore is that all moral frameworks in society have historically been influenced by religious traditions I have no problem iF some society condone homosexuality or teenage sex so long as they can point to their source of morality which tells them it's ok to do so. It's u that's against homosexuality that I need to know your source of morality. What tells u homosexuality is wrong without appealing to religious dogma u were raised in. Neoteny:[/quote]Yeah, logic is when u failed to convince anyone here what is the basis of your moral principles. Even in my initial mention to u, I tried to redirect your attention to the core argument instead u went on off tangent attacking christianity. Finally u got it and realised your source of morality IS WHAT U ARE TOO ASHAMED TO ADMIT. THIS IS NOTHING BUT ACT OF HYPOCRISY. U BENEFIT FROM THE SOUND MORALITY FROM AN IMAGINARY SKY DADDY BUT U ARE TOO ASHAMED TO ADMIT IT. MAYBE U CAN MAKE AMEND BY NOT INSULTING THOSE WHO WORSHIP THIS IMAGINARY SKY DADDY because THEY ARE THE ONES WORKING SO HARD TO BUILD AND INSTILL GOOD MORALS AND VALUES IN THE SOCIETY THAT HYPOCRITES LIKE YOU LOVE TO ASSOCIATE WITH. |
THEDEEPSIGHT:Someone your daughter loves. u gonna deny your daughter the love of her life based on classism. I hope u know classism itself is considered immoral and most atheists (maybe liberal ones) frown at classism. |
LordReed:Did I dispute with u that morality is not relative? My morality is absolute to me and all other christians BUT relative to others. That's not the issue. pork is forbidden in Islam, it's considered immoral to eat pig. other faith dont care. If u ask mMuslims, they will tell u they derive that morality from a higher power. polygamy is forbidden in christianity but not in islam or hinduism eating cow is frowned upon in hindusim but not christianity or islam. everyone will tell u what's forbidden in their faith comes from a higher power. THEY DERIVE THEIR MORALITY FROM A HIGHER POWER, IT DOESN'T MATTER IF THESE HIGHER POWERS DONT ALWAYS AGREE. THAT'S NOT THE ARGUMENT HERE. so what's the point about your relative morality. It's like u guys dont understand my queation. whether morality is absolute or relative, that's not the issue. My question is what is the source of your relative or absolute morality? as a conservative atheist (as one of u called himself here), if u think teenage sex or homosexuality is wrong, where did u derive that morality from? of course atheist living in liberal societies dont see a big deal in this things because they derive their morality from liberal secularism. so if u as an atheist living in conservative society see homosexuality and teenage/carefree sex as wrong, what is the source of that morality. thats my question. |
THEDEEPSIGHT:The morbid obsession of atheist to the God of the bible needs the be specially studied. It's beyond ordinary. U already rejected what's in the bible, so whatever morality derived from it shouldn't be your headache. It's like me scrutinizing the morality of sango worshippers or Hindu followers when I already consider their god false. Mr Man I got a fine man for your lovely daughter. Tell me, if she brings this handsome Bobo as her future husband, will u object? If u object, based on what grounds. What morality will u appeal to that will make u reject this potential son in law
|
Dtruthspeaker:Pls don't derail this thread with your shallow knowledge. People even corrected u in those thread but your obstinacy no gree u see road. THIS THREAD IS NOT ABOUT WHO HAS THE BEST MORALITY BUT WHAT IS THE SOURCE OF YOUR MORALITY. Since u think polygamy being a sin is derived from a higher power, then no need proceeding further. Atheist here are already trying to drive the discussion into the direction of whether the morality of God is the best. I will appreciate if u don't give them the fuel for that, the question is clear WHAT IS THE SOURCE OF MORALITY FOR THOSE WHO DONT HAVE A HIGHER POWER. |
LordReed:Something that's in the bible !!!!! Polygamy is permitted and marriage bed undefiled are both derived from the bible. |
LordReed:polygamy is not a sin according to the bible, anything God permit cannot be a sin though not expedient and not part of the original covenant btw God and man. hebrew 13.4 makes it clear marriage bed should be undefiled. any sexual act outside the marriage bed is a sin. masturbation is sexual pleasure without a partner- that's outside of the marital bed. If u want masturbate, invite your partner and do it in his/her presence. note- your partner must willingly agree to it, approve of it and must derive sexual pleasure from the act. anything outside of this a sin/sexual abuse/sexual cohesion. |
