stcool: If it is N26 and above... I will make a kill. If it about waiting for payment. I base in Lagos I go pack to the registrars office and I sabi shout well o! dem go think say na be the highest shareholder!
Anyways at this price, I am willing to wait. Where am I rushing to?
its not only about waiting (that is the lesser risk)
the Major Risk is Alhaji rejecting the offer then u wld be left with an empty shell cos the company had been loss making of recent then the price cld even plunge to sub 6 which was the last strong support so LOOK WELL at your RISK before u park ur fortune inside ooooooo
like is said i have some unit which if thing go awry might be painful but wnt kill me
i wld rather w8 to get more hint that Alhaji had accepted the offer b4 i wld park a fortune inside the thing because at that point it take on the xterictics of a fixed deposit
stcool: My Oga, No be say I must buy o! But this MTN listing be like NAHCO that year. The money I made from the IPO, bonus and price appreciation that record is hard
I will try my luck tomorrow, if I no see buy I go wait. Meanwhile Oga abeg help me look DF well, the way I dey load am fear they catch me.
I am confident of N21-N25 or is there anything I am missing. If Olam can pay that I will be almost OK for the year.
i think ur figure is correct going by current financials
where the risk is largely situated is if Alhaji does not accept the offer or ask for higher price and olam rejected (note it is only the N26 that is binding on Olam) if u also rememeber something similar happened to Alhaji of recent when he made a binding offer for a cement coy / plant on southafrica and the coy requested for higher pricing which Alhaji did not agree with hence the deal failed.
a lesser risk is that of long drawn / prolonged payment even if the deal scales through.
i think this two risk is what is being priced in and why the price on NSE is not closing in on the N21-25
so the question for you wld be how SURE are you that Alhaji wld accept the N26 / N130b offer
and are you ready to wait for the prolonged period before the cash is paid if the deal scales through? (particulary in this period of cash being king?)
N.b im a foot deep so my view might be tinted / biased
And with the way the market is, there is money everywhere. So keep packing. And when the oyibos wake up, you will be in Bora Bora sending your sell mandates and sipping coconut water. Don't forget your sunglasses then
My Oga i ask a question of u some moons back but didnt get a response
what metrics do u use to measure when price had gone ahead of value
i presently use 5 year average p/bv though it had failed me on some few occassions so i am looking to compare
RabbiDoracle: Your call on leaving it alone is the same I have.
In the Serengeti the best catch is gotten when you stalk and Chase with all animals unaware.
Now everyone is looking and wanting to jump in. I usually stay out.
People can make money from the stock but there are other tested companies out there trading at a discount. I cannot come and kill myself.
My Oga like Mendes wld say im an old man and i dont have d strength to struggle with agile and able bodied men (whether to enter or to exit)
My preference is for slow and steady not fast and furious.
The thing about life (which the NSE completely mirrors) is that it always present ENOUGH opportunity. if u miss one just wait PATIENTLY and be PREPARED for the next one, for it wld come sooner than you think.
Try and extrapolate this to 4 quarters. And it could come lower possibly.
I don't do IPO. I wish people can learn from times before 2008 crash.
But wetin concern me. No be my money!
with a FY2018 PAT of N145b and 1st quarter of N48b extrapolating, the best that could come from MTNN FY2019 wld be N200b which wld give EPS of N10 which gives P/ E ratio of 9, with a payout ratio of 80% dat is N8/ share at introductory price of N90 gives a dividend yield of 8.88%, the PBV while not available wld not look good also considering that the company is quite leveraged due to easy access to debt (probably one of the best entity any bank in Nigeria can lend to presently)and hence it is exposed to easy and favourable credit terms.
In view of the fact that the above figures qouted are the best estimate (which means the figure can only get worse and not better) then in my opinion the price of N90 had already priced in ALL FAVOURABLE FACTORS.
The rational decision (from fundamental perspective) wld be to leeave the thing alone becos there are other well tested shares in the market with more favourable metrics like div yield of 14%, p/bv less than 1, P/E of sub 5, and also favourable liquidity.
However i think from technical / jijo perspective it wld be a good one considering the hype and sentiment surrounding it
Finally personally i would take the advise of one prof here who said it is a dangerous venture to pursue a moving train.
my prayer is that the listing should bring in more players to the NSE which could possibly rub off on other shares
Kagame: FBNH has like another 3-4 yrs before it fully recovers.Normally,if you are an SIB and your NPL is above 5% upwards to alarming levels,CBN will invite you to present a 4yr remediation plan which I think FBNH did in 2015.
