|Join Nairaland / Login / Trending / Recent / New|
Stats: 1225737 members, 1604594 topics. Date: Friday, 22 August 2014 at 12:49 PM
Ifeanyi Uba Caught Cheating In Anambra Political Debate. / 1914 Amalgamation - A Historical Mistake? : Nairaland Political Debate / Gov Orji Walks Out Of Political Debate!can It Affect His Election? (1) (2) (3) (4)
|NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 9:01am On Oct 08, 2012|
The moderators of this section have decided to introduce a monthly debate session as a way of raising the intellectual value of the section.
We are aware that debate goes on everyday here and indeed every thread is a debate, but the difference this would make is that it is going to be moderated and there shall be winners.
We are proposing last Saturday and Sunday of every month (6-8pm Nigerian time, to be dubbed 'Weekend of Titans' or 'Political el-Classico' or any other fanciful name to add some colour to it)). First round on Saturday and final on Sunday. We are starting this October.
The topic shall be drawn from contemporary political issues or any other topical issue. As much as possible, we shall avoid very sensitive and emotional topics.
There shall be 4 debaters in each cycle (month), to be paired and the 2 winners slug it out at the finals. Debaters will be arrived at through voluntary indication of interest and/or nomination by members.
The Mods shall be coordinators and will not be part of the panel of judges.
We shall have a standing panel of 10 judges, nominated by members and mods. But only 5 shall be used in a round of debate. The 5 shall be arrived at based on their expertise on the subject, neutrality, non-connectedness to the topic etc. In choosing judges, consideration shall be given to posters known for their neutrality or middle-course approach to issues. e.g where Sanusi's CBN is being discussed, I cannot be part of Judges based on my history on NL.
My partner will come in to chip in more things.
Your input and opinion are welcomed in the meantine.
UPDATE TUESDAY, OCTOBER 10, 2012
UNVEILING THE 10 WISE-MEN!!!
After 48 hours of extensive deliberation on and off this thread, taking into consideration popular opinion as well as our educated discretion, we have come up with this list as our Standing Pool of Judges:
1, COOGER: Cooger has been on Nairaland for more than 4 years and has been a valuable member of the forum, contributing to different topics in different sections. He brings to the table versatility and experience. He is also well-known for his command of the queen’s language
2, SISI_SKILL: Sisi_skill is well experienced in judging online debates, being on board of the panel of judges that successfully executed the Literary section debate in July 2012. She has been active on Nairaland for many years and understands the dynamics of the forum and psyche of the members.
3, AJANLEKOKO: Highly sought-after Ajanlekoko is Nairaland’s resident career consultant. He is a respected voice on many issues and not known for frivolities. We expect Ajanlekoko to bring to bear his acclaimed maturity and expertise in multi-disciplinary matters and critical thinking.
4, EZIACHI: [/b]Eziachi is a Nairaland veteran and one of the encyclopedias of Nigerian political history on Nairaland. He is a well-respected figure in this section. It is this rich background in political knowledge that Eziachi brings to the team.
[b]5, PHYSICSQED: Physics is one of the most cerebral political analysts on Nairaland. He is also well known for his fact-based debating skills, a tool that will be useful as a judge in this programme.
6, E-GUERILLA: e-Guerilla is another well-respected intellectual on Nairaland. He adds to the team analytical depth.
7, IBIME: Ibime has been on Nairaland for more than 5 years and has continued to add value to debates from his repertoire of knowledge and experience. He brings balance to the team, as the other 9 wise men.
8, Ogugua88: Ogugua is well known for the logic of his analyses and presentation. He will be useful in spotting the logic of arguments in our monthly debates.
9, LONDONER: The man from London is a leading intellectual on Nairaland, adding candour and colour to threads. We have so much confidence in his ability to dispassionately dissect arguments in his judgment.
10, TALINA:[/b]In my brief citation on the 9 judges above we have left out their tribe and region of origin for obvious reasons, but we are safe to introduce Talina as a Canadian. Talina brings international flavour and insight into the team.
We do hope our judges will justify the confidence reposed in them as unbiased umpires.
Ladies and gentlemen, join me in wishing these TEN-WISE MEN success in the assignment.
UPDATE OCTOBER 11, 2012
[b]PROCEDURE IN 5 STAGES
1, Choosing of topics
2, Choosing of debaters
3, Choosing of 5 judges from our pool of 10
4, Debate proper
5, Post-debate discussions
NOTE: All planning(steps 1-3) will be taking place in this mother-thread, but special dedicated thread shall be opened for each debate, to be opened few hours to debate. W
1, CHOOSING OF TOPICS
This shall be thrown open, suggestions taken from everyone, and topics arrived at by consensus. Topical and developmental issues shall be given preference. 2 topics shall be arrived at, one for first round, another for final. Or same subject but different angles as points of debate in first round and final.