Neoteny:I already told u ancient civilisation including all the ones u mentioned attributed their morality to a higher power. I already mentioned this, are u deaf or what. They never said our morality came from no where, they wrote down books and attributed their morality to deity they worship. pls don't appeal to ancient civilisation again, because THEY MADE IT CLEAR THEIR MORALITY CAME FROM A HIGHER POWER. Neoteny:I'm not here to discuss theology, I'm here to discuss values, dont confuse the 2. Most chrsitians dont even understand atonement or concept of original sin but based their lives on christian values. Judeochrsitian simply means beleivers who share common ethics and values coming from the bible. and it was first coined in 1821 by jewish who converted to christianity. it has nothing to do with your bogus zionism or nation of Israel conspiracy. Neoteny:U guys can just let it rest. I'm not here to tell u my source of morallity is better than yours. I'm simply here to show u guys that it's impossible for your morality to come from nothing. There's a source for everything. WHAT IS THE SOURCE OF YOUR MORALITY? Neoteny:I think u guys are the ones confused with your Belief system. I am here asking u what's the source of your morality and all u do is attack christianity or is your source of morality anything against xtianity? Neoteny:actually homosexuality and transgenderism has everything to do with atheism because the cultures that rejects it are deeply conservative cultures where the source of morality is attributed to higher power. show me a culture that reject atheism that is not a religious society, just one. I challenge u to name one. A typical example is china where homosexuality is legal and LGBQT communities thrive in urban areas that are mainly atheist while it's frowned upon in rural areas that still held on to some religious beliefs. when the west was deeply religious, u will be jailed for being homosexuals, it was even considered a mental disorder until the 1960s. u dare not get pregnant outside of wedlock, u and your family will be ostracized from the society. The community will tell u not to corrupt their kids with your immoral behaviour. This was in the 1950s not some 18th century- There are people who witnessed that era still around with us today. so dont even put modern west with christianity at all. They have abandoned religion, that's why they see nothing wrong with onlyfans models. so if u are atheist WHY ARE U AGAINST 18 YEAR OLD BEING AN ONLYFANS MODEL? THE REASON U ARE AGAINST HOMOSEXUALITY IS because U WERE RAISED IN A CONSERVATIVE RELIGIOUS CULTURE. NOTHING MORE. THERE'S NO OTHER REASON TO HATE HOMOSEXUALITY IF U HAVE NO RELIGIOUS INFULENCE IN YOUR MINDSET. KISS THE TRUTH. FOR CHRIST SAKE WHY WOULD U BE AGAINST HOMOSEXUALITY IF U HAD NO RELIGIOUS MORAL GENE FLOWING IN your blood. EVEN NON RELIGIOUS CONSERVATIVES IN WESTERN COUNTRIES HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH GAY. WHY SHOULD U HAVE PROBLEM WITH YOUR 18 YEAR OLD DAUGHTER HAVING SEX WITH HER BOYFRIEND IF NOT FOR THE RELIGIOUS MORALITY NEURONS SPARKLING IN YOUR BRAIN. U HAVE BEEN INDOCTRINATED BY RELGIOUS DOGMA TO SEE THOSE THINGS AS WRONG AND THAT'S WHY U CONSIDER THEM WRONG. GET OVER IT AND KISS THE TRUTH. Neoteny:philosophy didnt exist before religion. philosophy as a separate branch from religion influence started with Socrates around 500BC. even the torah had been written by that time. and FYI- Socrates was rejected by his culture and sentenced to death because he was accused of corrupting the minds of the youth with his philosophy by making them question morality. SO NO, PHILOSOPHY DIDN'T PRECEDE ANY MORAL LAWS. AND PHILISOPHY ITSELF DIDNT CREATE ANY MORALITY INSTEAD IT QUESTIONED IT. Neoteny:so if morality is down to your conscience, will u have a problem with your 18 year old daughter joining onlyfans model. How does it affect your cosncience if your 18 year old daughter becomes onlyfans. That's what I want to understand. pls answer. |
DeepSight:pls dont bring that political correctness nonsense hre. she came her insulting people up and down, but u didn't correct her. I noticed she's female thus better ignored rather than dragging words with her, u came here with your political correctness rhetoric. |
yemmit90:give me example of a civilisation that based their morality on laws of nature. pls dont mention ancient civilisation because they based their morlaity on their religious text. |
geoworldedu:sha dont raise your daughter a prostitute, that's my own. take a seat, when we discussing the case of God's morality, u can join the discussion |
mayor1814:Everybody in uk knows multiculturalism has failed. But the truth is nothing can be done to reverse it anymore. The uk culture as we knew it b4 is gone forever. The country will likely plit into different factions in the future with each one controlling their territory. The only way to fully reverse it is a civil war. |