As you rightly pointed out ,the books will improve this year but that’s just halfway through the journey.This year,FBNH will likely write off over N300bn from their loan books due to Atlantic energy. For proper context, FBNH has made total NPL provisions of over 500bn since 2015 but yet, this huge amount only gives just over 80% (about 70,if you use IFRS 9) coverage ratio, this is really unprecedented in the history of Nigerian banking industry, smaller banks would not survive this ~ the rot is really deep.
If you look at their 2018 audited results, you will realize that NPL increased to about 29% from 25% . Why? The implementation of IFRS 9 which provides for proactive loan provisioning.With this accounting standard, there’s another N200bn of loans which has been moved to stage 2 (payments of interest and principal missed for 9months or so).
With the possible write off this year, NPL ratio will come down to manageable single digit but the bank will require more capital which means they will have to retain a lot of their profits and pay less dividend for a few yrs cos they can’t even come to raise Tier 1 from the market ~ they already have the biggest number of shares among listed banks and the current pricing is not favorable. As a matter of fact , the GMD of FBNH admitted that the bank (First bank) will not upstream dividend to the holding company except they make a significant recovery from their bad loans.
I have a positive bias for the current management, they are not afraid to let you know how bad things are ,which is good cos they were hired to clean up the mess. I believe in a few yrs when they are done with the transformation, the bank will come out stronger and will reward investors by way of capital appreciation and dividends . But there’s something very Nigerian (apologies) about FBNH that tells me that in a few years, probably in 5yrs time, after the current management might have left, the bank will return to old ways of sharing the “national cake” like we do in Nigeria.To avert this , the culture of the bank needs to change to one of excellence and efficiency like their peer GTB.
On current prices,if I’m to invest in any Nigerian bank with the aim of making my return in less than 10yrs , I’d put my money in Zenith ~ heck it’s 14% dividend yield and they are sitting on tonnes of cash by way of shareholders funds, I only worry a little about their corporate governance and their inability/reluctance to crack retail banking.That explains why investors price them a lot lesser than GTB.
If I want to make my return in 15yrs without checking the NSE everyday and probably retain some hope of transferring equity to my grandchildren,then GTB is it. But it doesn’t come cheap because ,no be only me dey see am, institutional investors wan die there!
There could be other good banks, but I’m sorry they are not on my radar for now.
Apologies I had to quote you with this long epistle, I only wanted to write briefly about FBNH but I found myself delving to other things.
God Bless you plenty for this thorough and unbiased analysis
wish there could be more of same on other counters so pple can make more informed decision
stcool: And you believe a fake news that did not come out until CBN governor was nominated for a second term, you think Buhari will listen to that Bullshit.
Una go dey alright las las.
There is no linkages between this market and CBN news but pple cld choose to belive what they want to believe
The NSE had detach away from so many of its traditional anchor (oil price / budget release/ company result e.t.c) the only thing it respond to nowadays is news at it impact individual stock (a l dangflour/transcorp e.t.c). That is what makes the whole thing scary. i dont think things wld get better until it attach back to an anchor (probably volume on the I&E window)
OakPearl: All that is happening is typical of the stock market all over the world. It is the market manifesting a mind of its own that we all should be used to. Nothing new. If you are a jijoist, hold break. If you are a long term investor, food don done. Oyonburu na turn by turn.
i would even advise long termers to hold still or at best test waters with a foot (and not even leg) one after d other cos Technically the fall from this 28k level is quite steep (arnd 25-26). This kind of fall wld require the heavies (Dangcem/ Nestle/ FUGAZ e.t.c) to still shed substantially (10-15%) from current level to attain that (25-26k) though if 28k hold we might see substantial climb also.
N.B i am a novice on the technicals above is just my interpretation of what i am seeing on the chart
tritritri: better rain ooh....everyone is no where to be found.
My broda the rain is still heavy im waiting for it to slow down to drizzling so i can enter and get wet a little bit because if one enter this heavy one the kindly cold wey go catch person no go be small.
Opiletool: Go to YouTube bro. His albums are there. And if you wanna download, I'd advice you get a YouTube download app like Tubemate (you won't find it in playstore or apple store) and download pure versions. Those ones on naija music sites have been altered with those annoying intros, except for tooexclusive.
Happy Birthday Brymo. Always and forever a fan of yours.
Thanks appr8. i actually had been able to stumble on some yday. wld follow ur tip further
rebekah2011: Yes ooooo. Imagine if one can build a tidy and healthy portfolio that return good dividends every year.