2, CHOOSING OF DEBATERS
This can be by voluntary indication of interest and/or nomination by another member. At the end of the day, we shall settle for 4 debaters for each cycle(month). Topic will also play a role in settling for debaters.
3,CHOOSING OF 5 JUDGES
We shall contact all the 10 judges and confirm their availability on the debate day. If we have positive answer from more than 5, we shall use our discretion to settle for 5. Rotation will also be considered.
4, DEBATE PROPER
Debate thread shall be opened at least 3 hours to the commencement, where the rules, brief Nairaland citation of debaters, list of judges, shall be posted. The thread will then be locked till 5 minutes to start of debate when the coordinators shall declare the debate open. The debaters can then post their arguments within 20 minutes. Then, the debaters will be given another 20 minutes to take on one another, fault opponents arguments etc. Then another 20 minutes for judges to throw their questions at each of the debaters and debaters to respond. Then we shall take 1 question from audience(viewers) based on first post, first recognized basis. Note that the viewer/audience rep is only to ask question and not endorse/fault an argument.
While the debate is going on, any comment other than from debaters, coordinators and judges shall be hidden and the poster risks 2 hours ban from Politics section. When it's time to take a question from 1 viewer/audience, the coordinator will announce.
Then the judges will compile their results and email to the coordinators, who will aggregate and announce the results on the thread.
We expect the exercise to take between 2-3 hours.
Then the thread shall be declared open for regular Nairaland discussion and comments.
October topic - page 16
November edition - page 24
December edition planning - page 29
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Afam4eva(m): 9:34am On Oct 08, 2012|
Great...finally we have a politics section debate. How will the debater be chosen?
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Gbawe: 9:41am On Oct 08, 2012|
The moderators of this section have decided to introduce a monthly debate session as a way of raising the intellectual value of the section.
Well done guys. Good to note you have listened to the suggestion of some of us that the politics sections should be a more useful 'tool' to Nigeria and Nigerians , as an Arena of ideas, instead of the 'Jerry Springer' Stadium it currently is. With this move, you set a precedence for civil discussion that will hopefully be entrenched and accepted generally by users of this forum.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Dotman01(m): 9:53am On Oct 08, 2012|
Interesting!. . . Can we suggest topics too?
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 10:04am On Oct 08, 2012|
The success or otherwise of the exercise and the ability to achieve the bigger picture of intellectualizing discussions here depends on everyone of us.
A good number of Nigeria's policy makers and pundits actually come here to read these stuffs. I know Pat Utomi does, I know el-Rufai does, I know many politicians do, that is why some of them have planted their boys here to project their image.
So, we need to raise the level of discussion on this forum so that the potential can be achieved.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 10:06am On Oct 08, 2012|
Dotman01: Interesting!. . . Can we suggest topics too?
Yeah, free to suggest topics, and if passes consensus and scrutiny, will be considered the topic for the month.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 10:07am On Oct 08, 2012|
afam4eva: Great...finally we have a politics section debate. How will the debater be chosen?Through nominations and voluntary expression of interest.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by CrazyMan(m): 10:13am On Oct 08, 2012|
Wao this is good.
But please avoid choosing topics that would make the thread a battle ground for tribal bigots.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 10:27am On Oct 08, 2012|
CrazyMan: Wao this is good.Sure, sensitive and emotional topics will be avoided.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 10:32am On Oct 08, 2012|
This just crosses my mind.
Can we start with these guys?
1, Ekt-Bear - Politics section poster of the year 2010
2, Gbawe - PS POTY 2011
3, Katsumoto - Runners-up 2010
4, Onlytruth - Runners-up 2011
This sounds interesting?
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 10:36am On Oct 08, 2012|
Or better still, can we use them as judges? Every year, PS POtY and their runners-up are inducted into our panel of judges.
What do you guys think?
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Gbawe: 10:39am On Oct 08, 2012|
Jarus: The success or otherwise of the exercise and the ability to achieve the bigger picture of intellectualizing discussions here depends on everyone of us.
Totally correct. Jarus, I see you and OAM4J as decent guys. I am just surprised this has not happened earlier. I have been saddened that a powerful forum like this, which should naturally be used to put our leaders under pressure and make them understand we are their boss, is a congregation ground for rancour, e-fights and ethnic bigotry. Anyway, better late than never. As I said earlier, this may just set a precedence that will impact positively on how we discuss here. Good one guys.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Afam4eva(m): 10:43am On Oct 08, 2012|
Jarus: This just crosses my mind.You can't use people such as these as judges. They're as bias as they come and are involved in partisan politics in one way or the other. While Gbawe ia probably a card carrying member of ACN, ekt-Bear and Katsumoto are bias for anything Yoruba which includes ACN. Same goes for Onlytruth, who's bias for anything Igbo.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Demdem2: 10:47am On Oct 08, 2012|
Good Initiative. Kudos to u guys.