geoworldedu:I don't know what's more immoral than pi.mping your daughter into prostitution and following her into the trade. This is no longer immorality but mental illness. God gave u a beautiful daughter to raise and help her become a pride in this world. Instead u want to turn her into a piece of shameful public amusement while u collect fare from the audience. |
geoworldedu:if u not an atheist, then I think u should take a back seat. This thread is for those who are outright atheist or doubt existence of God. if u believe in God, then no point being here. besides, I find it very disturbing u said there's nothing wrong pi.mping your daughter into prostitution. u even said u will join her in the business. daughter is calling customer, father is doing the transaction. That doesn't look like a healthy family at all. Pls in the name of whatever u worship, dont raise your daughter with such mindset and pls go and seek help from a therapist. dont take this advice lightly. |
yemmit90:pls stop going around in circles and answer my queston. whether u believe in the gods of a culture or society is irrelevant. That culture is telling u that the source of their morality is from their gods. whether u think its an imaginary sky daddy is completely inconsequential. They derive their morality from religious belief. Now u tell me, what is the source of your morality if u don't believe in an imaginary sky daddy. stop appealing to ancient civilisations that dont share the same opinion with u regarding the source of their morality. |
yemmit90:u have to prove that. as far as I'm aware, incest is considered immoral in all ancient religious text- mesopatamia, ancient egypt, ancient greece, ancient Rome, ancient akkadian. marriage btw son and mother or even siblings is seen as a curse and could bring the wrath of the gods on the land. So yes ancient civilisation derive incest morality from a higher power not some innate nature as u claim. There's clear evidence for this. anyway we know close family marriage is unhealthy and brings about genetic disease in the offsprings, so I'm not even going to bother about that since incest should be discouraged based on health ground. |
LordReed:Genesis 16 3 So after Abram had been living in Canaan ten years, Sarai his wife took her Egyptian slave Hagar and gave her to her husband to be his wife. 4 He slept with Hagar, and she conceived. Genesis 25 Abraham had taken another wife, whose name was Keturah. The bible didn't tell us Abraham had sexual relationship with other women apart from the above women and Sarah. The word concubines can be used in ancient culture to mean secondary wives with lesser legal status, social ranks and without equal inheritance rights. Sarah actually have Hagar to Abraham as a wife but also treated her harshly when she challenged her authority in the marriage. This shows social hierarchy within wives. its common practice those days as seen with Bilhah and Zilpah who became wives of Jacob but never as a valid union, even the kids they bore to Jaocb went to their mistresses- Leah and Rachel. Genesis 30 4 So she gave him her servant Bilhah as a wife. Jacob slept with her, 5 and she became pregnant and bore him a son. 6 Then Rachel said, “God has vindicated me; he has listened to my plea and given me a son.” Because of this she named him Dan. 9 When Leah saw that she had stopped having children, she took her servant Zilpah and gave her to Jacob as a wife. 10 Leah’s servant Zilpah bore Jacob a son. 11 Then Leah said, “What good fortune!” So she named him Gad. |
yemmit90:It's like this one hasn't heard of Epstein island where millionaires go to do touchy touchy of little girls. yemmit90:u guys are just going through a round hole. The so called societal norms morality comes from where. where does the society gets its morality from? pls answer the question |
Offpoint1:actually morality is instilled. children dont have any morality, they are very selfish and believe in the principle of self preservation. They will cry and throw tantrums if they dont get what they want NOW. As they grow and learn, they become to understand the importance of value and societal expectation. and the need to validate morality is what brought about myths and legend. People needed to explain why certain morality is non-negotiable so they connect it with a supernatural story. and all morality known to man came from a belief system or a spirtual knowledge. whether ancient or modern civilisation. even the modern atheist civilisation in the west came from liberal secularism. morality never came from nothing, that's what u atheist from conservative background fail to understand. |