.
its quite possible if one really make use of recent downturns. 10-13% dividend yield and disposing whenever you see price run ahead of value to restart again with same stock.
rebekah2011: The stock is valued between 80-85 naira per share. Dangote Cement has about 17b shares and it is selling for N181. The PAT of Mtn Nigeria for 2018 was N453b. It is poised to go higher this year, it, therefore, suggests that the outstanding shares are not too large.
Hello Chief.
if u numbers are right it implied a P/E of abt 4. Kindly corect me if i am wrong also would appreciate if you give insight into what the P/BV looks like and also div yield should in case u a privy to same
rebekah2011: Picked small of Zenith at 20.55 today, not bad for a stock that will likely pay N2.80 in 2019. Looking at picking UBA too. N6.50 will be a good price for a stock that will likely pay 85kobo next year.
That is really an Old man way of doing things slow and steady and not the fast and furious of nowadays people
Tvegas: This is the defeatist mindset that holds the average Nigerian down, why dont you allow the OP make an attempt first. Except you were making an attempt at sarcasm or some jokes that comment is somehow.
mayb u need to check out the history and evolution of the several shareholders association that abound in the nation b4 u come to ur defeatist / unpatriotic conclusions
stcool: I don't know how we can go about this, but i feel through this forum we can make a positive change. Can we have members here register a forum or organisation that would protect the rights of shareholders. I mean most of the irregularities in the market are first pointed out on this forum and we can have a voice that would demand a change and see that this companies are held accountable.
I remember the Oga taking on AIICO on this same issue of taking minority shareholders for granted and other cases that initiated from discussions here. You can imagine if we all join hands to this course, protecting the rights of the common investors. Cases where we need to write this companies we would write them, where protests are needed we come out in solidarity, and if we need to take it up with the authorities we do so as one voice until justice is served.
I am telling you this companies would wake up...and our voices can become very powerful for the next generations!
Then they wld buy some of u pple off just like they did to shareholders associations which eventually led to shareholder association proliferation in other to create food for some pple.
laydap: Forte Oil might be the next bull .. With the conclusion of the disposal of the Upstream, Foreign and Power Assets and payment of the Special dividend, phase 1 has been concluded. Phase 2 which is very imminent is the exit of Femi and sale of the remainder of FO (downstream Assets) to the Prudent Energy Group (Ignite). Modelling FO’s potential valuation including using OANDO 49% sale to Helios and the Mobil’s sale to NIPCO, we should have some handsome valuation with good upside to the price FO’s is currently trading at. We may currently be witnessing a "shakeout" after the Q1 result before the acquisition announcement is made soon and the bus takes off..
tritritri: without general bull transcorp alone cannot last..over 40B OS ...
its not even d 40b dat is d problem the problem is really dat the 40b is widely dispersed if the OS is 40b and one or two institution hold more than 80-90% then d remaining wnt constitute too much problem
RabbiDoracle: They seem to be normalizing the yield curve.
Now they want investors to be packing their money into longer dated bonds rather than short term bonds. Soon Tbills (less than 1 year) will not be attractive.
its d next logical step in the evolutionary chain and i wld expect more of such shld b issued going forward.
High yield on TBills (< 1 year) is actually an anomaly, that it has been so in this clime in recent years doesnt make it a norm.
you are really seeing ahead of d curve
multi year NSE recovery seems to b in d offing when and the triggers are what i dont know (and trying to find an answer to)
maishai: After listening to uacn conference call I think whay befall them is about to befall flour mills and honeywell as olam enters the game big time, they complained bitterly about a new competitor in their animal feed market and how this competitor is price cutting them.........
Anyway, the way these companies go about valuation makes me wonder if annual financial statements are true positions of this companies......I can imagine some one buying DF 4 years ago at 0.90k and cashing out #26 in due time(even warren buffet will envy you)
while i agree with the fact that competition in the flour space wld become stiffer for FMN however i dont see them going d way of UACN. The major problem of UACN was due to management that behave like dinosaur for more than a decade thereby looking on while there competitive advantage were been eroded right in the face and not giving adequate response to same.
you cant say the same of FMN, the major problem FMN had within the last 3-4 years was finance which was occasioned by getting caught flat footed during the last round of currency devaluation (i.e. FX derived losses). in anycase same OLAM had always been a player in the flour space. what buying DF wld do for them is to increase scale as they are not entirely a new player in the industry