I nominate myself to be a judge for any issue that has to do with GEJ
jarus, abegi set me free. banned wrongfully by pyguru
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 10:48am On Oct 08, 2012|
I agree. But they can debate.
Also, do you have anybody with balanced, near-neutral member of the forum with moderate view in mind that you can nominate as Judge?
I am suggesting Max Siollun, but he is not a regular member.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Jarus(m): 10:50am On Oct 08, 2012|
Demdem2: [b]Good Initiative. Kudos to u guys.Don't worry, ban expires by 11.02 am, that's next 15 minutes.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Demdem2: 10:52am On Oct 08, 2012|
i have Eziachi in mind but dosent come around frequently
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Afam4eva(m): 10:55am On Oct 08, 2012|
Jarus:I will suggest Abagworo, even though that his line of thought sometimes scares me. But he can be a neutral judge. I will also suggest edo.girl. I'll think of more people later. It's really hard to find an impartial judge on Nairaland these days.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by LongOne1(m): 10:58am On Oct 08, 2012|
Nice one, this means one can pick up one or two things instead of the utter chaos which is occasionally apparent, resulting in the drowning of good ideas.
Apart from announcing winners, is it possible to transform the solutions into something meaningful? Like, contact legislators/politicians or at least create ‘best practice’ solutions to known issues / some kind of knowledgebase for people in power? I know Jarus mentioned Pat Utomi and El rufai, but I mean people who are already there and capable of making a difference.
That way, even a Nairalander who finds him/herself in power one day, might remember this forum and put these ideas into practice.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by JomoGbomo2(m): 11:00am On Oct 08, 2012|
This is a welcome idea and i believe it will create a more friendly environment for us to share our views on our current political landscape.
And as a way to contribute, I will like nominate myself as a Judge in the first Debate session.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by OAM4J: 11:03am On Oct 08, 2012|
Thank you all for your support of this idea. We indeed want this debate to count and become a reference point to many of our politicians.
We want to get our panel of judges right. We need about Five people with at least 2 ladies. So we welcome more nominations. You can also nominate yourself.
I nominate Sisi_kill and Coogar among the judges.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Gbawe: 11:03am On Oct 08, 2012|
You make a good point here. The forum should seek out forumers who have shown, under all conditions, they are truly neutral, non-partisan and generally stand up for what is right and just.
Let us look for 'Judges' like Eziachi, Pukkah, eGeurrilla, Ajanlekoko, Paddy Lo, Northsharp, Ufeolorun, Kilode, Rossikk, Sagamite, Mikeansy, Akanbi Edu, Haka Nai, Nagoma, HNosegbe, Ballabriggs, Jason123, Ogugua88, Edo girl et al. I think those sort of posters , even when controversially 'passionate' now and then, can be trusted entirely to be fair to all.
In fact, to even gain more neutrality, we should consider non-Nigerian Nairalanders who know Nigeria well and tend to be fair like Bennyboy and Akwasi. Judges should be those who are civil and tend to be able to view things dispassionately.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by OAM4J: 11:06am On Oct 08, 2012|
Also feel free to oppose any nomination you disagree with, and state your reasons.
We (moderators) will pick the final 5 judges from the nominations that are not effectively opposed.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Demdem(m): 11:07am On Oct 08, 2012|
Again Eziachi comes to mind.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by PointB: 11:07am On Oct 08, 2012|
Good development. I like to feature as a judge. Well, unless the organizers feel otherwise. In any case, there are few individuals with commitment and tenacity such as myself, and moderating/judging seems to be my forte.
What say you?
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by PointB: 11:10am On Oct 08, 2012|
Guy, free me jare. I am addressing reasonable folks like Jarus, and OAM4J
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Demdem(m): 11:11am On Oct 08, 2012|
In a public forum like this, u are addressing all. Dont u get it? better adjust ur post to specifically suggest such.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Afam4eva(m): 11:13am On Oct 08, 2012|
PointB: Good development. I like to feature as a judge. Well, unless the organizers feel otherwise. In any case, there are few individuals with commitment and tenacity such as myself, and moderating/judging seems to be my forte.You can make a very good moderator. Infact, you're the best in Nairalander as it pertains to moderating. But as far as judging is concerned...I can't also feature as a judge because even though i try as much as possibly to be unbiased, you'll still feel that tribal affiliation in my posts.
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by PointB: 11:14am On Oct 08, 2012|
In this instance, I am specifically addressing Jarus and OAM4j. How many times do you want me to say that?
|Re: NL Monthly Political Debate by Demdem(m): 11:18am On Oct 08, 2012|
ur original post didnt suggest such. Anyway, will let u be even now that my post has been hidden.
Anyway, making u a judge in my opinion will be calamitous
|Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health |
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket
Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2014 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See Nairalist and How To Advertise. 94