Neoteny:so first u need to understand my thread is not about the source of my morality is better than yours. I am not here to sell the biblical God as a better source of morality. Thus the condemnation of the biblical God is highly inconsequential to the debate. u said Abrahamic religion emerged 2000 yrs ago- its actually 4000 yrs ago. That means other civilisation had their morality from another source That exactly is my point, every civilisation has a morality sourced from their belief system linked to a religious spirituality. Be it ancient egyptian, mesopotamia, akkadian empire or shang, these civilisation has their morality sourced from a spirituality. So appealing to them wont help your case. They beleive in a higher power who gives guidance and morality. The question remain athest dont believe in any god at all. be it biblical or not. So what is the source of their morality. U argued my questions can be answered by the expectation of the society u live. which society? last time I checked most atheist society is perfectly ok with homosexuality or 16 yrs old girl having sex. The society that frowns at such are actually the conservative religious ones and we know where that source of morality comes from. secular/liberal/atheist society dont care if their adult daughter choose to become onlyfans model neither do they care if their 19 year old son wants to change his gender. They will even support such change. Why is such morality from an atheist culture repulsive to u? That's the question u guys do not want to answer. Telling me your morality is influenced by a religious society shows atheists benefit from sound morality coming from a higher power, something they dont want to accept. and that's the point of my topic- modern atheism morality is actually influenced by judeochristian values esp atheist born in conservative culture. They can deny it but the inability for u guys to convincingly show the source of your morality is clear evidence u dont have one. U live off the morality other spiritual cultures worked hard to build. |
LordReed:Abraham didn't sleep with a woman who is not his wife. Both Hagar and Kenturah were called his wife in the bible. |
Scientheosopher:Every human action has long term effect even those we consider morals. Celibacy had long term effect, being too meek or gentle has long term effect. Is AI Moral? People are worried it will lead to massive loss of jobs but we still pushing for it. I don't see any long term effect for premarital sex, most people do it and get away with it. Even teenage pregnancy has no longer term effect in a well supported system. Looking at long term effect of an action cannot be the source of morality. |
geoworldedu:Lord Reed u see what I'm talking about. Atheist will never any question but turn every argument into God of the bible. Every belief system derive their source of morality from a source. The only exception is atheism whose source of morality is unknown. This guy came here and said he has no problem pushing just one of his daughter into prostitution but he objected pushing all his daughters into the business. I then asked him what is the source of that decision. What is the foundational principle that makes u think it's MORAL FOR YOU AS A FATHER TO love-vendor JUST ONE DAUGHTER INTO PROSTITUTION BUT NOT ALL YOUR DAUGHTERS. WHERE DID U GET THAT MORALS. now he has refused to answer, instead he wants to know if the source of my morality is the good or not. I AM NOT HERE TO DEBATE IF MY OWN SOURCE OF MORALITY IS BETTER THAN ANYONE ELSE. ALL I WANT TO KNOW IS SINCE ATHEIST REJECT ALL BELIEF SYSTEM, THEN WHAT IS THE SOURCE OF ATHEISM MORALITY. I HAVE TOLD U THE SOURCE OF MY MORALITY, Tell ME YOURS. EXCEPT U TELLING ME THE REASON U BECOME ATHEIST IS because U HATE CHRISTIANITY. then u are not an atheist but a Christian hater and this topic is not for u. |
geoworldedu:Atheist are the most confused bunch I ever see. They make it seem as if the only God that exist is the one spoken about in the bible. Guy my thread is about all gods that people believe in. U guys don't believe in any. Will u stop becoming atheist in Japan, India or Thailand where Abrahamic religion isnnt the main religion. Traditional worshippers beleive their morality comes from their gods, do u believe in their existence. I want to know the source of your morality. Whether the source is immoral or not is completely irrelevant. U don't think the source of my morality is clean. Fine no problem. Case closed. Now tell me the source of your morality that think it's ok for just one of your daughter to be a prostitute but not all of them. I want to know the source of that morality. |
LordReed:Ok I get u now. My response is regarding if masturbation is sexual immorality. Any sexual behaviour outside of MARRIAGE is sexual immorality. Pleasing yourself is not within the confines of marriage, u are enjoying pleasure without your partner. Now if your religion allows for more than one wife, sexual pleasure remain within them. My argument is not even about God of the bible but what is the source of morality for atheist since they deny existence of all gods whether they allow for more than one wife or not. I want to know the source of u guys morality. Masturbation is a sin in Christianity but do atheist consider it immoral. If the answer is yes, what is the source of that morality. If masturbation is not wrong for u guys then no point debating it. I intentionally brought up complex cases that u guys will struggle with to determine your source of morality. That's the point of this thread not whether God of bible is moral or not as some of u has turned it to as usual. As if u people will stop becoming atheist if u live in India or Japan or Thailand. |
geoworldedu:Stop deflecting and answer my question. Your opinion of God is completely inconsequential. U already rejected him so calling him immoral is highly irrelevant. I told u the source of my morality is Christ. And Christ told me prostitution is a sin, so none of my daughters will me encouraged into the despicable behaviour. Now tell me the source of your morality. Is it ok to allow your 4 daughters to go into constitution. U already said it's ok for one of your daughters to be a prostitute. U said it here so pls don't take it back. I just want to know if that decision is based on having other good daughters or u think it's ok if all become prostitute. If your answer is no, then why is it ok for just one and not the other 3. What is the source of that moral decision. Your moral principle is based on what source. That's my question. Pls answer. |
LordReed:Abraham is not morally perfect. He followed what was socially/culturally accepted norm by misleading his wife and putting her at risk 2ce. That was needless because God already assured him of his safety. So yes he committed sin. But we don't judge prophets based on their moral flawless but their willingness to be used by God. Abraham took a huge leap of faith by coming out of his already established home to journey into the unknown wilderness just because God told him to do so at a time YHWH was a relatively unknown deity. It's like someone leaving his successful career in New York to go and live in a remote village in nasawara just because an unknown god told him to. Most of us will conclude he's crazy. That's exactly the case for Abraham and that's why he's called the Father of Faith. |
geoworldedu:No because as a Nigerian Christian I don't follow the law of ancient Israel- mosaic law. I have no business with it. I didn't become a Christian because of mosaic law but the law of Christ which is the new testament. The law of Christ which is the foundational principle of my morality NEVER INSTRUCT ME TO KILL MY KIDS IF THEY DISOBEY ME INSTEAD IT ADMONISH ME TO CORRECT THEM GENTLY BY DIRECTING THEM TO THE LORD. THAT IS WHAT CHRIST SAID. Now for the last time answer my question. Is it ok for u to allow your 4 daughters enter prostitution if that is their wish. Answer the question. Stop deflecting. What is the source of your morality. |
geoworldedu:This is about source of morality, not textual criticism of the bible. But because I never told u before I will indulge u last time. Now u quote from the mosaic law which consist of moral law, ceremonial law and civil law. The law u quoted is a civil law which is the basis for the nation of Israel constitution. I'm not an Israelite and the ancient Israel nation no longer exist. Thus the civil law is null and void. The Midrash and the mishnah which are the Jewish interpretation of the Torah described the civil law comes from ancient Israel’s legal system, not a general instruction for all people at all times. By the time of Jesus Christ, the law had been abandoned. It's meant to be punishment for targeted extreme, persistent behavior (described as violent, destructive, not just “disobedient”) despite repeated warnings and not a single isolated incidence. So it functioned more like a societal law in a theocratic setting, not a blanket moral rule for families. Now answer my question. I want to be sure I understand u. Are u saying it's ok to allow your 4 daughters enter prostitution if it's there desire? Is that what u are saying ? |
UnknownQueen:I will be surprised if your Brian size is beyond that of a fish. No wonder she has never spent enough time to know that time was created when universe itself was created. B4 that there was no concept of time. You are woman anyway so no point. |

